Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Presence of evil

793 replies

beachcitygirl · 17/01/2022 14:03

Aibu to ask if you've ever felt yourself in the presence of evil. Following on from
The intuitiion thread.

I once met a friend of my ex in a coffee shop. The man was nothing but civil & friendly. Soft spoken & was an ex police officer. My then husband was there also.
I went to the loo & spent ages as something about him made me feel afraid. I stress it was just a feeling. Zero untoward behaviour.
Many years later he was arrested & found guilty of violent rape.

Has anyone else ever sensed evil? (For want of a better word)

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 20/01/2022 18:20

@dibly

It’s been a great thread on the whole OP most people have taken it in the spirit intended, the others seem to have an overwhelming need to have the last word and bore people into submission.
Thank you! X
OP posts:
dibly · 20/01/2022 18:12

It’s been a great thread on the whole OP most people have taken it in the spirit intended, the others seem to have an overwhelming need to have the last word and bore people into submission.

beachcitygirl · 20/01/2022 16:01

Sorry for typos.
Should say. I didn't expect this to turn into a thread about the sky fairy or hatred of a black woman. Lesson learned. Thanks folks

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 20/01/2022 15:59

I am quite new to posting.. lurking for years. I did say at the beginning that I used the word evil for want of a better word. I guess it's an education how S
People can make everything about their hatred of a black woman or their personal sky diary ba.
Lesson learned. I'll go back to lurking Confused

OP posts:
ChargingBuck · 20/01/2022 15:48

@TatianaBis, @Kanaloa

If you didn’t want people to discuss the nature of evil/the existence of evil then maybe you should have started a thread called ‘creepy stories but no rational explanations please.’

Grin Grin Grin Grin

disconnected101 · 20/01/2022 14:26

@SingleMamaGY I think your post and so many other similar ones serve to highlight where real threat/danger/malice comes from - people
It's people who are capable of doing awful things. The potential to do harm is inherent in humans. Every human possesses the capacity for a spectrum of behaviour and personality traits. I think we mostly have developed senses and learned responses which override risky and harmful behaviour, and instincts which serve to protect ourselves and keep our offspring safe in order to survive.

As for spooky feelings provoked by places etc. I do think there are logical explanations for the vast majority of them but they make for good stories and a good thread, when not derailed by a debate on morality and so on and I say that even though I've contributed to the debate (because it pisses me off when real human people are not held accountable for or thought capable of truly awful actions).

I'm really logical and rational but I still love reading threads like these at night & feeling spooked, like watching horror movies. Your rational self takes a back seat for the thrill.

SingleMamaGY · 20/01/2022 14:02

I moved house once and went back a few weeks later to pick up any post that hadn’t been redirected. I knocked on the door and a handy man answered and said the owners weren’t home but invited me in. As soon as the door shut I felt spooked by his demeanour and he asked if I wanted to have a look upstairs at the new works that he had done. I made my excuses and left.

Gonnagetgoing · 20/01/2022 12:55

@Sazzasez

Well, we were hitching in his area, in his heyday (1976), and he clearly spent a LOT of time driving around & offering lifts to young women. We were lucky there were 3 of us, and he was alone.

It’s in the middle of a 3-year period when he’s not known to have killed anyone. Still: I’m glad I didn’t get back into that van.

There were a lot more hitchers around, too.

I told this story (there’s more to it) at a True Stories Live storytelling event just before the pandemic, and a young woman in the audience came up & said her Dad got lifts from Fred West, who he knew from his building work. They lived in Cinderford in the Forest of Dean, which is close to where we were hitching.

@Sazzasez - interesting what you say about Fred West.

I used to holiday in a village in SW England and we got to know a local family, the father was an artist and he had 2 daughters and a son as well as a wife. The daughters were 11 and 13 when I met them and the eldest was into horse-riding and the younger one more into animals and art. Anyway, they were into the Specials a lot and had the haircuts (sort of a skinhead) - they'd had lovely long hair beforehand but were pretty girls and used to come up to London when they could for concerts/parties etc - we lived on outskirts of London so it was handy for them to get a lift and/or stay with us sometimes. We lost touch over the years and then I got in touch with the younger daughter via FB. I asked about the elder daughter who they'd had a big falling out with as a family. One of the girls went on to go to art college. The younger daughter lives in a big city now in SW and the last time I was in that area (due to relatives living nearby) I went to meet up with her and subsequently stayed with her. We were talking about my and her family, I have cousins who live in Gloucester but about 10 years younger than me. Cheltenham was mentioned too as other cousins used to live and go to school there. I mentioned Fred West and how spooky and strange that was and she suddenly said 'do you know, we were given a lift by him once? We'd been asked to stay with friends just outside Gloucester, there had been a party happening and they got lifts as they often did. They got a coach to Gloucester but then had to get a lift from the city centre to where the party was. There were buses but it was winter and it had snowed and they tried to get a lift. They recalled actually being picked up in a car or van by a very strange man who had said, if they needed a place to stay, he had rooms in his house free and also asked them what were they like re looking after young children. Luckily both of them got the lift, made their excuses and got out where he dropped them but my friend described him down to a T, small man, Gipsy looking (a bit like the singer, can't think of his name) and dirty. Friend told me years later they were looking at TV/newspaper footage of the murders and of Fred West and she turned to her then boyfriend and said I accepted a lift from him when I was hitchhiking! Lucky escape.

