Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable? Holiday situation in a blended family

210 replies

OnlyInOne · 17/01/2022 19:29

Perhaps not unreasonable as I can also see DHs point but more a WWYD?

I will try and keep it as short as possible.

I have one son with my husband who has another two DC from a previous relationship. Our son is 2 nearly 3, my DSC are 9 & 11.

My parents have asked if me DH and DS would like to go away with them this year, their treat to a nice destination. It would be outside of school holidays as understandably that's when my parents prefer to holiday!

We have never been abroad on holiday with any of the DC. DSC have been with their mother but never us (we have had holidays in the UK before with them).

So here's the dilemma, DH is obviously concerned about it seeming unfair if we take DS away without DSC. We can't afford it ourselves in the school holidays and I can't expect my parents to both change it to school holiday time and pay for two more people but of course, DSC likely wouldn't see it that way and I totally understand DHs concern.

Here is where I'm not sure who's unreasonable... I have then suggested that I go alone with DS and my parents and DH stays home with DSC. I do not want to pass up the opportunity of a holiday for DS, one that we couldn't afford ourselves, and yes for myself as well.

DH is understanding of this and said that's fine but he has also admitted he wishes I wouldn't go because he feels in a no win situation where he misses DS's first holiday and should be there but can't go because it's not fair on DSC. He is still okay with me going though, but I know it has upset him.

I have said if I do go, we should prioritise savings for a family holiday next year in the school holidays with everyone.

So... WWYD? Do I go still? I want to, but I don't know if I'm being unfair to DH.

YABU - you're being unfair to go without DH, none of you should go.

YANBU - you should go and not pass up the opportunity for DS to holiday with grandparents.

OP posts:
Chloemol · 17/01/2022 21:10

Your dh needs to understand his two older children also have other grandparents they can go away with, just as they have been abroad with their mother

In this case your parents have offered the three of you, their immediate family the offer of a holiday, why should they pay for two other two and move to school holidays?

The kids are old enough to understand that your Karen’s may purchase the odd thing for them, but in this case want to holiday with you and your son, just as they can go on holiday with their other grandparents. Likewise they can understand that they have been abroad with their mother, and in this case the opportunity is there for their younger half sibling

You will have holidays with them at some point

So go, with or without him

Chimley · 17/01/2022 21:10

Does your DS get taken on holiday by your DSC's mum?

Thought not. You're absolutely fine to go on holiday without your DSC.

Ponoka7 · 17/01/2022 21:09

I agree that children should be treated fairly and that doesn't mean the same. Your DH had holidays with his children before your child was born. Even in none blended families, it's fair that activities/holidays are split because of age appropriateness etc.

MsAnnFrope · 17/01/2022 21:08

Your DH is choosing to miss out. We have a blended family, when DD was preschool age we did things in term time with her that we didn’t do with DSC. Now they are all in school we do stuff together but sometimes go away me, DH and DD when DSC are away with their mum.
All the DC get treats and holidays but these are sometimes spread around at different times.
DSD and DSS do lots with their mum which is great, sometimes DD does stuff just with me. Everyone seems fairly happy bar the usual teenage and tweenage strops!

halfgirlhalfturnip · 17/01/2022 21:06

You go with your son. You are both over thinking it. If it is a priority that you all go then plan accordingly next year - this is a lovely gift and your son will love it.

Gooseberrypies · 17/01/2022 21:06

No, I’d be really annoyed at him. It has nothing to do with his children. Your parents are the ones paying, and they aren’t DSC grandparents. It’s a gift from them to their family members, which DSC aren’t. Their own grandparents are welcome to take them if they want to, and absolutely no way would my DC be missing out because of it. It would be different if you were planning and paying for the holiday. Presumably DSCs mother won’t be inviting your DC on any trips just to make it fair?

Starseeking · 17/01/2022 21:06

You're in for a bumpy ride if your DH believes he has to forgo a free holiday with his own child to make up to his other DC who weren't actually invited. You'll end up living as a single married woman, i.e. married, but having to behave as if you are single of your DH doesn't pull his head out of his arse in relation to his other DC.

I'd accept the holiday for your DS, you and your DH. If your DH chooses not to go due to some misguided loyalty, expect this type of thing to happen over and over again.

*is it obvious that I've been where you are, and left a situation where my DC were treated as second class citizens by their own father?!?

cosmicbabe · 17/01/2022 21:06

Well it's an easy one as it's in school time so the DSC can't go anyway as they are at school. Easy!

sadpapercourtesan · 17/01/2022 21:05

For me there's nothing inherently wrong with your parents only wanting you pay for you and your child, but the issue is whether your DH comes, which makes it a "family holiday".

Do the DSC have grandparents of their own who would be likely to treat them to a holiday without your child? Is their mother in a position to take them on holidays? If not, and the only chance of a holiday they would have would be with their father, then I don't think he should go away without them.

If the proposed trip would encompass any of their usual contact time, then I also don't think he should be going away without them.

6464zz · 17/01/2022 21:04

So would you be going on the week off? If so, I'd definitely go.

JugglingJanuary · 17/01/2022 21:04

I think he just feels a bit stuck, he'd love to come and experience DS's first holiday but feels like he can't because he'd feel too guilty not going with DSC

Well, he's being daft. Tell him
If his ex's parents offer to take him in holiday, all expenses paid, with his older DC he's welcome to go.

He can't opt out if DS's life because he can't do exactly the same thing with his older children!

OnlyInOne · 17/01/2022 21:04

@6464zz

How often do you see your stepchildren? Would they even know you're gone? If not then it's a no brainer for me. If it means they miss out on normal contact time then I'm not sure, I think DH would have to stay.
50% one week on one week off.
OP posts:
OniferousWasp · 17/01/2022 21:03

When DSC went on holiday with their mum, did they feel sorry that your DS couldn’t go?
Your DH should do with you, DS and your parents because it’ll be within the school term.
If he definitely doesn’t want to go, he should keep his guilt inside his head and leave you to go and enjoy your holiday abroad!

OnlyInOne · 17/01/2022 21:03

@tanstaafl

Is it possible he doesn’t fancy the idea of a blended holiday and the DSC are being used as an excuse ?
No he seems genuinely upset about it/ not sure what to do.
OP posts:
tanstaafl · 17/01/2022 21:02

Is it possible he doesn’t fancy the idea of a blended holiday and the DSC are being used as an excuse ?

6464zz · 17/01/2022 21:02

How often do you see your stepchildren? Would they even know you're gone? If not then it's a no brainer for me.
If it means they miss out on normal contact time then I'm not sure, I think DH would have to stay.

OnlyInOne · 17/01/2022 21:02

I think it would be unreasonable to exclude your DSC from such a trip

It's not really my trip to exclude or include anyone on though. It's my parents holiday which we have been invited on. I can't turn around and insist they include DSC.

Plus DH isn't upset about that, he agrees it's not for my parents to take DSC away.

OP posts:
JugglingJanuary · 17/01/2022 21:00

@StrawberryFever

I don't understand people saying it's not fair that you and your ds miss out on a trip because your DSC have to miss out.

If, in a non-blended family grandparents were willing to pay for a holiday for one child only, everyone would be saying it's not fair to favour one child like that - it's all or none, not focusing on those who had been favoured missing out on the opportunity.
Note, I'm not saying that the gps in this situation are unfairly favouring one child - obviously it's different for their grandchild Vs step-grandchildren, but that, I think the argument focusing on you and your ds is misleading.

If this were an every day trip I'd say you were being reasonable, BUT this is your ds's first trip abroad and a special one off trip for the rest of you, I think it would be unreasonable to exclude your DSC from such a trip.

If you can't afford the extra to pay for your DSC to join you/ go in the holidays I think you should decline, save up and go another year when you can afford to have everyone go.

Nope, couldn't disagree more.
JugglingJanuary · 17/01/2022 20:59

@OnlyInOne.

I didn't vote because neither option was how I feel!

DH is being unreasonable.

He decided to have a child with you. He can't 'shortchange your child together because he has other children. The children cannot be treat equally all the time because they ALSO have mothers & maternal families. His older children have been on holidays, his older children get things from their mum & her family, just as your child can get things from you and your family.

You DS & DS ARE being treat by YOUR parents. You haven't saved DH's wages and chosen not to take his other children, it's completely different . Does he presume to tell his ex inlaws & his ex that they can't do anything without your DS?

Holiday aside... you don't have to treat children the same, to treat them fairly!

There are going to be all kinds of things that come up over the years. Is DH not going be a dad to your DS because he can't do the same thing with his older children? Is he not going to take DS to swimming lessons or football - because he can't take all 3 kids?

I don't feel like I'm explaining it well, but he needs to be fair to all the kids, but fair doesn't mean identical - but doing your best for them all.

buckeejit · 17/01/2022 20:59

Dh should go & just bring back a nice gift for dc. It won't always be possible to treat them all the same.

Also I'd buy the gift at home first so I didn't have to worry on hols & just get a wee keyring or something while away

Bigettywitch · 17/01/2022 20:58

Yanbu…go!

StrawberryFever · 17/01/2022 20:57

I don't understand people saying it's not fair that you and your ds miss out on a trip because your DSC have to miss out.

If, in a non-blended family grandparents were willing to pay for a holiday for one child only, everyone would be saying it's not fair to favour one child like that - it's all or none, not focusing on those who had been favoured missing out on the opportunity.
Note, I'm not saying that the gps in this situation are unfairly favouring one child - obviously it's different for their grandchild Vs step-grandchildren, but that, I think the argument focusing on you and your ds is misleading.

If this were an every day trip I'd say you were being reasonable, BUT this is your ds's first trip abroad and a special one off trip for the rest of you, I think it would be unreasonable to exclude your DSC from such a trip.

If you can't afford the extra to pay for your DSC to join you/ go in the holidays I think you should decline, save up and go another year when you can afford to have everyone go.

AutumnLeaves21 · 17/01/2022 20:56

I would go. I understand you don’t want your husband to miss out but it’s his own decision. I agree with everything previous posters have said.

Larryyourwaiter · 17/01/2022 20:56

I’m from a large family. We only started going abroad when my elder siblings grew up/moved out as it’s when my parents could afford it.
Technically it could be seen unfair but it’s just the way it was. Nothing is ever totally equal.

I’m all for you not going abroad of SC can’t go, if they also don’t go on holiday with their mum. It’s nonsense. Nothing will ever be equal.

olympicsrock · 17/01/2022 20:55

Of course you should go. DSC are older and can’t take advantage of cheap term time holidays.
DH should join you and enjoy it.
You can still all do a family holiday, treat this one as an extra.

Are DSC never allowed to do anything with their mother’s family either? Ridiculous!

Swipe left for the next trending thread