Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think £175 is an excessive amount to pay for breakfast for 2?

239 replies

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:06

Or AIBU to think child maintenance system needs reform for shared care arrangements?

If there is exactly 50-50 shared care no party pays, but as soon there's a day a year different the non-resident party has to pay four-sevenths of what they'd pay if they never saw the kids.

My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal so would be liable to pay maintenance with a two-sevenths reduction.
Plugging this into the calculator I'm told I should pay:
£132.50 a week
or £574 a month
or £6,886 a year
which seems a smidge excessive for 39 breakfasts for 2 children, one of whom doesn't do breakfast. (£175 per breakfast)

The proposal from Cafcass was I should have them 6 nights a fortnight instead of ex's suggestion of 5 nights + 2 teatimes. That would mean the children would have 19-20 nights a year fewer with me and would increase my maintenance reduction to three-seveths. I'd then only have to pay
£106 a week
or £459 a month
or £5507 a year
which still seems a trifle much for 20 nights for 2. That's £275 a night and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems…

To be fair if they're with my ex on a school morning they are sent in with packed lunches or my ex pays for school lunch, but I'm still not convinced the cost is justified.

Can anyone point me at the law where they devised these calculations? So I can trawl Hansard and see how it was discussed and how the government decided this was reasonable.

OP posts:
SpringDaisies · 18/01/2022 03:09

In 20-30 years time when one of your children send you an email saying they have worked it out, and the cost of them and their family visiting you that weekend (petrol, wear and tear on vehicle and clothes, lost opportunity costs in attending children’s clubs and sports already paid for etc etc) will you be proud they learnt the cost of everything, but the value of nothing from you?

£175 isn’t just for breakfast and you know it.

OniferousWasp · 18/01/2022 02:34

I don’t understand why route getting such a hard time!
I agree with 50:50 and no maintenance. You shouldn’t be struggling to provide for your child.
Yabu to dwell on not being able to afford consoles though. It’s good for them to have a break from them some part of the week.

NoRaceInThisHorse · 18/01/2022 01:54

CMS isn't just for breakfast... as you know.
Anyway if you don't want to change it, don't. I assume you have a court order?

Moonbabysmum · 18/01/2022 01:05

There's quibbling about a few days, but this is essentially near enough 50-50 that children will cost each parent a similar amount as a minimum (and then if one wants to buy consoles that's their choice).

I think it's petty trying to get a sliver over the 50% mark, and then claiming maintenance in those situations.

I can see why the OP has got flack for reducing it down to breakfasts, but I can totally see why the situation is unfair.

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:43

I think the OP problem is that ex is apparently rolling in cash (somehow) with what sounds like mansion billionaires row London, cash for unlimited holidays presents probably hand made designer clothes, personal helicopter and servants.

While OP sits in bedsit crying.

Sorry if harsh but listen to yourself op!

Your posts come across with your entire focus on money and being hard done by. And children hardly mentioned at all.

You're not coming across well, in short.

And you still have not answered key question, how old kids and what is ex shift pattern and how is child care around that managed now?

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:43

If high earning parent has children 50% of time, in the event of a clean break (which is what we’re talking about here), why should they subside other parent!

That’s spousal maintenance through the back door!

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:40

[quote TheCatShatInTheHat]@Quincythequince
The OP certainly is 'unique' in his views but if he has them 50:50 and pays half of everything, then I don't see the problem.[/quote]
But that’s not the case! You can’t imply kids coat nothing to care for, then say you don’t want to pay it for various reasons including that you want more money to spend on your kids for standard kids things like consoles/trips etc

They either cost money to care for, or they don’t (clearly it’s the diner!)

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/01/2022 00:40

The problem with your post is that you’ve expressed it as all about the money.

Do you want to spend as much time as possible with your kids? Do you think that’s best for them, or do you feel that the majority of the time in one home works best? Do you think it’s sensible to work to whatever pattern gives the children the most stability with a shift working parent? Those are the sort of things I’d want to hear if I were a judge, not calculations about how much you’re being charged for breakfast Hmm

No maintenance when it’s 50-50 is desperately unfair when there is a big discrepancy in incomes.

Also this.

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:38

Yep, OPs ex partner is a woman, no idea what OP is though. Going to hazard a man, for many give-away reasons!

TheCatShatInTheHat · 18/01/2022 00:37

@Quincythequince
The OP certainly is 'unique' in his views but if he has them 50:50 and pays half of everything, then I don't see the problem.

Woffle · 18/01/2022 00:35

The gender has been spotted! Whoops Wink

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:30

@TheCatShatInTheHat

I don't get why you are having such a hard time here.

You do 50:50 each and no one pays any maintainace! Help her out by being flexible around shifts and she gets the days with the kids when she isn't working. All other money for use on the kids is split evenly.

No one should be paying anything if its 50:50.

Really? You don’t get why OP has been given grief?

Did you read the OP properly?! Equating maintenance costs to solely how much kids eat?!

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:30

By the way you can get pretty decent tech 2nd hand cheaper from CEX and other places too.

What are are they?

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:29

I am also confused about relationship with ex.

On one hand your posts sound like communication channels pretty much closed. Certainly you come across as resentful, bitter, angry, and not working together at all.

OTOH she asked you for this change. Was that directly or through 3rd party?

I think that potentially (probably) making her work situation really complicated maybe even untenable, or meaning kids don't see ex much, is definitely not good fit kids.

Can't you sort out through year that you have them extra days during year to even if out? Given its the money that's your big issue here.

TheCatShatInTheHat · 18/01/2022 00:26

I don't get why you are having such a hard time here.

You do 50:50 each and no one pays any maintainace! Help her out by being flexible around shifts and she gets the days with the kids when she isn't working. All other money for use on the kids is split evenly.

No one should be paying anything if its 50:50.

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:24

Some jobs eg DH the shift pattern is fixed and key to role.

He couldn't go part time after we had kids because of that.

Not everyone can change shift patterns. Don't want/can't do the shift pattern = leave job.

What shifts ex do, and how do they cover childcare?

We've had to spend ££££ when I went away for work. Due to the hours needed for care.

PickAChew · 18/01/2022 00:24

Saying no" is insanely expensive it's risky, lawyers and courts now make me feel physically sick, and most importantly the stress would trickle through to the kids and that's not on. Well just fucking pay for your children instead of using them as chess pieces, then.

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:19

I'm still slightly aghast that you sat down, worked out number days over year in two different scenarios.

Used online calculator or by hand worked out 4/7 this and X days and so on.

And then posted on MN to have a bitch about it!

That's a very sort of. It's about what's best for your children.

You need to share her shift pattern OP.

Unless ex has someone at home to look after kids while at work. Being able to single handedly juggle kids and work could well be incredibly tricky.

How old DC?

I mean mine 12 14 but if I'm not here, it wouldn't be on to leave alone from 430am, or no one home till 1030 pm. Weekends no one home 7-4...

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:19

And I realise the above isn’t uncommon at all, but not for people who earn silly money!

Have you said you’re happy to allow a bit more contact time, but only if you don’t pay as you don’t have the money?!

But the according to your OP, it’s food only so can’t you just send a loaf bread, box cereal back to cover these perceived costs! 🙄

CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 18/01/2022 00:17

It's not just breakfast though is it. Your ex is also paying for the music lessons and associated costs.
Are you doing half of the mental load of parenting? Sick days, drs, dentist etc.

And I would say (as an ex shift worker) that if you can be flexible around exes shifts then it's beneficial. It just seems a little pointless for your ex to pay for childcare when they're at work and then not see the dc on their day off if it's possible for you to switch contact days. Of course if its not possible without you needing childcare then it's a moot point. (This is also based on my experience of shift work which was 16 hour days, so I literally wouldn't see the dc on a work day)

My ex would refuse to swap his contact day if I was working because "Saturdays are my day" which meant I didn't see the dc for the entire weekend. (Weirdly the "Saturdays are my day" didn't seem to apply when he wanted to do something else!)

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:16

Then you can’t afford it, it’s not necessary, say no.

I don’t know what you earn, but it doesn’t sound that high to me at all. You can’t afford a console, rarely buy clothes, are in debt and drive a 10 year old car?! Really

WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 00:11

@Littlegreenfrogcake

You come across as anally retentive and hard work. Your children are not investments you can calculate value on.

Are you unhappy at how this money is being spent? Do your children want for anything?

You must be a high earner to be paying this much if calculated by CMS. is it causing a detriment to your day to day living?

Thanks, but don't worry I do get enough fibre.

At my exs no they want for nothing.
At mine they're doing fine but I can't compete with the consoles, holidays etc they get at the other side no.

Yes I'm paid a silly amount - however my ex moved to an insanely expensive part of the country, and I had to take a crippling mortgage to follow the children so housing costs eat at least half my salary. Then there are utility bills + food + transport and children's clothes, presents, clubs etc. I don't go out, my car is > 10 years old, I rarely buy myself clothes but it doesn't take much for me to end up in the red each month.

Is it causing a detriment to my day to day living - well there is the stress of being constantly in debt yes, and I want to be able to have spare money to spend on the kids here.

OP posts:
CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 00:09

I'm really confused.

Admittedly don't know much about divorce etc.

How if you are 50/50 looking after the children,
And ex earns more than you,

Are you paying ex maintenance?

You say ex claims won't see kids much if week on week off...
Claims?
You think that's not why wants to do it?

Why then? What do you think motivation is?

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 00:09

Why should OP have to pay more AND see their children less, to suit their ex?

Why?

Jellycatspyjamas · 18/01/2022 00:08

Wouldn't it hurt you if your ex effectively had £1000 per month greater spending power for the children, than you - even before their larger salary was counted?

Maintenance is about trying to give the children as close to the standard of living they would have had if their parents had not split up. Two higher earners means their lifestyle would have been pretty decent pre-split, your partner having more disposable income is irrelevant, the money isn’t for your ex, it’s to fund your children. Your support for your children would be the same if your ex earned £100000 or £10000, because it’s to pay for your children.