Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who is being unreasonable? Holiday situation in a blended family

210 replies

OnlyInOne · 17/01/2022 19:29

Perhaps not unreasonable as I can also see DHs point but more a WWYD?

I will try and keep it as short as possible.

I have one son with my husband who has another two DC from a previous relationship. Our son is 2 nearly 3, my DSC are 9 & 11.

My parents have asked if me DH and DS would like to go away with them this year, their treat to a nice destination. It would be outside of school holidays as understandably that's when my parents prefer to holiday!

We have never been abroad on holiday with any of the DC. DSC have been with their mother but never us (we have had holidays in the UK before with them).

So here's the dilemma, DH is obviously concerned about it seeming unfair if we take DS away without DSC. We can't afford it ourselves in the school holidays and I can't expect my parents to both change it to school holiday time and pay for two more people but of course, DSC likely wouldn't see it that way and I totally understand DHs concern.

Here is where I'm not sure who's unreasonable... I have then suggested that I go alone with DS and my parents and DH stays home with DSC. I do not want to pass up the opportunity of a holiday for DS, one that we couldn't afford ourselves, and yes for myself as well.

DH is understanding of this and said that's fine but he has also admitted he wishes I wouldn't go because he feels in a no win situation where he misses DS's first holiday and should be there but can't go because it's not fair on DSC. He is still okay with me going though, but I know it has upset him.

I have said if I do go, we should prioritise savings for a family holiday next year in the school holidays with everyone.

So... WWYD? Do I go still? I want to, but I don't know if I'm being unfair to DH.

YABU - you're being unfair to go without DH, none of you should go.

YANBU - you should go and not pass up the opportunity for DS to holiday with grandparents.

OP posts:
saraclara · 17/01/2022 22:27

Oh, and preventing you and your DC from doing things because HE would miss out (due only to his misplaced guilt) will one day ruin your relationship. Because he is setting up a pattern which will cause huge resentment. Between him and you, him and his child with you, and him and your parents.

saraclara · 17/01/2022 22:25

@gah2teenagers

He was the one who moved on with a 2nd family he needs to get over himself telling you what to do. Go and enjoy yourselves.
Yep.

Also why should his child with you not get to have his dad with him on holiday? That's not being fair.
You DH needs to recognise that there is no way his children with two different women can always be treated the same. It's just impossible..they have different homes and different lives.

There is no way to live a normal life if he's going to refuse to do things if they don't satisfy all three children. For starterd they're very different ages. They're not going to expect to do the same things..

jelly79 · 17/01/2022 22:24

I think you go on the holiday with DS

Your DH has 4 choices

  • pay for them to go if appropriate timing / can take out of school
  • take them somewhere separate that's affordable on his own
  • not go anywhere
  • explain It to them and go with you

All reasonable. You not going isn't reasonable

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/01/2022 22:20

Just to clarify - I don’t think he’s being ridiculous in not wanting to go himself - I think he’s right there.

I think he’s being ridiculous in suggesting that you and Ds not go, or that “missing out on his first holiday” in any way matters or is a thing.

ImFree2doasiwant · 17/01/2022 22:19

You should go and he should go with you. What happens if DSC go abroad with their mother?

gah2teenagers · 17/01/2022 22:17

He was the one who moved on with a 2nd family he needs to get over himself telling you what to do. Go and enjoy yourselves.

Whyisitsodifficult · 17/01/2022 22:17

Surely if the holiday is in term time his kids will be in school? He should go it’s not fair on you or your child by not going.

BitcherOfBlakiven · 17/01/2022 22:16

I fucking hate this.

Why should your DC miss out on his DGPs taking him abroad? No. They’re doing nothing wrong, and neither are you.

Go on the holiday.

DH can do as he wishes but don’t let him put all his Dad guilt on you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/01/2022 22:16

I think your DH is being ridiculous, and when he says it’s a “no win” he’s only looking at it from his own POV.

You should absolutely go OP. No sense in you missing out on a paid for holiday.

I can see the sense in your DH not coming because he probably doesn’t have limitless annual leave (who does?) and probably shouldn’t be using it up in term time rather than in the holidays when he can be around all of his DC (albeit not abroad).

I think it’s best that just you and DS go. It wouldn’t be the end of the world if he went without his older DC (your SDC)) in that yes they have other holidays, except for the limited annual leave point imo.

CharityDingle · 17/01/2022 22:14

@dopenguinsdance

Apart from anything else, why is it fair to impose 2 (unrelated to them) children on your parents during their holiday? Your DSC aren't old enough to be left unsupervised and I can imagine the holiday will end up revolving around what they want to do, or can do. If the facilites at your parent's chosen destination aren't right for your DSC, it might even mean that your parents don't get to go somewhere they want, . A two year old is much more portable and easier to entertain. I imagine tht your parents are looking forward to spending time with you, your DH and their grandchild and that's the point of their offer. Like PP have said you DH is being overly sensitive and isn't considering everyone ( you and your DC) equally.
+1 to this.

OP, go go go!

MsAnnFrope · 17/01/2022 22:14

@SecretKeeper1

If I were him I’d speak to your step children first and explain the situation, with a sweetener, a promise of something they’d like to do like a trip out somewhere with dad. And then he should talk to their mum. That way everyone is aware that it’s a treat from your sons grandparents while you can still do term time.

How long would it be for? Can you go away without impacting on the step kids time with you?

I think this is good advice. So much of managing a blended family is good communication.
Allycott · 17/01/2022 22:11

@LethargicActress

It’s sad how many people have so little regard for the feelings of the older children.

Presumably the DH is hesitant to go because he feels it would be unfair the older children, and they would feel it was unfair too. You can try and justify why he should go on holiday with only one out of his three children, but none of those made up reasons would stop two children feeling like they’re being left behind. Especially if it meant any change to their normal 50/50 contact, which it might well do by a day at least if the holiday is a week long.

