Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sad that lazy DS probably isn’t going to reach his academic potential

190 replies

bigroundsun · 17/01/2022 10:02

DS is now 17 and in year 12 so first year of A’levels. He’s always coasted at school achieving very well with minimum effort. He’s well behaved and does homework but that’s it.
Now he’s doing A’levels this attitude is really starting to worry me. Any encouragement from me to put in extra effort to ensure he gets the high grades he needs for the university course he’s interested in is pretty much ignored. I know that at his age it’s up to him but I can’t help but feel disappointed. Since he was little I’ve had high hopes for him as he was always so naturally clever, but I feel like he’s throwing it away. Help me get a grip!

OP posts:
NerrSnerr · 17/01/2022 14:30

My mum would have said this about me at this age. She has never quite been able to hide her disappointment that I wasn't what she imagined I'd be. I do fine, got a degree, have a decent job but it's not what was expected.

I may have had 'potential' but all the pressure of being a high achiever wasn't and still isn't for me. I have a comfortable mediocre life and it's fine.

sillysmiles · 17/01/2022 14:19

If his learning style and working ethic is to "coast" then what's the point in aiming for a course where he'll need to work really really hard for 4 years - when that is clearly not his ambition

You haven't said what it is that he wants to do after school? Are you projecting a career that he has no interest in on him?

Maybe he already has a work life balance sorted!

SocialConnection · 17/01/2022 14:16

Get a grip. They've been through shit the last few years. You say he always does well without too much effort? Well, this will either happen again in which case great, he's got his grades. Or it won't - and it will be a big wake up shock that any amount of mum going on at him could never achieve. If the results are not good enough he can retake. A year out working and travelling (if allowed of course) would do him good and make him more mindful and resilient about going into further education. Let it go. It's his life, he needs to experience it. He's not a kid any more, he's a young man.

Joined4this · 17/01/2022 14:11

I wish I had the answer OP I am in the same situation. But with the benefit of seeing myself not shine in my career thanks to being lazy. I did get an average degree after getting average A Levels and could have been earning so much more straight out of uni if I had just made the effort. But boys/alcohol/mental health got in the way. Nowadays I get top grades in everything, always go the extra mile to the point my kids biggest complaint is that I’m extra (do too much). But it feels as if it’s too little, too late. I have tried incentivising my kids to do an extra hour of work a day, without much success. Also, find something they do enjoy or excel at. The old adage” If it’s fun, it doesn’t seem like work” is true. I say this because the one who excels in one area puts a huge amount of effort in. That discipline and hard work applied to one area can also be of use getting them to work hard in other areas.

bigroundsun · 17/01/2022 14:07

These are all extremely helpful replies and have made me realise the only person who can do this is DS and no amount of encouragement from me will change that. I do like the praise idea though @FiddlefigOnTheRoof and am going to give this a go as he does respond very well when he gets good feedback from teachers. I suppose I need to let go of the dreams I had for him and let him get on with his life his way even though it’s difficult not to try to step in.

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 17/01/2022 14:00

You need to see what the teachers say at parents evening or on the end of year report. If they’re happy there is little you can do. They should be pushing him - mine certainly did.
Any sensible school will think carefully about predicted grades. Most schools tend to inflate them because they know that many unis will give an offer based on the predicted grades and might well be flexible if the end result is only a little lower. If they predict too low, the student might well not get the offers which will not work out well for the school. I’ve discussed this with the head of 6th form at school - I’m a Univ lecturer.
At the end of the day he needs to be able to motivate himself. I can spot students who clearly only worked when their parents piled the pressure on . It doesn’t augur well for their degree performance.

Chouetted · 17/01/2022 13:49

Also to add, the extra effort may not pay off, if he's really that bright. I understand A levels have changed a bit, but in my day it was more about targeting the mark scheme than actually thinking. I drove my teachers potty by coming up with correct answers that went too deep, used a different method, or veered in a slightly different direction. Revising for me looked like studying the mark schemes and learning what was expected of me. If I'd put any extra effort on I'd have made the situation worse!

OverByYer · 17/01/2022 13:46

My son was like this. I had to leave him to it, if I’d pushed him he’d have gone in the opposite direction. He took 3 years out, traveled and took som rubbish jobs.
In October 21 he enrolled at our local uni on a good course and is working really hard - he wouldn’t have if he’d gone straight from school.
The fact that they have to pay their way through uni means they can go at any point in their life.
Try to stay cool, and supportive and fingers crossed with time he will see if he wants a good lifestyle he will need to work for it

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 17/01/2022 13:43

And maybe try to inspire him but focussing on his goals. Take him to universities etc? He’ll realise he has more choices if he works hard now.

FiddlefigOnTheRoof · 17/01/2022 13:42

Kids of all ages react better to praise than nagging. Maybe back off, then when he does do some revision, you can jump on this and say ‘that’s great, you’ll see extra effort really pays off. I’m proud of you for putting that effort in. Then no matter your mark, you will know you tried your hardest.’ Or whatever.

purplemunkey · 17/01/2022 13:41

Mine aren't teens yet, so I've not been through this - but in my own experience I was always a B student being told I had potential to be an A student. To be honest I was always quite happy achieving what I did. I'm the same now in my career. I work hard enough, do well, get good results and reviews - never a 'star performer' though. I just can't be arsed.

