Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

6yo Birthday presents, who is being unreasonable?

219 replies

hollyisKey · 17/01/2022 06:51

Ds will be 6 next month and me and dp decided to get him a nice bike. The bike cost £190 and that is more than we would usually spend on birthdays.

Dp thinks that the bike will be all ds needs for his birthday. Since we have just had Christmas he doesn't need any toys, shoes or clothes.

I however, think that ds should have a couple of little presents to open too. Nothing really expensive but just so he gets to unwrap something.

We are no means rich but could afford an extra £30 - £40 for some extra presents. Dp is mostly concerned about the lack of space in our house. He saw getting the bike as one big gift and no smaller items to clutter the house with.

Aibu or is dp?
Thanks

OP posts:
XelaM · 17/01/2022 11:53

YNBU

AryaStarkWolf · 17/01/2022 11:49

I agree with your DH, one big present is absolutely fine and enough

Tiredmum100 · 17/01/2022 11:43

I would get him a book, some chocolate/sweets/ lego set to un wrap as well

AmyDudley · 17/01/2022 11:42

One sentence stood out to me, (and others have said it) - 'since we have just had Christmas he doesn't need anything else' (or words to that effect. It's not his fault he has a birthday near Christmas, don;t let your decision be influenced by that - if you would have got him more if his birthday was in June then bear that in mind.
I'm not saying the bike isn't enough - it sounds a lovely present, a few balloons a cake and taking him out that day to ride his bike sounds fine.
But having had two Dc very close to Christmas - I always made sure their birthdays weren't dismissed as being 'close to Christmas so no need to bother' as a near Christmas birthday myself that happened to me a lot as a child.

Contactmap · 17/01/2022 11:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

morechocolateneededtoday · 17/01/2022 11:35

@LaTomatina

*One big present is fine. Why would you wabt to teach him to expect lots and lots of stuff he doesn't even need? We're all conditioned to believe that excesive consumerism is a good thing. It's not.*

This. Too many parents over-buy their children out of fear that their children will be disappointed, and then act surprised when they raise entitled, self-centred teenagers who don't value anything. Honestly, less is more!! If a 6 year old is disappointed because he "only" got a new bike for his birthday, there is a big problem!!!

Could not agree more. We are teaching our children the bike is not enough by buying them more. You have said he has all he needs so the bike is perfect, especially if you are investing in a good lightweight one he will be able to use for a while.

I would take them out as a treat, cinema/bowling/ice skating etc but completely agree with no need for crap for the sake of buying it

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 17/01/2022 11:31

Little Bike gloves are a great idea! They used to sell them for

Ponoka7 · 17/01/2022 11:30

The one complaint you hear regularly from people whose birthday is around Christmas, is that they never got a Birthday on the scale other people do. There must be a couple of other bits you could get. I'd plan a day out that includes the bike.

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 17/01/2022 11:27

Oh pp suggested a great idea!

A bell. A helmet. A bike lock. Those would be great additional presents to unwrap as you have to buy them anyway! I found an eyeball bell for my boy! It was probably a bit gross but he loved it and used it for every bike he had until he was 10.

Mine had shiny star attachments that catch light on theirs (DS and DDs) which we moved from bike to bike - they go on spokes of wheel so that bike catches any headlights and you can get stickers that do same including ones for bike coats and bags. Cost about a £1 for a set of each in Poundland/ home bargains.

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 17/01/2022 11:21

Spend a fiver in few extra presents as a compromise. Few bars of chocolates, some silly putty or something small.

Your DH is right DS has a large gift from you so another £30-40 is unnecessary and doesn't teach value of money to your DS.

LuaDipa · 17/01/2022 11:19

I would get him a few bits and pieces to open. Also agree with indoor things since it’s still so dark most of the time. It doesn’t have to be clutter, it could be books games, crafts. I think even I would be disappointed to have nothing to open on my birthday!!!

aSofaNearYou · 17/01/2022 11:18

*You're part of the reason high street shops are closing!

You go in , try out their stock, and then bugger off and buy it elsewhere*

And also one of the people helping the environment by buying second hand where possible.

You win some you lose some!

Marvellousmadness · 17/01/2022 11:16

Absolutely the kid needs more gifts. You must start consumerism young.

00100001 · 17/01/2022 11:14

@LemonDrizzles

Have you considered getting the bike used? We went down to Halfords, our 6 year old tried a fee bikes, we settled on one that was £150 or £250 (can't remember now) then saw about 5 local people selling the same bike on Facebook and ebay. We missed ebay (they were a black away) but managed Facebook. Freed up funds for other gifts. And yes at Christmas, 6 year old got an elaborate Lego but oh no he felt he got less than his 2 year old sister because she opened more presents despite his elaborate Lego present costing more than his...
You're part of the reason high street shops are closing!

You go in , try out their stock, and then bugger off and buy it elsewhere!

stingofthebutterfly · 17/01/2022 11:14

Definitely get him some more things to open. You can buy a few cheap bits of useful stuff that won't create clutter. Bike accessories is a good idea, then sweets that will be eaten, craft kits that will be thrown away once complete, same for colouring books, a t-shirt with his favourite character on, some bath bombs or something like that etc. You don't have to create clutter or spend much at all.

WhaleSnail · 17/01/2022 11:07

I would get my DC some extras. I don’t think that’s spoiling them or setting them up to expect lots of gifts. He’s 6 he doesn’t know a bike costs lots and I don’t think adding 4/5 small parcels to his day will ruin him. Something like a T-shirt with favourite character, a small Lego set, craft sets, educational style games and books. Things I’d class as “practical” especially books as that’s encouraging his reading, etc. Nothing has to cost a lot. I usually get a small “pile” for birthdays 4/5 things as they love opening and having a variety of things. This year basketball and books etc which came to £40 total. He was delighted. It wasn’t about the money. The year before he needed a next size scooter so we got that plus similar books games etc but with scooter that birthday was over £200 spent. DS had no expectation that he’d had £200 worth of toys this year again and was totally happy with the £40 we spent. No difference to him between the two birthdays.

I’d be cautious about saying he doesn’t need anything as he’s just had Christmas. That might be true but it wouldn’t be said if his birthday was say June. It’s not his fault the two are close together. You could always get “summer” stuff like outdoor bits etc.

Finally, I do think some posters assume the child will have lots of other gifts. We have a very small family. The only set of grandparents give money to savings (which I’m very happy with!) and a small sticker book type gift to unwrap. One Uncle gives perhaps a small Lego set some years if he sees us around time of birthday otherwise no gift. That’s it. Friends don’t exchange gifts in his circle. So literally it’s our gifts only. We have him a class party one year and felt overwhelmed (but very grateful!) with all the gifts received. If that is the yearly experience of other children then I can understand why posters are saying the bike is enough because they are also assuming he’ll have many other small gifts to open from family friends etc. Every family is different so this would change my response.

WhereTheWildlingsLive · 17/01/2022 10:59

Haven't read the whole thread but replying as we just had Exactly the same scenario! Ds didn't even really Want the bike as a birthday present but really needed one fed up of hitting elbows with knees so it was given as a part of his present.. made this birthday super expensive tbh but it'll last him about 3yrs now, and fortunately the present he Really wanted wasn't much more than a tenner (plus we added a few more for added opening!) so not too bad! 😂
So obviously I'd say yes you might want to buy a few littlies to boost the pile!

JaninaDuszejko · 17/01/2022 10:52

Another vote for wrapping the helmet, bike bell, etc separately. That's what we did and the DC seemed happy with that.

justasking111 · 17/01/2022 10:51

If you're recycling toys no longer used, there's nothing you can do about clutter bar looking at a storage system.

You're saving a lot of money not having a party. The little man deserves something else. Supposing that the weather is awful that day so he can't go riding, he's going to be a bit sad. He's at the age where he knows what other children do and have on their birthdays

pradavilla · 17/01/2022 10:50

Your dp is. Get ur ds some little presents to open up on the morning of his birthday. Some books, crafts etc doesn't have to be expensive.

Squiblet · 17/01/2022 10:48

A good-quality bike can be sold on after it's grown out of, if it isn't too beat up by that time. So you can think of it as an investment rather than a capital expenditure.

I had serious qualms about buying £££ Islabikes for our DC, but DP is a serious cyclist and insisted they would be better. Sure enough, we've sold on several models through ebay for nearly as much as we paid for them.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/01/2022 10:47

At 6 I’d want to get him something to open on the day. Needn’t be expensive but something like a dressing up outfit, some Lego (not a huge box), a toy to get out and play with, whatever his interests are.

You can’t keep the house completely clutter free with a 6 yo.

Your DH sounds like he’s being a bit mean spirited.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 17/01/2022 10:43

Yanbu - a 6 yr old wants more than 1 present to unwrap- colouring book, a book from the works, crayons- honestly doesn’t have to be expensive

Loveisthere · 17/01/2022 10:42

I agree with GEORGIA some extra bits for his bike maybe knee and elbow pads

Kotatsu · 17/01/2022 10:41

Against the grain, but I think little presents will actually take away from it.

I still remember going downstairs and seeing what turned out to be my bike under a sheet in the kitchen - I was so excited, that other presents would have just distracted me. The best present would be for him to immediately be able to go out and ride it, then and there, rather than have to wait until after breakfast or something