Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If a family member moves away - are you obliged to travel to them?

296 replies

BendyWendyCheesyFeet · 17/01/2022 08:15

Parent decided to relocate to another part of the country, a four hour round trip away instead of being in the same town. They can't drive, and they have since realised it's 3 or 4 trains away and a lot of travelling to get to us.

They have complained that we don't see them often enough anymore, but we have three kids in school with clubs at the weekends and it's an absolute nightmare to fit in. Meanwhile they are retired and have no commitments.

I also feel angry that they moved to a really inaccessible location in the first place and just expect us to upheave our family to see them, when they used to have us on their doorstep.

AIBU to say that if you decide to move away from your family, the onness should be on you to go see them the majority of the time.

OP posts:
mrsmigginswiggins · 17/01/2022 10:17

I think anyone can move anywhere, and absolutely should if that will make them happy, if that's the other end of the country, or even abroad.

What the person who moved cannot then do though, is insist that everyone else has to make the effort to visit them and get the hump if they don't!

thing47 · 17/01/2022 10:17

Missing DC's clubs and activities may be nothing to you, but that doesn't mean it is to OP. I prioritise my children over my parents, so definitely wouldn't be insisting they miss out on weekend activities they enjoy to visit grandparents who have chosen to move away.

If the GPs want to maintain a close relationship, the onus really is on them to do so, and it doesn't sound like they are that bothered, so I fail to see any way in which the OP is unreasonable.

lottiegarbanzo · 17/01/2022 10:17

Given your regular weekend commitments, I'd expect you to arrange to see them in school holidays, half terms etc. So you need to plan ahead and all be able to commit to dates, probably for overnight visits.

Days out half way between you could work well too.

I consider it normal for people to move all over the place, so don't see the 'home town' connection as necessarily trumping any other location. But retired grandparents do have choices and they've made one.

Maintaining a relationship can easily be done with 3 or 4 face to face meetings a year and regular video calls. Do what works for you.

Do not get into a habit of 'putting yourself out' in order to have your feelings trampled over. Your DC will feel that discomfort and rejection too and teaching them to ignore their own feelings, in favour of those of domineering selfish people, is not a healthy life lesson for them.

Poundlick · 17/01/2022 10:16

@RedskyThisNight

And by the way - we are in the home town. I think that's what feels so odd. Now that my parent lives in my siblings new town, that seems to be the new home town, rather than this place my parent lived for 65 years.

I think for an awful lot of people, having a "home town" is not really a thing. It's just the place you happen to be living at the moment.

I'm always bemused when I tell people my parents live 4 hours away and they ask "who moved away?". Moved away from where? My parents were the last movers, but since I lived with them (at age 18), I've moved 10 times and they've moved 6, many of these moves to different parts of the country.

Yes, exactly -- the 'who was it who moved?' question that comes up on here so often fascinates me, because it's so alien to me as a way of approaching the issue of seeing family who don't live close by.

to relocate without considering any implications, like how you are going to see people, is odd. To maintain the relationship we had would require us to totally change how we live our lives, no popping by for cups or teas or trips to the park, but having to plan a full day every time we want to see them, and it's only us that has to travel. I feel that's not something we signed up for, that was their decision.

Look, obviously the onus shouldn't be on you to be the ones who always travel, @BendyWendyCheesyFeet (utterly revolting username, by the way! Grin) but it's the rest of the bit I quoted that interests me, again because it feels culturally 'other' -- I suppose it seems to me quite strange to expect that someone else would base their decision on where to live on whether a family member felt it was more convenient for them to stay where they were so they could pop in.

TenoringBehind · 17/01/2022 10:16

2 hours is no big deal.

In your shoes I’d probably do one visit each school holiday, when maybe there aren’t so many weekend commitments. for a day or staying overnight depending on how much you like them!

saraclara · 17/01/2022 10:16

My in-laws lived 2.5 hours away so to me, travelling to see them with babies/toddlers/kids/teens was a norm and not an issue. We are the ones that moved and they came to visit us as well, so I suppose resentment didn't come into it.

However, my mum, in her mid to late 70s, moved 5-6 hours away. To a tiny rural hamlet with no public transport and that got snowed in every winter. She wasn't bothered about leaving us and her grandkids, and in the year she was there, she didn't visit us and we didn't visit her. A 12 hour return journey with nowhere to stay just wasn't an option. A year later she had a massive disabling stroke. We had no option but to have her brought back to her home area for nursing care, but she was furious. I don't know how she thought we could possibly support her care from six hours away.

saleorbouy · 17/01/2022 10:15

Make the effort to visit them once or twice a year and perhaps meet halfway at one of the train interchange stations make it less of a journey for all involved.
It's about making an effort so your kids have a relationship with them, what's the point in being bitter about them moving, you don't have to stay in your "home town."

FocacciaFingerer · 17/01/2022 10:14

My Outlaws moved to a crappy part of Wiltshire from Ealing, it's a 2hour plus drive for us as we take our dog and he needs a stop or two as he gets a bit stressed. When we do get there the tv is on full blast, so we have to shout over it, my MIL will go on her Ipad and gets the royal arse because my FIL loves our dog and our dog adores him

Planning to move to Kent and I've told the Husband already that I'm not doing the drive there and back in a day and definitely not staying, so the next time I see them will probably be the last time and we're fine with that, I would never stop him seeing his parents and I'm quite happy to have the dog if he wants to stay.

When they moved they expected everyone to visit they were in their 80's, both quite capable of making a journey and booking a hotel knowing that I would take them where ever they wanted to go for the duration of their visit but they never made the effort and MIL got quite aggrieved when hardly anyone visited

In my opinion you have to be prepared to accept the fact that not a lot of people will have the spare time or the cash due to rising fuel prices to visit.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 17/01/2022 10:14

In my head I vowed to not move myself away from family and expect them to constantly travel to me. In reality, and retired myself now, it doesn’t always work out as you expect it to

I think what you're describing is different though. You're not saying people shouldn't move, just that if they do they should not expect people to travel to them - nice if they can and choose to do so though. I think for the OP it is the expectation which is the biggest problem.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 17/01/2022 10:12

[quote MananaTomorrow]@Whatiswrongwithmyknee, I don’t think the onus is on your sister to come and see you because she moved to NZ.

However, reality dictates you can’t do it.
It might be that reality also dictates they can’t do it either.

In which case, the solution is to have regular FaceTime etc… until one of you has that opportunity (and even then it might only be you or her travelling).
But starting form the point for ‘well it’s her loss. I’m not going to make an effort because SHE moved away’ isn’t helping either of you.[/quote]
They can do it and they have. They are much wealthier than us.

We do try and do zoom but it is hard to find a time when everyone is awake. It's not really a solution TBH as it's nothing like actually seeing people. her choice though. I wasn't at all starting from the position that 'I'm not going to make an effort' and never said so. Just that it was horrid of her OH to suggest to the kids that the reason we're not visiting is because we don't want to when to get the 9K together to do so is something beyond most people. Fine for them to move, fine for them to hope we will visit. Not fine to lead their children to believe that we cba to see them. I can't go on my own btw as can't leave my OH to care for the kids on his own for that long. I also can't travel that far on my own due to health needs. Other sister and I wondered whether once the kids no longer need any day to day support (so we can leave for a longer time) maybe we'll do it together. Will also mean - I hope! - that we can afford it as we'll not be spending 100's every month on the kids!

EllaDuggee · 17/01/2022 10:11

I moved three hours away from my family on my twenties because I was utterly miserable where they lived and it was the best decision I've made. People shouldn't be punished for pursuing what is going to make them happy, or going where there is better job prospects or oppurtunities if they are stuck in a dead end where they are. I know they are retired and this is not that situation exactly but people should be able to pursue their dreams.
I think it depends on what you have going on in your life. When I first moved I did all the visiting mainly as I was single and child free. Now I have toddlers we don't make the journey that often as it's such hard work the age they are, my parents probably visit a bit more often and we don't see extended family very much. We do meet people half way every now and again though, could you do that? And two hours each way isn't yoo bad if you share the driving. You will just have to tell thèm about everything you have going on and that you can only visit /meet up in school holidays every however many weeks and they need to come to you as well regardless of how long it takes, as being retired they do have time.

FlyingSoHigh · 17/01/2022 10:11

My SIL moved to Oz and used to come home every 2-3 years. When she came, the PIL would often help pay for flights, there was room for her to stay with them and they lent her a car so her vists usually cost very little.
For us to go there were would have to pay for 4 flights, rent somewhere to stay and hire a car. I worked out the cost once and it was so far out of our budget it was funny.
She remains cross we've never been to see her. I don't think we ever will until the kids have left home.

mrsmigginswiggins · 17/01/2022 10:10

Similar issues here. DM moved about 4/5 hours away from our hometown to live near DB and his young family. For the first year or two, I had more free time, so I used to visit every few months, now I have weekend commitments and animals, so it's trickier.

Her idea was that she would come back once a year to see me and other family and friends, she's done it once in 5 years, and then decided she doesn't like the drive and she's not doing it again. Will not take public transport, will not meet me for a day out somewhere halfway. But she regularly moans about how she doesn't see enough of me, how DB and family aren't' supportive enough with helping her as she gets older, and how it would be much better if I moved near her etc etc.

Years ago, when I moved about 3 hours away for Uni and stayed in my Uni town for about 10 years afterwards, she never ever visited and I was expected to come back home to see her. And she was younger then than I am now, so it isn't an age thing!

ShinyHappyPoster · 17/01/2022 10:08

Honestly you're still annoyed they moved closer to your sibling and you're using that to make excuses not to visit. You need to work out how to deal with it. Stop pretending it's about anything else.

A 4hr round trip is nothing and missing a DCs' club occasionally is nothing too. Perhaps I'm overly sensitive because our DC lost their last GP last year. Whining about not being the favourite sibling and a 4 hrs drive; and prioritising clubs over a relationship with GPs looks pretty petty from here.

fuckyourpronouns · 17/01/2022 10:08

When you say 4 hour round trip - this is 2 hours each way in the car?

