Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think £175 is an excessive amount to pay for breakfast for 2?

239 replies

WafflesnBlueberries · 17/01/2022 23:06

Or AIBU to think child maintenance system needs reform for shared care arrangements?

If there is exactly 50-50 shared care no party pays, but as soon there's a day a year different the non-resident party has to pay four-sevenths of what they'd pay if they never saw the kids.

My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays)
If we did this then I'd have them 39 nights a year less than equal so would be liable to pay maintenance with a two-sevenths reduction.
Plugging this into the calculator I'm told I should pay:
£132.50 a week
or £574 a month
or £6,886 a year
which seems a smidge excessive for 39 breakfasts for 2 children, one of whom doesn't do breakfast. (£175 per breakfast)

The proposal from Cafcass was I should have them 6 nights a fortnight instead of ex's suggestion of 5 nights + 2 teatimes. That would mean the children would have 19-20 nights a year fewer with me and would increase my maintenance reduction to three-seveths. I'd then only have to pay
£106 a week
or £459 a month
or £5507 a year
which still seems a trifle much for 20 nights for 2. That's £275 a night and while they do both eat a terrifying amount for dinner it still seems…

To be fair if they're with my ex on a school morning they are sent in with packed lunches or my ex pays for school lunch, but I'm still not convinced the cost is justified.

Can anyone point me at the law where they devised these calculations? So I can trawl Hansard and see how it was discussed and how the government decided this was reasonable.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Xenia · 21/01/2022 16:18

I am glad you have sorted it out. In general terms if you have to go to court over child issues both sides have lost. It is not ideally a thing that courts should decide and is much better when parents can agree it.

My biggest wish is that the courts would force men to have children 50/50 if the mother and the children want it (writing as someone whose ex did not have them for even ONE night a year and pays nothing).... yet there are obviously men out there who would adore 50%!

WafflesnBlueberries · 21/01/2022 16:10

@CheeseMmmm Next time, maybe talk to her first?

I'd tried.

I'd asked verbally, requested mediation and asked in writing before I finally felt forced into court when she threatened to move them to another county for secondary school.

I think it was only the threat of court that caused a rethink. I suspect the court would have given the children at least an extra night a fortnight with me - as suggested by the Cafcass report, but we both agreed we preferred giving the children the two extra evenings a fortnight instead.

OP posts:
PicaK · 21/01/2022 14:39

Or maybe just recognised her kids needs have changed over time and is willing to adapt to the new option OP has outlined.
Which neither her, cafcass, the kids or the judge considered suitable in the past.
Kids needs change.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 21/01/2022 07:39

@CheeseMmmm

Hello op thanks for update.

So you spoke to your wife.
Explained what you weren't happy with.
She said yeah that's not fair on you.
And you agreed on a mutually agreeable solution that is also fine for kids seeing both, and doesn't mean you angry costs, or she totally screwed re shifts.

Next time, maybe talk to her first?

Will save you a lot of time and be better for emotional state.

Roughly translated to she's decided to be reasonable after 10yrs.
CheeseMmmm · 21/01/2022 02:53

Hello op thanks for update.

So you spoke to your wife.
Explained what you weren't happy with.
She said yeah that's not fair on you.
And you agreed on a mutually agreeable solution that is also fine for kids seeing both, and doesn't mean you angry costs, or she totally screwed re shifts.

Next time, maybe talk to her first?

Will save you a lot of time and be better for emotional state.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 20/01/2022 18:50

I'm confused do your children not come together?

WafflesnBlueberries · 20/01/2022 17:57

@Hrpuffnstuff1

Why can't you do a week on and a week off as I do? It's so easy. I think people make a co-parenting complex with arrangements that are not simple. I very rarely speak to my ex. I don't need to.
Sometimes I think DS1 would like week on week off but having the opposite schedule to DD so he never sees her!

We don't do week on week off partly when we divorced my ex was not willing to give me 50-50. Anyway week on week off seemed way too long a time apart from either parent as they were not quite 3. We started the alternate weekend system with a midweek stay, and that's what they're used to now so we wouldn't currently want too big a change.

