Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this a love actually scenario?

60 replies

Isthislikeloveactually · 17/01/2022 15:32

Inspired by another thread, just wondering what impression others get of this.
Several Christmases ago when I had two DCs under 2, I found a kindle in DHs car. I thought it was for me so said nothing. But lo and behold it never showed up on Christmas Day. Turned out it was for his junior (married) female colleague who he said had deserved it because she was brilliant and they got on really well. He vehemently denied it was anything more than friendship and said he would never cheat.
He’s never bought such a gift - or any gift - for any other colleague, before or since.
I met her and her family. Seemed ok. They no longer work together but I know are still in touch as friends…occasional coffees and chats and know what’s going on in each other’s lives.
We’ve had our ups and downs but currently we seem to be getting on well. He can go a bit distant at times, maybe once a year for a few weeks, just seems distracted and a bit irritable, then snaps out of it. I can be like that too occasionally but I also snap out of it. I’ve never suspected him of cheating with anyone else.
What would people make of the kindle?

OP posts:
NeedAHoliday2021 · 17/01/2022 16:43

If my dh was buying a gift for his deputy he usually would run his idea by me. Although one year he asked me to get her something and I wasn’t thinking properly. I know her and bought her a bracelet in her style. Dh was a little mortified at giving jewellery but decided she would line it so we wrote the card from us both and he gave it to her declaring dw chose it (so it didn’t look dodgy). But then that’s my relationship so I guess it depends how weird it is for your dh.

ninjafoodienovice · 17/01/2022 16:28

I was given a gift at work once, a really generous one to do with a hobby/interest shared with an older male colleague.
I really liked the gift but then not long after he made a pass at me and it seriously tainted the gift. Naively I thought it was really kind as we shared this interest. He then went on to seriously harass me at work and really try it on. If his wife had seen the gift she probably wouldn't have even noticed it (or been interested by it) as it wouldn't have been seen as obviously intimate. I guess what I'm trying to say is that it doesn't need to be an intimate object to have intimate sentiments with which it's given.
I hope I'm wrong in your case OP.

LifeExperience · 17/01/2022 16:25

He hid the Kindle. He knew it was wrong. He still maintains a personal relationship with her even though he knows it bothers you. That is not only morally wrong, it is hugely disrespectful of you and your marriage. A truly innocent husband, having been confronted about the Kindle, would take the utmost care to guard your feelings by having only the most minimal and required contact with the other woman going forward. He didn't do that. He is either having an emotional or physical affair. Either way, he has broken his marriage vows. What you do with that knowledge going forward is up to you.

Palavah · 17/01/2022 16:22

[quote Isthislikeloveactually]@palavah
At the time, about the same amount would have been spent on me as on her.[/quote]
Yeah, that's not really on, is it?
Was he buying birthday and Christmas gifts for his family too or were you sorting that?

Ploppy1322 · 17/01/2022 16:20

You don't buy expensive gifts like kindles for work colleagues, I'd bet there's more to it, especially as he didn't mention it Tbh

Newgirls · 17/01/2022 16:15

@Bluebluemoon39

I don't think it necessarily means they had an affair or anything but it suggests your dh had feelings for her that were more than just friendly.

Once when I worked in an office a much older (married) man bought me a gift which was quite personal for my 21st birthday. It was completely inappropriate and I was embarrassed. I distanced myself from him after that as I was worried he'd taken our chats (we did get along and had a similar sense of humour) the wrong way.
I always wondered what his poor wife would've thought if she'd found out. And I realise now I'm much older and wiser that it was his way of letting me know he liked me and seeing what, if anything, happened next.

I think this ^

He prob hasn’t done anything but it has prob crossed his mind

Isthislikeloveactually · 17/01/2022 16:10

I brought it up with him. It was in the boot of his car.
I told him I thought it was inappropriate and he said he hadn’t thought of it like that. I said if he had feelings for someone else he could leave but at least let me know so I could make my own plans. All very dramatic, baby in arms. He seemed very shaken and apologetic.
After that we were invited to her house along with other colleagues. She was friendly and so was I. I didn’t sense anything between them. Looking back though, I probably wouldn’t have gone to her house. I still feel there was a teeny little emotional affair hovering in the background of it all - nothing they would have done anything about, but nice for them to know it was there.

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 17/01/2022 16:09

@sadpapercourtesan

No, I don't think most men would buy a woman a Kindle because he knew she liked reading. I think you'd have to know her reading habits, whether she would actually want or need a Kindle - maybe she travels a lot and it would be useful on journeys, or she finds a paper book unwieldy to read in bed, or whatever. It seems to me like a gift a man would only buy a woman if he knew she wanted it, iyswim.
I still disagree, it could have been a simple conversation that prompted it, maybe he saw her reading on a break and she said she must get a Kindle instead of carrying books around with her or maybe she said she had one and it broke or maybe she doesn't like reading at all and he bought her one anyway and she thought it was a shit present, god knows enough women on here complain about their OH's getting them awful presents!
Bluebluemoon39 · 17/01/2022 16:09

I don't think it necessarily means they had an affair or anything but it suggests your dh had feelings for her that were more than just friendly.

