Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think £175 is an excessive amount to pay for breakfast for 2?

239 replies

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:06

Or AIBU to think child maintenance system needs reform for shared care arrangements?

If there is exactly 50-50 shared care no party pays, but as soon there's a day a year different the non-resident party has to pay four-sevenths of what they'd pay if they never saw the kids.

My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal so would be liable to pay maintenance with a two-sevenths reduction.
Plugging this into the calculator I'm told I should pay:
£132.50 a week
or £574 a month
or £6,886 a year
which seems a smidge excessive for 39 breakfasts for 2 children, one of whom doesn't do breakfast. (£175 per breakfast)

The proposal from Cafcass was I should have them 6 nights a fortnight instead of ex's suggestion of 5 nights + 2 teatimes. That would mean the children would have 19-20 nights a year fewer with me and would increase my maintenance reduction to three-seveths. I'd then only have to pay
£106 a week
or £459 a month
or £5507 a year
which still seems a trifle much for 20 nights for 2. That's £275 a night and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems…

To be fair if they're with my ex on a school morning they are sent in with packed lunches or my ex pays for school lunch, but I'm still not convinced the cost is justified.

Can anyone point me at the law where they devised these calculations? So I can trawl Hansard and see how it was discussed and how the government decided this was reasonable.

OP posts:
WafflesnBlueberries · 19/01/2022 13:25

Thanks for the messages of support from many of you.

Obviously as expected I took a lot of flak for complaining about maintenance in this predominantly female sphere, where I know many mums will have been abandoned and will not be being paid the money they need to care for their children. The tone/coherence of my vent, was probably not helped by its nocturnal nature and having shared a bottle of wine before hand :-) - also Mum's net - where's the edit function???

I got criticised for caring about numbers instead of the children's needs - I don't care about money but I do care about what I can and cannot buy - and I generally spend on my children because… what else would I spend the money on?… I have children.

I also care about injustice, and yes like most people who've been divorced I'm scarred by the experience. However I know justice is often a pointless destructive goal, and the experience of my first marriage has made me a stronger person and a better more appreciative and more diligent husband.

I'm not consumed by bitterness, my ex is not evil, she too is scarred, both by the divorce and, I believe, by her upbringing which has left her thinking being controlling and abusive is normal and needed to deal with useless men.

I do not want her to change her work so she can care for the children - she worked hard for her job and I want her to continue setting the example to both DS1 & DD that women can have good demanding jobs that they shouldn't have to give up when they have kids. Some childcare is fine, but the quantity feels wrong when it's at the expense of time with me and their brother and step mum.

Most importantly yes we have shielded and continue to shield our children from any conflict pretty effectively. Until the age of 8 they were still pestering us to all move in together - mum, dad and step-mum - they do now know that's not how most families work. I don't know how normal it is, but it is possible to have disagreements with your ex and to switch off those thought processes when you're around the children. I wasn't seething and biting my tongue when I last saw them with their mum. I know children (and animals) can pick up on moods even if your words are polite - I was happily dropping something round, chatting about the pandemic and admiring DD's latest creation.

OP posts:
WafflesnBlueberries · 19/01/2022 13:22

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee re how many nights "extra".
(excuse me those who find any numbers distasteful but I'm answering a point about numbers in a thread that started about finance.)

It depends how you define extra, I mean "extra over 50-50".

Equal time over a fortnight is 7 days.
If the kids are only with me 5 days a fortnight then I'd say they are with her 2 extra nights a fortnight or one extra a week.
So they are with her 1 night extra over 50-50, but she has them 2 nights more than me.

Similarly if two people each have £1000 pounds and Alice pays Bob £100, then Bob now has £1100 pounds so has an extra £100. Bob does now have £200 more than Alice though.

However you look at the numbers, I think it's too much but I accept I have to pay, and so unless she or the courts say otherwise I'll continue to pay.

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/01/2022 13:09

No, it hasn't cost his ex anything, because he's effectively paid for her court costs via his maintenance.

But if that's the case then he can't say that the maintenance he's paying is just for breakfast which is the argument he wanted to make.

Yerroblemom1923 · 19/01/2022 12:36

Wow. You've done your homework.

