Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Presence of evil

793 replies

beachcitygirl · 17/01/2022 14:03

Aibu to ask if you've ever felt yourself in the presence of evil. Following on from
The intuitiion thread.

I once met a friend of my ex in a coffee shop. The man was nothing but civil & friendly. Soft spoken & was an ex police officer. My then husband was there also.
I went to the loo & spent ages as something about him made me feel afraid. I stress it was just a feeling. Zero untoward behaviour.
Many years later he was arrested & found guilty of violent rape.

Has anyone else ever sensed evil? (For want of a better word)

OP posts:
Charliet22 · 18/01/2022 23:37

@oakleaffy by any chance, was this hostel in Kent ?

Libby98765 · 18/01/2022 23:19

Even spirits are very real, you may not be able to see them (although some people and animals do) but they inhabit or hang around people and places. It’s all complex, but the bottom line is, yes, your human spirit (beyond your natural self) is sensing something in the spirit realm and in this case, it wasn’t good.

Meowandchoppychops · 18/01/2022 22:56

Definitely had creepy vibes off people and places. I seem to attract the weirdos on public transport and out and about.
I was about to hit a narrow and very busy bit of road so I hopped off my bike and decided to walk the last bit home. Clocked this guy ambling along towards me and just got a bad feeling off him. Somehow he ended up getting me to stop and talk to him for over half an hour, kept offering to walk me home, asked me my address, how long I lived there who I lived with. If anyone was going to be home. Invited me back to his for some casual drugs, persisted in offering to make sure I got home safe even though he'd made it clear it was completely in the wrong direction for him. Just wouldn't drop it. Eventually had to fake needing the loo to get away from him but it was really hot and I had smart trousers and a blouse on. So I just started walking but he kept following me and talking at me. Insisting he take me home. I was getting a bit freaked out by this point so had to jump on my bike and make a dash for it. Took a detour to try and loose him and dashed in my house quickly and quietly so he couldn't see where I had gone. Told my husband at the time and he thought it was suspicious. Lived in a dodgy area and he is a PC. Two months later he asked me to describe this guy to him again and said he matched the description of a guy who'd been to court for murdering some poor girl after inviting her back to his. ConfusedSad
One of my OH's best friends growing up turned out to be a massive distributor of the most severe types of child pornography. We had no idea, he was a nice bloke, quiet, but weirdly absolutely terrified of children, almost seemed repulsed by them if you even offered to hand him a baby. My husband was devastated when he found out. Thought he should have known somehow with him being a pc.

I do sometimes wonder if places can hold onto evil. There was a spot in my Nan and Pops house on their landing outside their bedroom that just oozed malice. Felt like something really didn't want you there and that you were being watched and preyed on. I always thought it was me being an overly sensitive child but when I spoke to my brother and cousins as adults, they pretty much everyone in my family they all felt the same, even as adults. After my Nan died my dad had the house "cleansed" by a pastor, he felt something evil had been invited in, because of my Pops association with the Free Masons.
I do think my family have experiences of waking nightmares or sleep paralysis which would probably explain a lot of their horrible experiences of places.
But I vividly remember one night I did feel like there was something vile lurking outside my brother room. Felt a bit stupid but I did tell it to go away. My brother said the next morning he felt like something was trying to throttle him and kill him in his sleep. My dad said he'd felt something disturbing in the house for a few days before then but it had gone by the morning. I get swept along by mine and other peoples emotions and opinions very easily, and always been curious as to why. I do love old places but rarely had bad feelings in them.

Mollymoostoo · 18/01/2022 22:52

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

Well evil doesn’t exist, so no, but you can certainly form accurate gut instincts about people based on unconscious signs they give off.
Evil doesn't exist? Of course it does.
Clearthinking · 18/01/2022 22:51

There is an awful bridge near were we live. Very narrow, gets very narrow under a train track and very dark with a unlit park one side and quite a fair way away some houses. Always frightened the crap out of me, as when a train goes past, the noise could drown out any screams and the dark no one can see you. My dad would always walk me, my mum or my nan under it. Its ways got "history" and stories of horror as its been like it at least from early 19th century. My neice (16) walked alone under it and told me a group of young blokes appeared from no where and were quickly walking to catch her up. I thank my lucky stars a chap in his 40's (prob a local) walked with her and said "I can see them just walk with me" up to the main road and watched her get on a bus. Thank you x

StorminaBcup · 18/01/2022 22:47

Years ago I lived in a small town in Germany (Weeze), and every Saturday afternoon there was a train crossing that I went over to go to the swimming pool (I’d ride my bike there with my friend). If I mis-timed my journey I’d be stuck at the crossing waiting for a long cattle / freight train to go past that used to absolutely terrify me (i was around 8 so not fully aware of the holocaust at that time).

