Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Unsure about being a guarantor

269 replies

Dave20 · 17/01/2022 19:49

So DWs niece is 18 and has a baby girl. She lives with her mum, DWs sister.
Now she’s a single mother and doesn’t want to be on the council list, as she thinks it’ll take too long.
She can rent privately, but needs a guarantor. You must earn a certain wage and be a home owner, which we are.
Now DW is all up for doing this because she trusts she will pay her rent and wants to help.
I have my reservations. Firstly, she’s only 18, never had a job, never paid a bill and a bit naive like young people can be.I think she’s too excited about the prospect of having a nice little flat, and is impatient to be on the council list.
DW is adamant that her niece will always pay her rent and is sensible enough to not go down the road of not paying.

However, even if she has every intention of paying, what if she can’t pay? DW just said, well in that case, we’d be notified that’s she’s fell behind on her payments and we would have to come to an arrangement. Her mum, DWs sister said she would pay the costs. DWs sister isn’t a home owner and doesn’t earn enough, she can’t be a guarantor herself.
But is it really risky being a guarantor? We have a mortgage and 3 children, we remortgage ever 2-5 years. Will this effect our applications? We have a long time on our mortgage.
What if her rent goes up? Does her benefits pay for this? I have no idea how benefits work personally.
I can’t really stop DW being a guarantor if she wants to, but we’re linked obviously financially.
Would a guarantor be linked financially to the person? Does it affect mortgage and credit applications? Is it for the duration of a tenancy?
Is it too risky?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
HelloFrostyMorning · 19/01/2022 12:54

Great result @Dave20 Smile

Tabitha888 · 19/01/2022 11:25

Oh thank god it's not happening 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻

RozHuntleysStump · 18/01/2022 21:46

We’re guarantor for our son but I think that’s different. I don’t know if I’d want to do it for a niece. I don’t think you have to be a homeowner. Just have a steady income.

Bouledeneige · 18/01/2022 21:42

I have been guarantor for my DDs rental agreement for the last 2 years with a private landlord whilst she's at university. I re-mortgaged last April for my new home and it never came up with my mortgage provider.

You shouldn't act as a guarantor if you can't afford it though.

MaggieFS · 18/01/2022 20:05

Hooray. And phew.

Dave20 · 18/01/2022 19:35

Apologies again- can’t believe I forgot to mention the baby’s dad. Yes I hardly know him, but he’s in the background occasionally.
They aren’t together.

Update- I got home from work in the last few minutes. It seems DW agrees with what I said last night. She also mentioned this to a school mum friend who said something like “ don’t do it! You’ll need a blank cheque book for a limitless problem!

So sense has sunk in. Being a guarantor is not a wise move. Shame she didn’t think of this straight away though!
I’ll also add that DN was fine about it, and didn’t actually ask DW, it was DW who said she’d consider it.
I’ve looked at the website someone posted about a company that for a fee, will act as a guarantor.
Maybe she should consider that, or other options.
Thanks for all your replies.

OP posts:
Ginger1982 · 18/01/2022 19:34

Yup, don't do this. Your DN has chosen to have a child and it's up to her to provide. If your DW wants to help, perhaps you could agree on a sum of money to gift her on a one off basis.

Dave20 · 18/01/2022 19:29

Oh sorry. Yes the father of the baby. I just read that I haven’t mentioned him at all.
He’s 19 I think. Smokes a bit of weed, lives local and she hasn’t gone after him for money through the CSA or anything. I think he occasionally sees the child, when it suits him.
A bit of a waste of space , only met him once.

OP posts:
MadMadMadamMim · 18/01/2022 19:23

What about the father of the baby, OP?

Is your DN still with him? Is he working? Is he contributing any money to baby's needs?

Wetellyourstory · 18/01/2022 19:16

I would ask how the DN is funding everything needed to set up this flat? Will it be furnished/unfurnished, kitchen items, TV/ Agency letting fees/ security deposit/requirement for one months rent in advance? If she has enough money to cover all these other costs associated with the rental (which she may not have even considered) then she can use these funds to pay for a company to act as guarantor and you/DW can support by buying items for the flat. You’re still supporting then but not taking on an unlimited liability that could have disastrous consequences for your family finances.

SheldonesqueTheBstard · 18/01/2022 19:12

I think DN’s mam is fairly switched on.

DN moves out - financial responsibility passed to someone else. No need to be a built in babysitter. No sleep disturbed.

Job done.

Dave20 · 18/01/2022 18:50

DN’s father , separated from my SIL ( wife’s sister) when she was a baby. They do see each other but I don’t think he’s the greatest dad in the world.
He’s not able to help in that way. I handy had much to do with him, DN was about 4 when I first met her.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/01/2022 18:38

PP means the baby's father presumably

You're right, I did
It seems a little odd that he's not been mentioned at all, despite several posters asking what the situation there is

iloverunningslow · 18/01/2022 18:03

My dad, who is a millionaire and a financial adviser, always told me he would never be a guarantor for anyone. He is an extremely generous person and would happily have put up six months deposit for example but he could never have afforded an uncapped liability as in being a guarantor.
For example, if the niece falls on hard times, benefits get stopped, runs up debt, gets ill and can't work etc, she won't get a council place until she is evicted. But why would landlord go through the pain of eviction when someone is on the hook to pay in perpetuity?

ChargingBuck · 18/01/2022 18:00

DN is either bizarrely naive or hugely entitled.

She's chosen to have a baby at 18, despite not having her own roof over her head or a job.

Now she wants a flat, & is looking to you & DW to fund it.

Her intentions may not be that black & white, but the effect is the same. Somebody needs to give DN a reality check.

user1471442488 · 18/01/2022 17:58

You would be absolutely mad to act as a guarantor in this situation.

PermanentTemporary · 18/01/2022 17:54

I doubt very much they're trying it on. I should think they're just not very good at looking ahead or dealing with really painful decisions. Such as (sorry) whether to go ahead and have a baby with no job, no training or education on the cards, no plan, apparently no partner and 4 other people in the house. I would say it was a brave thing to do and it will be, if your DN uses this experience to grow up and get their teeth into working, childcare and all the requirements of adulthood. But at the time... it sounds like it wasn't much of a brave decision.

sanbeiji · 18/01/2022 17:38

@Dave20

To be honest I’m not sure that DN asked her. I think she told her the situation and DW suggested she could maybe do it, subject to her asking me. I don’t like the thought that I’m slagging my DWs family off, but I wanted to check I wasn’t being unreasonable! DN’s dad doesn’t have his own home and isn’t financially secure himself. I don’t know him that well to be honest, but he separated from her mum when she was about 2.
PP means the baby's father presumably
Dave20 · 18/01/2022 17:33

To be honest I’m not sure that DN asked her. I think she told her the situation and DW suggested she could maybe do it, subject to her asking me.
I don’t like the thought that I’m slagging my DWs family off, but I wanted to check I wasn’t being unreasonable!
DN’s dad doesn’t have his own home and isn’t financially secure himself. I don’t know him that well to be honest, but he separated from her mum when she was about 2.

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/01/2022 17:31

her mother has most likely been the most influential in terms of the niece's financial acumen so this doesn't bode well

Another very valid point, and I wonder just what the chances are that they've both worked out where the "available money" is and tried it on?

Also where's the child's father in this? I expect you'll probably say he's a waster, but even wasters can be persued for money ... have they tried?

sanbeiji · 18/01/2022 17:21

Does bad financial sense run in your wife's family?
We've all made stupid financial decisions (well I have at least) but...

  • Your niece already has a safe home
  • Has never worked and has a baby
  • Just google 'risks of being a guarantor' and loads of horror stories etc pop up.

I hope your household money management isn't done by your wife...

Tabitha888 · 18/01/2022 17:16

OP please update us when you can. Honestly so worried for you! No offence by DN sounds a little deluded. We've got a baby on the way, it's gonna be a struggle with two of us! She's so selfish to ask you both to do this!

Puzzledandpissedoff · 18/01/2022 17:09

They don’t have savings and her mum has a historic bad credit rating

It gets worse doesn't it?

And no, she probably can't really afford rent, bills and to eat properly as well, but then if you were misguided enough to underwrite her there's every chance she wouldn't bother herself about it

Dontfuckingsaycheese · 18/01/2022 17:01

This is on Radio 4 tomorrow. Maybe you could pop this on..

Unsure about being a guarantor
Dave20 · 18/01/2022 16:57

Her mum lives in social housing with her three other children. DN is the eldest and obviously has a baby.
They don’t have savings and her mum has a historic bad credit rating.
I’m all for helping family. I’d consider being a guarantor for a mobile phone, even maybe a car. But a property is a big things.
I don’t understand universal credit, or benefits or housing benefits.
If I don’t understand something, it’s foolish to get involved in it. Benefits is a complex system isn’t it?
All because her 18 year old niece has rushed into a decision to go private , because she wants a cosy flat.
I’ve no idea that anyone has properly spoken to her about her affordability. I can’t personally see how a young lone single parent clan rent a property and pay all bills and have enough to buy shopping on.
It’s a big gamble to simple say- let’s give her a chance to see if she can do it.
As someone else said, the world changed very quickly in 2020, to a world none of us have seen before. People lost their livelihoods, their incomes in a short space of time.
I haven’t seen DW today yet as I was at work early but if she still doesn’t respect my concerns, then that’s another matter...

OP posts: