Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think £175 is an excessive amount to pay for breakfast for 2?

239 replies

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:06

Or AIBU to think child maintenance system needs reform for shared care arrangements?

If there is exactly 50-50 shared care no party pays, but as soon there's a day a year different the non-resident party has to pay four-sevenths of what they'd pay if they never saw the kids.

My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal so would be liable to pay maintenance with a two-sevenths reduction.
Plugging this into the calculator I'm told I should pay:
£132.50 a week
or £574 a month
or £6,886 a year
which seems a smidge excessive for 39 breakfasts for 2 children, one of whom doesn't do breakfast. (£175 per breakfast)

The proposal from Cafcass was I should have them 6 nights a fortnight instead of ex's suggestion of 5 nights + 2 teatimes. That would mean the children would have 19-20 nights a year fewer with me and would increase my maintenance reduction to three-seveths. I'd then only have to pay
£106 a week
or £459 a month
or £5507 a year
which still seems a trifle much for 20 nights for 2. That's £275 a night and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems…

To be fair if they're with my ex on a school morning they are sent in with packed lunches or my ex pays for school lunch, but I'm still not convinced the cost is justified.

Can anyone point me at the law where they devised these calculations? So I can trawl Hansard and see how it was discussed and how the government decided this was reasonable.

OP posts:
BitcherOfBlakiven · 18/01/2022 21:59

Honestly, where do you people find the time to argue over this shit?

I’m 10 years on from splitting with my ex who cheated on me when our DDs were 3/6 months old.

There is some serious bitterness and high conflict from the pair of you and if you think you’ve shielded your DCs from that, let me tell you, you’re wrong.

They’re in Y6.

Cafcass and likely the Judge would want to speak to them this time due to their ages.

Why would you put them through that?!

WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 21:46

*@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

OP you are not doing yourself any favours when you keep not mentioning the other things this covers like music lessons, shoes (unlikely to be as little as £40 per child over a year) and hair cuts. You might consider these costs irrelevant but they clearly are not. If you want to get people on board then you need to be honest. This isn't and is suggestive, fairly or not, of someone who is dismissive of other people's views. *

A quick check on the Clarks website suggests £40-£50 is reasonable for a pair of school shoes. I'd expect them to last at least September to July - they have so far for all 3 of my children. Other shoes/ trainers / wellies/ beach shoes etc I obviously buy.

Music lessons are actually pretty significant I'll accept - it turns out the total for their 3 sets of lessons and instrument hire is £250 per term.

Haircuts - last time we sorted them my ex got angry at the kids about it, so yes she does it now, the cost is pretty low as someone comes to the house and does the kids with their mum perhaps once a term (DS1 gets very shaggy between cuts) so £30 a term?

OP posts:
cherrypie66 · 18/01/2022 21:37

Let the csa decide who pays what. I'm sure the money isn't just for breakfast you are being ridiculous there. Do what the authorities say and stop whinging about paying for your kids for gods sake

FlasherMcGruff · 18/01/2022 21:22

^ that’s a criticism of the system, not you, btw in case that’s unclear.

FlasherMcGruff · 18/01/2022 21:21

Unless you are running a B&B, adopting a ‘cost price for breakfast’ approach seems a bit ridiculous. They are your children. You don’t rent them by the hour.

WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 21:16

@Hemingwayzcatz

I can’t understand the argument about not wanting to pay CM because the RP earns more at all. Unless you have 50:50 care, you pay CM and that’s precisely how it should remain. You’re paying her for the time they’re not with you which, from what I gather, is most of the time… You may want 50:50 access but she doesn’t and a judge decided you shouldn’t either so you have to pay CM as a result. It wouldn’t matter if she were a millionaire and you were on min wage. CM is legally binding and you should just pay it and stop whinging about it. It’s all so petty.

Reading this I actually thought you’d recently separated but no, it was a decade ago yet you’re still squabbling over money. Just move on and drop the tension, it will be much better for your health. When they’re teenagers they will be able to travel to yours and spend as much time as they want with you provided you haven’t moved miles and miles away anyway.

Stating that CM is the law doesn't make it a good or just law.

The law stated that my mother's first tax rebate had to be paid to her husband, that was the law then, it was wrong and fortunately has now changed so a woman is allowed to have her own finances.

The current rules state that if I have our children 5 days fewer than my ex then she can demand I pay her ~£5000 per year. If however I had them 5 days more than her then I could demand she pays me ~£7500 per year. To me this seems insane when we share other costs, and saying it's the law does nothing to justify it.

If you think the law as it is makes sense when it can actually push children into poverty rather than helping them (obviously not my current circumstances) then we'll have to agree to disagree.

We've not been feuding this last 9 years, I've not rocked the boat for nearly 6 years, but I have had the children consistently asking me for more time. The recent threat of her moving them away is what's brought this to the surface, hopefully in a weeks time this can die down again.

OP posts:
SomeOwlsCoo · 18/01/2022 21:04

@TurtleBackUp

Why are people seemingly not reading what this guy is saying ?

He does have his kids. A lot. But because over the space of a year she has the kids 20 more than he does - CMS says he needs to pay maintenance.

Given that it's only 39 nights a year less and given that he pays for clothes, toys, food, pays for lunches, haircuts, swimming lessons and fucking egg boxes when the kids are with him (which is only 39 days a year less than him) why should he then have to pay support on top?

Because the cms work a reduction for the nights he has the dc into the calculation. They assume that each parent pays for those things on "their time".

Reading your updates OP, which were more balanced and coherent than earlier posts, I can see where you are coming from.

I used to work shifts. A combination of earlys and lates, very rarely nights.
The dc went to my mums when I was working as their 'd'f wouldn't even dream of having them if he thought it made my life easier.

I was very lucky that I worked for a very sympathetic boss who did his best to work everyone's shifts to suit them. (Admittedly we only had about 7 support workers to consider). So I preferred to work a late followed by an early so Mum could do school pick up one day and drop off the next without me/the dc feeling like we'd missed any time together.

Is that something her company would consider? Then you can work around her shifts, dc get equal time with both of you.

The cms is a very very blunt tool. Which doesn't work for anyone it seems.

TurtleBackUp · 18/01/2022 20:50

I'd go as far to say that seeing as you are basically only having the kids -one month a year that you only pay support once a year.

TurtleBackUp · 18/01/2022 20:48

Sorry she has the kids 39 more nights than he does.

TurtleBackUp · 18/01/2022 20:47

Why are people seemingly not reading what this guy is saying ?

He does have his kids. A lot. But because over the space of a year she has the kids 20 more than he does - CMS says he needs to pay maintenance.

Given that it's only 39 nights a year less and given that he pays for clothes, toys, food, pays for lunches, haircuts, swimming lessons and fucking egg boxes when the kids are with him (which is only 39 days a year less than him) why should he then have to pay support on top?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/01/2022 19:44

None of that has any relevance to my original point that the CMS rules seem unfair and harmful for families with shared care.
£5,000+ per year hurts.
£175 per night for bed, breakfast, packed lunch and laundry for 2, seems unreasonable when other costs are split evenly and when the receiving parent is not in need.

OP you are not doing yourself any favours when you

keep not mentioning the other things this covers like music lessons, shoes (unlikely to be as little as £40 per child over a year) and hair cuts. You might consider these costs irrelevant but they clearly are not. If you want to get people on board then you need to be honest. This isn't and is suggestive, fairly or not, of someone who is dismissive of other people's views.

Fairness will always be an impossible dream in this kind of situation. For me, I can see your frustration but I am more riled about the number of NRP, often men, who pay nothing. It's not a fine on the NRP either. That is q pretty PA thing to say and again does not engender sympathy.