disconnected101 · 20/01/2022 12:23

Faiths go back a thousand or more years, and is more often than not passed down in our genetic makeup
Genes do not code for religious faith. It is learned through your environment - parents, home/school/community life.

I believe that other faiths - Islam included - have also passed down the generations, and we can no more change others or ourselves to other faiths as we can insist they have a different gift passed on from ancestors
This is rigid thinking.

I am sorry you have such an attitude to faith, because I believe everyone needs to be with similarly minded people who understand their reasons for everything they do

Of course people seek to surround themselves with like-minded others to reinforce their beliefs, and not just where religion is concerned. I think it can be healthy, for eg. it can provide a community and the support that comes from belonging to such, and it can be unhealthy, such as in a cult, where beliefs are not challenged or questioned.

Kanaloa · 20/01/2022 12:07

@TatianaBis

OP did you really think you’d mention the “presence of evil” without people discussing the nature of evil?
Exactly. If you didn’t want people to discuss the nature of evil/the existence of evil then maybe you should have started a thread called ‘creepy stories but no rational explanations please.’
catzwhiskas · 20/01/2022 11:52

Years ago house hunting , visited one which was being sold after a divorce. Both of us had a terrible feeling and couldn’t wait to leave. We were both separately convinced there had been a lot of violence and abuse there. I have no spiritual or religious feeling, but I do sometimes have telepathic senses in other situations. I think we as women should always trust our gut feelings about men in particular as they could well save us from at best interaction we don’t want. These feelings are more important than the need to be kind and should be acted on. The number of women on this thread reflect their experiences and there are more men with bad intentions that’s we like to think.

buffyajp · 20/01/2022 11:50

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

You are wrong. Evil most certainly does exist. Just ask Women's Aid.

As a victim of DV I can assure you that it is all human force that abuses women.

Again you are confusing the word evil with supernatural. People carry out evil acts. Personally I think the word evil describes events like the holocaust perfectly. Evil as a act most definitely does exist.
TatianaBis · 20/01/2022 11:28

OP did you really think you’d mention the “presence of evil” without people discussing the nature of evil?

buffyajp · 20/01/2022 11:24

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

Well evil doesn’t exist, so no, but you can certainly form accurate gut instincts about people based on unconscious signs they give off.
Except it does, just because you don’t like the word. What you mean is you don’t believe in supernatural causes for it. Plenty of evidence of evil acts committed sadly.
ChargingBuck · 20/01/2022 11:13

@beachcitygirl

Also. This is a thread about creepy stories/gut instinct. Not a religious thread/not a thread to unload racism/not a thread to bitch about Meghan/not a thread to discuss what rape is.

If you want those type of
Threads then start your own. Most of us are enjoying this one without all that crap.

@beachcitygirl is this your first time on an internet forum?

You know how discussion works, right ..?
Somebody says the sky is blue, someone disagrees that it's grey, another random pops up to say the sky is irrelevant & why is nobody talking about grass today ... & so it goes on.

Relax. You don't need to police it.
& you certainly don't get to announce what you reckon "most of us" think and retain any credibility Grin

ChargingBuck · 20/01/2022 11:10

@llizzie

ChargingBuck I disagree with you. What do you think gives you that 'inner morality'?
Life itself gave it to me, @llizzie

Humans, like all herd & pack animals, have an innate awareness that others of their species also have feelings & that taking heed of them serves the general good.

Humanity. Soul. An intellect that can distinguish between right & wrong. God didn't give it to me, because god is a human invention. Mother nature did.

It's fine with me that you disagree, & I'm glad your faith gives you comfort.

beachcitygirl · 20/01/2022 10:42

Also. This is a thread about creepy stories/gut instinct. Not a religious thread/not a thread to unload racism/not a thread to bitch about Meghan/not a thread to discuss what rape is.

If you want those type of
Threads then start your own. Most of us are enjoying this one without all that crap.

