Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wish I had been thinner when younger?

169 replies

Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 13:01

So this is a really stupid thread but I’ll put it out there anyway. It’s not a TAAT but I just saw a post by someone my age (41) who used to cover Miss Sixty clothes.

I started gaining weight at about 16. I was probably around 11/11 and a half stone until I was 18. Then when I went away to university I slammed it on and was over 14 and a half stone. I was nearly 25 before I lost it and got down to 11 and a half.

I’ve only been below 10 and a half twice when I was ill.

It’s stupid really as in the scheme of things it’s not important. I have a lovely life, a job I like (sometimes) gorgeous kids but I do wish I’d been slimmer and more attractive when younger.

OK now flame me Grin

OP posts:
Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 16:20

I lost a lot after I had my DS, if that helps Flowers

Partly because the little so and so wouldn’t let me put him down for at least six weeks, and also he napped best in the fresh air so we walked miles with the pram Smile

OP posts:
Glitterygreen · 17/01/2022 16:17

I know how you feel OP. The only time I considered myself truly slim was when I was about 17 and a size 8.

In my early 20s I was a size 10-12 and looking back still looked slim but never felt it. But I started working in London after uni and gained weight which I've never lost since. Not massive but I've been a steady size 14 for the past 10 years.

I wish I'd tried harder to maintain a smaller size because now it's so much harder. Weight just used to drop off me when I dieted but now it's much harder to shift.

I'm also pregnant with my first and am worried that this is the start of me just getting bigger and bigger as my mum never lost the weight after she had me and my sister and has always struggled with it since, despite being very slim beforehand. I like to think I'll try and be healthy and lose the lbs after baby is here but I'm not convinced since I haven't even mastered that without a baby wearing me out!

Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 16:12

I think people are trying to help

Or, perhaps more likely, they wish to inform everybody that they were slim and pretty when younger? Wink

@5128gap I know what @Cottagepieandpeas means and possibly it is something you won’t ‘get’ unless you are in this position. For me, although I am a bit overweight, it’s in control and I am nowhere near as big as I once was, not even close. It’s worth losing weight so that my clothes fit, so that I am healthy and am a good role model to my children.

But realistically I am not losing weight so I can be a skinny, pretty girl on a night out (even though this comes with the price of being hassled by men). That isn’t to say it isn’t worth ‘bothering’ but purely in terms of aesthetics, looks do stop being the primary motivator after a while I suppose. And while that’s quite liberating, when you’ve never experienced it, it’s also quite sad.

OP posts:
lumpofcomfort · 17/01/2022 16:10

I was tall, slim and blonde in my teens and twenties but never had a very attractive face - there is always something you don't like about your appearance and you would probably have just honed in on something else you didn't like about your appearance, eg I was obsessed with my big nose. Also, feeling that my figure was the only attractive thing about me led to me developing an eating disorder.

SarahJessicaParkin · 17/01/2022 16:09

And actually, re some pps, I have known head turners / absolute stunners who have struggled a lot with ageing. Because that's who they were; the gorgeous one!

In a way, it's more of a blessing to be average looking or not especially attractive, like me Grin

Moonface123 · 17/01/2022 16:08

Well l was thin as a rake, still am in my 50' s but l can tell you for sure being thin is no guarantee for happiness.
At school l was always about two foot taller, or felt it than everyone else so l earnt myself the nickname Olive Oyl, Lanky Lill etc. l was incredibly self conscious , so much so that l used to wear lots of layers and even on the hottest day l wouldn' t bare my arms or legs for fear of being ridiculed. The thin look wasn' t in when l was a teen, it was more curvy, l was and still am incredibly flat chested, and often got told l looked like a boy, which didn' t help my confidence. My boyfriend said it was like laying on a rack of ribs, and l have lost count how many times l have been asked about my eating habits, do l have periods and have l got an eating disorder, which is highly insulting and incredibly hurtful.
l could probably go on and on but l just wanted to show you a different perspective about the joys of being slim when you are young. It took me a very long time to embrace my natural build, l absolutely hated it as a young girl and teenager, l felt a proper ugly duckling.

SarahJessicaParkin · 17/01/2022 16:06

And*

SarahJessicaParkin · 17/01/2022 16:06

I wish I'd been naturally slim like so many other girls seemed to be when we were teenagers. I managed to be downright skinny in my twenties, but I had to fight tooth and nail with myself. I regret that actually and wish I'd just been a weight that was more natural to me. I'm bigger but not massive now did significantly happier with my body.

But if I could be super slim with minimal effort - yes please!

5128gap · 17/01/2022 16:06

@Cottagepieandpeas

I understand this OP. I’m in my 50s now and feel it’s too late to be slim. I’ve always been overweight but when I look back at pictures of myself as a teenager I was quite pretty (& happy!).
Too late for what? For it to be achievable, or for it to be worth bothering with?
whatsinaname2 · 17/01/2022 16:05

In my younger years I was a head turner. It wasn't always pleasant as I was hassled by men a lot in my teens and 20s, but being good looking, tall and slim also opened a lot of doors that would otherwise have remained closed to me.
Now I'm in my 40s and starting to hit the middle age spread and my face is beginning to look haggard.
It makes me immensely sad to look back at old photos of myself and be reminded of how I was once so fortunate but now have completely lost my looks. So I don't think it really matters what you once looked like or what dress size you were, for some of us it's just the process of ageing which is depressing.

