Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sad that lazy DS probably isn’t going to reach his academic potential

190 replies

bigroundsun · 17/01/2022 10:02

DS is now 17 and in year 12 so first year of A’levels. He’s always coasted at school achieving very well with minimum effort. He’s well behaved and does homework but that’s it.
Now he’s doing A’levels this attitude is really starting to worry me. Any encouragement from me to put in extra effort to ensure he gets the high grades he needs for the university course he’s interested in is pretty much ignored. I know that at his age it’s up to him but I can’t help but feel disappointed. Since he was little I’ve had high hopes for him as he was always so naturally clever, but I feel like he’s throwing it away. Help me get a grip!

OP posts:
Sloughsabigplace · 17/01/2022 11:21

Oh and so tried it all - nagging, bribes, outright threats. Nothing worked.

Sloughsabigplace · 17/01/2022 11:19

I’ve been there with my ds, he’s 19 now.

He’s very good at the things he enjoys - for example, got level 9 at GCSE for English and history but level 2 (!) for maths and IT as he’s always hated the subjects and just couldn’t be arsed with them.

He didn’t get to do A levels in English, politics and history like he wanted because he failed maths, everyone told him that it would be the case for years but he still didn’t care, just hated maths and wouldn’t do it.

He had to do a BTEC in something he hated as a means to an end to get UCAS points to do the thing he wanted fo do, and only got through it due to lockdown and being able to just plough through it in a couple of months at home. He only scraped a level 4 maths when he re took becuase he didn’t want to have to do it again.

I just had to let him get on with it.

QueenOfToast · 17/01/2022 11:15

I'm another one with a 17 year old DS who is coasting along. He's in year 13 and has offers from RG universities, but I'm worried whether he will achieve those grades without a bit more work. He hardly does any work at home - he says that he gets it. done in his free periods at school. School agree that he's meeting expectations, but does not stretch himself.

I know from previous experience with this DS that nagging/shouting/threats/bribes will not work and that he now needs to make his own choices.

One of the things I try to remind him (and myself!) is that 5 minutes extra work is still worth it. You don't have to work for 5 hours every evening, but keeping your books organised and a quick read through of what you've done that day/week is better than nothing.

Doesn't stop me worrying though.

Beamur · 17/01/2022 11:14

It's frustrating for you, but aside from encouraging him, it's really up to him. He may be doing better than you know or he might get some disappointing results which might spur him on..

edwinbear · 17/01/2022 11:14

I did really well at GCSE level - A's and a couple of B's with very minimal effort. I was pushed into A levels I didn't really want to do, nor had natural aptitude for, by my parents and basically failed the lot. I walked away with a D, U, N in my 3 core subjects and a D in General Studies. The 2 D's got me into an ex poly to read economics, which I'd not studied at school, but I absolutely loved and excelled at. It was a risk to read a subject I knew nothing about, but the concept really interested me.

Failing my A levels was the shock I needed and I realised if I wanted any chance in an economics related career, I'd need to make up for it with my degree, especially given it would be from an ex poly. I worked really hard, got a 2:1, and have worked in investment banking my entire career. I really did need to understand the consequences of failing my A levels for myself, there is nothing my parents could have done at that stage to make me study harder, but it ultimately, didn't ruin my life.

BrunoJenkins · 17/01/2022 11:13

[quote bigroundsun]@Skeumorph that’s so true. I’m struggling to accept his lack of drive it’s incredibly frustrating.
Even though he’s doing homework he’s got exams coming up soon but not doing anything extra to prepare for them and any encouragement from me is met with ‘in a minute’ or ‘I will’ but doesn’t happen.[/quote]
His teachers will be setting revision tasks as part of his homework

hivemindneeded · 17/01/2022 11:08

Sorry but YABU. He knows what grades he needs for a course. You might need to tell him that the top unis aren;t keen on students resitting. But apart from that, tell him you trust him to put in the hours he needs or to review his aspirations.