If his current level of effort actually puts his future plans at risk, it might be worth intervention. But if he's doing ok and he's happy, then just leave him to it.

gsaoej · 17/01/2022 13:40

Bribe with hard cash

Namenic · 17/01/2022 13:39

Haha - exconstance - I tell my kids the opposite! Interesting philosophies. As long as they try hard, I don’t mind. Obviously when they get bigger they can choose to work hard or not, but being able to push yourself and shift up a gear if they needed it can be helpful.

Nomoreporridge872 · 17/01/2022 13:38

I think you’re right to be concerned. I was bright and coasted, which works for GCSE (I got all As and A*s with very little work) but that just doesn’t cut it for a levels. It has impacted some of the jobs I can apply for as they don’t take less than 3 A grades at a level, so yes it does matter. As someone else suggested can you get one of his teachers to give him a kick up the bum? There is still plenty of time. If he does badly in his mocks that should really be all he needs to tell him he’s not doing enough

elbea · 17/01/2022 13:37

This was probably me at school, coasted getting top grades until A Levels where I got two Cs and an E. I was absolutely not interested, did no work etc…

I did an apprenticeship, found out what I was interested, did a degree and was earning significantly more than the national average by 25. A Levels are important but definitely aren’t the only thing that matters.

ExConstance · 17/01/2022 13:35

I used to tell my children that if they got an "A" for achievement I didn't care if they got an "E" for effort. To be able to get good grades without busting a gut seemed to be good preparation for adult life to me.

CatsArePeople · 17/01/2022 13:28

If he wants to go into a competitive field like medicine or dentistry he will be ruling himself out

Let's face it - this kid is hardly doctor material

Chouetted · 17/01/2022 13:21

@Sceptre86

There isn't much you can do apart from continue to be the supportive parent you clearly are. It must be so difficult to stand by whilst your kid wastes his potential but one thing I would say is that he should get a wake up call when he sits his mocks. The depth of knowledge is greater at a-level and the questions on exam papers are not just simply wrote, they require you to correctly identify the principles you need and apply them. That is often what catches out kids that did well at GCSe with very little effort. It's a different ballgame at A-level.

I completely disagree with the poster who said he has years to achieve his academic potential
If he wants to go into a competitive field like medicine or dentistry he will be ruling himself out of he doesn't get the necessary grades at A-level. You can of course do access courses but they too are competitive and it is a very long winded way of getting there. I'm not saying it can't be done but as a mature student there will be other factors that he would have to take into consideration that aren't at play now.

I'm not honestly sure studying medicine is the best example of "reaching your academic potential" - I was friends with the medics at my uni., and it mostly seemed to involve late nights, and a knack for rote memorisation. I would walk into their rooms and the walls would literally be plastered with information.

But, we don't know what he wants to do, and the OP did specifically say academic potential, so I think we can assume not a vocational subject.

MatildaTheCat · 17/01/2022 13:20

I feel your pain DS2 was a pretty lazy student. Never even read his A level Eng lit books all the way through. He somehow managed to achieve A* AA but it was a bit of a miracle.

Does your DS want to go to uni? If so going on visits and understanding that he’ll have to make the effort to go where he wants might be a more tangible reason to get down to some proper work.

Diddlydeee · 17/01/2022 13:13

I’m on both sides of this

Me: coasted through college and failed. In the end I restarted, did well at University and have a great career. But I did lose 2 years while being lazy and phaffing about

My son: high achiever, lazy, complacent and can’t be arsed. It’s painful to watch but frustrating knowing I was exactly the same.

Foxyloxy1plus1 · 17/01/2022 13:05

Not everyone is suited to a university education, although the aim was for 50% to have one.

There are some degrees that are ineffective in terms of leading to a career and some people would be better off following a different path.

Does he actually want to go to university? Does he have thoughts about a career? Sometimes people have to fail before they succeed.

TillyTopper · 17/01/2022 12:52

As long as he's happy and not expecting you to continue to fund his lifestyle then surely it's up to him?

Nonimity · 17/01/2022 12:47

I am just going through the same. After Xmas hols DS announced he wasn’t going back to college. I think that this year is a bigger challenge for yr 12s. They missed so much school, did easier GCSEs and then are expected to just step up to A level study. I don’t know how true this is but the college told me that the drop out rate is extraordinarily high for the year group. My son is changing direction and will study from home before joining college again in September. There are lots of cheap/ free courses out there.

Slingingcontest · 17/01/2022 12:46

I don't have a clue about boys or any professional skills in education; so the following are just a few ideas that I have picked up as a parent of a teen (and temp guardian of a young adult) and from the situations of friends and family , which may or may not be helpful, and may or may not apply to your individual son:

I think it is wise to stay out of conflicts in areas where teens have all the power eg food and study. But that doesn't mean that you don't show interest, ask pertinent questions, show support and encouragement, communicate with teachers, maybe express certain expectations (carefully) that are related to effort more than achievement, facilitate calm study areas and timetables, prepare snacks etc. Sometimes just sitting down regularly at home in a quiet space yourself and doing a couple of hours of your own work consistently over the week can help them to develop good habits and give them some companionship. But ultimately, the effort has to come from him. And he needs to be aware of that too.