OnaBegonia · 18/01/2022 22:44

I do believe dogs can sense better than we can.
Many years ago a friend used to spend his school holidays with his grandparents in Ireland, they owned the village garage and their dog would sit outside and passers by would pat her and stop for a chat, nice friendly happy wee dog but my friend recalls there was one man who the dog would back away from
and growl at, everyone was mystified, years later the man was arrested for child abuse spanning decades.

Greenshed · 18/01/2022 22:27

I believe acts of evil certainly exist - (look back through history if you don’t believe me), though it’s happening all around us all the time, now as well as in the past, and sadly it will in the future, too. I sincerely believe there are people who possess evil traits, and carry out evil acts, though, as SituationCritical says, it’s not always obvious to the majority that it is being carried out until (or even if), the perpetrators are caught and held to account. Whether they are possessed by evil, learn it, or are inherently evil is a moot point, and this is probably a topic for another discussion.

dibly · 18/01/2022 22:21

Yes a wedding venue my ex and I went to view, lovely old venue in North Wales (for the wedding which never happened🙌). We toured the whole venue, mainly small rooms, until we were shown the top floor which would have been most suitable. As the wedding organiser was giving her pitch I felt absolutely full of terror, turned to ex who asked if I felt it too and we got out of there as fast as we could. Will never forget that sense of evil, we weren’t religious but after a few days of trying to rationalise it went to see a vicar.

We since read that the spot we’d been standing on had been used to hang people. It was 22 years ago, but will never forget that experience.

Ahardyfool · 18/01/2022 22:18

@Verbena87 just wanted to say thank you for making that distinction (re. Picking up on difference and reaction being fear, NTs vs NDs, etc.) Smile

Goodluckanddontfuckitup · 18/01/2022 22:17

@Opal8 I know exactly what you mean about Stonehenge. I visited on a busy day last summer and it was silent. No background noise at all. I couldn't get over it. You'd expect traffic noise, chatter, birdsong but there was nothing.

AnnaSW1 · 18/01/2022 22:09

@oakleaffy not to go off topic, but I just had to say your post is extremely similar to what I experience with sleep paralysis.

Purpleavocado · 18/01/2022 22:03

I'm not a particularly animal lover, but I felt terrible in Seaworld Olando. Like I was going to be sick when I saw the animals were kept.
Also babysat in an old house. One child sleepwalked, there was a crying boy picture, and keys kept falling off the wall. Something felt evil about that house.

Imy06 · 18/01/2022 21:53

There was an online grocery delivery man for one of the supermarkets here. When he first showed up I instantly had the heebie jeebies but brushed it off. The second and third time the same and then the fourth time he made a comment about how he noticed my partners car wasn't in the driveway and he tried to bring the groceries right into the house instead of put them in the porch like usual, I had to almost shout at him not to.
My friend said she has got a strange vibe from him too although he had never done anything she could really put her finger on.
We found a few years later that he had been arrested and convicted of owning child pornography, and he was also found with footage and photos of women and kids in houses he had delivered to, and he had a house that he rented rooms out to women and he had set up cameras in the bathroom!

Katya213 · 18/01/2022 21:51

Worked with a guy who everybody thought was amazing, people loved to be in his company etc. I could not put my finger on why he made me feel so uncomfortable and nobody could believe why I was saying it. A week before I left, he came to work covered in blood, he had raped and stabbed a teenage girl in a country lane.

BasaltIsland · 18/01/2022 21:49

Years ago a childhood friend of my dp moved to the uk on a contract and was living in a hotel. We went to visit him there one evening and met his new ‘friends’, a bunch of contractors also staying long-term at the hotel. Dp’s friend speaks no English whatsoever, but is a ridiculously naive, friendly and trusting guy - also very generous, and was basically hanging out with these guys in the bar every night buying them drinks. He couldn’t understand anything they said, but dp and I quickly understood they were Not Nice People and wanted to leave. Nasty banter making fun of our friend and us. Can’t remember what prompted it, but one of them made a serious-not-serious ‘joke’ alluding to the fact he’d rape me and my dp. Dp didn’t pick up on it and I was too scared (and utterly ashamed) to make a thing out of it - because by this time I was really frightened of these people - so we couldn’t get away immediately.

Remember being really fearful on the way home that they’d somehow find out where we lived. Ten years later and I can’t drive past the hotel or even see the name of the place it is in without feeling sickened.

TurquoiseDragon · 18/01/2022 21:36

And I love hearing about all the dogs in this thread who could sense a wrong 'un

Dogs aren't as good as you think. I'm a nice, average person, never harmed anyone. Yet one dog started growling at me, and someone said "ooohh, dog can always tell the wrong 'uns". Turns out dog had a dislike of a certain perfume, which I'd worn that day.

It's good to be wary, but there are plenty of mundane reasons to cause a dog to react to someone.

bellalou1234 · 18/01/2022 21:35

When I was 16 I went to an agricultural college to do equine studies, awful place stuck in the country. There was a male student probably in his 40s I couldn't be in his company he made me feel so strange.

