Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Presence of evil

793 replies

beachcitygirl · 17/01/2022 14:03

Aibu to ask if you've ever felt yourself in the presence of evil. Following on from
The intuitiion thread.

I once met a friend of my ex in a coffee shop. The man was nothing but civil & friendly. Soft spoken & was an ex police officer. My then husband was there also.
I went to the loo & spent ages as something about him made me feel afraid. I stress it was just a feeling. Zero untoward behaviour.
Many years later he was arrested & found guilty of violent rape.

Has anyone else ever sensed evil? (For want of a better word)

OP posts:
MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/01/2022 17:41

if you mean me why don’t you quote me?

I did. I directly responded to your post.

Saz12 · 17/01/2022 17:40

But... I wasn’t having a dig at Megan! I was giving an example of people being unfair based on an unconscious bias/biases. I only picked on Megan Markle because she does seem to attract the very vague “there’s something about her I don’t like” comments, particularly on Mymsnet. I’ve no feeling (or much interest!) either way.

There are people in the public eye who I irrationally warm to, and others I’d just not “like”. I’ve no reason for it at all, but clearly there’s some past experience that means their traits makes me feel I like them.

I do think there are times when we 100% do subconsciously become aware that someone is weighing up wether we’d be a good future victim for them.

GettingStuffed · 17/01/2022 17:39

I was on the tube and a bloke got on and I felt uncomfortable, he changed lines when I did and got in the same carriage as me, still I got uncomfortable feeling so at the next station I changed carriages so did he. It was now obviously following me. When I got out of the station so did he, I ran up the stairs and luckily the lights were with me . A bus pulled up alongside me an asked if I was Ok as someone was running after me. I said know and he told me I get on . He dropped me off at the house I was staying in and he waited until I got in the house. The next few months there were reports of rapes in the area and the description was identical to the man who was following me.

I still mentally thank that caring bus driver.

Gonnagetgoing · 17/01/2022 17:38

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry - if you mean me why don’t you quote me?

I don’t actually dislike Meghan and someone else brought her name up, not me, so don’t pin that on me.

AppleBlueberryPie · 17/01/2022 17:36

Over 15 years ago I had a business meeting in London and stayed in some serviced apartments at Dolphin House, part of the giant Dolphin Square complex. I picked it simply because I was familiar with the Pimlico area (used to live in London) but without any inkling of its history.

The apartment itself was nice but the entire building felt empty for its size. There was an "arcade" of small shops in the back but most of the stores were closed giving it an eerie liminal space feeling. One morning the fire alarm went off at 6am. I wasn't sure what to do since it wasn't a hotel with a lobby and people working there, but I just grabbed my laptop & valuables and went downstairs into the courtyard. The inner area was entirely deserted and I didn't see a single person despite the fire alarm blaring away. What struck me most was an overwhelming sense of creepiness and sadness. It wasn't so much "scary" but more oppressive and disturbing. The alarm stopped and I went back to my room but that eerie feeling in the courtyard stayed with me for a long time. I made a note in my mind to never stay there again.

It was only years after that trip that I read in the papers there was a child trafficking ring operating out of Dolphin Square. I was shocked because I usually don't believe in "woo" type things but I experienced the strangest feeling at the location without knowing anything about its history. And as a disclaimer, I've lived in and travel to London frequently so it wasn't a one-off experience due to the architecture/atmosphere of a new country. I usually stay at serviced apartments in big blocks and none of the other places had the same disturbing vibe as Dolphin Square.

FireDancer1 · 17/01/2022 17:35

I was in a pub in a village called Forth in Scotland.. I told my BF at the time I needed the toilet and he showed me were to go. It was down a little corridor at the end. I started walking down, and then returned to my BF without getting to the toilet. I had the most awful feeling go through me. He told me I was being silly and waited at the end of the corridor while I ran through. Once in the toilet it was so cold and the feeling didn't subside until I was back out. That pub is 100s of years old. I didn't go back

PeopleBakwas · 17/01/2022 17:34

17:29hangrylady

Alcohol and takeaways - you probably have a lot more to worry about than just your intuition

OddSocksSparklyDocsandDungaree · 17/01/2022 17:33

I always walk home across a grassy area. Its near a main road, has houses nearby but is surrounded by trees and bushes. Walking across one day, two guys were walking towards me. I instantly had a bad feeling. I stopped where I was and pretended to phone my husband up. With that, they separated and walked either side of the path as they approached me. I heard one say he would 'smash me' just as I veered off the path and made a quick walk across the grass to get away. I still can't explain the feeling!

PeopleBakwas · 17/01/2022 17:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

thenightsky · 17/01/2022 17:31

There are some really good podcasts on BBC Sounds app. Search for 'Uncanny'. They are true stories.

I listened to the first 3 last night and they gave me the proper shivers. Shock

lightand · 17/01/2022 17:30

A couple of things I have bought, and binned that day or the next when I got home.
They just t didnt "seem right".

hangrylady · 17/01/2022 17:29

@PeopleBakwas

There is no such thing as an evil presence. There is no devil or saint. We are the devil or the Saint or in between.

If you are in touch with your own instinct and not ruined it with alcohol, drugs and junk food, then it's easy to detect a good or bad person, good or bad intentions, as everyone has the same capabilities and it's our nurturing that allows our good conscience to stay away from the evil a human is capable of.

A human is never bad, a baby isn't born bad. It's the nurturing and the society that is evil.

Plus, all murderers are mentally ill, this reason should never be allowed to escape justice.
(Only self defence murders should be considered)

I'd better lay off the wine and takeaways then make the wronguns easier to spot.
reesewithoutaspoon · 17/01/2022 17:29

I think sometimes what we perceive as intuitively feeling a bad vibe is just us subconsciously reading non verbal cues.
Some people, specially women (due to socialisation) I think are good at reading non verbal cues, even though they aren't consciously doing it.
So that psychopath might be utterly charming, but they cant keep up the charming façade 100% of the time and you pick up on the non verbal stuff not matching what is being said, it jars and makes you feel uncomfortable and uneasy. Could be lack of eye contact or fake smiles or body positioning, but somethings just feels 'off'

Curioushorse · 17/01/2022 17:27

Also a teacher. I once had a class who were incredibly difficult- because they were utterly silent. You'd get no response from them. We jumped around like fools trying to get them to react, but they just sat there stony faced.

Then, one day, one of the girls was off. It was an entirely different class- bubbly, fun, focussed and chatty. We realised then they were so intimidated by the one student they wouldn't speak.

It was really strange. We tracked it for two years, and almost all the teachers of that yeargroup got involved- but it was really hard, because she never DID anything. No reports of bullying or anything.

In Year 11 two students were convicted of GBH against a third (trying to be vague here- but a very serious crime and injury). This student was present, but did nothing. Luckily the law had changed, so she was convicted of having got others to attempt murder for her. She served more years than them.....

......but not very many as she was a child. We (her ex-teachers) are confident she will get others to commit more serious crimes for her in the future.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/01/2022 17:26

@Kanaloa

I don’t really see the Meghan Markle thing. Sometimes her smile looks small/done for the photo but that’s because it is. You’re not seeing family snaps of her but pictures taken by a photographer.

I do think there’s a certain mindset where if you want to dislike somebody you will. Meghan Markle could climb into a burning building and pull out six children and two puppies, saving their lives, then put out the fire with a squirty cap water bottle and the next day on mumsnet there would be a thread saying ‘did anyone see Meghan using that disposable water bottle? Hmm and apparent they care about the environment so much. Her and Harry are disgusting. If only Kate had been there, she would have put the fire out with a reusable chilli’s bottle and looked graceful and sincere in the process…’

Yeah- this.

Amazing that someone actually managed to turn this thread (about the presence of fucking evil) to get their daily Megan dig in. Hmm says a lot.

52andblue · 17/01/2022 17:23

@Kanaloa

I suppose evil really means something deeply wicked/immoral, however it is generally characterised by an association with the religious or supernatural, or an idea about the inherent ‘badness’ present in someone.

That’s why I don’t really agree with it as a concept. To me it’s the same as the word ‘monster’ when used about someone who has murdered someone, and is mainly used to ‘other’ people who have committed horrific crimes rather than accepting that it’s likely to be in some way a societal issue rather than that some people are inherently evil. It sort of removes blame or responsibility for the crime in my opinion.