I think week on week off is still a bit too long for our 10 year olds, it would certainly be too long for DS2 to be separated from his big brother and sister.

We still don't have to see each other much - handover happens at school and my ex has a box outside that we use to exchange clothes / kit.

OP posts:
WafflesnBlueberries · 20/01/2022 17:40

Update - I've had the only answer that really matters to my AIBU question - from my ex.

My ex now agrees that if we split all other costs equally, and the only difference in time from 50-50 is I drop them back after dinner one of "my evenings" a week, then it would not be fair to ask for £550 a month.

So yes she'll be paying for an extra breakfast a week and an extra school / packed lunch, but she sees them more.

They'll be with me:
Alternate weekends from school on Friday to school on Monday. Overnight on Wednesdays - from school to school of course.
1 other night a week - from school for dinner and then back by 8pm.
50% of the holidays.

Some of my evening only days may change into nights and some of them will be stay with mum. We'll work it around shifts, clubs and what the children ask, but that's the basic pattern.

She'll add me to her existing apple family calendar, we'll meet once a month on neutral ground (but not have seconds or a mediator).

Finances - we agreed that although she earns more than me - what we earn is not the other one's business and we'll provide for the children at our own houses ourselves, mortgage, bills, cars, toys, clothes.

Clubs, music, trips, shared uniform / shoes etc we'll agree and then split 50-50 regardless of whoever's night the club / camp falls on.

We both think the children will be happy with this arrangement, but we'll review each year.

So everyone wins (except the lawyers who won't be getting any more from us for now).

I still think the way the current system works is flawed, especially for shared care parents. At any time my ex could change her mind and start asking me to pay her again, I don't like an ex having that power over me… but do trust her to keep the deal.

Perhaps … although the current system is divisive and encourages parents to squabble over nights… perhaps it's the least bad option...?

OP posts:
Hrpuffnstuff1 · 20/01/2022 17:30

Why can't you do a week on and a week off as I do?
It's so easy.
I think people make a co-parenting complex with arrangements that are not simple. I very rarely speak to my ex. I don't need to.

DropOfffArtiste · 20/01/2022 17:00

The proposal for an additional evening sounds great, however as CM is calculated by overnights it won't change your payments. You might not like this, but there are many things about CMS which are unpopular and unfair.

The reason your payments are high is due to your high income - 16% net and then reduced for overnight contact. With an additional reduction for your other child.

It does sound as though your ex bears some additional costs, including antisocial hours childcare which is not free or easy to obtain.

There are drawbacks to being NRP, but RP are also stigmatised and discriminated against in many ways.

Being contacted second by school, doctors etc is often the case with fathers, even when couples are still together, due to our sexist society, even when explicit instructions are given to the contrary.

Perhaps you can reflect on a successful co-parenting relationship over the last decade and consider how you have both contributed to this and the wellbeing of your children.

WafflesnBlueberries · 20/01/2022 16:33

@Ikeptgoing I'm sure I won't convince you and I've attempted to be as clear as possible without publishing my the entire schedule and finances for each family.

Currently the children are with me 5 days a fortnight during term time or 2.5 days a week. It is entirely "accurate and mathematical" to say that that's 1 day a week less than 50%. Yes mum now does 2 days a week more than me but one of those would be her responsibility anyway if we were 50-50, so I only "owe her" for one extra night a week in term time.

In any case my initial and much slated breakfast post was questioning how reasonable the Child Maintenence rules are for a proposed change where the children would be with me for 5 overnight stays and 2 evenings per fortnight.

Currently the children are with me alternate weekends Friday school to Monday school (I'm already going to the school every day for DS2). They are also with me one night a week - school to school.

The proposal is that I pick them up from school on an additional night - flexibly around her shift patterns, give them dinner and then drop them back in the evening, so they see mum then or at least in the morning.

