Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Feel sad that lazy DS probably isn’t going to reach his academic potential

190 replies

bigroundsun · 17/01/2022 10:02

DS is now 17 and in year 12 so first year of A’levels. He’s always coasted at school achieving very well with minimum effort. He’s well behaved and does homework but that’s it.
Now he’s doing A’levels this attitude is really starting to worry me. Any encouragement from me to put in extra effort to ensure he gets the high grades he needs for the university course he’s interested in is pretty much ignored. I know that at his age it’s up to him but I can’t help but feel disappointed. Since he was little I’ve had high hopes for him as he was always so naturally clever, but I feel like he’s throwing it away. Help me get a grip!

OP posts:
Fhee · 17/01/2022 20:44

Yes, there is room for improvement, but that improvement will come from developing those qualities, which are completely separate from cleverness. Who knows what his potential actually is in that respect.

Slingingcontest · 17/01/2022 20:25

@Fhee

There is no such thing as ‘potential’ that is separate to qualities such as self motivation, ambition, work ethic, focus, drive. If he doesn’t want to, or can’t, apply himself you are going to have to downgrade your ‘dreams’ for him. It will do fuck all for his future levels of success if you manage to put the pressure on to get him to achieve what you think he should be achieving. It will all just fall apart once that external pressure isn’t there any more.
While I agree that hard work, self motivation etc are key; I think this is a bit harsh.

The op's son is only 17 which means his brain is reorganising itself and while it does, he is much more influenced by his limbic system rather than logical thought, which tends to take over again around the age of 24/25 yrs. In other words, there is still room for improvement!

amusedbush · 17/01/2022 20:18

I coasted through school and got solid results in my Standard Grades (GCSE equivalent) without cracking open a book. Then I moved up to Higher level (A-Level), realised I couldn't fluke it, fell behind and couldn't catch up. I got shit grades - I couldn't have gone to uni even if I'd wanted to at that point.

I got a job, got a couple of promotions and when I was 24 they paid for me to attend an evening course at the local college. I kept working there full-time while I did a part-time undergraduate degree and then an MSc. I'm now in the second year of a funded PhD and teaching at a university on the side.

My brother didn't show any interest in academics - ever. I have never seen him read a book. He ballsed up his exams, left school at 16 and lounged around until he got a mechanic apprenticeship when he was 19. He is now 25, qualified, incredibly hardworking and earning more than our parents (not that I'm bitter, living on a grad student stipend Grin).

There are so many different routes to success but our society tries to force teenagers down one single path and it's damaging. I spent years thinking I was "thick" or not cut out for studying because that path didn't work out for me Sad

sanbeiji · 17/01/2022 20:17

[quote bigroundsun]@Wannakisstheteacher he got 7s, 8s and 9s with minimum effort. Therefore I suppose he could have done better with effort but I couldn’t really complain.
I’m just aware that you can’t really approach A’levels in the same way and expect As and A*s.[/quote]
You don't need perfect grades to go to an employable course at a good university. Besides failing miserably at mocks IS a wake up call for many students.

thegreenlight · 17/01/2022 19:59

A recent study (please don’t ask me to link!) suggested that only 8% of success is reliant on academic achievement. I’ve been telling myself that while struggling myself with a lazy and unmotivated but very bright boy!

Fhee · 17/01/2022 19:50

There is no such thing as ‘potential’ that is separate to qualities such as self motivation, ambition, work ethic, focus, drive. If he doesn’t want to, or can’t, apply himself you are going to have to downgrade your ‘dreams’ for him. It will do fuck all for his future levels of success if you manage to put the pressure on to get him to achieve what you think he should be achieving. It will all just fall apart once that external pressure isn’t there any more.

bigroundsun · 17/01/2022 19:27

@Wannakisstheteacher he got 7s, 8s and 9s with minimum effort. Therefore I suppose he could have done better with effort but I couldn’t really complain.
I’m just aware that you can’t really approach A’levels in the same way and expect As and A*s.

OP posts:
Wannakisstheteacher · 17/01/2022 18:12

How did he do in his GCSE’s? Do you think he reached his potential in them?

NiceShrubbery · 17/01/2022 18:08

I have this with DS16. He is clever and articulate but lazy, has always been very erratic and only did the bare minimum last year which resulted in failing 2 key subjects and needing extra tuition. He continued putting no effort in with the tutor, until I said I was no longer paying for the lessons and would let him fail the retakes. That produced the desired effect, he passed them. I didn't congratulate but said he'd done the bare minimum and I was very disappointed with his attitude, he is wasting his chances and letting himself (not me) down, that he'll regret it when he goes to uni, meets a lot of high achievers and realises he could've been one of them but has poor grades below his ability and a poor work ethic.

Basically I told him he's old enough to vote and get a job, and he needs to grow up and take responsibility for his life because nobody else is going to.

Seems to have worked, his grades are really good in all subjects except one he doesn't like, and he's stopped making excuses. I think it is possible, good luck!

sanbeiji · 17/01/2022 17:10

@JuergenSchwarzwald it’s all relative. IME people who claim to be ‘not career focused’ are usually privileged. Subsidised by a higher earning spouse, have family help, or actually earn a good wage (only low by their industry’s standards). Again depends on your worldview - lots on MN moaning about how above NMW job is a privilege .others say earning 30K easy, who knows the truth…

BlackeyedSusan · 17/01/2022 17:05

My ex is the same. Really clever but is happy working on a reasonable job (could achieve more but what's the point of the stress?) and has lots of time for the kids.

JanuaryBluehoo · 17/01/2022 16:57

Can you pay him? Would that motivate him?

