Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kicked off while FIL in house

108 replies

Lucynamechange · 17/01/2022 22:31

I WFH as a lawyer. A lot of my hearings are on zoom. DH is home with kids at the moment as it is holiday time (we are not in UK).

Had a case conference on zoom (no video) and told DH everybody needed to be really quiet at time it was on. His FIL turned up to take kids out, I was assured they would be gone by time it started. Great.

I have a fraught history with FIL - he is a misogynist who once had a go at me for keeping my DH living overseas and for making him do loads around the house and with kids. In reality we share most responsibilities and DH just does his fair share which is unpalatable to FIL. He ended up apologizing but it has never been the same. It took me a long time to get over feeling like a shit and lazy mum.

Anyway FIL arrives, they are in the lounge, I go in before 10am to make a tea and remind them to be quiet. At 10.05am my DS5 gets home with his friend, all kids of noise starts. I mute myself and shout to them to be quiet. End up missing something that was said and had to ask for it to be repeated. Noise carries on as friend's nanny arrives at front door to see if they want to go out. You can imagine the stress.

Luckily it was only a quick thing and afterwards I come out and was super cross and said as much to DH. DH having a go back at me saying not his fault. FIL is upstairs listening. DH saying he "can't control" people coming to the door and making noise. I am saying you can tell them to stfu and move away, it is not hard. Kids were supposed to be going out!

Now it has cooled down I know FIL heard me and feel like crap. I know he'll be judging me because my DH can do no wrong. I am just so frustrated because I feel like anything I do is not good enough in FIL eyes and even my job is not taken seriously. FIL was not making noise but I thought they were all going out before 10am. If my DH was in the other room on a work call nobody would be permitted to make a peep, in fact I would taken them all out before 10am. I would protect his work time. DH just says it is not his personality type to be so firm with people.

AIBU to be so bloody fed up.

OP posts:
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 18/01/2022 09:26

Reading all the comments I am wondering what office space everyone had pre-pandemic that they are used to being able to work in silence!

I've been in practice for over 20 years working in a variety of firms, plus visiting various firms and chambers. I have had an office with a door I can close for about 6 months of that time. It is overwhelmingly common for even senior lawyers to be working in open plan or with fairly flimsy partitions to give limited privacy. Often meeting rooms are overbooked and you can't expect the use of a private space for a call. Then there's fire alarm tests, the chimes on the sandwich van, sirens going past outdoors, and all kinds of other distractions that we get used to. WFH is much more peaceful!

Notcontent · 18/01/2022 09:22

Some of the people on this thread seem to be living on another planet and have never heard of COVID and the fact that many people are now having to work from home. And all the suggestions about finding an alternative place to work?? Where? No one I know has done that as it’s too difficult/too expensive - really not an option. Same with the suggestion about finding a place in the house away from the noise. In my house no such place exists! As for noise cancelling headphones - I have a very high tech set provided by my work - the problem is that unless you can be on mute the whole time the microphone will pick up noise.

Yaya26 · 18/01/2022 09:18

If your call was super important and your DH was aware of this. Kids nd DH should have been out of the house 10 mins earlier. Normal calls - reasonably quiet, some distance and headset. When wfh if I needed absolute silence for a call and it wasn't likely indoors - small house, three young kids I have resorted to taking the call outside in my car. Rare thankfully.

diddl · 18/01/2022 09:13

I don' t understand why you are getting so much aggro about this Op.

My take is this was a one off & organised in advance for the kids to be taken out.

Why your husband hadn't fetched the 5yr old from next door & got the kids ready & waiting to just usher out is beyond me.

If he's on holiday atm, why wasn't he taking them out himself??

SeeMyLanyardAndWeepBitch · 18/01/2022 09:13

Some of the last few posts show how WFH isn't the panacea we've sold over the last couple of years. If your home set-up isn't suitable you need to get back into the actual office, or invest money in either renting a hot desking space or extending/improving your home to give you a dedicated workspace in the loft or garden. Even then, if you have children in the house while you work you can't do your job properly OR your parenting properly if you are trying to juggle both. It's very unfair on the children to have to tiptoe around their own homes.

