Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Presence of evil

793 replies

beachcitygirl · 17/01/2022 14:03

Aibu to ask if you've ever felt yourself in the presence of evil. Following on from
The intuitiion thread.

I once met a friend of my ex in a coffee shop. The man was nothing but civil & friendly. Soft spoken & was an ex police officer. My then husband was there also.
I went to the loo & spent ages as something about him made me feel afraid. I stress it was just a feeling. Zero untoward behaviour.
Many years later he was arrested & found guilty of violent rape.

Has anyone else ever sensed evil? (For want of a better word)

OP posts:
lemuelgulliver · 17/01/2022 22:28

@Thatsplentyjack

When I was younger we used to go on holiday to a place called Killin in Scotland. There was a small road that you could walk along next to the caravan site, which took you to the entrance to a field that had a path to walk around the Loch. The first bit of the road was fine. You crossed a bridge, there were a few houses on the left but then there was a stretch that had trees on either side. Now I wasn't really a child that was phased by being in forests etc. We went to places with forests and walks in the middle of nowhere all the time, but this stretch of road terrified me. As a young child I had to get one of my parents to carry me and I would hide my eyes the whole way through that bit. I used to panic the whole way because we had 2 little dogs and I was so scared something was going to happen to them or me. Like something was going to come and snatch us away. Then my younger brother was born and I honestly remember feeling sick to my stomach walking through there with him as a little baby/toddler. I went back a couple of times as a teen and still felt pretty uneasy walking through there, although that could have just been because of the memories as a child. I used to get this image in my head of big old grave stones at the top of the hill the trees went up. I have bo idea if there were graves stones up there though. I also have bo idea if anything bad had ever happened there, but I've been to loads of really old places in my life. Done ghost walks, been to old jails and castles as a child and I never felt like that anywhere else.
This made my eyes water! I've been there and felt the same!
Pawprintpaper · 17/01/2022 22:22

There is a very friendly older man in my village, once after we hadn’t lived there long, he started talking to me in the post office, chatting to my child in the queue (he was in front of me) after he went to the counter the woman behind warned me to be careful, he’d served time as a paedophile (I don’t know if this is true but we live in a small place and everyone knows everyone).

Many years later I was on a bus with my youngest and I saw him on there, he sat a few seats in front. Initially the bus was quite empty but slowly filled up. Weirdly, the seat next to him remained empty the whole journey despite people standing and lots of other oldish men being there to sit next to, he wasn’t the only one.

It intrigued me whether her was giving off a vibe, or it was my own bias.

HappyBunny123456789 · 17/01/2022 22:21

@Kanaloa I didn't even fully disagree with you... I said that humans were indeed complex and even Hitler was probably doomed from the start due to circumstances. Fine, read whatever "tone" you like into my comments. As unpleasant as you see fit. Clearly I had a very tough upbringing.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/01/2022 22:19

I asked you to try and convince me i was wrong, i ve tried to understand your POV but you haven't actually said anything of substance, so its difficult.

Grin
Etsylicious · 17/01/2022 22:17

My danger instincts are pretty sharp and I’m a good judge of character… but years ago I worked with, and was friends with a prolific paedophile… I had no idea… just thought he was a bit of a loner, had questionable personal hygiene, but in the main sweet and genuine 😑😑😑

Alexandra2001 · 17/01/2022 22:16

@MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry

Ok *@Alexandra2001*. I’ll leave it there. You’re asking me to explain “truly evil acts” when it’s something that I don’t believe exists. It’s a pointless question. You’re going in circles. You might as well ask me to explain how Jesus walked on water. I can’t because it didn’t happen.
That's why i put "evil" in quotes, as its the word i use, i don't know what word you would use as you never said....

I asked you to try and convince me i was wrong, i ve tried to understand your POV but you haven't actually said anything of substance, so its difficult.

BTW i don't believe in good or evil people, i think evil resides in all of us (as does good) it just takes circumstance to bring it out and there are degrees.
e.g. my father wasn't as evil as Fred West but he was evil none the less, he could also be an extremely loving parent and husband too, most of the time he was but then something changed in him and he wasn't.

Kanaloa · 17/01/2022 22:15

*now being utterly obtuse, sorry.

You have a really condescending tone too. It’s quite unpleasant to read.

Kanaloa · 17/01/2022 22:14

@HappyBunny123456789

We're not getting into a "sensible conversation" because you've literally got no way to prove your outlook on life is valid, and neither do I. These things are intangible but making everything soothingly black and white and then escaping makes this world a more bearable place to live in. I get that.
Okay, in addition to patronising you’re not being utterly obtuse.

I’m not the one being ‘black and white.’ That is what you are doing. I’m the one saying humans are complex creatures and almost all their behaviour is down to some mix of environmental and genetic influence. You’re the one insisting there’s some form of inherent ‘evilness’ that can’t be explained.

CurryLover55 · 17/01/2022 22:13

ghostyslovesheets Clifford Tower is one of the most haunted places in Britain & York one of the most haunted towns

Stormwhale · 17/01/2022 22:12

When I was at primary school a new head teacher was due to be appointed and students were selected to meet with him to see how he interacted with us. I was one of the children chosen. I went home afterwards and told my mum I didn't like him, but couldn't explain why. He was perfectly nice to us, but something felt wrong. My mum didn't think much of it until a couple of years down the line when he was arrested for indecent images of children (of all levels of severity) found on his computer at the school and his home. It wasn't really necessary to say I told you so, my mum was devastated.

Thatsplentyjack · 17/01/2022 22:12

When I was younger we used to go on holiday to a place called Killin in Scotland. There was a small road that you could walk along next to the caravan site, which took you to the entrance to a field that had a path to walk around the Loch.
The first bit of the road was fine. You crossed a bridge, there were a few houses on the left but then there was a stretch that had trees on either side. Now I wasn't really a child that was phased by being in forests etc. We went to places with forests and walks in the middle of nowhere all the time, but this stretch of road terrified me. As a young child I had to get one of my parents to carry me and I would hide my eyes the whole way through that bit. I used to panic the whole way because we had 2 little dogs and I was so scared something was going to happen to them or me. Like something was going to come and snatch us away. Then my younger brother was born and I honestly remember feeling sick to my stomach walking through there with him as a little baby/toddler. I went back a couple of times as a teen and still felt pretty uneasy walking through there, although that could have just been because of the memories as a child.
I used to get this image in my head of big old grave stones at the top of the hill the trees went up. I have bo idea if there were graves stones up there though. I also have bo idea if anything bad had ever happened there, but I've been to loads of really old places in my life. Done ghost walks, been to old jails and castles as a child and I never felt like that anywhere else.

TotheletterofthelawTHELETTER · 17/01/2022 22:11

[quote whiteworldgettingwhiter]**@Nowayoutonlydown* - She text me that night and asked how I knew. Knew what? That he had raped and attempted to murder his ex.hes on some sort of lifelong thing where he has to give the details of his crime before he sleeps with someone.*

This is batshit. Some people a on this thread are just daft.

Why would have been in your friend's house? Why would she have let him in? Why didn't she tell you about him when she saw toy were talking to him?

And there is NO 'lifelong thing where a criminal has to give details of his crime before he sleeps with anyone'! Where's your critical thinking? How would this ever be policed? And why on earth would anyone do this? 🙄🙄🙄[/quote]
Sexual Harm Prevention Orders quite regularly have this clause in. Offender managers in public protection teams police it, spot checks on offenders with it in their licence etc, polygraphs are used if they believe someone has breached it in some cases.

IncompleteSenten · 17/01/2022 22:11

Yes

Next door neighbours son when I was a kid. Gave me the heebie-jeebies. Later he was found to have assaulted a little girl.
Friends boyfriend creeped me out. He went on to grope me.
(Now Ex) husband of a woman I know turned my stomach from the day I met him. He is currently in prison for attempting to meet up with a very young teenage girl for sex. Turned out to be a vigilante group. While that was being investigated the fucking creep went and did it again. But again it was this group. Not only is he a disgusting pervert but he's as thick as pigshit.

But there have been more times that I've been wrong than I've been right. I remember those three because they're bloody awful but I often really don't take to people and never learn anything bad about them.

There's also been people I thought were ok who turned out to be total twats so 🤷‍♀️

HappyBunny123456789 · 17/01/2022 22:10

We're not getting into a "sensible conversation" because you've literally got no way to prove your outlook on life is valid, and neither do I. These things are intangible but making everything soothingly black and white and then escaping makes this world a more bearable place to live in. I get that.

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 17/01/2022 22:09

Read the 'Gift of Fear'. We often pick things up without being able to pinpoint what it is we are reacting to. The book tells us to trust our instincts.

KERALA1 · 17/01/2022 22:09

No Im hopeless at this -used to do criminal law and as a trainee was happy to accept a lift at night from a client after a meeting - a senior barrister ran after us and told client we needed a further discussion and he should go ahead without me then turned to me and said I was insane to even consider getting into a car with client on my own! I had thought he was quite nice. I met murderers and rapists and never got the sixth sense

LouiseBelchersBunnyEars · 17/01/2022 22:07

I don’t think I would describe evil as supernatural personally, for me, acts I would describe as ‘evil’ are committed by those with no remorse, by those with no empathy, the kind of people who get pleasure out of torturing people/animals.

