Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsure about being a guarantor

269 replies

Dave20 · 17/01/2022 19:49

So DWs niece is 18 and has a baby girl. She lives with her mum, DWs sister.
Now she’s a single mother and doesn’t want to be on the council list, as she thinks it’ll take too long.
She can rent privately, but needs a guarantor. You must earn a certain wage and be a home owner, which we are.
Now DW is all up for doing this because she trusts she will pay her rent and wants to help.
I have my reservations. Firstly, she’s only 18, never had a job, never paid a bill and a bit naive like young people can be.I think she’s too excited about the prospect of having a nice little flat, and is impatient to be on the council list.
DW is adamant that her niece will always pay her rent and is sensible enough to not go down the road of not paying.

However, even if she has every intention of paying, what if she can’t pay? DW just said, well in that case, we’d be notified that’s she’s fell behind on her payments and we would have to come to an arrangement. Her mum, DWs sister said she would pay the costs. DWs sister isn’t a home owner and doesn’t earn enough, she can’t be a guarantor herself.
But is it really risky being a guarantor? We have a mortgage and 3 children, we remortgage ever 2-5 years. Will this effect our applications? We have a long time on our mortgage.
What if her rent goes up? Does her benefits pay for this? I have no idea how benefits work personally.
I can’t really stop DW being a guarantor if she wants to, but we’re linked obviously financially.
Would a guarantor be linked financially to the person? Does it affect mortgage and credit applications? Is it for the duration of a tenancy?
Is it too risky?

OP posts:
Nannyamc · 17/01/2022 22:22

No. Did it once for a friend on car loan. He never paid. Turned out it was in my name. Called to my work to reposess car knew nothing about it. Had it repossed and cost me. They never spoke to me again and i had trouble getting my first mortgage. Never again not even for dcs. Lesson learned.

Frollop · 17/01/2022 22:21

I forgot to add when I was younger a relative persuaded me to get a joint phone contract with them as it worked out cheaper...they were working. They soon ended up not paying and I had to pay it all...they made me feel uncomfortable and like I couldn't keep asking for the payments as if I was pestering them.

kylesmybaby · 17/01/2022 22:20

@Elieza

The best thing your wife can do is encourage the girl to wait a bit longer.

She will have more points than some because of the baby so she will get a housing association or council property in due course.

It’s the best kind of rental as it has security. Many would bite your hand off for that.

A private let is not the way to go. She just needs to take her “spoiled brat / apple of the mothers eye” attitude and swap it for a reality check.

If your wife really wants to help her she should save up and give the girl the money to do her pad up in due course. Much better idea than guaranteeing payments that could leave you forced to sell your own house to pay any debt for the girl.

This times one hundred 😁
kylesmybaby · 17/01/2022 22:18

Try and get her to wait for a council property or housing association property to come up. With a baby she will get one. The rent will be so much cheaper.

GreenClock · 17/01/2022 22:17

I agree with your concerns OP. What on earth makes your wife think that a teenager on benefits is not - objectively - a financial risk? It’s a huge risk hence the requirement for a guarantor ie a mug who owns their own home.

lemans · 17/01/2022 22:16

Like others have said, don't do it.

I did once for a family member's rent. After a few months, they couldn't pay (genuine as it happened but that doesn't really matter after what happens). As soon as they defaulted, I was next on the hook and had to pay or face proceedings against us both. I paid up and they managed to pick up the payments after three months, but if they had gone on to renew their tenancy, so would my being a guarantor. Without the landlord's permission there would have been no way out of it.

Never again. Not for family or friend.

Elieza · 17/01/2022 22:15

The best thing your wife can do is encourage the girl to wait a bit longer.

She will have more points than some because of the baby so she will get a housing association or council property in due course.

It’s the best kind of rental as it has security. Many would bite your hand off for that.

A private let is not the way to go. She just needs to take her “spoiled brat / apple of the mothers eye” attitude and swap it for a reality check.

If your wife really wants to help her she should save up and give the girl the money to do her pad up in due course. Much better idea than guaranteeing payments that could leave you forced to sell your own house to pay any debt for the girl.