5128gap · 17/01/2022 16:03

I think people are trying to help, and the person telling you they were thin and pretty is just offering the, valid I think, perspective that it may not have been how you imagined if you had been, as its likely you wouldn't have seen yourself that way. Young women's casual confidence as you phrased it, is an elusive thing. Most suffer anxiety about their appearance, if not their weight, then their body shape, face, hair, clothes. Few drift through life secure in the knowledge they are attractive, and when they do, its often down to their character and self esteem rather than their actual looks.

Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 16:00

Oh I know that @DisappearingGirl but I still feel I am at liberty to point out that I am not posting about now, or asking advice about my weight now, or seeking to ‘make up’ for my youth.

I will keep repeating it and hope someone may understand what I am saying.

OP posts:
ElftonWednesday · 17/01/2022 15:58

My advice is to move on from dwelling on your past and work on now, though. You can only make changes now. Perhaps you need to talk to someone about appreciating and loving the girl you used to be and are rather than looking upon your past self critically.

Cottagepieandpeas · 17/01/2022 15:58

I understand this OP. I’m in my 50s now and feel it’s too late to be slim. I’ve always been overweight but when I look back at pictures of myself as a teenager I was quite pretty (& happy!).

JuicySatsuma85 · 17/01/2022 15:58

Not yours! A PPs.

DisappearingGirl · 17/01/2022 15:57

I think weight is a very emotive issue OP, especially on here - every thread about weight ends up in a bunfight! So you may not gain what you hoped from the thread for that reason.

Bells3032 · 17/01/2022 15:56

Honestly I spent most of my 20s skinny after having gained a lot during uni and lost it all at 21 and gained weight in my late 20s. Honestly I have been happier when overweight. When I was slim I had a lot of my guy friends fancy me. It caused a lot of drama and I dated a lot of guys I never really felt like I could be myself around and that I constantly walked on egg shells around. Most just wanted to sleep with me and that's it.

I met my now husband when I was at my biggest... A size 22 at the time. I have zero doubts and insecurities about how much he loves me as well as finds my body sexy as hell.

Id like to be skinnier for my own health but if and when I do it it's for my own sake not for someone else.

Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 15:55

But I’m not posting about now, @ElftonWednesday

I am posting about how I feel about my past.

OP posts:
Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 15:54

@5128gap

How did you see the thread going OP? What were you looking for?
I think it’s an interesting discussion but as I explained in my OP, it stemmed from a completely harmless different thread. The OP there was looking back to a time when she wore certain types of clothes.

Coming on a thread like this to say - ooh, I know exactly what you mean but even though I was nothing like you and I was very thin and pretty but I didn’t really appreciate it so really we are the same - do you not think that lacks a bit of sensitivity and tact?

Of course, people are free to say it, but I am also at liberty to point the above out.

OP posts:
ElftonWednesday · 17/01/2022 15:54

You can't change the past. Why not work on your health now?

Then when people post about how much slimmer they used to be in their youth you can congratulate yourself that you are much slimmer now.

I'm 46 and recently hit 11st 6lbs - I also weighed that when I was 16 ( I was actually slimmer in my last teens and 20s but hadn't been anywhere near that weight since before I had DD2 (who is 13)). My heaviest was 14 and a half stone five years ago.

It's not easy when you have to cook for a family and have 101 things to think about but it is possible to lose (a lot) of weight in your 40s. A lot of people find Fast 800/4:3/5:2 helpful. It's also important as you get older as excess weight becomes a greater health concern.

5128gap · 17/01/2022 15:50

How did you see the thread going OP? What were you looking for?

Onceiwasfat · 17/01/2022 15:40

I know @Cam2020 but can people not see that’s the point? I don’t get to look back and marvel at how slim and attractive I was, because I wasn’t Grin And people coming on the thread to tell me that they were is not really where I saw the thread going, if I’m honest.

@JuicySatsuma85 - which post are you reading? Confused

OP posts:
JuicySatsuma85 · 17/01/2022 15:37

You look back on the last 25 years & “have nothing to show for it” because you weren’t skinny? Honestly that’s the most pathetic thing I’ve heard in a long time. It sounds like in the last 25 years you got married, had at least 2 kids, maybe have bought a home, had a career? But because you weren’t skinny you have “nothing to show for it”? Get a grip.

Wilkolampshade · 17/01/2022 15:37

😂 No idea why 'dozen' is in caps... Soz.

Wilkolampshade · 17/01/2022 15:35

I know EXACTLY what you mean OP. I'm 53 and just starting (again) to lose the extra couple of stone that take me into the noticeably fat category. It's a constant battle I've been having all my life. Pictures show I was always fat, even before I was aware of it. In school I was so aware of how the 'normal' girls looked like a different, prettier, more acceptable species to me. I couldn't imagine how it would be to have such elegant arms, legs.. I wore extremely different, homemade clothes to try and put a brave face on it but really, I was just sad, all the time. 🥺 I knew no one would ever really fall passionately in love with me, and I would have to 'settle'.
There are no photos with me and the kids. I think literally fewer than half a DOZEN, and Everyone around me knows I don't want to see myself. I'm tall too, so feel mannish and unfeminine.. ..it doesn't help that my DH is smaller than me.
These days things are better. I'm still big but have made peace with and now love myself having realised how a lot of the eating behaviours of my childhood were not my fault.
Maybe spend some time on yourself this year OP and make it a goal to have some nice pictures of yourself, that you control and are happy with, by the end of it.