Illputtheminapie · 18/01/2022 09:13

@Totalwasteofpaper oh my dear - I have actually just had a little cry for you that is absolutely horrendous I'm so sorry. I could totally feel your emotions through the screen!!! You have my utter sympathy and I hope it never happens again. Flowers

LessTime · 18/01/2022 09:12

Luckily it was only a quick thing and afterwards I come out and was super cross and said as much to DH

What did 'super cross' mean. Were you really shouting? I'd be annoyed too but I can't stand it when people loose their temper over things that were not deliberately nasty. If I had lost my temper and screamed and shouted and my FIL had heard I would be embarrassed but it would be on me not him.
I would definitely be annoyed that they had t kept quiet though.

HermioneKipper · 18/01/2022 09:12

FIL sounds awful, who cares what he thinks.

Your husband needs to be more respectful of your work. Can you sit down with him when you’re calmer and talk it through?

TokyoDreaming · 18/01/2022 09:01

It's the holidays so I think you're unreasonable to expect perfect silence and your husband can't stop people from knocking on the front door.

It doesn't sound like WFH is sustainable for you unless you make some changes such as using noise cancelling headphones.

ECLT · 18/01/2022 08:57

@WhatNoRaisins

I don't get why you weren't in a room away from the front door. Would sound proofing in your home office help with this?
Sorry, had a good laugh at this. I WFH at the moment in a small mid-terrace with NOWHERE to hide. Soundproofed home office my arse!

Good humoured post, honest. Not intended to be a dig. WFH and teams meetings have been very entertaining for my colleagues and me where many of us don't have the luxury of an office at all let alone soundproofing.

On that note OP, give yourself a break, I think your colleagues will be more forgiving than you think in relation to a bit of noise and some unexpected disruption. Do the best with what you have I know it can be infuriating but it isn't always easy to WFH for everyone in the house. I have had my outbursts too I think you need the patience of a saint sometimes!

Doomscrolling · 18/01/2022 08:56

I’m with the consensus - you can’t control others’ actions, but you can do things yourself to improve your situation.

As PP suggest, proper headphones with a microphone and talking an important call in another part of the house are simple steps you can take to protect your working environment. Yes, it would be great if everyone was very respectful of your request for silence but WFH is always a compromise.

None of this has anything to do with your FIL. Ignore him, his views don’t need to matter to you.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 18/01/2022 08:49

Your FIL is clearly a bit of a dick and you need to stop caring about his opinion.

However you are being a bit OTT about having silence while you are working. I'm a lawyer too and have had various conferences with clients, witnesses, counsel, experts etc as well as court hearings done by zoom from home so I know what it is like.

Get a headset for calls, full earphones not buds for both ears and a microphone attached. I was working during some horrendously noisy building work outside (enough to shake the house) and due to the headset people I spoke to could barely hear it and didn't really notice until I mentioned the noise.

People on a call don't expect silence. If it is a court hearing you need to ensure that no one is coming into the room or speaking to you but a bit of background banging or shouting is just life. Obviously swearing or inappropriate language would be an issue but the noise of little kids is entirely normal.

I warn my DH before a call and say whether I am on video or audio only and if it is the sort of thing where he shouldn't pop in to grab my mug when he makes a coffee but I don't expect him to be silent.

GoGoGretaDoll · 18/01/2022 08:49

This is only a big thing because you hate your FIL and never want him to see your DH as being a less than perfect support. Which I totally get because your FIL is an arse. But actually this isn't a big thing in the grand scheme of things. Sort your working environment better - headphones and a mic would have made this a non-issue. Oh and stop taking everyone out when your DH has a call. Tell him it's because of your personality type.

madisonbridges · 18/01/2022 08:43

I don't understand why you're giving a go at your FIL. It doesn't appear that he did anything wrong. He was respectful in not making any noise. He didn't interrupt your argument with your husband, stand up for him or indeed make any comment about it at all.

UserBot999 · 18/01/2022 08:34

I can't work from home btw. I hated it. My DC are teens but they were making pancakes around me, playing music, fighting, laughing, phoning their friends. It was just hell. I thought work was going to call me and say why did you get about 40 minutes worth of work done in 7 and a half hours??

So I've been going in almost every day throughout the pandemic. not looking for a medal there. In fact, I worry that I'm inflexible and couldn't adapt to working from home, or will be perceived to have been unable to adapt to working from home. (which was the truth!)

UserBot999 · 18/01/2022 08:32

I sympathise. WFH is difficult with DC but you asked for quiet well in advance. Your DH sounds weak. I'd say that that's why your FIL sees him as being able to ''do no wrong''. he thinks his Son is weak and feels the need to protect him, but he doesn't need to protect him from being asked to show an equal partner respect as you do that for your husband too.
I'd feel the need to kill an FIL who wanted to protect his son from an equal partner but as another poster says he is always going to be like this, he's not going to wake up one morning and confront all of his projections and delusions and his misogyny.

Mellowyellow222 · 18/01/2022 08:27

You FIL isn’t the issue here your husband is.

You understandably dislike your father in law - but it’s your husband who has let you down here

LadyPropane · 18/01/2022 08:26

Ah, fuck what your FIL thinks. He sounds like a prick. He'll thing negatively of you regardless of what you do so I just wouldn't give it any head space.

JustcameoutGC · 18/01/2022 08:24

I suspect there are a few things going on here, but it is totally unrealistic and not fair on your children to expect silence when working from home. No one should be expected to tip toe round their own home. And no employer should be in the least bit surprised to hear some background noise. I have been streaked by naked children whilst on calls. You had to ask for something to be repeated, no big deal. Get some decent head phones. Sorted. Or go back to the office.

But i suspect this isn't about the noise.

FlamingoQueen · 18/01/2022 08:20

Why was your fil upstairs?
Seriously though, your dh should have just taken everyone out whilst you were on the call. Don’t stress over what your fil thinks of you (easier said than done, I know). If he is not supportive over your career then that’s his problem.
It doesn’t matter if he heard you have words with your dh - I bet there are not many people who haven’t been overheard having words whilst someone else is listening!

Fairyliz · 18/01/2022 08:17

Just go back to the office. This is just another example of why wfh doesn’t actually work, people need separate areas for separate parts of their life. It’s my madness to try and mix them.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 18/01/2022 08:13

@Mummyoflittledragon

As your ds 5 was only next door, your dh should have ensured he was home by maybe 9:40 and out of the door well before 10. I agree with others about giving him a taste of his own medicine. ‘Not in his personality type to be so firm with people.” Lol you can have a field day with this.
Ooh yes..

It's not in my personality type to do housework /cook/think what to buy for presents Grin

Presumably he benefits by using the money you earn as a lawyrr....?

Spell this out very clearly the link between his 'personality type' and your ability to earn loads....

Perhaps he can modify this trait...

CoronaKidd · 18/01/2022 08:08

Your FIL does sound like a knob.

As far as WFH is concerned, you’ve said it’s the holidays there so it sounds like for your own sakes you need to set your work area up somewhere more quiet, even if it’s just for the holidays. It’s not really fair for everyone to tiptoe around you while you work.

LookItsMeAgain · 18/01/2022 08:03

You had one requirement that you outlined to your DH.
It was up to HIM to keep his dad quiet because he should respect your work. He didn't. In my mind, HE is the one you should have the now calm conversation with and discuss how disappointed you were that for this one important Zoom call, that things didn't go according to what was, in your mind, an agreed plan.

As for your FiL - ignore him and whatever he thinks. He's not worth giving over anymore headspace than you already have. Seriously, don't worry about him. He'll have his ideas of what is right/wrong but they have no impact on you.

That's my take on it.

Hopefully, today will be a better day!

Spilltheteaplease · 18/01/2022 07:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.