This additional evening cuts down the current the week long break from Thursday morning to Wednesday evening where they don't see me, their little brother or stepmum.

We'd be 50-50 care in all ways apart from me dropping them back after dinner one night a week in term time.

I'd continue to be the NRP and according to the rules she could still demand I pay >£500 per month.

To me that seems unreasonable especially when it then impacts what I can afford to do with the children. Yes that ~£550 per month is not just paying for 40 breakfasts a year - it would also be 40 packed or school lunches a year, and it would be showers and laundry. It's also true that because I'm currently forced to pay maintenance I don't currently pay my half of their £250 a term music fees, and mum's bought the last few sets of school shoes, and pays for a hair cut per term. However even if I also stopped paying for any school trips and demanded she bought all the uniform it still wouldn't add up.

Aside from the money which is a tangible factual thing, as soon as someone is branded the NRP, they are immediately treated as a second class parent. People, assume NRPs don't pull their weight, know nothing about the costs and stress of childcare. NRPs are either not contacted or contacted last about anything regarding the children.

Re, holidays, bank holidays, inset days and sick days. Yes we now officially split holidays 50-50 - that was how it had normally worked out but she was giving me more time with the kids as a favour to me to take it up to 50-50, it's now agreed that we will split 50-50. Bank holidays / inset days they stay with the parent they were with that weekend. I don't work bank holidays and have to look after DS2 on inset days anyway so I've been a bit gutted when it's not been my weekend but also grateful to spend time just enjoying DS2 (even if he'd rather DS1 & DD were about). Sick days are flexible around our work/shifts (I'm fine working from home with a sick kid snuggled on the sofa, but if mum's not working and the kids are already with her).

OP posts:
Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/01/2022 21:31

Midweek each week? Take that day off if they are sick ? The next day off? Either the Friday and Monday off on your Alt weekends if they are sick or inset day?

To be fair, OP has said he will look after them if they can't go to school on one of 'his' days. That doesn't make it clear whether sickness is really 50/50 or not but is a lot more than some NRPs.

He does also say that they pay for clubs based on 'who takes them' suggesting that actually his ex therefore pays more for clubs than he does as she has them more.

For me, there is a still a lack of honest detail. That, combined with the fact that the OP has brushed over a number of other expenses which his ex covers, makes me wonder whether he is not willing to properly think about where the maintenance goes and what it really covers. Big red flag for me when someone says it's just for breakfast and then we find out that it's also for music lessons, instrument hire, shoes, hair cuts and clubs when they are with his ex.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/01/2022 21:20

@Sowhatifiam

timtab.com/50-50-custody-not-working-negative-co-parenting-effects/*Here's an interesting which discusses shared parenting and debunks some myths.I think it's quite balanced

written by what kind of expert? we haven't used the term 'custody' in this country for over 30 years now. Any suggestion that a baby should share care makes credibility questionable - no understanding whatsoever of what baby's need in their first 12 months in terms of primary care givers.

You haven't read it then. What a surprise.
Ikeptgoing · 19/01/2022 20:41

So

OP has Fri to Monday - (Fri sat Sunday nights) alternate weekends and one night midweek each week
Just checking if it's a full 5 days... in this 5 days NRP : 9 days RP fortnightly split

So is that a
Collect Friday (?morning and take them to school?, pay for school dinner that day? ) or a Collect straight after school Friday or later after mum picks up? When do you collect when not in school?

Midweek each week? Take that day off if they are sick ? The next day off? Either the Friday and Monday off on your Alt weekends if they are sick or inset day?

Pay for lunches on your Friday and Monday or does either become mums job?

Have actual 50:50 during school holidays/ inset days and BHols? school holidays are 13 weeks a year (most of us have 4.5 weeks AL a year but need could days for own own GP appmts so let's say 4 weeks) and also with5 days of inset days per year (ignore bank holiday cover although a shift worker may have to work BHs) - is it shared? Evenly? 4 weeks shared each leaves 6 weeks of DCs holiday cover needing childcare paid or arranged.

I'm just asking a mathematical question about how evenly it splits in terms of responsibility?

My school holiday childcare cover - which is 6 weeks - if two parents separately took 4 week separately each in holidays and was reliable -
Would be £180 per child per week- so for two children that is £2160 pa. Just for school holiday cover that taking everyone's AL wouldn't cover

Sowhatifiam · 19/01/2022 20:23

timtab.com/50-50-custody-not-working-negative-co-parenting-effects/*Here's an interesting which discusses shared parenting and debunks some myths.I think it's quite balanced

written by what kind of expert? we haven't used the term 'custody' in this country for over 30 years now. Any suggestion that a baby should share care makes credibility questionable - no understanding whatsoever of what baby's need in their first 12 months in terms of primary care givers.

Ikeptgoing · 19/01/2022 20:14

I just can't help but think of you really wanted your DCs 50:50 shared care and you dropped the money issue, you would find a way forward.

She has the bulk of the expenses and you throw so much facts based on money calculations that you miss the extras, the adhocs, the responsibility that comes with being the RP.

I know so many families with equal shared care, that I find it difficult to believe if you weee truly flexible and around more for your first DCs that a judge would have found different. But we can't know all the details of what s/he (judge) took into account.

If you really are in a good place now to be able to flex around these great children you have together what they need and as you say they are telling you they want more time with you, then apply to court and do it cheaply. You can be litigant in person and not use expensive solicitors. For then grand price of the court application £300 ish , you are perfectly able to advocate. (But I'd drop the money calculation fog as that is never what it's about when a judge looks at what is in best welfare interest of the children involved.)

Ikeptgoing · 19/01/2022 19:53

@WafflesnBlueberries

If the kids are only with me 5 days a fortnight then I'd say they are with her 2 extra nights

But that's not accurate nor mathematical is it?

There are 14 nights in a fortnight, so if you have them 5 nights your ex has them 9 nights. Almost 2/3 of the time. You have 35% She has 65%. You are the NRP. Most of that over the weekend?

You should be paying CM. And that isn't perfect though it's law- it's well known that it is far less than DCs need, it's a minimum that government set. What parent thinks ooh this minimum amount is all I'll pay for my DCs whom I love?

It's not "£175 per breakfast" - you've argued a blinkered point.

It's about the RP who has to have rooms for DCs, the extra bills you are failing to consider, (she pays that whether they are there or not as she has them lost or the time), the bulk of all the mental load and lack of freedom, having to put your career second & move your work around DCs, the one who has to find money for everything that "just crops up", the childcare and to be responsible when they are ill that she is first call and takes time off. Does the medical care and appmts.

It limits your career, your time and whilst it's great you have them 5 nights a week, it's the mundanity and slog that looking after DCs is, is that really an even split between you? I'm not sure when you say it's a £175 breakfast that you really comprehend anything about caring for DCs. You have new DC but that doesn't change existing DCs you chose to make still need you, and their needs don't change if you think it should be watered down as you can't afford all your children! Don't make new DCs then!!

Your posts are intelligence misused. There's academic and financial intelligence. And emotional intelligence; parenting intelligence. They are all different and your posts make me think you spectacularly miss the point.

That fabulous mind of yours could be better used finding better solutions and creating a strong Co-parenting bond between you and your first lot of DC's mother. I bet you can do it if you choose.

FreedomFaith · 19/01/2022 18:20

You shouldn't have had kids if you are going to not like paying for them. Use contraception in future or get sterilised.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 19/01/2022 18:18

[quote WafflesnBlueberries]@Whatiswrongwithmyknee re how many nights "extra".
(excuse me those who find any numbers distasteful but I'm answering a point about numbers in a thread that started about finance.)

It depends how you define extra, I mean "extra over 50-50".

Equal time over a fortnight is 7 days.
If the kids are only with me 5 days a fortnight then I'd say they are with her 2 extra nights a fortnight or one extra a week.
So they are with her 1 night extra over 50-50, but she has them 2 nights more than me.

Similarly if two people each have £1000 pounds and Alice pays Bob £100, then Bob now has £1100 pounds so has an extra £100. Bob does now have £200 more than Alice though.

However you look at the numbers, I think it's too much but I accept I have to pay, and so unless she or the courts say otherwise I'll continue to pay.[/quote]
I'm not sure what you mean here but you don't mention the word 'extra' in your first post so this doesn't really answer the question. You said that My ex is suggesting I should have our 2 children for 5 nights + 2 evenings a fortnight, in term time (equal holidays).

This appears to mean that you have them for 5 nights a fortnight. Your ex then has them 9. Never mind 'extras' which is not really relevant for CM which is about actual time with parents, not relative to a 50/50 standard.

If so, even if we ignored everything else your ex is paying for from the maintenance, can you explain how this makes £175 per breakfast?

Your ideas about how to make the system 'fairer' don't seem fair to me.
a) Both pay equally
Most mums do much more than 50% of care so entirely unfair just to expect each parent to pay half. Also does not recognise the career hit many mums take when they are the primary carer . These issues equally apply when the father is or has been the primary carer .

b) Both pay according to ability, (so if Alice has twice as much money as Bob she pays twice as much)
This fails to separate our money needed for basic living costs so will unfairly burden lower earners.

c) Pay according to the child's need. (Where the would the money benefit the children most?)
Not workable at all not least because who on earth would decide where the money will benefit the child the most?

To me c) seems the most important. If no maintenance was paid my children would not be in need so I'd say a) or b) should then be considered
Parents should be paying because they chose to have children not just when the children are in need. That would be a devolvement of responsibility.

On balance I'd then think that a) made sense - both parents can pay their share of the children's financial needs without hardship
you'd have to be pretty daft not to know how complex it is to really establish exactly who is paying what with some costs being more indirect/ muddled up with other household costs.

so although my ex earns more than I do - and I have greater outgoings (another child), I wouldn't think it fair to ask her to pay more, I'm equally responsible so should pay for half of their financial requirements
I agree with you here.

*Other views expressed in this thread seem to be:

d) Absent fathers should pay. Any parent who has a day less than equal time is an absent father. If there's exactly 50-50 care then dad is a "good parent" so no maintenance needs to be paid, even if mum is penniless.*
Nope, it's that NRP - male or female - should pay. You can try and see this as sexist in a bid to dismiss views but it's really not.

e) There is no such thing as shared care. All children have a primary carer. If the children spend one night a month less with the secondary parent he'll no concept of the cost of childcare and cannot share costs 50-50. He should pay, it's not just food.
You say this but you also leave it to your ex to sort out instruments, hair cuts, shoes. The reasons why you've done this are neither here not there - she does take more responsibility than you.

f) The law is the law. It's perfect and always has been. We should never question it or suggest changes.
Nope - people are saying that no system can be perfect. A system which protects children who have absent parents who pay nothing and then are living in poverty are the ones the law most needs to protect.

Hrpuffnstuff1 · 19/01/2022 18:08

@Sowhatifiam

I cannot fathom why if the other has no parental issues, why the default is not 50/50 shared custody

50/50 is about the parents. What is ‘right’ and ‘just’ for them. It rarely has anything to do with the wants and needs of the children concerned. One of my children wasn’t even born when my ex walked. The suggestion that he should have had 50/50 is abhorrent in those circumstances. Ditto small children who have been mainly in the care of a sahp suddenly expected to be half their time with a parent they barely know and who knows nothing of their routines, Other children don’t cope well with the constant chopping and changing and some parents refuse to do things like play dates and parties which leaves a child outside of their friendship group. I am not sure a default 50/50 is the right way to go at all

timtab.com/50-50-custody-not-working-negative-co-parenting-effects/

Here's an interesting which discusses shared parenting and debunks some myths.
I think it's quite balanced.

