Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think £175 is an excessive amount to pay for breakfast for 2?

239 replies

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:06

Or AIBU to think child maintenance system needs reform for shared care arrangements?

If there is exactly 50-50 shared care no party pays, but as soon there's a day a year different the non-resident party has to pay four-sevenths of what they'd pay if they never saw the kids.

My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal so would be liable to pay maintenance with a two-sevenths reduction.
Plugging this into the calculator I'm told I should pay:
£132.50 a week
or £574 a month
or £6,886 a year
which seems a smidge excessive for 39 breakfasts for 2 children, one of whom doesn't do breakfast. (£175 per breakfast)

The proposal from Cafcass was I should have them 6 nights a fortnight instead of ex's suggestion of 5 nights + 2 teatimes. That would mean the children would have 19-20 nights a year fewer with me and would increase my maintenance reduction to three-seveths. I'd then only have to pay
£106 a week
or £459 a month
or £5507 a year
which still seems a trifle much for 20 nights for 2. That's £275 a night and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems…

To be fair if they're with my ex on a school morning they are sent in with packed lunches or my ex pays for school lunch, but I'm still not convinced the cost is justified.

Can anyone point me at the law where they devised these calculations? So I can trawl Hansard and see how it was discussed and how the government decided this was reasonable.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 18/01/2022 00:07

If you can be flexible to accomodate her shifts, just do it with good grace. Its better for your children if you can bring yourself to co-operate with your ex, rather than seethe with resentment and pretend maintenance is the cost of a breakfast.

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:04

So you don’t have equal time, and are currently paying more, and have been for 9 years?

But now the ‘more’ will be greater?!

Just…say…no!

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:04

I suppose I'm saying the shifts complicate things. How does it work now? Is that the reason they've asked for to to have more so as to fit round work?

I mean rather than just because feels like it.

Not your problem obviously!

Whether you both male, female or one of each sex. It doesn't make any odds obv but I wonder why you've obviously decided to write post in way that doesn't say. That's pretty unusual, that's why I noticed.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/01/2022 00:03

I can hear how frustrated you are but I'm not sure it's helpful to reduce this to breakfast when that's really not what the money is all about. Pretending that it is may be stopping g you thinking more rationally. You say your ex pays for music lessons. With instrument repairs, exam fees, lessons and club memberships it would be possible for this to be costing 2k per child. It may not be of course, but you need to be really clear about what the maintenance is covering. The extra school dinners your ex pays for are easily £16 a week so over £600 a year. I wasn't clear from your post whether you 50 50 on all clothing. If you took the emotion out of it, what is your ex really paying for which you are not?

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:02

Do you currently have them 50/50 and are you currently paying, or have previously paid any maintenance?

You are not clear!

And if it’s stressful etc, tell your ex to just leave it, and try to sort their shifts out!

Their work and hours etc, is not your problem if it means you will see your children less than you want AND have to pay for the privilege.

Sort0f · 18/01/2022 00:01

Do you think it would benefit your children if they heard you discussing this?

If the answer is no, you are on the wrong track.

NYnewstart · 18/01/2022 00:00

And yes if you can be flexible about which 7 nights then you can accommodate her shift patterns in your 7 nights a fortnight.

Haffiana · 17/01/2022 23:58

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

NYnewstart · 17/01/2022 23:58

It’s such a small difference in time. I’d definitely be looking to make it 7 nights a fortnight.

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:58

@Quincythequince

So say no to her! Have them 50/50 no extra money needed. Your OP implies she’s asking you to change it so she gets them more, not that that’s how is is now. Just say no!
I've tried saying no to my non-gendered ex. When we separated I said I wanted equal time. Between us we must have spent at least £30k in court, the judge was glowing with meaningless praise for me but I lost.

9 years later and yes I can go back to court and spend another £10k of my money (ok I'd have to borrow it) and £10k of hers, but if Cafcass have spoken should I really fight?

Another poster suggested I "must earn a decent amount", yes I am paid very well, (earn is subjective - I don't work any where near as hard as eg careers, teachers or nurses - I'm just lucky), but still saying "Saying no" is insanely expensive it's risky, lawyers and courts now make me feel physically sick, and most importantly the stress would trickle through to the kids and that's not on.

