Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mother's posting photos breastfeeding on social media?

119 replies

hardlythecinderellastory · 16/01/2022 16:44

I understand it's natural and it should be normalised etc. But when I see it on my social media.. people who purposely post selfie's of themselves breastfeeding it makes me feel like shit as I failed both times at breastfeeding, the most recent times due to PND. I find it a bit "triggering" as it reminds me that I failed or didn't try hard enough. I think sometimes people feel so proud of BF'd that they don't think these photos might make other women feel a bit inferior. I don't post a bottle feeding photo as a) no one ever takes photos of me when I'm feeling her and b) I'd feel like it would be judged.
Is this an unreasonable opinion?

OP posts:
Cheesybiscuits01 · 16/01/2022 18:37

OP there is a book by Amy Brown called why breastfeeding grief and trauma matter. It might help you process some of your feelings.

In short people should be able to post whatever they want on their in social media pages. Breastfeeding has not been normalised yet in this country and so more work is needed on this. However if I were you I would unfollow that friend. I would also never send breastfeeding selfies or congratulatory messages about myself feeding to a friend who struggled to feed.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/01/2022 18:36

I hadn't seen your update before posting, to the tune that a particular friend seems deliberately to be rubbing your face in it by sending you DMs and constantly boasting about BF, especially when she knows you've suffered with PND.

That is spectacularly insensitive and of course it's unreasonable. In that particular circumstance I think I would lose the 'friend'.

CheesecakeAddict · 16/01/2022 18:36

In the gentlest possible way, you are comparing yourself to her and making yourself feel like shit. She feels like superwoman for doing those things, because it's not her normal. She's after a pat on the back and clearly thinks of you as a friend who will understand this isn't a normal thing to accomplish. Have you tried bragging to her about your achievements and seeing what her response is?

You need to focus on where you want your own life to be instead of grading yourself against a criteria that you can't succeed in because you can't change the past.

To some people my life would be a fail (my grandmother for example has told me many times how disappointed she is in me). I am a divorced, single mum who lives in an ex council house and works every hour of every day. On the flip side, I was homeless and worked solidly to buy my own home. I have 2 postgraduate degrees and I'm running up the promotion ladder. To some people, I am a failure, to some people I am success. I can't amend being a survivor of domestic abuse, but it doesn't stop me being happy for other people on their engagements, weddings and anniversaries. I'm sad for myself but then I remind myself that I don't have to think about dinner for someone else, I get a double bed to myself, I don't have to compromise on decorating my home and I don't pick wet towels and undies off the floor. To my grandma I am a failure, to myself, I'm winning.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 16/01/2022 18:33

A county with statistically higher breastfeeding rates needs to be the aim: in terms of general benefits. Too often it's presented as something of a niche choice, to be practiced by earth mothers or rigid adherents to attachment parenting, whereas in fact it needs to be normalized as the standard human method of feeding our young. In this instance, I would not see BF as something to be particularly 'proud' of (and yes, I did BF for 18 months), rather as a perfectly ordinary activity that humans have been doing since time immemorial. There's also a taboo which sees breasts as objects of sexual fetishization - and this is something that urgently needs redressing.

If for whatever reason a mother has taken the choice to formula feed because that's what was best for that family at that particular time, that's fine, too. Formula isn't poison. Plenty of babies can and do thrive on it: the vast majority, in fact, as BF rates in the UK are so woefully low.

It's the latter that is the issue, IMO: for some reason it isn't working out for the majority and we need to tackle the problem of WHY it isn't working out for the majority. This isn't an indictment of any particular individual.

From that perspective, YABU.

QuiltedHippo · 16/01/2022 18:28

[quote hardlythecinderellastory]@HardbackWriter I don't know but she knows how badly I suffered with PND. I was admitted to a mother and baby unit. And she knows how I wanted to BF but it was just another stress and then I couldn't as I wouldn't have been able to take the medication I needed.
She's always telling me how she's a superwoman breastfeeding all day and night and having her partners tea on the table - while I've recently separated from my partner and back at my parents. It's like she goes out of her way to make me feel like shit.[/quote]
I BF day and night and generally get tea made, I think what you've been through is more super woman worthy. Your friend is a dick.

Quite like my csection scar though, it's where my baby was born and hardly obvious Wink

GreetingsAndSalutations · 16/01/2022 18:26

I didn’t manage to BF my babies. Yeah, I felt a bit crap at the time and I too had PND which frankly doesn’t help either. But my children are now at the teen/tween stages. The baby stage is so small compared to the rest of their lives including their childhoods. How they are fed (breast or formula) is an even smaller part of that. Mine give zero shits about how they were fed as babies.

Beowulfthethird · 16/01/2022 18:18

I once thought friends shouldn't post pictures of their babies because it hurt my feelings ... A bit ridiculous looking back. I'm glad I didn't say anything

Beowulfthethird · 16/01/2022 18:17

Not unreasonable to feel but a bit unreasonable to expect others to keep bf off social media for this reason as the reasons for doing it probably carry more weight. I don't think you should feel remotely bothered as anyone who keeps babies alive and vaguely clean is heroic

Redwinestillfine · 16/01/2022 18:15

I hope you find peace op. Counselling will help as will coming off social media. Please don't ruin what could be a good support system in your friend but be honest with her that you are taking a step back from FB and whatsApp and that you have found her posts hard even though you know it's irrational and you are getting help. Best of luck.

Phrenologistsfinger · 16/01/2022 18:14

YABU - we are struggling to conceive after multiple losses and IVF isn't going well and I feel absolutely awful when I see:
pregnancy announcements,
bump pics,
scans,
baby pics or
pictures of people’s kids.

But that doesn’t mean I think they shouldn’t post them! I just know I need to avoid them!

Whatinthelord · 16/01/2022 18:13

Generally I don’t think there is anything wrong with people sharing BF pictures on social media. Can it sometimes feel a bit performative? Yes, but doesn’t anything else on social media….isn’t that why anyone shares any photo on SM?

Why does your friend specifically send you photos of her BF?
Do you think she realises it upsets you?

RedCandyApple · 16/01/2022 18:12

I feel triggered when I hear
People passing their driving lessons as I failed and don’t drive? I mean where do you draw the line, yes YABU.

UniversalAunt · 16/01/2022 18:12

Flowers @Sedai Very wise words.

Candyss · 16/01/2022 18:11

OP if you had started the thread with am I unreasonable to feel upset that my friend is sending me pictures of her breastfeeding then your responses would of been different.

I'm actually a bit confused why that wouldnt of been the point of your thread tbh and has only come up after most said yabu.

RedCandyApple · 16/01/2022 18:11

I feel triggered when friends posts pics of them getting engaged as I’m single, see how ridiculous that sounds 🙄

And people do post pics of their babies being fed with bottles? I see it all the time?! Not sure why you said they don’t?

BFPDec21 · 16/01/2022 18:11

In general YABU and I'm sorry you feel like you failed. Another person's positive journey is not a slight on you.

In relation to this friend, you need to be honest with her about her comments about being superwoman, etc.. Her reaction will determine if you should drop her.

thewhatsit · 16/01/2022 18:10

Sending you photos isn’t on, but sharing on her SM is entirely her prerogative. All social media is about is people posting things they are proud of to simply show off or to share with others so they can be proud / happy for them - it’s why people post photos of graduation days, their children getting good scores in tests, the cutest photos of their kids and pets, photos that show their home in the best light. People rarely show unflattering photos or share that their child got a mediocre 7/10 on a spelling test or whatever. Even if they are posting a seemingly negative post eg about how tired they are - it’s always going to be competitive - I’m more tired that you are, my child wakes up more than yours, I win and you can comment “I don’t know how you do it!” …

I think it’s pretty outrageous that it’s always breastfeeding that can’t be shared in case it upsets others. You could extrapolate this to basically anything but somehow it’s ok to be proud of anything other than breastfeeding. I’ve breastfed for years with both children and I’m allowed to be proud of that. It’s been a huge part of my life and taken a monumental m effort. I have never posted a breastfeeding photo online because I don’t like sharing much but I’m allowed to be proud and me being proud isn’t a slight on Jane Doe down the road who didn’t.

AnneLovesGilbert · 16/01/2022 18:09

I’ve also seen loads of pix of people ff on Facebook. I don’t think it’s that’s rare given that so many people do it.

UniversalAunt · 16/01/2022 18:09

We all fail at something or other during our lives.
If we avoid failure & any difficult feelings, then we cease to develop ourselves or build resilience.

So, you couldn’t breast feed as you hoped?
You say that you were unwell with PND
You have brought lovely children in the world & overcome a difficult condition. You have done very well

Some people cannot process their difficult feelings & progress, so they dump their shit, knowingly or not, on other people. This is not who you are.

Just because your babies are close in age, this does not make you natural allies after maternity. If you feel less after contact with this person, it is because she is feeding off your self doubt which is a remnant or ashes of your PND.

MrsAvocet · 16/01/2022 18:08

Sending you pictures directly is odd and as others have said, at best insensitive and very self absorbed and at worst downright nasty.
Posting general stuff on social media is fine, but seemingly targeting someone that you know is likely to be upset by particular things is different.
I lost my job last year due to ill health, and also can no longer do my main hobby. I still have ex colleagues and hobby related friends on social media so of course I see things that at times make me sad. But they are still living their lives as normal, and why shouldn't they share things. That's for me to deal with and I either have to accept it or stop following them. But if they started sending me private messages with things like "hey, here we are enjoying our Christmas night out that you're not part of any more" or " bet you wish you were out with us enjoying our hobby on this lovely sunny day" then I would feel very differently!
I would agree that you either need to talk to this friend or stop communicating- I guess it depends on your relationship.
Another thing you might consider is something that I do if I'm feeling particularly sensitive, or if say, there is a big event coming up and I know my newsfeed is going to be flooded with pics. I use the Snooze function so you dont see someones posts for 30 days unless you actively go and look. (Facebook- I'm not sure about other socual media platforms). I find that can be a good coping mechanism if I'm a bit fragile but don't want to actually lose touch with someone. After a bit of a break I usually handle things better again.

ItsSnowJokes · 16/01/2022 18:07

As everyone else has said YABU, maybe just don't use social media for a while. You can't get pissed off and triggered at other people feeding a baby, it's just not right.

I would gently suggest maybe some counselling or seeing your gp, you are going to see this all the time in day to day life, its not fair on you being triggered by this when some help may stop this.

WonderfulYou · 16/01/2022 18:01

This isn’t about Facebook or breastfeeding, it’s about your competitive “friendship”. Your comment about your scar free stomach is as unpleasant as what you think she’s doing with feeding photos. You’re thinking like it’s a competition even though you’re not saying it to her.

I agree and it’s very common when friends/family members have babies very close to each other

Somebodylikeyew · 16/01/2022 17:51

Sweetie, photos on social media aren’t the problem- your friend is.

If she’s a friend you want to keep, I’d tell her how her messages are making you feel. Her response will tell you whether this is a friendship that is worth continuing with or not.

girlmom21 · 16/01/2022 17:47

Why does she send you pictures? That's unusual. Does she know how you feel?

Somethingsnappy · 16/01/2022 17:47

After your update op, it does sound like your friend is being either spectacularly insensitive or deliberately provocative. Not about the social media pictures, but about her private pictures and messages to you. Perhaps raise that side of things with her? Her reaction will be quite telling I suspect.

Swipe left for the next trending thread