Fere · 19/01/2022 12:15

Thanks @39VodselForDinner for pulling the OP on his lack of logic.
He presented his case in such way that he gets his ego stroked for being badly treated as his ex.
He's having them 2.5 days per week on school weeks.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/01/2022 12:06

@Xenia

I agree with WafflesnBlueberries that the system should be fairer. However the CMS percentages are one of the few areas of divorce law with at least some clarity so at least people can look at x% of net salary. Even then there are complications for people who are paid via rent from homes they own or low wages deliberately from family companies their parents own or people who go abroad deliberately or give up work and let the new girl friend/wife do the work so the ex gets less.

Divorce division of capital is very hard to assess as the test to be fair is in my view far too complicated given most people cannot afford lawyers. If we had complex well written internet tools that gave couples their starting point with say 100 variables you could type in that might be better for starters and perhaps a decision instead of court based on the papers only that could be cheaper.

The bottom line is in the bible with Solomon - you cannot cut children in half and give each parent half. Also most teenagers do not want two homes. They want one base where their stuff is. The idea the children stay in the one house and the parents take turns living there puts children first but is not at all popular with parents of course.

In a sense I was lucky as my children's father chose not to have them one night a year and paid and pays nothing. At least there is no dispute over that and we had our court order on finances without any court hearings and "just" £20k of solicitors' fees (that was paid entirely by me as the higher earner -I paid both sides' fees)

We have shared custody it works very well, in fact over the Xmas period they stopped at mine for 10 days straight, went back to mums, and then they came back for a further 5 days.

They have 2 homes, fully equipped for their needs.
I cannot fathom why if the other has no parental issues, why the default is not 50/50 shared custody.
The legal system has a vested interest in whipping up business by having both parties at each other throats.
We didn't even have mediation, we agreed between ourselves, although in the beginning, she attempted via the solicitors to turn the whole event into a battle.
However, I snuffed it out pretty quickly.

Xenia · 19/01/2022 10:58

I agree with WafflesnBlueberries that the system should be fairer. However the CMS percentages are one of the few areas of divorce law with at least some clarity so at least people can look at x% of net salary. Even then there are complications for people who are paid via rent from homes they own or low wages deliberately from family companies their parents own or people who go abroad deliberately or give up work and let the new girl friend/wife do the work so the ex gets less.

Divorce division of capital is very hard to assess as the test to be fair is in my view far too complicated given most people cannot afford lawyers. If we had complex well written internet tools that gave couples their starting point with say 100 variables you could type in that might be better for starters and perhaps a decision instead of court based on the papers only that could be cheaper.

The bottom line is in the bible with Solomon - you cannot cut children in half and give each parent half. Also most teenagers do not want two homes. They want one base where their stuff is. The idea the children stay in the one house and the parents take turns living there puts children first but is not at all popular with parents of course.

In a sense I was lucky as my children's father chose not to have them one night a year and paid and pays nothing. At least there is no dispute over that and we had our court order on finances without any court hearings and "just" £20k of solicitors' fees (that was paid entirely by me as the higher earner -I paid both sides' fees)

DebbieHarrysCheekbones · 19/01/2022 09:14

[quote Socialcarenope]**@Fere yes I am unhappy about paying my ex money - wouldn't you be, after a "clean break divorce"?

It's clean break from your spouse, not from your kids![/quote]
This

Sowhatifiam · 19/01/2022 08:59

He wants his children 50/50.There should be zero subsidies for either party

He doesn't have his children 50/50, therefore legally, maintenance is due.

Nomoreusernames1244 · 19/01/2022 08:39

Are you unhappy about paying maintenance for your kids?
They will remember that when they grow up, and would love you for it. Guaranteed!

Not guaranteed at all. When you’re the nrp there is so much that affects the relationship. When you only see your kids part of the time you simply cannot build the same quality of relationship. Then there’s step parents and parental alienation- even little comments can be detrimental.

To reduce a parent- child relationship to “pay and they will love you” is ridiculous.

Feduprenter · 19/01/2022 08:18

And we haven’t heard the wife’s version of events here, it’s very easy to say that she’s doing this for five grand but let’s be honest if you were earning the kind of money that a consultant earns and you had somebody competent available he was able to make your life easier and let you get on with the job in hand five Grand is peanuts to her.