PrincessPaws · 17/01/2022 22:12

Your wife doesn't earn enough so she can't be a guarantor. You would have to be the guarantor which is a bad idea

Justmuddlingalong · 17/01/2022 22:10

DN will promise you the moon if it enables her to have a home for her and her baby. But the reality is, she could default on the rent or cause damage to the property and you will be liable. If she gets into financial trouble, it would be easy for her to scuttle back to her mum's, leaving you to deal with her debt and the enormous family fallout that would undoubtedly follow. I think your DW is being completely naive.

Lysianthus · 17/01/2022 22:05

Another no vote here. Let’s hope your DW is on MN!

JaceLancs · 17/01/2022 22:05

I would only be a guarantor for my DC as they have never let me down and even if they did I would pay to help them
Anyone else including ex DH and ex DP no chance as I couldn’t afford it if they default which is very likely
I’ve been letdown by friends before too which has probably coloured my decision

Fluffycloudland77 · 17/01/2022 22:04

I know two people who’ve done it and it’s gone wrong for them.

Basically it’s the landlords way of saying your high risk.

Frollop · 17/01/2022 22:04

You're wife can't guarantee her niece will be responsible. Noone knows what the future holds...
My friend was a guarantor and was let down she has to make the payments.
I've been asked in the past declined because I'm not willing to take the risk and being a guarantor is a risk. An ex also tried to pressurise me into being one.

In life when making decisions sometimes it's good to think what's the worst that could happen and only go ahead if you can deal with the worst.

I know it sounds negative but it's the reality of what could happen.

hotchocandtwosmokybacon · 17/01/2022 22:03

I would not be a guarantor except for my own daughter. Be prepared to pay up if she cannot pay the rent. Can you and your DW realistically afford that? If she and her own mother cannot satisfy the landlord, I can't help but thinking she is spending beyond her means. I would not want to encouraged that nor get involved.

xfgdhfgnhkk007 · 17/01/2022 22:02

Another one here saying Don't do it. Please make your DW read this thread.

If DW can't cover the niece's costs then the courts will come after YOU, as you are married. It's not worth the risk, only time it may be worth it is for your own kids – and only then if you're sure they're responsible.

I almost became a guarantor for my bf, when he was moving jobs and homes at the same time. I thought it just meant that I vouched for him, that he was a good person and maybe cover the odd rent while he was looking for work. But when I looked into what it meant, no effing way! He was OK about it, we were both shocked when we found out what it actually meant.

TurquoiseDress · 17/01/2022 21:58

This has red flags all over it!

I've never been a guarantor but have friends/acquaintances who have and none of them seem to have had a smooth process, there was stress involved and in one case costing them £££

Think very very carefully before entering into this agreement. And then think again!

Dave20 · 17/01/2022 21:57

Ive no idea how long the term is or the rental cost- I just put £750 as an example, sorry should have said that.
As I understand it, people try to private rent with housing benefit when they don’t or can’t rent with social housing.
I don’t know how housing benefits work or universal credit.
She’s single with a baby. I’ve no idea how much she gets in benefits. Or how much she’d get in housing benefits. Would she really have enough to live on in a flat paid for by the government? ( putting aside the guarantor part).

OP posts:
OnTheBoardwalk · 17/01/2022 21:56

Surely you would have to declare being a guarantor and this will impact your re mortgage applications

Yes it won’t appear on your credit record but you would need to declare it under credit obligations. As you say you can’t afford the monthly rent so it worked impact your affordability score

DeliriaSkibbly · 17/01/2022 21:56

@Dave20

This is the south east, not London. The points I made to DW were that we’re talking about an open financial agreement, and that the benefits system is complex, and housing benefits are complex. DW said- but she’s never asked for money! FFS- she’s missing the point entirely. I said she may not be able to keep up with her payments, even through no fault of her own, and she could be stuck in a contract with her landlord. Meaning we’d be tied to it. How would we pay for it? Why isn’t DW seeing this ? DE said we needed some financial help from family in the past and she’s like to help - yes but I’ve never asked anyone to be a guarantor, that’s a different thing altogether.
I think you need to be firmer with your DW - easier said than done I know.

You need to say to her, very simply, that if your niece misses a payment at any time for any reason then you are automatically liable and ultimately you can lose everything.