You make very good points here@Kanoloa

I agree that 'evil' is used as an 'othering' term when we must do work on why some in society feel so othered that they feel they can / must enact awful actions. It is easy, and unhelpful to point and shout 'evil'.
The worst example of that I can think of is the media treatment of Thompson & Venables, the two boys who killed James Bulger in 1993. It was a dreadful crime, which rightly 'shocked the nation'. But the 'othering' of the two damaged boys who had committed the crime was also disturbing (they were kids, tried like adults). I remember my Psychology professor at Uni talking about that element of it quite a bit & how 'Society' needed to stop with the 'evil' labels & understand & act on the complex issues involved. Still a toddler lost his life in a way which I imagine many would call evil.

I guess I am using the word as a heading. The 2 people I mentioned had a deeply scary 'vibe' about them. I later read 'The Gift of Fear' and I think it is important to trust your gut about a person. You may later find they did something awful or not, but it is important to keep safe.

Strange 'vibes' about a place are a bit more odd. I once bought a house which had come up for sale due to a recent murder suicide (and I didn't know until I bought it, or I wouldn't have done as I am a bit of a wuss). It was the nicest house, no 'atmosphere' at all. The house I am in now, though is a different matter: uneasy at best.

TatianaBis · 17/01/2022 17:22

@MedusasBadHairDay

I think you need to define what you mean by evil tbh, if you assert that it exists

a. I just did, and b. the dictionary does that for you.

I didn’t say “evil exists” I said psychopathic acts and people exists.

My point is that everyone in this discussion or not needs to define their terms.

Generally in secular society evil is used to define acts that are so profoundly wrong, harmful, brutal, inhumane, and on such a scale that ‘bad’ is inadequate.

Kanaloa · 17/01/2022 17:21

I don’t really see the Meghan Markle thing. Sometimes her smile looks small/done for the photo but that’s because it is. You’re not seeing family snaps of her but pictures taken by a photographer.

I do think there’s a certain mindset where if you want to dislike somebody you will. Meghan Markle could climb into a burning building and pull out six children and two puppies, saving their lives, then put out the fire with a squirty cap water bottle and the next day on mumsnet there would be a thread saying ‘did anyone see Meghan using that disposable water bottle? Hmm and apparent they care about the environment so much. Her and Harry are disgusting. If only Kate had been there, she would have put the fire out with a reusable chilli’s bottle and looked graceful and sincere in the process…’

MedusasBadHairDay · 17/01/2022 17:20

@Saz12

I wonder how often the “there’s just something about him/ her that I don’t trust /creeps me out” really just boils down to prejudice. A bit like a more subtle version of those awful people who claim “I’m not racist, but there’s just something about that Megan Markle I don’t like”. EG men who aren’t good at making appropriate eye-contact... they often seem to make people feel threatened but it’s just a social skill that’s not in our cultural norm that makes them seem “off”.
I imagine there's a degree of it, but also pattern recognition will play a part. Eg. red flags that women who've been in abusive relationships might recognise in a man who hasn't yet revealed his full self.
MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/01/2022 17:12

Unfortunately (hate to derail this thread) - Meghan Markle has always given off a slightly smug vibe - regardless of anything else, her smile to me on the whole has always come across as insincere.

Whereas, e.g. Camilla Parker-Bowles (Duchess of Cornwall?) has always to me, seemed sincere in her manner and smiles, regardless of what she's actually done (e.g. had affair with Prince Charles)

Maybe that’s to do with the fact that Camilla grew up in and was well practised in that world, was very comfortable in it and her ease was apparent- it was her world. whereas Megan markle very much didn’t grow up in that world, nor even the UK and spent her adult years under the Hollywood glare, having to continually earn her place and so developed a “celeb” persona that of course isn’t her natural personality, and doesn’t fit so naturally with the world she then moved into and was clearly not as at ease in as camilla- who grew up in it- was.

Beseen22 · 17/01/2022 17:10

My DH is listener and I am a talker. We were at Christmas as newlyweds and my uncle's mother was there. She was a bit posh, not particularly pleasant and maybe a little racist. In the car on the way home my DH who never had any 1-1 conversation with her said "there's something really off about her, she's an evil woman". My DB and I laughed and said she was a bit grumpy but harmless but he wasn't convinced.