Sowhatifiam · 19/01/2022 17:06

if you are looking to change the law to benefit families in future, these changes would certainly benefit many

Yep. I am all for fairness but whilst we have a system where thousands of children have no support from one of their parents - my children are now 12 years and counting - I can’t get worked up about perceived unfairness because the ex earns more (which is what this is about when it comes down to it) when payments are within the law. There are way bigger issues with the system than this.

Sowhatifiam · 19/01/2022 17:02

I cannot fathom why if the other has no parental issues, why the default is not 50/50 shared custody

50/50 is about the parents. What is ‘right’ and ‘just’ for them. It rarely has anything to do with the wants and needs of the children concerned. One of my children wasn’t even born when my ex walked. The suggestion that he should have had 50/50 is abhorrent in those circumstances. Ditto small children who have been mainly in the care of a sahp suddenly expected to be half their time with a parent they barely know and who knows nothing of their routines, Other children don’t cope well with the constant chopping and changing and some parents refuse to do things like play dates and parties which leaves a child outside of their friendship group. I am not sure a default 50/50 is the right way to go at all

DropOfffArtiste · 19/01/2022 14:19

You have missed the current state which is paying a percentage of YOUR income.

The calculation of nights is a blunt instrument, but then so is the income calculation which is not varied unless income changes by +/- 25%. Annual reviews of income are rarely accurate or timely.

The percentage of income owed is net of pension contributions and can be further reduced due to additional children in the household of the paying parent, even if those children receive maintenance from elsewhere. These could also be considered unfair.

Why should your children receive reduced maintenance because you have chosen to have another child?

That is without addressing the issues of CM avoidance through fraud, working cash in hand and lack of enforcement.

If you are looking to change the law to benefit families in future, these changes would certainly benefit many.

Kotatsu · 19/01/2022 14:08

I actually think that the children's financial needs are in many ways irrelevant.

The point is that you pay according to your means. Now in practise I pay >50% of my salary out in child-related things, and my ex pays

WafflesnBlueberries · 19/01/2022 13:36

Here's an attempt at a clearer explanation of my views on how Child Maintenance should work - trying to remove the personal from it, and not mentioning breakfast.

I can think of three reasonable possible starting points for maintenance. With the aim of meeting the children's financial requirements. (yes I'll agree that sometimes calculating their financial requirements is tricky.)

a) Both pay equally
b) Both pay according to ability, (so if Alice has twice as much money as Bob she pays twice as much)
c) Pay according to the child's need. (Where the would the money benefit the children most?)

To me c) seems the most important. If no maintenance was paid my children would not be in need so I'd say a) or b) should then be considered. On balance I'd then think that a) made sense - both parents can pay their share of the children's financial needs without hardship, so although my ex earns more than I do - and I have greater outgoings (another child), I wouldn't think it fair to ask her to pay more, I'm equally responsible so should pay for half of their financial requirements.

Other views expressed in this thread seem to be:

d) Absent fathers should pay. Any parent who has a day less than equal time is an absent father. If there's exactly 50-50 care then dad is a "good parent" so no maintenance needs to be paid, even if mum is penniless.

e) There is no such thing as shared care. All children have a primary carer. If the children spend one night a month less with the secondary parent he'll no concept of the cost of childcare and cannot share costs 50-50. He should pay, it's not just food.

f) The law is the law. It's perfect and always has been. We should never question it or suggest changes.

The current law seems to be d), it does not take into account the vital point c) - "where the would the money benefit the children most?", it seems solely to be targeted as a simple way to make "absent fathers" pay. It's also unfair with respect to a) and b) and by its nature works to inflame tensions and discourage parents from working together in amicable shared care. It forces people to "count nights".

I don't think I'm "some sort of free thinking anarchist," but I can't understand point f). Yes I understand the law and will follow it, but if I think it's wrong I'll argue for change even if I know that change won't help my family.

Changing the law would help families in future. It would help children who need more support from their fathers. It would help not hinder, parents who even after divorce want to share responsibility and work together on the best and most important task in their lives, raising their children.

OP posts: