Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If a family member moves away - are you obliged to travel to them?

296 replies

BendyWendyCheesyFeet · 17/01/2022 08:15

Parent decided to relocate to another part of the country, a four hour round trip away instead of being in the same town. They can't drive, and they have since realised it's 3 or 4 trains away and a lot of travelling to get to us.

They have complained that we don't see them often enough anymore, but we have three kids in school with clubs at the weekends and it's an absolute nightmare to fit in. Meanwhile they are retired and have no commitments.

I also feel angry that they moved to a really inaccessible location in the first place and just expect us to upheave our family to see them, when they used to have us on their doorstep.

AIBU to say that if you decide to move away from your family, the onness should be on you to go see them the majority of the time.

OP posts:
MananaTomorrow · 18/01/2022 14:34

It can change in an instant regardless of your age.

I first started it have symptoms of my chronic illness before I was 40yo.
Some people have car accidents etc etc…

It’s not just people in old age who can have health issues sprung onto them.

dafey · 18/01/2022 14:07

A relative had a stroke last year, the appointments & care needed really brought home how important proximity to family & medical facilities was. Life can change in an instant.

dafey · 18/01/2022 14:04

but to all those posts where people are saying that parents should stay in the home town in case at some point they need care.

Surely it's about thinking that wherever you end up has good public transport, hospitals close etc. It's just practical.

Ormally · 18/01/2022 13:43

It's that if you move somewhere relatively inaccessible, then be sensible and be aware that things change and that at some point, you might want to think about moving back or at least being somewhere easier to get to.

Very true. It's also sadly not unusual that you get no warning of the changes that may quickly make life 10 times more difficult - not that this has to be in old age particularly, but that has been one of the catalysts.

When DF needed certain treatment in hospital, both as an outpatient and then on a ward, the specialist unit was in the nearest large city, but was still a 2-bus journey - advice was not to drive himself. The surgery used by my DPs has 2 branches. One was walkable but recent developments have meant they, and medication requests, have been transferred to the second branch as the first has been changed for clinics only. The first appointment booked there, this was not made clear and DM turned up confused at the surgery they expected.

BendyWendyCheesyFeet · 18/01/2022 13:43

@SenselessUbiquity

Haha good guess 😉

OP posts:
MananaTomorrow · 18/01/2022 13:38

Well no. In that case they have moved significantly closer to their (preferred) child.
So by that account, they have taken the right decision.

As it is, it has also taken them away from their (not as preferred) child. And they are asking that child to go way over board to come and see them. A complete different issue really.

BertramLacey · 18/01/2022 13:28

but to all those posts where people are saying that parents should stay in the home town in case at some point they need care.

It isn't that. I'm 200 miles away from my home town as it is. It's that if you move somewhere relatively inaccessible, then be sensible and be aware that things change and that at some point, you might want to think about moving back or at least being somewhere easier to get to.

Fine, move away. God knows I have, several times. But that has consequences. I'm far away from family but have made sure that I can drive, am near bus routes and can get to an airport fairly quickly if I need to. My worry is people moving somewhere inaccessible and then bellyaching people don't visit. And whilst it's fine to move around, it's also sensible, as you get older, to think about being near good facilities, whether that's also near family or not.

HairyScaryMonster · 18/01/2022 13:02

I said yabu because I feel it's about seeing them less than them doing the travelling. I agree somewhere nice an hour away from both of you sounds like the best compromise.

mrsmigginswiggins · 18/01/2022 12:51

@ineedsun would you have been able to manage that though in the scenario you were an only child, and all the expectations were being placed on you to support despite the distance?

I don't think anyone is saying parents need to stay put in case they need care later on.....but in the scenario where they have moved a significant distance away from adult children, by choice, surely they then need to recognise that to then expect those children to support them practically in old age by visiting more regularly than is really reasonable, and sacrificing their time and money to do so is actually pretty selfish!

ineedsun · 18/01/2022 12:21

@HardbackWriter

I guess I may have a different perspective from some because as kids we lived about 4 or 5 hours from grandparents and managed to stay in contact and between us, care for them in their old age without any drama. I suppose it’s different if you’ve only ever all lived in the town you grew up in.

They must have been very lucky in the level of support they needed in old age? We lived four hours from my grandparents and it was fine and we had a lovely relationship but it completely fell apart when they got very elderly. There was an awful period where my dad was doing the eight hour round trip in a day every single Saturday and it was still a lot less than they needed. They ended up moving near us.