Verbena87 · 18/01/2022 21:34

I’ve taught a child who frightened me, like a few other teachers on this thread. Definitely wouldn’t use the word ‘evil’, but the child seemed fanatically interested in controlling the others through fear and manipulation, and didn’t seem to understand why this was problematic. His reaction to distress in other kids was detached interest. I found it very uncomfortable to witness and never found a behaviour management strategy that seemed to work. I assumed he was being bullied at home but when the school checked this out we couldn’t detect any abuse or issues.

I do think we’re tuned in to picking up difference, and that our knee-jerk reaction to difference is fear. Which is sometimes useful and sometimes really shitty for people who are not neurotypical, or not from the same race or sex or cultural background or faith as we are.

And I also think I might be able to smell psychosis, which in itself feels a bit delusional but there we are. Had a very close friend who went through a period of dreadful mental health including periods where he was psychotic and his smell changed. It was an awful time, really traumatic and I ended up being on the receiving end of physical and emotional abuse from him while he was in the grip of paranoid delusions - it was terrifying and really sad and has definitely left me with some mental scarring. I had a student who was very mentally unwell and had to ask not to teach her because she smelled so exactly like my friend when he’d been ill that I’d get a gut-punch of visceral panic and a blinding sense of not being able to keep her or anyone else safe when she walked into the classroom.

TurquoiseDragon · 18/01/2022 21:31

@disconnected101

I think our brains try to make sense of things that don't make sense. Think of optical illusions. Think of how effective the power of suggestion is. Say there was a bad feeling in a room - to use previous examples, due to toxic mold, lead in the paint, infrasound, dodgy electrics, magnetic energy etc. and we couldn't figure out why, our brains & imaginations try to rationalise what we think we're seeing/feeling and fills in the gaps. There's a classic example online of infrasound in a room due to a faulty fan & one of the symptoms was to cause minute vibrations in the eye causing people to 'see' grey/whitish indistinguishable shapes in their peripheral vision. When they looked around they were gone. What does that sound like?
I think there are plenty of rational things, like this post, that explains "evil".

I don't believe in evil as a separate force. Any evil in this world comes directly from us humans.

And far more people are capable of evil acts if our societal restraints were removed, than would ever admit to it.

I remember reading a war novel, a long time ago, by an author called Sven Hassel. While his later books were made up nonsense, his first book was pretty much autobiographical, detailing his experiences in the German army in WW2. He was in a penal battalion, so his comrades weren't exactly posh officers.

He wrote that his experiences made him realise that people enjoyed killing and other nasty stuff when no one was around to enforce laws.

Humans only have a thin layer of civilisation.. We are all capable of more than we think, good or bad.

TatianaBis · 18/01/2022 21:30

And in terms of criminality and the law the term evil is pretty unhelpful

Is it? How do you differentiate between someone who murders one person and one who murders millions?

All it actually means is ‘profoundly immoral’.

Livelovebehappy · 18/01/2022 21:30

I’m very naive about people in general, always seeing good and never seeing bad, so my judgement is always off. My trust in people has lead me down some slippery roads. So no, I can’t say I’ve ever felt the presence of evil, although I’m sure i’ve been around it sometimes without realising. I think some people just have that sixth sense, and some don’t.

Timeturnerplease · 18/01/2022 21:28

@CaveWoman1 Honestly, there is just something terrifying about him. Just no emotions whatsoever, though he had learnt to act happy/sad/apologetic depending on the context by the time he left us. But the eyes never changed.

I really hope he doesn’t become another sad story that maybe could have been helped early on….

GinPin2 · 18/01/2022 21:28

Yes, a man who lives down our road.

We gave him a lift home once, I moved to sit in the back with our daughters so that he could sit in the front.
It was my idea to give him a lift, my husband would never have thought about helping anyone.
Anyway, it was only about a 15 min journey but by the time we reached our road I really needed him gone, there was just a strong presence of something being very wrong about him. I got my husband to let him out at his house even though we are only 5 houses away. I was so disturbed by his presence.
It was about 27 years ago and he has never done anything wrong to my knowledge but he is a real loner since his wife left him 30 years ago.

He retired from being a pharmacist about 8 yrs ago and his house, garage, etc are in ruins. We say hello to each other ( well he grunts ) but he won't look at me. I don't have the same feeling now when passing him in the street during the day.
Maybe it was just something about being in an enclosed, captive space with him.

disconnected101 · 18/01/2022 21:26

@MummyBearBoo

My cat did when my ex came round he sat on the opposite sofa and glared at him he turned out to be a very horrible guy! With my now DH he went straight up to him and sprawled out on his legs!!
@MummyBearBoo what an awesome cat. And I love hearing about all the dogs in this thread who could sense a wrong 'un
Swipe left for the next trending thread