Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel such bad guilt st splitting family to be gay?

141 replies

WorriedWilma123 · 17/01/2022 09:06

I am really struggling with the guilt of this.
I keep looking at divorce statistics and worrying I’m causing untold damage to my 2 children by coming out as gay and hurting their dad during their childhoods.
We will be living together for the foreseeable future mainly got financial reasons which whilst it’s lovely for the children in the respect they both have free access to a lot of time with either of us, it’s so hard for me to see everyday the pretty perfect family unit I have destroyed.
I keep trying to imagine going back to it and wondering if I would be able to - I feel so selfish feeling like this as I do love my husband but the thought of being anywhere near him intimately I can’t even imagine now as it’s been over a year as we’ve been separated fully; separated rooms etc since June last year.
Will the guilt ease or is the guilt telling me to make it work and the children will be happier with their unit back together?

OP posts:
Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 08:53

If you can feel guilty dumping a cheat, you can certainly feel guilty when there’s been no cheating and in a sense ( being gay) ther was no other choice for this relationship.

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 08:52

Is there anyone with kids in a no fault relationship breakup who doesn’t feel a bit guilty ??
A good friend’s b’tard of a DH had an affair with a 21 year old co-worker when friend had just given birth to their 2nd child. She gave him a 2nd chance and decided that actually she deserved better so dumped him.
He was furious as he had ‘generously’ given up the girlfriend to give their relationship a go and blames my friend for their split.
She STILL feels a bit guilty about being the one to split up the family unit.

Isaw3ships · 18/01/2022 07:06

Having a relationship while living with your ex will never be ideal, esp. if the break up isn’t really mutual.

SammyScrounge · 17/01/2022 22:50

@Justilou1

I’m nearly 50 and a lot of my friends (older and younger) have “changed teams” or told me that they are actually bi. We have discussed the possibility that maybe some women were straight and actually changed over time. (Hormonal changes, maybe?) Who knows? The world is a different place to the one we were in two years ago, let alone ten or twenty. Your sexuality isn’t going to affect your kids. Your behaviour and mental health will though. How you break up and how you coparent will as well. There is no such thing as a perfect family. All families have secrets, resentments and arguments. Some are worse than others. If you are honest with yourself and leave your husband to find happiness with someone who can truly love him the way he needs, surely that can only benefit your kids. Your kids will grow up in an environment with at least one parent who is “safe” to discuss their own identity issues with if they realise that they are not straight too.
Why on earth would the children have 'identity issues' if they realise that they are not straight too'
AlwaysinaFlap · 17/01/2022 17:37

@draramallama

The end of any relationship is sad and painful. But you can't live a life without experiencing sadness or pain - they're temporary and survivable emotions.

If the op had simply posted that she had fallen out of love with her husband and it wasn't salvageable, she wouldn't be condemned like she has been by some here. What difference does it make that she realised she had fallen out of love with him because she was gay?

She says she didn't cheat - fair enough. She has agreed to live separately with her H in the same home and that has been a year now but refers to her girlfriend and partner so there IS another relationship there .

Her question however is about her guilt which no one can answer for her!

Isaw3ships · 17/01/2022 17:17

OP has repeatedly said she hasn’t cheated. But even if she had, then what? She’s supposed to stay with a bloke because of that??

AlwaysinaFlap · 17/01/2022 17:14

@WorriedWilma123

I’m just not coping with the guilt I’ve broken my children’s home. I’m not going to go back over the other threads as it’s not helpful. Financially I can’t leave and give the children a stable home for when they’re with me and he doesn’t want that anyway, he doesn’t want the kids living between 2 houses: So it’s a decision we’ve both made for the time being as I do all the childcare and he can’t due to his job.
I’m not going to go back over the other threads as it’s not helpful

but relevant

AlwaysinaFlap · 17/01/2022 17:12

@WorriedWilma123

I didn’t post the details on this thread because as it shows without even doing so it completely takes over. I didn’t have an affair. I told him I was gay and we separated. Everyone said I was having an affair with her before this point because she was a friend but I WAS NOT. She told me she was in love with me and after I realised I felt the same I told my husband, had counselling, cut contact and then last summer we sat down and decided to separate as my feelings hadn’t changed. He told the children I was gay so to all those asking that, there is no pretence, the kids are fully aware of that fact.
But you refer to her as your partner?
Glitterygreen · 17/01/2022 15:45

I just don't think you're ever going to be able to move on and feel better until you break this status quo OP.