NellieWellietheEllie · 17/01/2022 16:57

Sounds like he's doing okay to me. I was like this. Got decent A-levels and a decent degree from a less good uni than I was probably capable of. I've got a decent job. I am much less anxious than most of my peers. Knowing you could do more if you needed can actually be good. I quite like being just a tiny bit lazy. Maybe he's got it right?

JanuaryBluehoo · 17/01/2022 16:56

Op you need to find out what motivates him.

For instance does he appreciate beauty, is oxbridge or Egham uni on his radar!

Is it a course, interest, subject?

Unfortunately it's hard for such young people to understand this stepping stone and what it means.
If he isn't motivated... He isn't motivated unfortunately.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 17/01/2022 16:54

@ExConstance

I used to tell my children that if they got an "A" for achievement I didn't care if they got an "E" for effort. To be able to get good grades without busting a gut seemed to be good preparation for adult life to me.
I was like this at school, coasted and my ds was the same. I've not been massively successful in my career, although I've not had any trouble getting jobs. But I've not been promoted or told to be a mentor to others - I just do what I have to do to get my job done. We're not all careerists and it doesn't matter. Maybe my mother expected me to be a partner of a city law firm and earn £1 million a year. I didn't and I don't but I earn enough to fund the lifestyle I want.

So I'm with you really - my ds is similar to me. He probably won't do as well as a lot of people who do less well at A level and university but work harder, but ultimately career success is down to work ethic, people skills and how much you want to earn, not academics.

Really I just want him to be happy and have a life without loads of (negative) drama. Level of salary is not important as long as he earns enough to be comfortable and not be wondering where the next meal or energy bill is coming from.

sanbeiji · 17/01/2022 16:53

Also people mature differently. Even as children one sibling is a saver, the other a spender.

He’s unlikely to end up in the streets, so don’t fret.

sanbeiji · 17/01/2022 16:51

You mention ‘your dreams’. But in Op- course ‘he’ is interested in. Which is what?

You don’t need ‘super high’ grades for most things.

DerAlteMann · 17/01/2022 16:32

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Also, the way things are done in many workplaces, you’re better off with a higher class degree from a less well known/ thought of Uni, than a lower class degree from a Uni where it’s very rigorous.

(Disclaimer - this isn’t me being sour grapes as I got a good class degree!)

I agree with this. As far as most UK and US employers are concerned UK universities comprise Oxbridge and "the rest". If you are not Oxbridge it's the level of your degree that matters, not where it's from.
TulipsTwoLips · 17/01/2022 16:25

@Skeumorph

Something that I think people realise very late is that drive, ambition and levels of basic laziness ARE a key part of 'academic potential'.

It's not necessarily the cleverest academics who get to the top, or those that have the best/most original ideas... it's those who will doggedly put in the hours writing papers etc., those who will slog at it.

You can probably transfer this to pretty much every industry I imagine.

You absolutely cannot influence it at this stage, but what might happen is that when he fails at something (could well be his A-levels) he will realise that he DOES have some of that drive, and will start turning that element of himself around.

In that sense, it's far better to mess up A-levels than swing those but mess up Uni/placement/first job/whatever.

But however you look at it - in terms of achieving 'success', your ability to put in effort, concentrate, work, not be lazy - they are part of your academic ability, not something that just 'affects' it.

Totally agree
fairylightsandwaxmelts · 17/01/2022 16:21

Life is more than academics.

I was pushed to go to university because I was smart and it was totally the wrong path for me. I did graduate, but with a low 2:2 and my degree was honestly a total waste of time.

I now run my own business in a totally unrelated field and I'm the happiest I've ever been. Please don't let your hopes and dreams force him down a path that's not right for him.

CatsArePeople · 17/01/2022 16:13

My mum would have said this about me at this age. She has never quite been able to hide her disappointment that I wasn't what she imagined I'd be. I do fine, got a degree, have a decent job but it's not what was expected.

I was pressured into academics and a degree because of "potential" (school being effortless). However, I was no academic material. So its mediocre paper-lifting jobs for me. I still wonder if I had done better if I had learned a trade instead.

Embracelife · 17/01/2022 15:51

@bigroundsun

These are all extremely helpful replies and have made me realise the only person who can do this is DS and no amount of encouragement from me will change that. I do like the praise idea though *@FiddlefigOnTheRoof* and am going to give this a go as he does respond very well when he gets good feedback from teachers. I suppose I need to let go of the dreams I had for him and let him get on with his life his way even though it’s difficult not to try to step in.
What are his dreams? What does he want to do?
2bazookas · 17/01/2022 15:28

Relax. Two possibilities

He can swim like a duck. You just can't see what's going on under the surface.

He is in moult. No wonder he looks a mess. When his adult feathers grow in, you'll recognise the secret swan.

UndertheCedartree · 17/01/2022 15:10

Not quite the same but I can sympathise. My 14yo DS is very clever but I home educated him due to his autism. Up until he turned 14 he was always so enthusiastic. He wanted to do well in his studies. He is now at college doing GCSEs and he has that teen apathy. It's frustrating but I remember being exactly the same!

seekinglondonlife · 17/01/2022 15:04

I feel your pain OP. Ds got straight A*s and A's at GCSE with no work and started 4 A levels. Within 2 weeks he wanted to drop out of school as there was too much work and he'd "have to put in effort" Hmm Long story short, I nearly had a heart attack over those 2 years, he was constantly wanting to drop out and become a professional gamer or rugby player. Long story short he's in his first year of uni and wants to drop out of that too. Told him last night I'm not going to financially support him unless he gets his act together. It's so incredibly sad, as he's so bright but cannot be bothered. It makes me so angry as ds2 has learning disabilities and works so incredibly hard for bare passes.