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 20/01/2022 10:37

@Wavypurple

Not trying to de-rail but in response to your OP there’s no need to distinguish his crime as a ‘violent’ rape, all rape is violent.
Doh! Of course it is, but in addition to the violence of rape, he also hit her with a hammer.
OP posts:
llizzie · 20/01/2022 01:51

ChargingBuck I disagree with you. What do you think gives you that 'inner morality'?

llizzie · 20/01/2022 01:42

Kanfuzed123 Oh there are - many of them. They come in all shades of colour and religion. I would venture to suggest that it is these fanatics that enable us to continue in our chosen path, because they show us what can happen if we get a lust for power and control.

There have been some groups and sects who have called themselves Christian. If they do not act as Christ taught them, then they are not Christian. They may think they are, but they are not.

Every faith has people who see an easy way to control others by trying to convince them that the stricter they are, the more people will like them, and that just happens to be happening in the Middle East just now. Rule by force will never work, and we know that, but it is still tried over again. I myself have always been treated well by people of other faiths.

llizzie · 20/01/2022 01:34

disconnected101 There are many faiths going back centuries. It is not blind questioning that keeps fear at bay, so you say. Faiths go back a thousand or more years, and is more often than not passed down in our genetic makeup, in a similar way that we can inherit gifts of music (just one example) from our ancestors.

I see my God through the eyes of Jesus Christ. I have no memory of being taught about Jesus by anyone. I learned the prayers we said at infant school and always understood them. The study of scripture was my favourite subject at grammar school. If I could tell you about the many miracles I have experienced you would not believe me, or you would think it unfair that so much has happened to me and not to you.

This life on earth is not the end. If souls can leave the body while it is still viable, it can certainly do so when the body is dead, and I like to believe and hope that if I follow the Way of Christ, that is where my soul will be when I have finished with this life on earth. Jesus said ''In my Father's House are many mansions. From that, I think that God has a place for the spirit of every faith and that we should only be concerned for our own souls, and satisfy ourselves that God caters for everyone.

I believe that other faiths - Islam included - have also passed down the generations, and we can no more change others or ourselves to other faiths as we can insist they have a different gift passed on from ancestors.

I am sorry you have such an attitude to faith, because I believe everyone needs to be with similarly minded people who understand their reasons for everything they do. I find it very distressing to hear of people being forced to change their religion, because they cannot. It is not in their psyche to do so. That is what is so bad about the Taliban. They are forcing their own version of Islam onto people who cannot protest.

disconnected101 · 19/01/2022 23:52

@llizzie

ChargingBuck by using your intuition and not getting into friendship with someone who would lead you up the garden path! I do not know who or what atheists turn to when in the presence of evil. I would think you would recognise evil. A lot of people are surprised that Satan is the ruler of this world.

I deliberately used the word 'faiths' in the plural, because there are many different faiths where people share the same interests, and those faiths keep the evil ones away if they follow the teachings of whichever deity they have faith in.

Faiths help us live by giving us hope that if we do the good we are taught, when our body dies, the soul will have somewhere to go.
Now there is food for thought.

Faith (blind unquestioning) serves to keep fear at bay - the fear that this is all there is & there is nothing after we die AND serves to control people. Mass mind control. I think it would make life easier to be so deluded tbh. It would alleviate some of the pressure and responsibility, to have some doctrine to live by and other people to tell me how to abide by it.
Getoutofthis · 19/01/2022 23:47

^ Croissantly
This is an interesting thread aside from those who weirdly feel like they need to do a deep dive into whether evil exists and in what form, lighten up ffs. ^

Agreed, this is a great thread but people are being so pedantic AND all the bickering - urgh! No one cares people, we are here to read the creepy stories, stop spoiling it.

Maggiethecat · 19/01/2022 22:14

I was in uni halls and fell asleep one night with my balcony door open in warm weather with the curtains drawn across the door.

I was on the first floor and there was a landing outside the first floor rooms but I think we all felt fairly relaxed about unlocked doors as we were on the first floor.

This particular night I woke up out of my sleep and had a strong sense that someone was outside my door although there was no sound. It was just the most palpable feeling.

When I drew back the curtains there was someone outside my opened door, just standing still, not poised to pounce or anything - just there.

I retreated back into my room and started to holler upon which the entire hall woke up and came running out in various states of undress and the guy just bolted over the balcony.

I think about how easily I could have been assaulted or worse that night and am thankful that I sensed something.

Verbena87 · 19/01/2022 22:06

@StepAwayFromTheEcclesCakes besides the ill-informed comments about sharia law, this raised my eyebrows as well “ What has changed that we no longer do these things, have people generally discovered a conscience that we didn't used to have, has society enforced a change in behaviour. Child abuse was rife in victorian Britain.” - I’m guessing you don’t work in any capacity where safeguarding training is involved? Child abuse is rife in Britain. Current Elizabethan Britain. I really don’t see that we’ve become more virtuous or moral as a society. Our taboos and norms shift but our brains have essentially stayed the same for thousands and thousands of years.