In my head those people are evil.

Saying evil doesn’t exist, in my mind is just like saying good or bad doesn’t exist.

You can’t objectively say one way or another as it’s subjective as to how an individual interprets ‘evil’

Kanaloa · 17/01/2022 22:04

Okay, I mean I don’t think we’re going to really be able to get into any type of sensible conversation about it.

I guess the difference is that you wonder about whether we’re all ‘fundamentally good’ and I don’t believe anyone is fundamentally good or evil.

HappyBunny123456789 · 17/01/2022 22:01

@Kanaloa I can see why you've extrapolated what I've written to conclude I divide people into goodies and baddies based on some supernatural force. That's not true. I don't know what makes them do what they do. I don't know why I like to stroke pets and some people get actual pleasure from hurting them. I've wondered if we're not all fundamentally "good",but we're born with limitations that are exacerbated by our upbringing. I honestly think think in this scenario Hitler was just born bitter, he didn't actively choose to be evil but his genes and a couple of sucky life events enraged him.

MRSAHILL · 17/01/2022 21:57

Many years ago when I was a teenager, I was walking down a quiet country lane after finishing an afternoon shift at my waitressing job. A fat, ugly, leering man pulled up alongside of me and offered me a lift. He chilled me to the bone and I somehow knew if I got in that car, something terrible would happen to me. I refused and carried on walking very quickly. To my relief, he drove off but instead of waiting ages to catch a bus home as I'd planned, I walked to the nearest phone box and rang my mum at work, begging her to collect me immediately. She told me to wait in the little shop nearby until she arrived. Unfortunately, it was early closing day and I was too shy to tell the shopkeeper about the man and ask if I could wait with her, as I would do if it happened now. I sat outside the shop on a wall, waiting for my mum. It was in a little village and there was absolutely no one around. Suddenly, the car driven by the scary man pulled up alongside me and he asked if I'd had a nice phone call. I realised he must have driven ahead and waited for me, watching while I rang my mum. I was absolutely terrified but told him that I'd rung the police and given them his car registration number and that an officer was on the way to meet me. He swore at me but drove off and my mum arrived soon after. She laughed when I told her and thought I was over exaggerating. Years later I was convinced that I saw the man again on the news. It was levi Bellsfield, the evil monster who murdered young Millie Dowler and some other poor girls.

Kanaloa · 17/01/2022 21:54

[quote HappyBunny123456789]@kanaloa I understand it's more comfortable to have a rational explanation for anything. But that means there's no "good" either, there's just people who had nice upbringings and parents who taught their children to behave. The people who go on to torture, murder and take pleasure in others pain must have been treated pretty badly by their parents. No Peppa for them, just government Covid briefings! :D[/quote]
No it doesn’t. I think you might be struggling to understand. There are good and bad actions. Some of those bad actions are crimes. I do not believe that people who commit those crimes do so because they are fundamentally evil/marked with some supernatural concept of ‘evil.’

And as for comforting to believe blah blah - that’s not me, that’s you. I believe humans are extremely complex creatures who are shaped by their genetics, experiences, culture, and society. You believe that some of us are ‘good’ and some are inherently ‘evil’ as in marked with some supernatural form of malice.

That’s extremely reductive. It’s like a children’s fairytale level of simplicity. This is the good person. She does good things because she was born good. This is the evil person!! She does evil things because she is evil.

It refuses to consider the actual reality of the human condition.

tableanadchairs · 17/01/2022 21:54

In a room with Peter Tobin before he was found guilty of his evil acts. There was just something about him that made me very very frightened and sent shivers down my back

HappyBunny123456789 · 17/01/2022 21:51

@kanaloa I understand it's more comfortable to have a rational explanation for anything. But that means there's no "good" either, there's just people who had nice upbringings and parents who taught their children to behave. The people who go on to torture, murder and take pleasure in others pain must have been treated pretty badly by their parents. No Peppa for them, just government Covid briefings! :D

Kanaloa · 17/01/2022 21:50

What ‘truly evil acts’ is it that can’t be explained? Like can someone actually name an ‘evil act’ that can’t be explained by anything other than the inherent ‘evil’ someone was born with.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 17/01/2022 21:49

Ok @Alexandra2001. I’ll leave it there. You’re asking me to explain “truly evil acts” when it’s something that I don’t believe exists. It’s a pointless question. You’re going in circles. You might as well ask me to explain how Jesus walked on water. I can’t because it didn’t happen.