Socialcarenope · 18/01/2022 19:38

@Fere yes I am unhappy about paying my ex money - wouldn't you be, after a "clean break divorce"?

It's clean break from your spouse, not from your kids!

DropOfffArtiste · 18/01/2022 18:55

I can see her point. What would be your preferred arrangement? Week on/week off?

WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 18:42

@DropOfffArtiste

So you have a family court case ongoing at the moment? Your argument is that you want to have equal shared care and their mum's argument is that she doesn't want to separated from the kids for several days due to her shift patterns?

Is there a reason you can't cover to match her shift patterns? Have you been through mediation?

We've mediation on going, we may come to a conclusion before burning more money in court.

I've always stressed my flexibility but her issue is that even if she is working an evening shift - she'll see the children in the morning or vice versa.

We'll see - and either way - I've tried and I get to see them and get to be far more involved than separated dads in our fathers' generation. I'm probably lucky enough to be more involved than most non-separated dads to be fair :-)

OP posts:
Hemingwayzcatz · 18/01/2022 18:38

I can’t understand the argument about not wanting to pay CM because the RP earns more at all. Unless you have 50:50 care, you pay CM and that’s precisely how it should remain. You’re paying her for the time they’re not with you which, from what I gather, is most of the time… You may want 50:50 access but she doesn’t and a judge decided you shouldn’t either so you have to pay CM as a result. It wouldn’t matter if she were a millionaire and you were on min wage. CM is legally binding and you should just pay it and stop whinging about it. It’s all so petty.

Reading this I actually thought you’d recently separated but no, it was a decade ago yet you’re still squabbling over money. Just move on and drop the tension, it will be much better for your health. When they’re teenagers they will be able to travel to yours and spend as much time as they want with you provided you haven’t moved miles and miles away anyway.

DropOfffArtiste · 18/01/2022 18:33

So you have a family court case ongoing at the moment? Your argument is that you want to have equal shared care and their mum's argument is that she doesn't want to separated from the kids for several days due to her shift patterns?

Is there a reason you can't cover to match her shift patterns? Have you been through mediation?

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 18:28

Sorry for typos, am on phone.

But I wish you well and I’m sorry for giving you a hard time!

Quincythequince · 18/01/2022 18:27

OP, now that you’ve explained this better, I just want to say, I understands it makes more sense.
I don’t think your narrative and choice of words did you any favours, but all things considered as you’ve now reported them mean I think it looks like you’ve had a tricky time of it l, not least because you do want to see your kids, are happy to support them and would like for it to be fairer!

I get it.

I hope it works out for you, and at the very least, no matter what decision is reached, they will someday know you did what you thought was best for them.

WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 18:24

@Hapoydayz

You really come across that you see your children as a possession. No thought for what is best for them just something to be haggled over.
Hey there's a good reason I don't work in PR.

Like any decent parent I love my kids, and want to see them.

We've shielded them from any conflict for 9 years, sadly now they are finally aware there's some discussion about more time. They understand that both Mum and Dad love them and want to see them more, but can't agree on the time so are having to ask a Judge to help decide. That's not a terrible thing for them to know. They've no concept about money - if they had I think they'd be appalled I pay so much and would have asked for an officially even split of time - even if they then spent the odd unofficial extra night at their mum's around shifts.

I'm not pleased that Cafcass asked my 10 year olds who they wanted to spend more time with. I argued against Cafcass bothering the children and I'd been assured Cafcass would just be checking how happy they were at each house and if they had any concerns, not putting them on the spot and asking them to choose between parents. But both children said they wanted a little more time with me, one of them adding "but not at the expense of time with Mum", they love both of us and don't want to seem disloyal. I've reassured them there were no wrong answers and that although they'd be listened to they were not responsible for making the final decision.

