Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think £175 is an excessive amount to pay for breakfast for 2?

239 replies

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:06

Or AIBU to think child maintenance system needs reform for shared care arrangements?

If there is exactly 50-50 shared care no party pays, but as soon there's a day a year different the non-resident party has to pay four-sevenths of what they'd pay if they never saw the kids.

My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal so would be liable to pay maintenance with a two-sevenths reduction.
Plugging this into the calculator I'm told I should pay:
£132.50 a week
or £574 a month
or £6,886 a year
which seems a smidge excessive for 39 breakfasts for 2 children, one of whom doesn't do breakfast. (£175 per breakfast)

The proposal from Cafcass was I should have them 6 nights a fortnight instead of ex's suggestion of 5 nights + 2 teatimes. That would mean the children would have 19-20 nights a year fewer with me and would increase my maintenance reduction to three-seveths. I'd then only have to pay
£106 a week
or £459 a month
or £5507 a year
which still seems a trifle much for 20 nights for 2. That's £275 a night and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems…

To be fair if they're with my ex on a school morning they are sent in with packed lunches or my ex pays for school lunch, but I'm still not convinced the cost is justified.

Can anyone point me at the law where they devised these calculations? So I can trawl Hansard and see how it was discussed and how the government decided this was reasonable.

OP posts:
CiaoForDiNiaoSaur · 18/01/2022 07:38

Consultant appointments, egg boxes?

I guess that answers the question of who does these things Wink

And OP looks like you've had a name change fail. It might be easier to change back so your posts are highlighted. It makes the thread easier to follow/people can filter to only read your posts.

Momicrone · 18/01/2022 07:33

We did 50/50, no maintenance deals, just tried to divvy up expenses as fairly as possible when they arose no drama

Mummy1608 · 18/01/2022 07:27

and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems...
Op you sound just like my own dad, thank god we have cut contact. He calculated the cost of everything to do with us even though he was relatively well off then. Listen to yourself, even begrudging their healthy appetites.

There's a story in the bible where two women insist a baby is theirs. Solomon says we'll cut the baby in half. Woman 1 says that's fair, the second screams, no, let the other woman have the baby. The second woman gets to keep the baby.

Op, you don't give a shit about your kids really, their welfare and happiness. You just think this is all a battle you want to win in the war against your ex.

My dad gave my mum such a hard time my whole childhood because we were reluctant to see him so she was "poisoning us against him". She never did, he did that all by himself.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 18/01/2022 07:25

@Sowhatifiam

So who is paying for and arranging childcare, lunch, evening meals, school uniforms, school trips, haircuts, presents for parties attended, shoes, trainers, music lessons, other activities, arranging play dates, fancy dress days at school, charity days at school, take an egg box to school for art class….? Who does the school phone to pick up a child when ill? Who does medical appointments, dentist, consultants appointments?
Consultant appointments, egg boxes? Xmas Grin
Sowhatifiam · 18/01/2022 07:19

So who is paying for and arranging childcare, lunch, evening meals, school uniforms, school trips, haircuts, presents for parties attended, shoes, trainers, music lessons, other activities, arranging play dates, fancy dress days at school, charity days at school, take an egg box to school for art class….? Who does the school phone to pick up a child when ill? Who does medical appointments, dentist, consultants appointments?

Heronwatcher · 18/01/2022 07:18

I really don’t understand your mindset. You say you get paid a lot but you obviously begrudge this money. It seems as though you’re downplaying what it has to pay for- the principle is that the parent with more contact has more outgoings across the board (house, bills, transport, clothes etc). You need to try and understand this, sort out your obvious resentment of your ex and enjoy the time you do have with your kids or you will make them and yourself unhappy. If you genuinely can’t afford it seek a reassessment, otherwise you need to move on.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 18/01/2022 07:10

We share 50/50, so a week on a week off, no monies are exchanged between either party.
Both families pay for their own expenses. I don't have a childcare bill, she does. All other expenses are kept in house.
She did try at one point to insist on me paying the dinner monies, even though she receives the child benefit.
So we cover a child each.

I think the way access is granted/managed by both the law and the other party is obscene. Caveats being abusive parents.

Beautiful3 · 18/01/2022 07:05

You sound disgruntled. They're your children so you plan around what works best for them send you parents, not the calculator. My bil hated his ex and tried 50 percent residency, to avoid paying a penny. After 6 months, he admitted that it didn't work as he worked full time. He was palming the girl off into grandparents, when he wasn't around. Those grandparents started saying no. Anyway the child soon went back to the mother, which was easier as she worked part time. Bil saw her Friday till Saturdays which was more sustainable long term. The money you pay, covers heating, food, trips, childcare if they're away and clothes including uniforms.

girlmom21 · 18/01/2022 07:05

So you can't say no, you don't want to go to court, you don't want to pay maintenance?

You need to do at least one of the three.

trickytimes · 18/01/2022 07:04

If she’s earning more money than you then you shouldn’t be paying if it’s a true 50/50. So say no to the proposal. Demand more nights. Are you arranging and paying for play dates and birthday parties and school uniform and all of that? Why don’t you go back and say you’d like a monthly list of all expenses so you can split them 50/50? Surely that’s then fair?

JugglingJanuary · 18/01/2022 06:45

@Quincythequince

And if this is indicative of your general approach to child-tearing/shared responsibility, I can see why you are an ‘ex’
Only surprising thing is they're not in some footings somewhere!!
cookiemonster2468 · 18/01/2022 06:33

Then there are utility bills + food + transport and children's clothes, presents, clubs etc

So, doesn't this answer your question about the amount of maintenance money? You're not only paying for cornflakes and rice krispies Hmm

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 05:59

Think OP legged it. If not. Shift patterns please OP for ex. Why unhappy ex using apparently too much childcare (to cover work).

Meanwhile. You happy lockdown saw loads more kids.
Therefore meaning your job interfered with having so much time before?
And ex presumably said can you have kids extra next week because work you said fine? So... You do communicate, help ex out...?

And generally you can't see them so much because of work...
Who looks after them when you not there then? Given you have 50/50 arrangement?

I mean.

None of this adds up at all.

Didn't from the start.

Dunno if allowed to say.

Bitter man, fixated on how been done wrong. Focused on money. Wallowing in self pity. Angry that ex has better job and I'll bet is happier without OP.

Appalling unfairness means anger at women in general for being advantaged over men everywhere.

Led to. I'll make s thread on MN. Those women always think women fab men horrible. I'll cleverly disguise the sexes. Let's see how anti men they all are...

OP posts first comment. Ha! They're bamboozled!

9/10 who read OP first post.

That's obviously a bloke.

Nice one OP! You proved... Something!

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 05:46

Contd.

And now the MASSIVE CLANGER in OP quote above.

'Lockdown was good from that point of view as I saw more of them).'

Oh. Oh? Oh really?

So you work outside home standard office hours then? That's not easy when responsible for children is it. Arranging to leave early certain days, come in late when have them after school run. Being on call for school. Pick ups leave work early. Even if they old enough to get home snack... (OP never said age DC) ... Clubs, sorting out uniform homework, feeding, chat about day etc..

Not all employers ok with that. OP must be lucky with job.

Hold on though!!!!

So OP is in contact with ex presumably, having children while WFH to help ex out.

Which usually OP couldn't do as... Out at work. Convenient for him. Yes over DC come!

Hnmmm. Yet ex saying can we do this because I have work hours can't change..

OP says. Not on. Don't like ex using childcare while at work....

Question then.

Given op more or less week on week off. When not lockdown. How did OP cover childcare for when he at work?

CaMePlaitPas · 18/01/2022 05:44

Stop press, man doesn't want to pay for his kids, thinks it's "unfair".

Yawn.

PearPickingPorky · 18/01/2022 05:42

What childcare do your secondary school age children go to, OP?

CheeseMmmm · 18/01/2022 05:37

OP not been back, shame.

Hope back tomorrow.

Never says what ex shift pattern was, or how ex manages that currently.... But read OP posts again and is mentioned:

OP:
'I'm also unhappy I don't get as much time with my children as I'd like, and that my ex has used so much childcare (Lockdown was good from that point of view as I saw more of them).'

OP works shift pattern. Uses childcare to cover. I know from experience that out of usual hours it is vv hard to find, and costs eyewatering.

OP is unhappy that ex uses childcare so much? What the fuck else they supposed to do???!!

SavBbunny · 18/01/2022 04:37

£175 a week for two children? Lucky you. If you can afford music lessons at £40 per 30 minutes this is peanuts. To pay half you salary on housing costs is quite normal in the south east. Bills on top should be no more than £1000 unless you sre living in Windsor Castle! If you are normal height and weight you can buy fab designer clothes off fleebay. My children grew up with feast or famine. If you have been divorced 9 years they are secondary school age. No one likes a mean man. Give up the rant, be nice. Tomorrow is another day. And remember your children choose your nursing home!

Mummyoflittledragon · 18/01/2022 04:10

Have you discussed this with your ex? And explained you’re struggling to give the kids a nice time at yours because of this? Maybe that would be the first port of call.

notyouagainn · 18/01/2022 03:35

Who's paying for -
Clothes
School dinners
Childcare (if needed)
Toys/crafts/books etc
School supplies
School trips
Hair cuts
Birthday parties
Main household/car expenses

If it's you then yes you are overpaying if it's your ex then you need to contribute

Youngdumbandfullofrum · 18/01/2022 03:33

Yabu just on the basis you made such petty, penny pinching calculations - let alone your suggestion it's simply an expensive breakfast you're financing!
Perhaps you could put your love of maths to better use and channel the spare time and energy you suddenly find you have into saving for that precious games console once you tuck that bottom lip in and stop sulking :)
I'll bet there are certain things she feels go unfairly in your favour when it comes to co parenting but it's not about fair, it's about ensuring the children have a stable upbringing. If you're arguing just for the sake of it it's your children who'll pay in the end, emotionally. Let it go.

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 18/01/2022 03:26

Oooh typed so fast I missed a phrase out

But I do know if you were not as busy at work and said you want DCs 50:50 and had a good case for it where you are available and out your DCs first, then you'd have a good argument for 50:50 shared care . If you can't and don't, then please don't pretend it is about the cost of a bowl of cereal!!

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 18/01/2022 03:24

Apologies for typos
But typed so fast!!! As couldn't believe what I read in OPs post.

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 18/01/2022 03:23

What???

It's not "just costs of breakfast" though is it? I cannot believe that a parent who has the children less time is thinking about the extra cost as being per day and just for breakfast?!

Are you for real?

If you want 50:50 then make a case for that. If you are too busy at work to take off tile to do 50:50 then accept that other parent will be the one that does majority of care, majority or the nights, the homework the organising, the angst, the costs of childcare and taking time off when they are unwell.

I'm not sure you argued your care very well when you talk about breakfast costs only. But I do know if you were not as busy at work and said you want DCs 50:50 and had a good case for it where you are available and out your DCs first, then you'd have a good argument. If you can't and don't, then please don't pretend it is about the cost of a bowl of cereal!!

SpringDaisies · 18/01/2022 03:11

Correction - should be “cost of them visiting you exceeds their costs “