I think his peers and the school ethos play a huge part in this. If he is in a school where effort and academic achievement is encouraged and it's not seen as uncool to study, then that is some part of the battle won. It still depends on individual effort though. A good school will start upping demands around the age of fifteen/sixteen but some pupils, especially boys, can be late developers. How mature is your ds in the rest of his non-academic life? It's good to take that in to account as I've found that teens can be high achieving in one area and not so good in another; progress isn't always even or linear.

Teens aren't always known for their forward planning skills ! Smile Something that might help is a day out or a weekend away devoted to getting him to think about his future. This might include visiting someone doing a job in an area he is showing some interest in and researching it together - even writing out in map form - the steps it takes to get there. The discussion with the adult should include the benefits of doing the job in terms of personal fulfilment, challenges overcome, independence (flat?/car?) and the skills that job requires. Maybe a few on-line college or rl university visits? Discussions with uni students you know?

You might take your DS to lunch and ask him how he sees the next five years panning out? Maybe avoid getting too bogged down in career talk but try and connect with him on a more adult-to-adult level and tell him how excited and interested you are to know what direction he is going to take his life in, and get the message across that he has the control and needs to plough his own furrow. I think adopting the position of "interested to know what you are going to come up with" is a better dynamic than "frustrated parent constantly forced to nag" ifyswim because it puts the ball in his court.

It's so hard emotionally as a parent to step back, watch them make mistakes, and let them find their own way. One of the hardest things about parenting in fact. But it is imho so much better to do this in their teens than find yourself with adult offspring who have "failed to launch" because they haven't learned to take responsibility for themselves.

One of the difficulties with modern education is that pupils can be bombarded with rules and assessments and "what they cannot do" for seven years and they forget to empower students with the skills and strategies required for them to take personal responsibility or indeed emphasise the notion that they are in charge of their own destiny,; so ram that message home. School can appear like a series of discrete, meaningless obstacles that pupils have to jump over without much personal investment. It's our job as parents to connect the dots. Talk to him about how you made your career choices, take him through it step by step. Introduce him to colleagues, friends, encourage and facilitate contacts.

Perhaps set your son a few tasks (either professional or domestic) that are slightly above his level of competence or slightly outside of his comfort zone. Duke of Edinburgh award is good for this but it could be solving a professional (logistic) task involving interacting with adults or voluntary work Involving children or the elderly or conversing in a foreign language, where your teen is put on the back foot a bit (in a safe way) and is designed to shake teens out of any "coasting" behaviour, or feeling like "they know it all", take responsibility, stretch them a bit and build confidence. Overall this can have a good effect on other areas of their life such as academics. (Difficult with a pandemic going on but worth trying!)

Also, it's worthwhile checking out, or at least discussing, how many hours your DS spends on his phone or gaming. Does he have a good life balance? Does he exercise? Is he gaming a lot or on-line when he should be sleeping? Faced with difficult challenges or difficulties sometimes it's easier for our teens to sink in to the comfort of an instantly accessible on-line life, instead of confronting RL realities i.e. their marks! I know I do this when times are stressful! I would have had difficulties with self discipline if I had had a smart phone when I studied that's for sure; with constant notifications sounding, I would have been hopeless. I don't know how teens do it now tbh, with so many distractions at their finger tips!

Something related to living on-line too much can be a certain underlying anxiety (this may not apply to your son). But some teens (often girls) find it difficult to study because they are overwhelmed or anxious or comparing themselves to ridiculously unrealistic levels of perfection that they see on-line. In this case it's helpful as a parent to model tackling tasks that are overwhelming and difficult and breaking them down piece by piece. And working on them consistently and with a positive "let's get stuck in" outlook.

And try not to betray too much anxiety (difficult though this is) around the area of academic achievement. It's such a fine line and will depend on whether they need a rocket, or a bribe, or just some steering, but ultimately you want to avoid being so anxious that they come away thinking you don't believe they are capable! Installing confidence in their capabilities is key! And of course trying to do all of the above while maintaining, most important of all, a good loving relationship!

[Lastly, this probably doesn't apply to your son if he has achieved well previously but always best to check if a student has any learning difficulties. Believe it or not, the teen boy of a friend of mine only had his dyslexia discovered when he was in difficulty with his A-levels. And because the lad was quiet and handed hwk in, his mild learning difficulty had escaped his own attention and that of his parents & teachers.]

Sorry for the essay but I found this period of life with my teen difficult to negotiate! It's really tricky! Good luck Flowers

CatsArePeople · 17/01/2022 12:45

He doesn't want to be an academic. He's probably just "interested" in university to just to please you. What other paths he might consider? Apprenticeship? Military? University won't run away if he rediscovers his motivation later.