It was extremely tough for my DP when he split from his ex too. He had to move back in with his parents and didn't get to see his children every day anymore, but with time and space they all came through it and out the other side. Things are better for both parents and children now that they're not constantly niggling at each other and trying to force something that just wasn't there anymore.

I understand you feel guilty but you need to try and move past this. You are still a good mother who is doing her best for her children. You don't sound like your mindset has moved on much from your last thread, but you need to try and get out of this headspace. What's done is done and plenty of parents split up along the way. You will all be fine.

phishy · 17/01/2022 15:09

It doesn't sound like OP cheated, from the post shared upthread. She went for a coffee with a woman after husband told her to do what she wanted.

Mydogmylife · 17/01/2022 14:58

@AlternativePerspective

Why are you posting this again?

In this post you have omitted to mention that the reason you are leaving your husband is because you had an affair with the OW you are planning to leave him for.

Being gay is a red herring.

You cheated on your husband. That’s no different whether it was with another man or a woman. And chances are that if your children find out they will have negative feelings towards you not because of your sexuality but because you cheated on their father.

Gosh, this kind of changes things a bit. OP has cheated ( whether with a man or woman) and hasn't just been wrestling with her sexuality. Disappointing, I'm a staunch believer that if things aren't going well with your partner ( for whatever reason) you either have a good go at sorting it out or end the relationship before having an affair with someone else.
WorriedWilma123 · 17/01/2022 14:51

It’s just the guilt

OP posts:
Isaw3ships · 17/01/2022 14:25

‘ but I don't think anyone who actually believes you could stay with your husband would dare poat publicly here.’

Why the F would any half sane person tell a gay woman to stay in her heterosexual marriage to a man for the sake of, what? The kids? Convention? God?
Get a grip. The reason no-one is telling someone who wants to end a marriage to stay in that marriage is because they know that it’s not the 1960s and a woman unhappy in her marriage doesn’t have to suck it up and stay miserable for the sake of convention.

Isaw3ships · 17/01/2022 14:09

‘People find it hard to understand how someone couldn't know they were gay. Maybe that's something that needs to be talked about more as I didn't know that could happen.’

Literally happens all the time.

Many children learn, directly or indirectly, that only men and women should have sex with each other. Heterosexuality is taught as the norm. If your sexual orientation doesn’t align with that dictate, you might repress your feelings in order to avoid rejection, to fit in, to not disappoint your parents, your family. Section 28 was in force from 1988 to 2003. That’s a lot of years making gay kids feel they were abnormal and wrong. People Come out later in life all the time, and not because they just like to mess things up for their families. Homophobia is rife

You only have to look at some of the comments on here to see that. If OP
Had said she had fallen out of love with her DH and couldn’t see herself being intimate with him would people be queuing up to tell her she’d ruined his life??

WorriedWilma123 · 17/01/2022 14:05

I’m just not coping with the guilt I’ve broken my children’s home.
I’m not going to go back over the other threads as it’s not helpful.
Financially I can’t leave and give the children a stable home for when they’re with me and he doesn’t want that anyway, he doesn’t want the kids living between 2 houses:
So it’s a decision we’ve both made for the time being as I do all the childcare and he can’t due to his job.

OP posts:
MimiDaisy11 · 17/01/2022 13:36

If the op had simply posted that she had fallen out of love with her husband and it wasn't salvageable, she wouldn't be condemned like she has been by some here. What difference does it make that she realised she had fallen out of love with him because she was gay?

People find it hard to understand how someone couldn't know they were gay. Maybe that's something that needs to be talked about more as I didn't know that could happen. And so if they don't accept that they see dishonesty.