They have so much going on at this stage in their lives. With Covid on top, not surprising motivation is rock bottom.As PP's say, he has time to develop a work ethic and get the grades he needs.

LovelyMoans · 17/01/2022 11:05

His homework doesn’t seem to take him long though, although from sneaky looks through his books he’s getting decent marks for it.

Are you sure he isnt doing enough? If he is very able it may simply be that it won't be much of a stretch for him to continue getting high grades.

Namenic · 17/01/2022 11:04

A levels is v early on. Lots of people have hiccups on the way. I was v driven, conscientious and I’ve had my share of failure and issues.

Just talk to him about what he wants from life and show the link to his exams. Personally I discuss the competitiveness of jobs and difficulty if they wish to buy a house with my kids who are primary age. I say that work put in now will increase their chances of getting a job of their choice (either well paying or interesting or both - depending on their motivation). Catching up with Studying later on (eg during uni or after while working will be a lot harder because they they will have to do it in their spare time). So any effort they can do now will likely help them in the future.

thecombineharvester · 17/01/2022 11:02

Don't pressure him. You'll undermine any internal motivation he does have. And don't worry about him - if he is genuinely clever he can turn things around at any point. You can go to university in your mid-twenties, or you can do a Masters' at a 'fancier' university than your undergrad, if you want to. A-levels are very much NOT the be-all and end-all. I even know people who went into medicine later in life.

The minute he decides he wants to work hard he will do it, and it will probably be when he really sees that there's something in it for him, not to please someone else.

Also - and I don't think this is him - I underachieved/looked like I was coasting due to adhd. But I have a high earning job/career now, a few years after being diagnosed. My point being that you can struggle in your career for a long while but then turn it around at any point, even mid thirties. Education is life long now, it's not all about A Levels and a degree by 21.

DropYourSword · 17/01/2022 10:58

@lastqueenofscotland

Knuckles down not knickers Down!!! Blush
Oh god, that's a funny typo!
Angrymum22 · 17/01/2022 10:54

My DS17 is exactly the same. Has always found school easy and even with the bare minimum of work is a high achiever. He disengaged this time last year, did zero work or revision but still came away with grade 7s and above in 10 GCSE’s. School did 3 lots of exams to base grades on so it wasn’t just an estimation. He was predicted 8s and 9s. We were delighted with his results because we knew how little he did, however, sad he didn’t feel that he’d let himself down.
He is doing ok at A level but still has the breeze through attitude.
I have to admit that I was very much the same, I realised that life is a balance and life is for living, reaching beyond your capabilities can lead to stress and anxiety. I breezed through my degree, when others burned the midnight oil studying I was partying. But maybe this is how it should be, if you have to constantly struggle to achieve then anxiety becomes your best friend. Ultimately you end up in a roll you are unable to sustain.
Breezing through life is ok. Struggling to keep up is stressful and frustrating.
Your DS’s natural ability will always show through, just be thankful you don’t have to invest time, stress an money to wring the last bit of ability out of him to achieve a decent set of results.
DS is at a selective independent school where some children are asked to leave if they can’t keep up. So many parents, who are already shelling out thousands in school fees, are paying even more in extra tutoring just so the children keep their place.
They have their whole lives ahead of them and plenty of time to do a u turn. Pushing them into a bottle neck career pathway will lead to burnout.
I was very sure that I wanted to be a dentist and even now, 40 yrs down the line, really love my job. I want DS, who currently has no idea what he wants to do, not to feel shoe horned into a career not of his choice. We let him choose his Alevel subjects, not my preferred choices in view of his ability but he wanted to do subjects he hadn’t done before. His GCSEs will get him into Russell group unis with a good set of grades at A level and with a general degree he will have a good baseline education for whatever career he chooses.
It is so unfare that you have to make future limiting choices at such an early age, particularly for the current A level students who have missed out on so much over the last two years.

lastqueenofscotland · 17/01/2022 10:52

Knuckles down not knickers Down!!! Blush

lastqueenofscotland · 17/01/2022 10:52

OP that was me and then got through my second year of uni, realised I had to actually do some work and I wasn’t special, just bright enough to wing GSCEs/Alevels.
Knickers down, now have and MSC, a good job and working (hard!!!) toward some prestigious professional qualifications. I think until he realises he can’t coast, he will coast.