None of that has any relevance to my original point that the CMS rules seem unfair and harmful for families with shared care.
£5,000+ per year hurts.
£175 per night for bed, breakfast, packed lunch and laundry for 2, seems unreasonable when other costs are split evenly and when the receiving parent is not in need.

OP posts:
DropOfffArtiste · 18/01/2022 18:22

But most of those things you mention have nothing to do with CMS calculations or money. You do have parental responsibility (parental rights are not a thing) and have equal say in their schooling, medical decisons etc.

WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 17:57

[quote girlmom21]@madisonbridges he doesn't want primary residency. He hasn't been to court for primary residency.

If he had I might be inclined to agree. [/quote]
Obviously I want primary residency, but I don't think that'd be in the children's best interest, they love both homes, they need to see both sets of parents, having two sets of parents cooperating is surely better for them… and we do co-operate, swap nights / weekends etc when needed.

I don't want to stop them seeing their mum, I just want to be treated as an equal party, with equal rights and an equal responsibility to trail all round the countryside delivering them to clubs, parties, doctors etc., and to try to harass them into doing their homework and eat in a half civilised fashion, brush their hair, turn their lights off occasionally. Being consulted about their schools would be nice too - that sort of thing.

Harmfully the CMS currently doesn't recognise the concept of equal shared care unless that's completely equal nights.

OP posts:
Mummy1608 · 18/01/2022 17:52

@Hapoydayz

You really come across that you see your children as a possession. No thought for what is best for them just something to be haggled over.
Exactly this, like the baby in the Solomon story I mentioned. Everything is bargains, trade-offs, little victories and losses. Poor kids. I remember being that kid and what a relief it finally was to go NC with my dad.
sanbeiji · 18/01/2022 17:49

@Hapoydayz

You really come across that you see your children as a possession. No thought for what is best for them just something to be haggled over.
It's in the children's best interest to have a good standard of living in both households. How does less money in their father's household (who by all accounts pulls his weight) benefit them?
WafflesnBlueberries · 18/01/2022 17:46

@DropOfffArtiste
"I wonder why she doesn't want you having more contact, if as you say, you get on well? Sounds like money isn't an issue and she can't relish shelling out for anti-social childcare."

I don't think she currently spends that much on childcare now, as she tends to use an elderly neighbour for the overnights, and uses another mum for some of the evening / early morning bits.

We get on fine, day to day, talking about the kid's latest antics, her telling me about some sport etc, but I can't raise the issue of time without conflict - so I avoid the topic.

My ex has previously said I'm an incompetent parent, but after the divorce my current wife saw how I was as a single dad and married me and had a son with me. I'm perfectly happy wrangling 3 kids on my own and various friends trust me with theirs.

I think my ex's problem may have been partly that she was controlling and because I didn't want confrontation then she thought I was incapable of making decisions. Then (after 13 years) when it finally came to something I cared about, we as a couple had no way to deal with the disagreement. She couldn't handle me not respecting her authority, and I knew no way to explain that "this thing does matter to me, and I have to say no".

Being charitable, as a loving parent she will always want more time with the kids and is worried that if she gives up time the because of her shifts she'll go for days without seeing them. There's some merit in that but it then does highlight a flaw in the system if just losing a couple of nights transforms me into the "non-resident parent"

Rasing children is hard - twins more so (for the first year at least), and in hindsight our marriage wasn't good. She had no ill intent but was abusive and controlling (learnt from her mother). When the marriage failed, lawyers were brought in and the relationship got worse. It was a long drawn out miserable time but is in the past and is mostly irrelevant.

Hopefully she's happier now and I certainly am, but the history and CMS's rules don't help coming to amicable agreements.

Again I'm not asking for pity - just saying the CMA's rules are unreasonable at times. I know it's a really hard problem to solve and that getting money to children who need it is a more critical issue than avoiding harm to families who share care.

OP posts:
Hapoydayz · 18/01/2022 17:17

You really come across that you see your children as a possession. No thought for what is best for them just something to be haggled over.