Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The PM has sold out the BBC

155 replies

Burnshersmurfs · 17/01/2022 06:29

AIBU to suspect that the agreed price of certain newspapers dropping the front page stories about partygate is the recent announcement that the licence fee for the BBC is being abolished?

OP posts:
Alexandra2001 · 17/01/2022 09:33

Let's not forget, C4 is publicly owned (albeit commercially funded), and therefore, their news output also should be objective and fair to all political sides. It is decidedly not so

CH4 holds politicians to account, i ve seen them grill labour Green and LD politicians but what the Govt doesn't like is how they have pursued the Grenfell and cladding issues - so sell them off, instead of fix the problems.

But what all media faces is that the Govt will boycott news programs that they don't like, so the Tories didn't appear on GMB for many months, they did the same to Ch4..... which means that probing questioning can't happen for fear of being "boycotted" shameful behavior.

supermoonrising · 17/01/2022 09:28

multiple studies have shown the coverage is not politically biased.

In fact they have shown it’s bias clearly; a clear and blatant bias in their coverage against the leader of the Labour Party at the last two general elections. I’m not sure what counts as greater bias than that in what is effectively a two party state.

Wokeism is not the same as serous left wing economic/social policy. The BBC is pro woke, but it’s no more left wing in economic terms and and it’s world view than the Daily Mail.

Snowdropsinourforest · 17/01/2022 09:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TempsPerdu · 17/01/2022 09:26

Agreed OP. I’ve posted extensively on the other thread in support of the BBC, but on reflection I think we collectively need to recognise this dead cat strategy for what it is and avoid losing focus on the real story of government hypocrisy and incompetence that Johnson and co are so desperate to distract us from.

againstalloddsss · 17/01/2022 09:26

The BBC isn't perfect, but it is a great institution and produces some fantastic output. During Brexit, I read and heard so many comments that the BBC was too pro or too anti Brexit. That tells me they probably get it about right. Some Conservatives are complaining about the party gate coverage, but I didn't see those same MPs complaining about the coverage about Corbyn and the anti semitism. It was disgusting what went on, and was rightly covered, but a lot of hypocrisy there. It is certainly a distraction from party gate and no doubt is being pushed a lot by the conservative loving press, which Boris needs to keep on side. I personally like the BBC and Sky and think they generally give an unbiased political read.

Alexandra2001 · 17/01/2022 09:26

[quote WorriedMumsDontSleep]@Alexandra2001 care to offer a defence of why women are so disproportionately pursued for prosecution by the BBC with the muscle of the state behind them?

Or are you just happy they fill their prisons nicely with vulnerable women?[/quote]
BBC don't make the law or have any control on the justice system.

The Govt, with a large majority can change this but won't (they actually ducked the decision in 2020) instead, they made the BBC an arm of the benefits system, charged with deciding who should get a free licence or not.

supermoonrising · 17/01/2022 09:23

All this government has to offer is gutter populism and endless cuts to public services.

LilithOfEden · 17/01/2022 09:23

"If the NHS is so wonderful, people will pay a subscription to use it."

I mean if you make the argument for one public service, surely it works for all?

What do you think we pay tax and NI for? The NHS is a subscription service. The NHS is free at the point of service, but it has never been free per se. No public service in this country is free. We recognise that certain services are vital, even if we don't use them, because they serve the country as a whole and assist the smooth running of it. Whist there is an argument to support the funding of a state broadcaster - newsworthy events being reported without fear or favour being a good thing - the rest of the BBC output contains nothing that should be compulsorily funded for the public good.

Let's not forget, C4 is publicly owned (albeit commercially funded), and therefore, their news output also should be objective and fair to all political sides. It is decidedly not so.

sjxoxo · 17/01/2022 09:20

Agree the BBC is good value for money & multiple studies have shown the coverage is not politically biased.

The fact people still think it is shows how powerful the RW media is.
I can’t believe we still have a buffoon as PM and people can’t see through these kind of stupid and damaging announcements, which are only done to distract from the huge failures of government that we are living through.

supermoonrising · 17/01/2022 09:19

I’m no fan of the BBC but this shameful PM and government - currently at under 30% in the polls, has no democratic mandate to be making a decision of such cultural magnitude which will impact this country’s media landscape for generations to come.

Woffle · 17/01/2022 09:19

Here we go again!

The licence fee is not being abolished!

supermoonrising · 17/01/2022 09:17

Regardless on your views on the BBC, this is smoke and mirrors. Johnson needs to resign for his personal and governments continuous and utterly shameful lawbreaking at a time of national crisis (not to mention being totally unfit to lead this country by any imaginable benchmark). And we need a general election.

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 17/01/2022 09:16

@Alexandra2001 care to offer a defence of why women are so disproportionately pursued for prosecution by the BBC with the muscle of the state behind them?

Or are you just happy they fill their prisons nicely with vulnerable women?

Alexandra2001 · 17/01/2022 09:03

@WeWashEverythingExceptLaundry

Germany's got a mandatory public service broadcasting charge. I think we pay 56 euro per quarter. And German TV is, with occasional solitary exceptions, unimaginably dire. Good radio, though, albeit nothing anywhere near the calibre of R4.
Yep at £13 per household, the licence fee is an absolute bargain....
TVTestCard · 17/01/2022 09:03

I was a big fan of the BBC but the fact that GB News covers the current threats to women’s rights much more than they do means I can’t support it in the way I used to.

Alexandra2001 · 17/01/2022 09:01

@Georgeskitchen

This is not a sudden decision. Groups have been campaigning for years against the forced purchase of TV licence an the threat of jail for non payment. I've heard it costs more for the pursual of non payers than the actual loss of revenue to the Beeb. People should not be forced to pay for something they don't use. And to add insult to injury being lectured by smug metropolitan lefties telling us what to think No thanks
We all have to pay council tax, regardless of whether you get all the services a city dweller might get....

and to add insult to injury, i m being lectured by a smug metropolitan rightwing bully telling me what to think.
No thanks.

Croissantly · 17/01/2022 09:01

@sst1234

Yes it’s a dead cat. Except the cat committed suicide when it went from being a treasured broadcaster with global soft power to a biased, self serving, left wing, woke culture warrior. The BBC out itself at the front of the queue for dead cat duties.
Yep pretty much.
WeWashEverythingExceptLaundry · 17/01/2022 09:00

Germany's got a mandatory public service broadcasting charge. I think we pay 56 euro per quarter. And German TV is, with occasional solitary exceptions, unimaginably dire. Good radio, though, albeit nothing anywhere near the calibre of R4.

Eleganz · 17/01/2022 08:59

@Postchristmasflab

I think the bbc has had its day, most of the decent content is now sold on to other platforms, like Netflix or even YouTube.

Bbc news is definitely getting more tabloid like, I actually use sky news more often now, I also think the bbc largely copies skys content anyway, but changes the headlines, a story will break in the sky news app first and appear on bbc news 5 mins later. I live in the north and find the BBC very London and the south focused news wise, I see shocking things in my local news papers that never make it to the BBC, while they are running stories about cycle lanes or pigeons in London or what ever. I live in a large northern city and the local news page for my area sometimes isn’t updated for days. Unless it’s sports.

I actually think “partygate” has been over done by the bbc too, I don’t know anyone in real life who is that bothered about it all, probably because unless people where working from home, the same was happening in many workplaces just not as posh. Wine Fridays would be biscuit and beer fridays in most of my friends and families workplaces.

I think you are very wrong to believe that the same was happening in lots of other workplaces and that people aren't that bothered. Most people I know from across a range of the political spectrum are angry about what went on and the idea that you could just nip to round the back of the office for drinks in May 2020 would be utterly preposterous for those businesses that had staff on the premises.

Although I suspect you know that and that is your political allegiance talking. The government's reaction in chucking out all these stories and announcements tells you that they know it is serious. I guess that is also why there are so many posters like you on this site trying to gaslight the rest of us into thinking it is all an overblown storm in a tea cup.

Bigettywitch · 17/01/2022 08:59

@LouiseBelchersBunnyEars

Good, long time coming if you ask me. To think, people have been put in prison for not wanting to pay for the BBC and their ‘unbiased’ opinions, it’s a fucking disgrace
I agree.
Georgeskitchen · 17/01/2022 08:57

This is not a sudden decision. Groups have been campaigning for years against the forced purchase of TV licence an the threat of jail for non payment. I've heard it costs more for the pursual of non payers than the actual loss of revenue to the Beeb. People should not be forced to pay for something they don't use.
And to add insult to injury being lectured by smug metropolitan lefties telling us what to think
No thanks

WorriedMumsDontSleep · 17/01/2022 08:57

@lightand

Both left and right think the bbc is a puppet of the other side, so it’s probably doing ok.

For me, it used to debate both sides of something. It no longer does this.
It presents its own slant on things. Which political way I woudlnt say for 100%.
But that for me is the point really. It should take into account all sides. But it doesnt. It presents it's own view or slant. It shouldnt. It didnt used to and should go back to presenting facts, and then have all sides of discussions, and let viewers come to their own conclusions. Not the conclusions of the BBC.

Spot on. I fumed at the coverage around the last election being so conservative biased. Since then the promotion of dangerous ideas about gender ideology has left me fuming. It's not about left or right, after all, the leftwing parties have all swayed so far to the left they've somehow managed to land themselves back to gender stereotypes and misogyny.

Cancelled ours a while ago. It's a lot of money saved and no biased British broadcasting for us anymore. Win:win
#nothankyou

CarlatheJackal · 17/01/2022 08:57

@TheWhalrus never knew Germany did this, too.

Ceramide · 17/01/2022 08:57

There are many rubbish 'filler' programmes on the BBC and just a few gems (usually involving David Attenborough).