MsChatterbox · 17/01/2022 10:51

If its his first year he might do poorly in his AS levels and give him a kick up the bum to study more for resits. This is what happened to me. D and E in as levels (I actually thought I was reading it wrong as like your son got by with minimal effort before!)... As in A levels.

bigroundsun · 17/01/2022 10:50

@Skeumorph that’s so true. I’m struggling to accept his lack of drive it’s incredibly frustrating.
Even though he’s doing homework he’s got exams coming up soon but not doing anything extra to prepare for them and any encouragement from me is met with ‘in a minute’ or ‘I will’ but doesn’t happen.

OP posts:
LemonViolet · 17/01/2022 10:49

[quote bigroundsun]@BrunoJenkins that’s quite reassuring thank you. His homework doesn’t seem to take him long though, although from sneaky looks through his books he’s getting decent marks for it.
@vodkaredbullgirl I concerned that his teachers will be predicting his university grades based on work he’s doing this year.[/quote]
His teachers will be giving predicated grades…..based on the work he’s done that he’s got decent marks for??? What is your worry, what more do you want???

vodkaredbullgirl · 17/01/2022 10:47

What does he want to do, when he goes to uni?

DropYourSword · 17/01/2022 10:46

Is there any chance he's just frustrated with / pushing back on the pressure you put on him.

Step back a little.

He's doing fine. His goals and ambitions might not be the same as your goals and ambitions for him.

BigSandyBalls2015 · 17/01/2022 10:45

One of mine was the same, great GCSEs without making any effort at all, however she couldn't pull that off at A level and left with nothing.
Thankfully she wasn't interested in uni and got herself a job which she loves, but if your DS is interested in uni then he needs to buckle down.

Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat · 17/01/2022 10:44

Is there someone who could intervene, a teacher, a sports coach or a family member who he really respects?

My Mum used to try to shame me about cooking when I was younger. It didn't work. It had the opposite effect as I couldn't stand the constant comments. I really love cooking now and might have gone in that direction careerwise if she had shut the fuck up!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/01/2022 10:44

Also, the way things are done in many workplaces, you’re better off with a higher class degree from a less well known/ thought of Uni, than a lower class degree from a Uni where it’s very rigorous.

(Disclaimer - this isn’t me being sour grapes as I got a good class degree!)

SirChenjins · 17/01/2022 10:42

DS1 was the same - very bright but lazy AF. He didn’t get into his first choice of university which he now regrets, but went to another university which was actually better for him as it had better links to industry. He got a very good Masters and he’s now working as a graduate in a large multinational and doing very well. He really just needed to mature, which thankfully he’s done. I’m sure your DS will be fine, it sounds like he’s just a bit fed up with school which is understandable after years of classrooms and exams. He’ll get there in his own time by following his own path Smile

Grinnypiggy · 17/01/2022 10:42

It may not mean much long term tbh. I studied hard, got good grades, went to uni, then didn't know what I wanted to do with my degree so have only had jobs, not a career, and never earned more than 23k. That's fine, I don't mind, but I know some people would see that as underachieving. I just made choices which made me happy and I don't regret anything. But getting good grades didn't help me really.
My best friend on the other hand, did poorly at school, then went to college in her early twenties, worked her way up, and is now an engineer on nearly 40k.
Anecdotes don't help your son I know. Can you talk to him about what he wants to do career wise? If doctor obviously he needs to pull his socks up! But if he doesn't know, then there probably isn't anything you can do apart from pointing out that good grades will give him easier options later.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/01/2022 10:42

My youngest brother completely coasted at school, especially in A levels, and for CCD. He’s the highest earning of the three of us by far!

I got AAB and I’m the lowest earning