Do we actually believe that she’s doing this out of pure spite ?

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/01/2022 08:13

@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

It has cost this poster £30,000 to see his kids and then upwards of £5000 a yr subsidy.

Not it hasn't. It's cost him 15K and he's guessing (not unreasonably) that it cost his ex the same.

No, it hasn't cost his ex anything, because he's effectively paid for her court costs via his maintenance. He wants his children 50/50. There should be zero subsidies for either party.
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/01/2022 08:10

I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal

Just want to check OP. If there are 39 school weeks and your ex has 2 kids for 2 extra nights each of those 39 weeks, then do you not actually have the kids for 78 nights a year less per child or combined 156 fewer nights a year? (39x2x2)?

So the £6886 is for 156 nights, music lesson, hair cuts and shoes (at the very least). You said school dinners are £2.75 each but it seems that only one of the extra nights your ex has them in term time are before a school day and music lessons are £750 a year. So assuming hair cuts are £120 a year for both kids and that shoes really are £80 a year for both. Also assuming that music lessons are the only costs (i.e. no music/ exam fees), then you need to take £1057 off the £6886 to find what is left per night. That leaves £5828 which is £37 per child per night for breakfast and the other costs associated with them staying with your ex more than with you. Quite different from the £175 headline figure? Or £76 if you are quoting for 2 children. Have I misunderstood?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/01/2022 08:01

I'm sorry, maybe she should consider a job which fits in more with family life instead of passing the children from pillar to post. She did have someone to cover the shifts, a husband but she quite obviously wasn't 'Happee'.

Nice world you live in whereit's easy to get new job in a role which can be shift working. Not sure what the 'happee' means - you're suggesting people should just stay with their partners no matter how unhappy it's making them? Seems a bit 1950s tbh.

LaChanticleer · 19/01/2022 08:01

and I had to take a crippling mortgage to follow the children so housing costs eat at least half my salary. Then there are utility bills + food + transport and children's clothes, presents, clubs etc. I don't go out, my car is > 10 years old, I rarely buy myself clothes

AKA being a parent.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/01/2022 07:59

It has cost this poster £30,000 to see his kids and then upwards of £5000 a yr subsidy.

Not it hasn't. It's cost him 15K and he's guessing (not unreasonably) that it cost his ex the same.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/01/2022 07:46

@CheeseMmmm

''Please reconsider your sexist attitude. I don't want bigots like you insisting my daughter should give up on a career and bear the brunt of childcare if she decides to have kids. Nor do I want my sons thinking they've a right to concentrate on their careers and leave responsibility for children to their future partners.

Stop being a dinosaur.'

But you have been bitching on about your ex using 'too much childcare' and saying oh overnight older woman, looking for help childminders etc.

Which she needs so SHE CAN WORK. And covering shifts is a nightmare. I'm not surprised she asking around. She needs overnights and v early morning etc.

So whose the dinosaur here again?

I'm sorry, maybe she should consider a job which fits in more with family life instead of passing the children from pillar to post. She did have someone to cover the shifts, a husband but she quite obviously wasn't 'Happee'.

50/50 should be the starting point. No monies exchange hands.
However, his ex-wife doesn't want 50/50 she wants £5000 and she uses the legal system to aid her in getting the money.
It has cost this poster £30,000 to see his kids and then upwards of £5000 a yr subsidy.
It's wrong.
His ex-wife has been playing a game of manipulation for 10yrs, it's wicked.

Jellycatspyjamas · 19/01/2022 06:16

Bit the OP has said he’d arrange contact to support her shift working, he’s not criticising her for working. From what I’m reading he would like to see the kids more, they want to spend more time with him too, she won’t agree to more time because it reduces her CMS. Given they appear to have an amicable, friendly relationship it’s not that she thinks he’s unable to care for the kids.

OP in your shoes (having read your subsequent replies explaining things more clearly), I’d be bloody livid.

CheeseMmmm · 19/01/2022 02:27

''Please reconsider your sexist attitude. I don't want bigots like you insisting my daughter should give up on a career and bear the brunt of childcare if she decides to have kids. Nor do I want my sons thinking they've a right to concentrate on their careers and leave responsibility for children to their future partners.

Stop being a dinosaur.'

But you have been bitching on about your ex using 'too much childcare' and saying oh overnight older woman, looking for help childminders etc.

Which she needs so SHE CAN WORK. And covering shifts is a nightmare. I'm not surprised she asking around. She needs overnights and v early morning etc.

So whose the dinosaur here again?

CheeseMmmm · 19/01/2022 02:25

You just can't stand your ex can you. That's what this boils down to.

She 'moved another man into the house'. I can't quite get whether this is when you were still there, after split, anything. The wording though is hardly neutral it signals bitterness and anger that you still express. What, a decade later? When you've remarried, had a baby with your new partner...

When you were together bringing in childcare for your children, who were babies at the time, was fine.

Now-
She's using various help to cover her shifts. You've said she's only adult in her home.
You say she uses too much childcare.
That the are they are now, overnights with older woman are implied to be not right in some way.
Something about various people looking after them.

She has early starts, overnights etc wtf do you expect her to do?
She works I imagine. To bring in MONEY to support her and the kids.

Finding childcare out of standard hours is a total sod and costs £££.

Having it all piecemeal is a huge effort to manage.

Been there, done that. Working out in advance. These shifts coming. Ask those people. If can't then... ? Call in favour, find someone else... It's a nightmare.

IF she's minted, ski holidays, expensive area £££ house etc.

I find it VERY hard to believe that she's juggling au pairs, neighbours, child minders etc rather than getting a nanny. Esp given when you were together had nanny.

Your posts just do not come across as neutral.

You have new wife and child. It was a decade ago.

Get over it. And behave like a grown up. Help her out, she will be more inclined to help you out. Communicate and work together as it's best for the kids.

And stop doing maths about fucking breakfasts, warbling on about looking at Hansard to see who involved in the calcs (WHY???), posting online to strangers about it, drop the resentment and get on with life.

What you're doing is tbh not healthy.

DropOfffArtiste · 18/01/2022 22:16

Ok, hold on. There is a threat of her moving them away? That is a very different issue to child maintenance.

Why are you arguing about the number of nights when there are bigger issues at stake?

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 18/01/2022 22:10

[quote WafflesnBlueberries]*@Whatiswrongwithmyknee

OP you are not doing yourself any favours when you keep not mentioning the other things this covers like music lessons, shoes (unlikely to be as little as £40 per child over a year) and hair cuts. You might consider these costs irrelevant but they clearly are not. If you want to get people on board then you need to be honest. This isn't and is suggestive, fairly or not, of someone who is dismissive of other people's views. *

A quick check on the Clarks website suggests £40-£50 is reasonable for a pair of school shoes. I'd expect them to last at least September to July - they have so far for all 3 of my children. Other shoes/ trainers / wellies/ beach shoes etc I obviously buy.

Music lessons are actually pretty significant I'll accept - it turns out the total for their 3 sets of lessons and instrument hire is £250 per term.

Haircuts - last time we sorted them my ex got angry at the kids about it, so yes she does it now, the cost is pretty low as someone comes to the house and does the kids with their mum perhaps once a term (DS1 gets very shaggy between cuts) so £30 a term?[/quote]
The actual amounts are not really the issue, the fact that you brush over them is the problem. There's nothing obvious BTW about the fact that you buy wellies and beach shoes.

SomeOwlsCoo · 18/01/2022 22:02

@Sowhatifiam

I’d expect them to last at least September to July - they have so far for all 3 of my children

Ha! Now you are talking rubbish.

I only ever had to buy new shoes in September. My dc had very well behaved feet that grew in the summer holidays.

Actually that's a lie. Ds2 wore a pair for an entire year and then until the Easter holidays of the 2nd year before he needed new shoes.

BitcherOfBlakiven · 18/01/2022 22:00

The only shows my DCs have had that have lasted an entire school year without falling apart are Docs. They’re twice the price of Clark’s.

Sowhatifiam · 18/01/2022 21:59

I’d expect them to last at least September to July - they have so far for all 3 of my children

Ha! Now you are talking rubbish.