OP posts:
LadyPropane · 17/01/2022 23:55

It's not just paying for their breakfast. It's them living in that home for an extra day a week. That's why you would be required to pay more maintenance.

Sorry if I missed this in your PPs, but why can't you do 50/50? Is your ex fighting against this?

I'm sorry you're going through this. It gets ugly when things become this petty, but it's sadly very common after divorce. I hope you are getting the time you want with your children, even if the finances aren't ideal.

cherryonthecakes · 17/01/2022 23:55

Your ex is right about shift work making a contact schedule difficult but if you can be flexible then hopefully you can work something out ?

CheeseMmmm · 17/01/2022 23:53

What shifts does your ex work? What age DC?

Shift work is v incompatible with school/childcare usual hours. How does ex manage that?

DH doesn't even do nights but still if I wasn't here leaving 430 am earlies, home 1030 lates works every other weekend... just as example totally incompatible with standard hours for children things.

Littlegreenfrogcake · 17/01/2022 23:53

You come across as anally retentive and hard work. Your children are not investments you can calculate value on.

Are you unhappy at how this money is being spent? Do your children want for anything?

You must be a high earner to be paying this much if calculated by CMS. is it causing a detriment to your day to day living?

cherryonthecakes · 17/01/2022 23:52

You're allowed to say no to her proposal and go for 7 nights a fortnight.

CM is based on overnight stays not hours during the day . If Dad feeds the kids dinner but the kids sleep at mum's house that night then mum gets maintenance in the same way that she would have if she'd fed the kids dinner and they'd sleep there.

Quincythequince · 17/01/2022 23:50

@LampLighter414

Well worded as to not reveal gender

Sadly on this site the assumption will be you are a man and your view will be disregarded if you are covering 50% of all costs. If you were a woman however there would be uproar about your ex refusing you 50:50 to their own benefit

I hope you're prepared

Utter tosh! No parent should have to sacrifice their own time with a child, solely to benefit the other parent!
Quincythequince · 17/01/2022 23:49

Assumption of sex (not gender), is neither here nor there!
The financial situation behind it is.

Definitely could be a woman posting. But I’m going to hazard a guess that most women, not all, don’t just think the cost of child rearing is based on how much a child eats, when CSA calculations come into play!

I could of course be wrong!

AlexaShutUp · 17/01/2022 23:47

Can't you just fight for 50/50 care?

Quincythequince · 17/01/2022 23:45

So are you paying maintenance now( which your last post says) or not, which your first post implies.

LampLighter414 · 17/01/2022 23:43

Well worded as to not reveal gender

Sadly on this site the assumption will be you are a man and your view will be disregarded if you are covering 50% of all costs. If you were a woman however there would be uproar about your ex refusing you 50:50 to their own benefit

I hope you're prepared

Quincythequince · 17/01/2022 23:43

So say no to her! Have them 50/50 no extra money needed.
Your OP implies she’s asking you to change it so she gets them more, not that that’s how is is now.
Just say no!

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:39

@Fere yes I am unhappy about paying my ex money - wouldn't you be, after a "clean break divorce"?

Wouldn't it hurt you if your ex effectively had £1000 per month greater spending power for the children, than you - even before their larger salary was counted?

When I pay for the children's clothes, clubs, etc when they are with me, and 50-50 of school trips and there's such a small difference in time, why should I pay that much?

To be fair I don't pay for music lessons but obviously would split them 50-50 if I stopped paying hundreds a month in maintenance.

As the non-resident parent I don't know precisely how much my ex earns but it's at least £25,000 more than me.

I'm also unhappy I don't get as much time with my children as I'd like, and that my ex has used so much childcare (Lockdown was good from that point of view as I saw more of them).

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 17/01/2022 23:35

Unless you tell us more about who is paying for what, we can't comment.

qualitygirl · 17/01/2022 23:24

@WafflesnBlueberries I wasn't for a second suggesting you didn't want to be with them...I was meaning it as why is your ex wanting you to have them less, is that what you want? If not then stay 50/50...

Quincythequince · 17/01/2022 23:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.