Ask your wife how she plans to pay the rent if your niece defaults. If your wife replies "Oh, but she won't" then she's just being unrealistic and you need to say this.

Asking for financial help is very different to being a guarantor.

Let's say your niece's rent for 6 months is £4000. I'm not privy to your finances but assuming you could somehow manage to scrape that together it's a one-off payment and it's done. The worst thing that can happen is you lose £4000. Would this be some sort of compromise you could offer ?

As a guarantor you can literally lose everything - including the roof over your own heads - if the niece defaults.

I agree with a previous poster; show your wife this thread. Literally nobody has said you should do this - everyone has said not to. Whilst we can't know all your circumstances, we can be objective about this.

Ultimately if your wife presses ahead with this I would do as a previous poster suggested and try to keep your finances separate because I fear your niece is simply going to default. It sounds like her family is not as sensible about money as you and I think the temptation to not pay one month because "Uncle Dave20 can cover it and my baby really needs a new [random unnecessary item] this month" will keep rearing it's head, she'll succumb and then she'll keep doing it because once it's done, there's no reason for her not to do it again.

Hillary17 · 17/01/2022 21:49

You can be a guarantor without being a home owner, so she’ll have other options. Personally wouldn’t risk it. She’s 18 and young, you would be liable for the whole tenancy payments and any damages etc.

ChiefStockingStuffer · 17/01/2022 21:44

Would be a Hard No from me.

Madness.

Have her watch a few episodes of 'can't pay? we'll take it away' ... so many family guarantors who would 'never do that' do just that.

DahliaMacNamara · 17/01/2022 21:43

Honestly, it's worrying enough when you have to do this for your own student DC, and that's usually for a very limited period where you can at least to some small extent keep an eye on things, and, if you're rich enough, pay the rent upfront and hope nobody trashes the place. I wouldn't contemplate casually signing away at best my peace of mind and at worst my family's security to keep someone else's child happy for five minutes. She probably has no idea of the reality of what she's asking, and by the sounds of it, neither does your DW.

soapboxqueen · 17/01/2022 21:41

If your DW wants to help she can gift her some money but being a guarantor is very, very risky.

If you can't afford to pay the rent if she defaults, how does your DW expect to pay it? She needs to understand that the LL wants a guarantor because your dn is at a significant risk of defaulting. They didn't pick her name out of a hat. It's happening for a reason.

I know pp have mentioned 'can't pay, we'll take it away' but there was one episode I'll never forget. Mum and dad acted as guarantor for their eldest daughter for a flat. Daughter had a job but hadn't been paying the rent so the balliffs turned up at the parent's door. They owed thousands. The dad was beside himself because he couldn't afford to pay it and the mum just sat in a chair sobbing.

They just didn't have the money.

They tried and tried to get hold of the daughter because they didn't even know she was in arrears (she'd bought a new car and was going on holiday). Eventually she answered the phone and just told them it was their problem.

Which it was because they'd agreed to cover the rent and everything else.

Also, I'm not sure what happens if she defaults but chooses to stay in the flat. Will the LL kick her out or if he's getting paid by you, will the contract just stay in place until she decides otherwise? With you still paying.

SuperLoudPoppingAction · 17/01/2022 21:38

Can't she get her name on the council house waiting list while looking for a private rental property?
And does the local council offer support for new renters?
Ours offers deposits, I think.

SilverHairedCat · 17/01/2022 21:38

OK @ Dave20 - let's pretend she'll be living in Ashford in Kent (first place I thought of for the SE).

As an 18yo single mum (by the sounds of it?) the maximum housing benefit she'll get for private renting of a one bed flat is £625/month. She's already into arrears of £125 every month. I'm pretty sure they will say a baby isn't entitled to a separate bedroom, but even if she was able to get a 2 bed, the max she'd be getting in housing benefit is £725/month, so £25/month arrears.

www.ashford.gov.uk/benefits/local-housing-allowance/

Has anyone actually sat down with your niece and run the figures with her? Go through a budget planner with her - www.moneyhelper.org.uk/en/homes/renting/how-much-rent-can-you-afford - and see if she can acually afford to move out at all.