2 years ago she passed away and it all came out that her husband had an affair when her kids were young and when he left she made all her children chose whether to be with her or their dad. The eldest was 12 and wasn't prepared to not speak to her dad ever again so her mother cut her off and hasn't had anything to do with her since. My uncle was only 8 and has never been allowed to know anything about his father or his sister. She played the 2 remaining boys against each other and their whole upbringing was jealousy and ultimatums. Neither have had their own family or been able to hold down a job (now in their 50s) as they had to be constantly there for her. Very presentable, church going lady but not a very nice woman.

torquewench · 17/01/2022 17:06

On holiday with friends we bumped into a colleague (actually her CEO) of one of my friends, who was with his friends (all in their mid to late 40s) on a golfing trip. I instantly got a bad feeling about of them (the others were paralytic and just annoying). We were invited to have a nosy round their (very fancy, posh) villa which was across the road from the bar we were in, which we'd been dying to have an excuse to nose about all week. We were all sat on the pool deck chatting when the one I had a bad feeling about tried to give me a drink, which I politely refused as I hadn't seen him pour it, and he hadn't offered the others anything. He didn't seem to take offence. Literally 30 seconds later he sat beside me, grabbed my wrist and whispered in my ear that he was going to break my arm. Wasn't going to wait around to find out whether he was joking so we left immediately without looking back.

Gonnagetgoing · 17/01/2022 17:05

@Saz12

I wonder how often the “there’s just something about him/ her that I don’t trust /creeps me out” really just boils down to prejudice. A bit like a more subtle version of those awful people who claim “I’m not racist, but there’s just something about that Megan Markle I don’t like”. EG men who aren’t good at making appropriate eye-contact... they often seem to make people feel threatened but it’s just a social skill that’s not in our cultural norm that makes them seem “off”.
@Saz12 - certain people regardless of who they are - even if you don't know much about them and regardless of their race/skin colour etc give off an unlikeable vibe, a smug vibe either.

Unfortunately (hate to derail this thread) - Meghan Markle has always given off a slightly smug vibe - regardless of anything else, her smile to me on the whole has always come across as insincere.

Whereas, e.g. Camilla Parker-Bowles (Duchess of Cornwall?) has always to me, seemed sincere in her manner and smiles, regardless of what she's actually done (e.g. had affair with Prince Charles). The British public should really hate Camilla for what she did to Charles and Di's marriage, but generally, we don't! Maybe that's due to time, things have died down and apparently I read recently William used to have screaming rows with her daughter (who's kept out of the public eye).

JarvisCockersRightEyebrow · 17/01/2022 17:05

[quote Gonnagetgoing]@JarvisCockersRightEyebrow - Conquest House. It had poured with rain all that day when I was in Canterbury and this was the icing on top of the cake - was there visiting a friend.

I do like Canterbury![/quote]
Fascinating, thank you!

I don’t… Grin

Gonnagetgoing · 17/01/2022 17:00

@PeopleBakwas

There is no such thing as an evil presence. There is no devil or saint. We are the devil or the Saint or in between.

If you are in touch with your own instinct and not ruined it with alcohol, drugs and junk food, then it's easy to detect a good or bad person, good or bad intentions, as everyone has the same capabilities and it's our nurturing that allows our good conscience to stay away from the evil a human is capable of.

A human is never bad, a baby isn't born bad. It's the nurturing and the society that is evil.

Plus, all murderers are mentally ill, this reason should never be allowed to escape justice.
(Only self defence murders should be considered)

@PeopleBakwas - I know an ex nun actually - therefore no alcohol, drugs and junk food.

She mentioned to me that once when she was at a church after she'd recently exited her convent that there was a man who always used to attend the church services and attend confession.

One day he didn't turn up. It came to light that he had actually murdered someone (hadn't confessed to that mind you) and was in prison.

She had no idea - he was there sometimes when she attended services, but the priest spoke to him a lot, this man also had helped with fundraising activities and no one thought he was bad or evil. Both these people were in touch with their own instincts so they said.

Also, no all murderers are not mentally ill. Say e.g. a man has beaten and abused his wife all her life, and the wife snaps and stabs him? After he's beaten her black and blue, raped her, threatened to kill her? So she would be mentally ill for murdering him (I believe it'd be manslaughter in this case).

Of course humans and babies aren't born bad and it's down to nurturing and society but sometimes there are certain people you can't change regardless of that, Jimmy Savile for one, he was evil and you couldn't have stopped him doing what he did. Only if he was found out and convicted.