It is irrelevant that the step children have been on holiday with their dad before, because no one had to watch their dad go on holiday with their sibling but not them. Same for the ridiculous point that the older children’s mum doesn’t take OPs child on holiday, or that they could go on holiday with their own grandparents. There is a big difference between those situations, because no parent is going on holiday with one of their children and not the others.

I'm no expert but I would imagine children whose parents go on to have other children start to feel left behind from that point forward never mind when it comes to high days and holidays
andweallsingalong · 17/01/2022 22:10

Agree that you should go.

Could DH spin it that it's your parents treat and they can't go because they are at school, but he will take them on a special trip just the three of them?

Doesn't have to be as expensive per head as a family holiday and obviously 3 people are cheaper than if you and joint DC also went. Maybe an adventure camping holiday?

Dashel · 17/01/2022 22:04

I can see both sides to this and it’s tough, but regardless of whether DH goes, I would start being proactive about a family holiday next year, looking at holidays, putting together a budget and savings plan, a separate pot so that it actually happens and you can discuss future plans with the DC.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 17/01/2022 22:03

@sadpapercourtesan

Projecting what? Confused

Not everybody who see things differently from you is projecting. That's a rather dim assumption.

The DSC going away with their mother is completely different, as other posters have patiently explained, because nobody is watching their parent take a sibling on holiday and leave them behind.

Ah right, so the SDC are allowed nice things regardless of the DC, but the DC cannot have anything the SDC can't. Ah, equality!

It's like the youngest DC isn't even a real person sometimes.

Beamur · 17/01/2022 22:03

You, DH and your DS should go on this holiday and be happy and grateful to your generous parents.
Kids in non blended families don't always get exactly the same things either.
DH and I have been away together/with our DD/with our SC (his older children). The SC have had some brilliant holidays with their Mum and sometimes their Mum went on holiday without them.
Your DH needs to have a think about this. The kids are growing up in different ways and will not have identical lives and experiences. Fair is not necessarily having exactly the same.

BigYellowHat · 17/01/2022 22:02

Well they do have a mother who can take them and you mention that she HAS taken them. I don’t really see a problem here. The people treating you are going at a time when the DSC can’t attend the holiday anyway, otherwise I’m sure you would have paid for them to come.

SecretKeeper1 · 17/01/2022 22:00

If I were him I’d speak to your step children first and explain the situation, with a sweetener, a promise of something they’d like to do like a trip out somewhere with dad. And then he should talk to their mum. That way everyone is aware that it’s a treat from your sons grandparents while you can still do term time.

How long would it be for? Can you go away without impacting on the step kids time with you?

sadpapercourtesan · 17/01/2022 21:59

Projecting what? Confused

Not everybody who see things differently from you is projecting. That's a rather dim assumption.

The DSC going away with their mother is completely different, as other posters have patiently explained, because nobody is watching their parent take a sibling on holiday and leave them behind.

dopenguinsdance · 17/01/2022 21:59

Apart from anything else, why is it fair to impose 2 (unrelated to them) children on your parents during their holiday? Your DSC aren't old enough to be left unsupervised and I can imagine the holiday will end up revolving around what they want to do, or can do. If the facilites at your parent's chosen destination aren't right for your DSC, it might even mean that your parents don't get to go somewhere they want, . A two year old is much more portable and easier to entertain. I imagine tht your parents are looking forward to spending time with you, your DH and their grandchild and that's the point of their offer. Like PP have said you DH is being overly sensitive and isn't considering everyone ( you and your DC) equally.

MsAnnFrope · 17/01/2022 21:57

@LethargicActress @sadpapercourtesan projecting much? For all you know the older kids won’t feel left behind or disadvantaged.
I’d hope the OP, her DH and all three kids will have time away together in the school
Holidays.
If her DH wants to cut off his nose to spite his face fine. His choice.

Flickflak · 17/01/2022 21:57

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

Jumpingintomenopause · 17/01/2022 21:55

Given you have your SDC week on week off would the holiday interfere with this schedule?

If so I would agree your DH staying hime is the fairest course.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 17/01/2022 21:54

@LethargicActress

It’s sad how many people have so little regard for the feelings of the older children.

Presumably the DH is hesitant to go because he feels it would be unfair the older children, and they would feel it was unfair too. You can try and justify why he should go on holiday with only one out of his three children, but none of those made up reasons would stop two children feeling like they’re being left behind. Especially if it meant any change to their normal 50/50 contact, which it might well do by a day at least if the holiday is a week long.

It is irrelevant that the step children have been on holiday with their dad before, because no one had to watch their dad go on holiday with their sibling but not them. Same for the ridiculous point that the older children’s mum doesn’t take OPs child on holiday, or that they could go on holiday with their own grandparents. There is a big difference between those situations, because no parent is going on holiday with one of their children and not the others.

Presumably they don't think it's unfair on their half sibling when they go on holiday with their mum and half sibling goes nowhere?

Swings and roundabouts.

sunlovingcriminal · 17/01/2022 21:52

@Hollywolly1

Of course her dh wants to bring his 2 older children as he's obviously a good father
Did you read the thread? Op's parents are paying. It's outside of term time so bringing his other two kids isn't an option... as it would mean the entire party having to pay school holiday prices for their break.

Are you saying if op's husband doesn't bring his other two kids, that he isn't a good father?!

Sometimes I feel like I live in a parallel universe where the very essence of sensibility and being reasonable has evaporated. His other kids will be at school during the day, with their mother in the evenings, and the op and her husband will put money towards a family holiday next year. In the meantime, the sc will probably have another holiday abroad with their mother.

Give your head a little wobble.