Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsure about being a guarantor

269 replies

Dave20 · 17/01/2022 19:49

So DWs niece is 18 and has a baby girl. She lives with her mum, DWs sister.
Now she’s a single mother and doesn’t want to be on the council list, as she thinks it’ll take too long.
She can rent privately, but needs a guarantor. You must earn a certain wage and be a home owner, which we are.
Now DW is all up for doing this because she trusts she will pay her rent and wants to help.
I have my reservations. Firstly, she’s only 18, never had a job, never paid a bill and a bit naive like young people can be.I think she’s too excited about the prospect of having a nice little flat, and is impatient to be on the council list.
DW is adamant that her niece will always pay her rent and is sensible enough to not go down the road of not paying.

However, even if she has every intention of paying, what if she can’t pay? DW just said, well in that case, we’d be notified that’s she’s fell behind on her payments and we would have to come to an arrangement. Her mum, DWs sister said she would pay the costs. DWs sister isn’t a home owner and doesn’t earn enough, she can’t be a guarantor herself.
But is it really risky being a guarantor? We have a mortgage and 3 children, we remortgage ever 2-5 years. Will this effect our applications? We have a long time on our mortgage.
What if her rent goes up? Does her benefits pay for this? I have no idea how benefits work personally.
I can’t really stop DW being a guarantor if she wants to, but we’re linked obviously financially.
Would a guarantor be linked financially to the person? Does it affect mortgage and credit applications? Is it for the duration of a tenancy?
Is it too risky?

OP posts:
caringcarer · 18/01/2022 16:26

I love my nieces and nephews and have in the past given them money for things including paying niece £30 a month for 4 years for internet whilst she was at uni and her parents could not afford to help her out, however I would only be a guarantor for 1 of my own children.

cruisecrazy · 18/01/2022 16:00

Belladonna12

Because the OP has said he could not afford to pay the rent. In which case the worst that could happen would be that the landlord took him to court for the rent and the only way he could pay would be to sell his house.

Comefromaway · 18/01/2022 15:54

£750 rent x 12 months is £9,000. Add on a bit for damages and legal costs and if you can't stump up over £10k then your house can be used as security.

Belladonna12 · 18/01/2022 15:45

@cruisecrazy

Do not under any cirumstances do this. You must explain to your wife the consequences if her niece fails to pay her rent, which seems very likely as she has never worked, that you could lose your own house. Has her niece looked into whether she can even afford to rent a flat or what benefits she will receive. Also private landlords will be very wary of renting to a single mother with no job and on benefits. I hope your wife will read these replies and really understand what being a Guarantor really means.
Why would they lose their house?
cruisecrazy · 18/01/2022 15:07

Do not under any cirumstances do this. You must explain to your wife the consequences if her niece fails to pay her rent, which seems very likely as she has never worked, that you could lose your own house. Has her niece looked into whether she can even afford to rent a flat or what benefits she will receive. Also private landlords will be very wary of renting to a single mother with no job and on benefits. I hope your wife will read these replies and really understand what being a Guarantor really means.

Talia99 · 18/01/2022 14:57

The only time anyone should ever be a guarantor is if they intend to pay the bills but want to help the person build credit. I know a number of people who have been guarantor on a loan taken out to buy a cheap car for their child at university but who have kept all the loan documents and made the payments themselves. Since they also paid the insurance, the risk was slight.

Other than that, guarantors are needed because the supplier thinks the risk of non payment is too great to rely on the recipient alone. They are transferring that risk to a third party. Don’t be that third party, OP.

MorningStarling · 18/01/2022 14:37

It's worth bearing in mind that guarantors don't necessarily get told that the person they are guaranteeing is running up debt. A friend of mine was a guarantor on a 12 month tenancy, with tenant or landlord able to serve a month's notice after six months. There was no contact at all until ten months down the line she received (a rather threatening) demand for nine months rent with ten days to pay it or face court action.

The landlord hadn't made any contact as the debt was being accumulated, nor had they tried evicting the tenant for the unpaid debt. There was no need for them to really, they had the guarantor to go after.

HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 14:07

[quote MRSAHILL]@HelloFrostyMorning Everything you've said is spot on. I wish I'd been as steadfast in my refusal to my ds to be his guarantor, as you were to your daughter. I think he sees me as a soft touch as his dad is seriously mentally ill and I am basically like a single parent at times. He finds it easy to wear me down. It would have saved me a lot of worry. Never again. [/quote]
I am sorry to hear that.... Flowers

I know (as a few people have said,) that some people won't be able to get a place, or the loan they want, without a guarantor. But the fact is that some people just can't - and should NOT be a guarantor. Some people will struggle to pay off 1000s of pounds of someone else's debts. As I said earlier, I don't think this should be a thing... NO-ONE should be asked to be a guarantor IMO. It's such a big ask.

Also, I truly believe that some people think that being a guarantor is like giving a character reference to someone. It's not. As has been said, it's a huge undertaking, and you could end up owing THOUSANDS! (I wonder if the OP's wife thinks this???) Is that possible @Dave20 ??? That your wife believes being a guarantor is just like giving a character reference?

bowlingalleyblues · 18/01/2022 13:50

Is there a reason she can’t stay with her mother? Get your wife to talk you through what her plan would be if her niece fails to pay. Would you be able yo end the lease and get her back to her mums without making her homeless? Has your niece or her mum got any savings?

Belladonna12 · 18/01/2022 13:47

Yes, some landlords let you pay a few months upfront rather than have a guarantor. Some landlords will accept guarantors that are not homeowners. There are also agencies which will act as co guarantors with the nieces mother (the agency will sue the mother if the rent isn't paid). There are many other options.

MRSAHILL · 18/01/2022 13:42

@HelloFrostyMorning Everything you've said is spot on. I wish I'd been as steadfast in my refusal to my ds to be his guarantor, as you were to your daughter. I think he sees me as a soft touch as his dad is seriously mentally ill and I am basically like a single parent at times. He finds it easy to wear me down. It would have saved me a lot of worry. Never again.

HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 13:13

@Dave20

All the replies are right of courses She’s 18, single. She lives with her mum and other siblings. A bit crowded, but as others said, she’s an adult. She made choices. I do emphasis and would love DW or me to help, but it’s a big ask..
Has your wife changed her mind?
HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 13:12

@Feduprenter But some landlords will let people move in without a guarantor if they pay the first 6 months rent in advance. I have seen it happen quite a few times.

I know there's other stuff to consider, (like damage to property and eviction fees and so on...,) but the fact is that some landlords/landladies will allow a tenancy with no guarantor if the first 6 months rent is paid upfront. Not all, but some.

thevassal · 18/01/2022 13:08

It is so so easy to get benefits sanctioned and can take months to appeal - your dn would have no money at all so someone (you) would be liable for her flat.

What if dn hates living alone and moves back in with her mum or a new boyfriend. She could be insisting that she's not living there so doesn't have to pay -landlord says tough luck you signed a tenancy agreement for 6 months/a year - you owe me a year's rent - again you are liable.

Lots of other scenarios.

Dave20 · 18/01/2022 13:04

Empathy, not emphasis!

OP posts:
Dave20 · 18/01/2022 13:03

All the replies are right of courses
She’s 18, single. She lives with her mum and other siblings.
A bit crowded, but as others said, she’s an adult. She made choices.
I do emphasis and would love DW or me to help, but it’s a big ask..

OP posts:
Feduprenter · 18/01/2022 12:57

@HelloFrostyMorning

I would rather fork out the first 3 months rent tbh. Which in most cases for uni rooms would be £1250 to £1500 GRAND for those 3 months.

Sorry, just £1500, not £1500 grand!

It doesn’t work like that though this is not just about covering the rent that’s on the tenancy agreement it’s about covering the six months it will take to get you out plus the court fees. And the main one is damage which could be a pack of a lot more than 1500 quid. And that’s why they require a guarantor they don’t want the rent upfront it’s just not the same thing
HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 12:56

Oops, also meant to say if you paid the first 3 to 6 months rent for them, they can pay you back in stages. Or pay some or most of it back... Whatever you all decide.

HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 12:55

I would rather fork out the first 3 months rent tbh. Which in most cases for uni rooms would be £1250 to £1500 GRAND for those 3 months.

Sorry, just £1500, not £1500 grand!

HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 12:52

@Dave20 As several posters have said, the vast VAST majority of unemployed 18 year olds do NOT have their own place. Why does your wife's niece think she should be entitled to this, at YOUR expense?

A number of posters have said they would not do it for anyone but their DC. We would not even do it for them. We were in a precarious financial position when our first DC started at uni - almost 10 years ago - and had a low income, and they shared the uni house with 5 others and were jointly and severally liable.

There's no way we could have forked out multiple 1000s of pounds if DC or any of their mates had defaulted. Fortunately, because they were the only one of 6 without a guarantor (a bunch of 6 friends,) the landlady let her in with no guarantor.

Turns out it was a good choice. She got excited at having some money to herself (student loan) and spent frivolously, and ran out of money quickly. She's an intelligent hard working, responsible young woman now, in her late 20s,) and is good with money now, but at 18, she was a bit reckless.

So long story short, 4 months into her degree (by the January,) she'd only paid one month's rent. She was on the phone crying and admitted she had no money left. We told her we weren't paying it as we simply didn't have the money (at the time.) We said 'you need to sort this out with your landlady...'

Luckily, the landlady was a lady with 7 properties that she rented out to students, and although she wanted the money, as it was her business, she was OK to wait a few months, and was very good and very lenient. By July, DD had caught up and was fully paid up!

It taught her a lesson, as we didn't/couldn't bail her out. (Probably wouldn't if we could have!) After that, she became more responsible with money.

Also, if this had been a strict, not so laidback landlord/lady, and we HAD been her guarantor, I have absolutely no doubt whatsover that they'd have been after us for the £1500 our DD owed.

Some posts on here are terrifying, like the poster who said she is a guarantor for someone who's buggared off and left the agreement and she owes six thousand pounds already. And the official agreement hasn't even taken place yet. Could be nine to ten thousand yet.

Even now, (being in a better financial position,) we STILL wouldn't be a guarantor. As has been said, it's basically an open-ended agreement with no limit. By the time someone is evicted and all the court costs/eviction costs etc are added on, you could owe 5 figures (over ten thousand pounds!)

I would rather fork out the first 3 months rent tbh. Which in most cases for uni rooms would be £1250 to £1500 grand for those 3 months, and around £1700 to £1800 for 3 months for many private let homes (in my area anyway.)

I'd rather pay the first 6 months even (maybe £2500 for a university house room,) than be a guarantor.

If you offered the first 3 months, they may not need a guarantor, and if you paid the first 6, they almost definitely won't need one in most cases. Seems like a lot, but at least you know where you stand, and there will be no nasty surprises of ten thousand pounds plus to pay!

HelloFrostyMorning · 18/01/2022 12:52

@Dave20 Hope you have talked your wife out of it!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/01/2022 12:28

I’m thinking of saying no anyway, so DW wouldn’t have a choice as she doesn’t earn enough

Very wise of you, OP
Practically everything you've said about her blood family comes down to airy-fairy "Oooo she'll be fine" or "Oooo we could sort it out", and it seems none of them have the money to back this up
No doubt they'd all be very sorry and full of excuses if it all went wrong, but that wouldn't get you off the hook would it?

With guarantors and everything else, wanting isn't the same as getting and I wouldn't touch this with a bargepole

Belladonna12 · 18/01/2022 12:21

I think that many (perhaps most) parents of students have to guarantee the rent as there is no other way of them getting accommodation, usually. However, I've never been asked if I was a homeowner. I know some landlords do but I think the niece has to go with a landlord who will just accept her mother's guarantee even if she is not a homeowner. Alternatively, the mother should lend the niece money to pay a few months rent upfront. After all, she had said she would pay the rent if her daughter fails to so she obviously can afford it.

Comefromaway · 18/01/2022 11:53

@Medievalist

What’s the chances of DW being accepted on her own then? She works part time on 10 k per year?

In this case, from my experience, she wouldn't be accepted as a guarantor.

I've acted as guarantor in the past for my ds. He moved last year after my income dropped and the letting agency told me it was no longer high enough for me to act as guarantor. My income is quite a bit higher than your dw's. DH and I are property owners and I offered joint bank account statements showing healthy income and relatively low outgoings (illustrating that we could afford to pay ds's rent should he default). But because I didn't hit the magic income mark they wouldn't accept me, and DH had to do it (ironic as we only have a joint bank account).

So I think you are probably worrying unnecessarily - unless your DW asks you to act as guarantor?

I agree.

I was initially turned down for my dd's guarantor because the letting agency mislaid my dividend certificate so thought I only earned £10k per year. This was despite me and dh owning a mortgage free property with significant savings from the sale of our old property.

HappydaysArehere · 18/01/2022 11:01

I did that for my dd and it worried me so much I swore I would never do it again. Luckily she moved and the next landlord didn’t require.one. I told her then that I wouldn’t be able to do it again.