A mixture of different needs but it involved us spending a lot of time finding the right care and support where they lived and regular visits. They didn’t want to move and I get didn’t need to move. They were happy there and we were happy to support between us all.
ineedsun · 18/01/2022 12:18

@MananaTomorrow

As for ‘your children don’t ask you to make the life choices you do’ well of course they don’t.

but then if you didn't actually btake your dcs into consideration when making lifestyle changes, you are the worst parent in the worl. How many bthreads on here about hiow ufaor it is to move away from because the dcs are stelled, they will miss their friends etc...? Or because you want to live in the cuntryside and there will be nothing for them to do/in the middle of nowhere etc..?

No our dcs dont ASK us to make specific lifestyle changes but actually you cant separate being a parent and making compromisies for your dcs.

Exactly! But that doesn’t mean that once they’re independent adults, parents should continue to be on call to their kids.

Again, this is not related to the OP where the parents have unreasonable expectations but to all those posts where people are saying that parents should stay in the home town in case at some point they need care.

NorthSouthcatlady · 18/01/2022 12:14

In answer to your original question @BendyWendyCheesyFeet; if a family member moved then everyone needs to make some kind of effort. But it sounds like your parents (and sibling) want to make zero effort and get you to run around after them. I moved away when l went to university about 20 years and never moved back. The circumstances were never right and now it’s gone in so long then it’s unlikely to ever happen. I I until now have made the majority of the effort but in the last year or so took a step back. I’m sick of the lack of effort by family members, when they come to visit me l need to drop EVERYTHING (even work even if they didn’t discuss the dates they were visiting). In contrast when l go to them, then l need to work around what they’re doing. For every 6 or 7 visits l did to them, they made about 1 back. They have more time and freedom then me but just can’t be bothered (l am also the scapegoat child!)

But with your backstory and the accompanying behaviours before / after the move. Then they are being unreasonable in the way they prioritise themselves, your sibling and your siblings children. While you are left with the scraps that are left and lm guessing are meant to be very helpful / grateful with them. Your parents need to get used to getting trains or learn to drive. If you do with to go see them, then do it in a boundaried way e.g. “we can do the first week of the Easter holidays, we are going to the zoo on the Wednesday but are free on the Monday, Tuesday or Thursday. We could go to X together?”. With no hanging around on standby in case the sibling and grandchildren aren’t available

I have taken a big step back in general with my family and feel way better for it. I’m sick of having to do the shitty jobs, make the effort, have my efforts go unrecognised. Whereas the golden child (my sibling) swans in and out, whilst my mum acts like it’s the 2nd coming Hmm

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 18/01/2022 11:47

@MananaTomorrow

3 or 4 trains would suggest OP lives in Inverness and her parents moved to the arse end of Cornwall.

Nope.
Try Middlesbrough to Liverpool.
About 2.5 hours driving but much longer and at least 3 trains.
The issues often arise when you go from east to west.
North to south is usually OK unless really far as you mentioned.

Or unless crossing London, then you commonly need to switch mainline stations via tube to get between e.g. Waterloo and Paddington. Thameslink fully crosses the river to go north, but most lines don't.
Jk987 · 18/01/2022 11:40

They should come to you more frequently. They can stay a few days in a Travelodge or Airbnb. They're retired and can make time to get 3 trains to see the grandkids.

HardbackWriter · 18/01/2022 11:37

I guess I may have a different perspective from some because as kids we lived about 4 or 5 hours from grandparents and managed to stay in contact and between us, care for them in their old age without any drama. I suppose it’s different if you’ve only ever all lived in the town you grew up in.

They must have been very lucky in the level of support they needed in old age? We lived four hours from my grandparents and it was fine and we had a lovely relationship but it completely fell apart when they got very elderly. There was an awful period where my dad was doing the eight hour round trip in a day every single Saturday and it was still a lot less than they needed. They ended up moving near us.

MananaTomorrow · 18/01/2022 11:30

As for ‘your children don’t ask you to make the life choices you do’ well of course they don’t.

but then if you didn't actually btake your dcs into consideration when making lifestyle changes, you are the worst parent in the worl. How many bthreads on here about hiow ufaor it is to move away from because the dcs are stelled, they will miss their friends etc...? Or because you want to live in the cuntryside and there will be nothing for them to do/in the middle of nowhere etc..?

No our dcs dont ASK us to make specific lifestyle changes but actually you cant separate being a parent and making compromisies for your dcs.

MananaTomorrow · 18/01/2022 11:26

3 or 4 trains would suggest OP lives in Inverness and her parents moved to the arse end of Cornwall.

Nope.
Try Middlesbrough to Liverpool.
About 2.5 hours driving but much longer and at least 3 trains.
The issues often arise when you go from east to west.
North to south is usually OK unless really far as you mentioned.

dafey · 18/01/2022 10:13

I guess I may have a different perspective from some because as kids we lived about 4 or 5 hours from grandparents and managed to stay in contact and between us, care for them in their old age without any drama. I suppose it’s different if you’ve only ever all lived in the town you grew up in.

Surely it depends on a number of factors. My grandparents are abroad & my mum & aunts/uncles had no issue visiting. They were money & time rich & the journey was actually very short.

dafey · 18/01/2022 10:08

I don't think it's black & white but having said that there are consequences to actions. You can't expect to shift your life around too much to accommodate their choice.

sueelleker · 18/01/2022 09:57

@Ormally

3 or 4 trains would suggest OP lives in Inverness and her parents moved to the arse end of Cornwall.

Not at all! There are parts of Essex, Kent and Suffolk that can be driven comfortably with an hour point to point, but bus means a lot of changes and train has to send you into and out of London, or via Stansted so you have at least 2 hours, a patchy weekend service, and eye-watering prices. The old timetables have reduced because of the pandemic.

The best compromise I found with a big distance between my & parents' locations was to book some long weekends cheaply somewhere between the two, about 3 times a year, and sometimes in a place giving the chance to visit other family for an hour or 2. Often that's a cottage big enough for everyone but whatever works. It's tended to work better than A stays with B or vice versa.

We live in Brighton and my SIL lives in Kent. The only way to get there without a car is to get the train to Victoria and another one down to Rochester. By the time you get there it's practically time to come home again.
Ormally · 18/01/2022 09:53

3 or 4 trains would suggest OP lives in Inverness and her parents moved to the arse end of Cornwall.

Not at all! There are parts of Essex, Kent and Suffolk that can be driven comfortably with an hour point to point, but bus means a lot of changes and train has to send you into and out of London, or via Stansted so you have at least 2 hours, a patchy weekend service, and eye-watering prices. The old timetables have reduced because of the pandemic.

The best compromise I found with a big distance between my & parents' locations was to book some long weekends cheaply somewhere between the two, about 3 times a year, and sometimes in a place giving the chance to visit other family for an hour or 2. Often that's a cottage big enough for everyone but whatever works. It's tended to work better than A stays with B or vice versa.

ineedsun · 18/01/2022 09:20

Just to be clear, I’m not talking about the OP, there are clearly other issues there in terms of inequity etc.

But there are lots of posts on here about how ridiculous it is for people to move away from family or to somewhere rural in their 60s because it won’t be long till they’re frail and need support. Someone even said that they expected their parent to move back to a care home near them if they became unwell because it was so ridiculous that they had moved in the first place.

As for ‘your children don’t ask you to make the life choices you do’ well of course they don’t. But we do things for our kids - I remember my mum telling me years after we’d grown up that she didn’t really have her own friend group that she would have chosen because they were all mum friends and until that point I genuinely never thought of the compromises that she had made.

I’m so desperate to move to another area but can’t because my kids are settled here, I don’t regret that for a moment but this isn’t my home and I don’t want to stay here forever just because it’s where my kids might choose to be later on.

I guess I may have a different perspective from some because as kids we lived about 4 or 5 hours from grandparents and managed to stay in contact and between us, care for them in their old age without any drama. I suppose it’s different if you’ve only ever all lived in the town you grew up in.

SunshinePiggy · 18/01/2022 09:19

YANBU, and I say this as someone who has lived a 5 hour drive from family in the UK and also in countries a 12+ hour flight away. Of course I would love people to visit, and I have paid for my mum to visit in the past, but I have to accept that I can't see them as much as I would like (friends, too) and my children are missing out on some relationships because of this.

Covid has made it much worse, obviously, but it is what it is. I planned to go back to the UK this summer, first time in 4 years, but I'm now aiming for next year as restrictions here make the possibility of a very complicated and expensive return too likely for me. I'm not in a position to risk being stuck in the UK and then paying thousands in quarantine fees etc for all of us.

We suck it up.

HardbackWriter · 18/01/2022 09:01

Those people who stayed in an area that they’re not overly keen on for the stability of the family. Don’t they get to think about themselves for a while?

Of course they do. But they should accept the trade-off - that they'll see a lot less of family and that they'll need to make a lot more effort if they do want to see them - with good grace. I 'went away' from 18 to 32, and then 'came back' and they have really different pluses and minuses but you have to accept them both for what they are.

Muckymaisonette · 18/01/2022 08:59

A relative moved to an impoverished island state, one of the poorest in the world, then complained that no one in the family had been to visit them. What with rampant typhoid and cholera (issues with getting it treated locally), frequent natural disasters such as earthquakes and hurricanes and political instability, topped off by the sheer cost and time taken to get there, it wasn’t top of anyone’s list to visit.