Tbh i think YABU to not visit at that distance. It's 1:45 to my ILs and that's more than doable in a day. Go in the morning. Make it clear to ILs that they need to do lunch. Spend the day with them. Get kids bathed there and fed for dinner and then drive home. They fall asleep in the car and can go straight to bed when they get home.

If it's 4 hours each way then that's completely different!

notthatonethisone · 17/01/2022 10:07

I think the distance, where they've moved to, location etc are all irrelevant

The point is you feel your kids are second best to the golden child sibling.

You have wait to find out whether your siblings children will be seeing your parent before you can arrange anything.

Your parent doesn't want you and your sibling and grandkids there at the same time.

Your sibling won't see you.

These are the relevant points. I would ease off. Don't beat yourself up, schlep your kids around and make your life difficult for someone who has made it clear you and your family are not their priority.

I would go low contact. If only because your kids will pick up on this inferiority. It's not healthy for them to know they're second best.

But sorry it sounds like you have a thoroughly shit family. I'd enjoy the space you don't have your toxic family living nearby any more! Thanks

IHaveToSay · 17/01/2022 10:05

I don’t think anyone is obliged to travel to see anyone, but I guess it depends whether you actually want to see them or not. My in laws moved abroad… we have no obligations to visit, but we do because we love them and enjoy their company. It sounds like you’re not bothered about spending time with them, in which case you have no obligation to.

Ragwort · 17/01/2022 10:05

I think both sides just have to accept that long distances are involved and relationships will clearly not be the same as if you live in the same town.
None of my siblings, or DH's, or our parents stayed in our 'home' town ... no one is left there now ... we are all scattered around the country. It's just the way it is and I think, has given us all better opportunities in life, and the ability to make new friendships and relationships. It means that we don't really see each other that much .... my DPs did eventually move near us when they reached their 80s, they accepted that was the 'sensible' thing to do.

WetLookKnitwear · 17/01/2022 10:04

I do think that “the world is your oyster” isn’t all it’s cracked up to be and the reality hits you hard when you have a baby and your family is hundreds of miles away.

BendyWendyCheesyFeet · 17/01/2022 10:03

@GemmaRuby

Thank you. We will go visit them, and we have already tried to make plans to meet them in a central location for a day out. That is how this conversation came about as they want us to go all the way. But you're right once we have visited them next we will return the invitation and see if they can be bothered.

Sibling last came here in 2018. They are not generous with their time IMO and have often cited the journey as being too long for them! We used to visit them multiple times a year before lockdown.

Thank you for understanding and for your advice.

OP posts:
ElectraBlue · 17/01/2022 10:03

Surely they should have thought about this before moving away?

They made their choice, they should live with the consequences. You don't have to change your life for them...

Ceramide · 17/01/2022 10:02

YABU. Your own home location isn't the 'default' or centre of everyone else's universe. Someone else's chosen location is just as much home to them as yours is to you. I have relatives in different places and it isn't easy to travel or find a suitable date, but we split the visiting/travel 50-50.

I know you've said you're in a town rather than a city OP, so the following isn't about you, and others may have had a different experience - but I've found Londoners more often turn their nose up at travelling elsewhere in the UK. It's strange as they often think of themselves as well travelled, but their own country apparently doesn't count Confused

WetLookKnitwear · 17/01/2022 10:01

My parents moved further than that, it’s about 5 hours one way if you’re lucky. I told them it won’t be possible for us to visit often, with our jobs etc. Before they moved, they were really blasé about the distance. Oh, we love driving, once you’re in the car what’s the difference between half an hour and 5? Etc. Now I think they regret it but they can’t stomach another house move. It’s quite sad for me to think about. Like you, I stayed in the hometown area and the in laws are here too so if we moved that would just mean someone else misses out.

Iamkmackered1979 · 17/01/2022 10:00

I had just had my first baby, my sister and I had moved sourh as there is literally nothing in our home town or jobs etc most kids have to move for uni as town is remote. So my mum moved to Australia then around Asia then came back to uk then my kids were 5& 1and lived 400 miles away from us. So she doesn’t complain we don’t visit as it’s 8 hours in the car and kids don’t enjoy it. Now with health issues and older age they feel isolated and fed up especially with covid they are lonely and want to move. Funny that. I’m used to not having them closer tbh I’ve managed fine without so it’ll be odd having them nearby but closer to favoured sibling which is fine by me 😂

I don’t think anyone is obligated to visit anyone, don’t if you don’t want to but parents who want their kids to stay in the backwater towns they’ve moved to and never spread their wings are selfish. Yes they are nice to bring kids up in and it’s nice but I want my kids to travel and move about and experience life. Not be stuck near me out of obligation or guilt!

LadyPropane · 17/01/2022 10:00

2 hour drive isn't far at all. You could knock out a visit in half a day! I thought you were going to say they'd emigrated to another country.

However it is very odd that they've moved somewhere like this when they don't drive. If they now expect you to do all the travelling because of this then that's not fair. Don't take on guilt for that.