Once when I worked in an office a much older (married) man bought me a gift which was quite personal for my 21st birthday. It was completely inappropriate and I was embarrassed. I distanced myself from him after that as I was worried he'd taken our chats (we did get along and had a similar sense of humour) the wrong way.
I always wondered what his poor wife would've thought if she'd found out. And I realise now I'm much older and wiser that it was his way of letting me know he liked me and seeing what, if anything, happened next.

HollowTalk · 17/01/2022 16:05

Book and device purchases, I mean.

HollowTalk · 17/01/2022 16:05

OP, do you have access to his Amazon account? You can see the different Kindle accounts there and you can see the purchases, too.

Lou98 · 17/01/2022 16:04

How did you find out who it was for? Did you tell him you seen it and then asked about it or did he tell you before he knew you'd seen it?

I think his reaction would have been telling. If he wasn't bothered that you found it or he told you without knowing you'd found it, I don't think it screams affair at all.
If he looked like a deer in headlights, I'd be a bit more concerned.

You said you've no other reason to think he's ever cheated and he seems to be open about their friendship in that you know they meet for coffees etc so I think I'd give him the benefit of the doubt here especially since it happened a while ago now but if you have any other reason to doubt that I'd bring it up with him

sadpapercourtesan · 17/01/2022 16:03

No, I don't think most men would buy a woman a Kindle because he knew she liked reading. I think you'd have to know her reading habits, whether she would actually want or need a Kindle - maybe she travels a lot and it would be useful on journeys, or she finds a paper book unwieldy to read in bed, or whatever. It seems to me like a gift a man would only buy a woman if he knew she wanted it, iyswim.

HollowTalk · 17/01/2022 16:02

What happened in my case? I found an eternity ring and realised I didn't want an eternity with him. I got a slave bracelet! (To be fair I doubt he knew that's what it was.)

The marriage ended at my bequest. He was a bugger to get out, though. He learned the hard way what "eternity" meant!

Gilly12345 · 17/01/2022 16:01

Do you have any male friends or acquaintances?

I find his relationship a bit odd, I’m sorry.

Do you get bought presents of this value?

ANameChangeAgain · 17/01/2022 15:55

The secrecy thing is different, I'm 99% sure that the wives would have been with my bosses when my gifts were purchased! There was never any need to keep it quiet.
A sub contractor once brought all of "the girls" in the office lacy thongs for Christmas as an intentially inappropriate joke. I very much doubt it his wife knew, but it was innocent.
I think its more telling if there are lots of working late, lots of business lunches, more working away?

BatshitBanshee · 17/01/2022 15:54

I think if there was anything to it OP a) he would be doing it more often and B) would have come up with a more convincing lie. I'd probably raise an eyebrow too but if there's nothing else, then there's nothing else.

LampLighter414 · 17/01/2022 15:54

If your DH is a big boss type and this lady worked directly for him or assisted him on projects or something regularly, I can see why he might have wanted to get her something fairly substantial as a reward for a year of good and helpful work.

PAs at my old place used to get very fancy gifts from the senior managers and directors they worked for. Have had other bosses ensure they buy lower level staff who don't get bonuses fancy gifts - champagne, hampers, alexa, £150 JL vouchers etc

Isthislikeloveactually · 17/01/2022 15:53

@palavah
At the time, about the same amount would have been spent on me as on her.

OP posts:
AryaStarkWolf · 17/01/2022 15:52

@sadpapercourtesan

I think a Kindle is quite an intimate gift for a man to give a woman actually. He would have to know her quite well.

It's still bothering you, so I'd wonder whether there are other little things that have kept you alert to suspicion.

Do you think so? All he'd really have to know is whether she was a reader or not surely? And the OP said they were friendly, meet for coffee's etc, knowing if she like reading is a pretty basic fact to know about someone and not really intimate i wouldn't think

But, yeah I agree that there must be a reason it's still playing on the OPs mind, her instinct is obviously flagging it for her

Isthislikeloveactually · 17/01/2022 15:52

@sadpapercourtesan
Yes exactly. He knew she’d like it, knew she didn’t have one, had put some thought into an expensive gift. In his line of work, chocolates and wine are often given but not gifts like this. It’s just not a thing.

OP posts:
Palavah · 17/01/2022 15:50

How much does he spend on presents for other colleagues/ friends/family compared with a kindle?

It's inappropriate for him to single out a younger female colleague like that.

AryaStarkWolf · 17/01/2022 15:49

[quote Anotherviewtoyou]@AryaStarkWolf Buying everyone chocolate is not even remotely the same. It’s completely normal to do that as a manager, if you go on holidays, when it’s someone’s birthday, for Easter etc etc[/quote]
I'm very sorry Grin

sadpapercourtesan · 17/01/2022 15:49

I think a Kindle is quite an intimate gift for a man to give a woman actually. He would have to know her quite well.

It's still bothering you, so I'd wonder whether there are other little things that have kept you alert to suspicion.

Isthislikeloveactually · 17/01/2022 15:48

@HollowTalk

This happened to me.

The thing is that a non-intimate gift can escape detection in the woman's house. He could hardly buy her underwear if she's married.

The fact he didn't mention it to you prior to giving it to her speaks volumes.

@HollowTalk What happened in your case if you don’t mind me asking?
OP posts: