Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a school Chair of Governors should be impartial?

38 replies

GivenchyDahhling · 16/01/2022 20:21

I’ve recently had reason to contact the Chair of Governors at the school at which I work.

I must confess that prior to this I was pretty ignorant as to how they work and what they actually do. I know they approve pay rises and policies but aside from that, as I said, I was fairly ignorant.

On investigation, I have discovered that the Chair of Governors in my school is in a very senior management position and a director of the company owned by the patron of the multi-academy trust my school is in. They are not at all local, do not seem to have had or ever had children attend the school - and took over the role when the MAT took over the school.

I am absolutely flabbergasted (sorry for the MN hyperbole) that this is allowed. Whilst perhaps expecting complete impartiality is unreasonable (eg I would often assume governors would have children at the school), to have such a blatant financial interest in eg keeping budgets slashed as low as possible surely is too far?

OP posts:
GivenchyDahhling · 16/01/2022 20:44

@topcat2014 It’s the best way I could think to describe it without it being incredibly outing as to which MAT I was talking about!

Kind of the “sponsor” of the trust.

OP posts:
topcat2014 · 16/01/2022 20:41

What is this 'patron' I'm confused?

It does sound like some independence is missing though

Lougle · 16/01/2022 20:40

@TheHoptimist

They dont approve pay rises. The chair is equal to all governors.

It is not good practice to have a parent governor as Chair

You need to look at the scheme of delegation for your Trust/school. That sets out what the local governance is and isnt accountable for.

In a MAT many decisions are not made at school level but at executive or board level.

It is not bad practice to have a parent as chair of governors.

The chair is just a coordinating role. They have the casting vote in the event of a tied vote, but otherwise have no more influence than anyone else.

On the face of it, being a patron of a company being involved in the running of the MAT isn't an issue (as long as it is declared) but that person would be wise not to be involved in key budgetary matters if there could be a conflict. Having said that, MATs still get their funding from the government, and around 85% or more of a school budget will go on staffing anyway, so there really isn't much room for manipulating budgets.

GivenchyDahhling · 16/01/2022 20:36

@OliviaBond I suspect this may be why it took me by surprise as I was a bit more familiar with my previous school’s governors and I think they had a good reputation for holding the head “to account” so to speak. From the composition of this board I find it really hard to believe that’s the case, half of the governors are linked to the executive leadership and then obviously the Chair is in the position in my opening post. I didn’t realise that MATs were allowed to operate their governance in this way (again, ignorance on my part!)

OP posts:
OliviaBond · 16/01/2022 20:33

Governing boards are weird in Trusts. And usually up the heads backside ime Hmm

rwalker · 16/01/2022 20:33

Can only speak form my experience it was a closed shop and far from impartial .

GivenchyDahhling · 16/01/2022 20:31

Just to be clear, I understand that there are normally a mix of people - ie some parents, school staff, people with an interest in education etc and of course people have financial interests. I think it’s because it’s specifically the chair that it just looks to me - and, in my view, would to anyone - like a lack of impartiality.

@Lougle It just; in a very vague way, has the name of the patron. Not the specific role; the fact they’re a director etc. Although Google didn’t take much searching to ascertain that for myself.

OP posts:
TheHoptimist · 16/01/2022 20:30

They dont approve pay rises. The chair is equal to all governors.

It is not good practice to have a parent governor as Chair

You need to look at the scheme of delegation for your Trust/school. That sets out what the local governance is and isnt accountable for.

In a MAT many decisions are not made at school level but at executive or board level.

MrsColon · 16/01/2022 20:27

Become a governor yourself! It's not acceptable for that individual to be the Chair - even if interests are declared, he'd need to recuse himself from financial decision making to ensure impartiality. Complain! Talk to your MP!

Lougle · 16/01/2022 20:27

That information should be published on the school website under pecuniary interests. Is it?

MyOtherProfile · 16/01/2022 20:26

There is probably a clear list of the make up of the governors on the school website. You usually get a mix of parent governors, community governors and teacher governors. In my experience parent governors are not always the best because they can have a very skewed view of what should be going on in a school.

PicaK · 16/01/2022 20:26

What has having children attend school have anything to do with being a governor (except for parent governors)??
Have you looked at the Governor section of your website?
Have you looked at the trust website?
Have you seen the declaration of interests?
Why don't you ask your Head for an explanation of how the trust is managed before you start having a hissy fit

topcat2014 · 16/01/2022 20:24

Schools have parent governors but also governors or trustees via other routes, for example appointed by local authorities.

All governors have to make a declaration of interests at the start of each term.

Swipe left for the next trending thread