RealBecca · 17/01/2022 13:33

Not being funny but you've already split up so why torture yourself over numbers?

Even if you could enter a male-female relationship with the kids dad again it wouldn't mean he would want a relationship with someone who is not into him.

Imo the on-off factor is worse for kids.

XelaM · 17/01/2022 13:33

My best friend's parents divorced when she was a baby, but remained living together at the family home (just in separate rooms) and both had other partners over the years. It worked well for them. Over 30 years later and all their kids out of the house, they still live together - just separate lives.

TedMullins · 17/01/2022 13:27

To all the holier than thou posters chastising the OP for ever getting married if she wasn't sure –just stop. Plenty of people are sure when they get married, then their feelings change down the line. Making marriage vows is not a cast iron guarantee that you'll be together forever and always feel the same. People break up for many reasons, being gay is no worse than any other reason someone might want to leave a marriage.

The OP and her ex husband BOTH deserve to live their lives happily. I agree that bringing in new partners should not be the priority, and that living together is not healthy or conducive to a separation, and I do tend to agree that the person ending the relationship should be the one to leave the home. I don't think that the OP being gay though makes this any worse than any other split. I haven't read previous threads but from the information given here it seems OP came clean to her husband about the other woman she had feelings for. No, it's not great, but it's hardly the crime of the century.

Applesonthelawn · 17/01/2022 13:22

If you can work hard to co-parent well and respectfully with their father, the damage will likely be very minimal, if anything at all, and potentially far less than staying with him. It's not so much the splitting up as how you do it. It may be hard initially to be friends but after a year you should be able to. Find someone's example to copy or develop your own template if you can't. It really doesn't have to be full of bitterness, hurt and recriminations, it's in your hands.

2bazookas · 17/01/2022 13:21

Youngest is 10; why can't you just house-share as family until they are 18/leave home.

There is no need for children to know about or be involved with any relationships either parent conducts in private outside the home.

kateluvscats · 17/01/2022 13:15

@Tal45

To be honest I think the guilt should be towards your husband as well, he married you and had two children with you having no idea (I assume) that you were gay. If you're gay then don't marry someone of the opposite sex, if you're not sure if you're gay don't marry anyone - it's really not that difficult. He's now trapped financially living with the person he thought loved him and that he was building a life with in some kind of limbo, with no opportunity to meet someone who really wants to be with him.

I've been in a similar situation and it sucks. You say you can't imagine being intimate with him but you managed to when you wanted kids with him. I feel really sorry for your husband and I really wish people wouldn't get married unless they were completely sure it was what they wanted.

Agree
Autumndays123 · 17/01/2022 13:08

@AlwaysinaFlap

OK I am confused - on another thread on Sat you said you have a partner you see. Not what you say on here *@WorriedWilma123*

If he happens to be cooking a Sunday dinner for instance this is when I will go out to see partner and he eats with the kids

Yes there is a lot of info omitted in this thread. If I remember rightly, neither the OP nor the husband had anywhere to go and she wanted the husband to move out anyway because she wouldn't be able to get a rental agreement with the income she had. She refused to listen to any advice on increasing income/moving with friends/moving to a bedsit/even a temporary shelter, despite the fact her kids were really really struggling with the situation - her son in particular who wanted to stay with his dad.
Isaw3ships · 17/01/2022 13:06

Trying to have a new relationship while living with an ex like this is very, wry tricky. I know 2 people who e done this - one was fine because the split was mutual and they lived together, separately with kids in house, for over a year but the children did find it confusing. As in why did the parents. We’d to split when they got on so well.
The other was an absolute shitshow, with one partner making the decision re end of relationship when the other wanted to stay together and then finding someone new while they all lived in the same house. That divorce is now absolutely toxic because of the resentment.
Best thing is to try to make a clean break as soon as financially possible - who did what when and why is really irrelevant now.
What is not irrelevant ( despite some posters on her saying it is!) is the fact that you are gay - it the whole impetus for what has happened and in time your DH will look back on what has happened and realise that there wasn’t much he could have done about it and hopefully, it will help him move on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread