Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring this up with the parents - my daughter's cousins told them they were thicker and not as good because they don't go to a private school (or should /I just lol and leave it alone!)

138 replies

HacketteofHacks · 16/01/2022 15:53

We had a family 'get together' around Christmas.
My daughters are 12 and 8, their cousins are 7 and 4.
The 7 year old told my 12 year old that she was 'brighter and better' than her because she went to private school.
She also later said to my 8 year old who was struggling to tie up shoe laces (trainers so they could go out to the park) and say 'I can do that I'm cleverer than you'. I've no reason to think my children are lying - I know these children have said other stuff in the past to me.
Now if my DC said that to another child (in an immediate family) I would want to know.
My DH (it's his DB whose children made the comments) thinks it's 'just people isn't it'. And thinks I should avoid...
And before you flame me.. I haven't really got a problem with private schooling - we are lucky enough to live in an area where all the schools are good. But DH and his brother went to a public school and hated it (in fact DH was surprised with DH sent his children to private school as they too live in an area with some good schools).
There also the issue that DB is paid via a limited company so while DH ( and I)pay tax via PAYE we know DB puts a lot of things through his limited company. So he doesn't pay the same amount of tax and maybe can afford to do the private school thing.
Neither DB or his wife went to university. His wife doesn't work (lucky her as her mum gave her shed loads of cash to buy their house) both DH and I do work long hours and we. both have masters degrees. But I would never think I was better than anyone else.
My question is - should I bring this up?

OP posts:
lesenfantsdelesperance · 16/01/2022 18:15

@5128gap

In fairness to your in laws, they might have picked this up at school, either from other students or the school itself. Schools after brag about having the 'brightest and best' students. It's supposed to foster pride in being part of the school community.
I think this is true. And I would start from that point to talk to the parents. It's not really very classy, is it? How good can the school that they are paying for be?
100problems · 16/01/2022 18:09

My kids would've just taken their cousins down. Isn't that what kids are supposed to do to irritating little cousins? Mine cousins certainly did.

RaoulDufysCat · 16/01/2022 18:08

@TheHoptimist

In what way do you think using a limited company saves tax? You pay tax in a different way and have more expenses linked to companies house etc but the days when there was a large difference are long since gone.
Yes, this. The actual difference is really small. You still have to pay personal tax on money you receive from the company, too, as well as corporation tax assuming the business is profitable. And there are very clear rules about what you are allowed to claim as expenses.
Athenajm80 · 16/01/2022 18:07

I used to get this but from my great-uncle. He was in his 40s and I was about 8. He'd make comments about how I might be at private school but he had to work to do well in exams and didn't have it spoonfed to him. He'd put Bamboozle on Teletext whenever we saw him and challenge me to answer the questions faster than him.

I just remember being a bit confused and also feeling bad for him that he felt he had to put down a child in order to feel better about himself.

I think I'd just tell your children to say something non-commital like "that's nice" and then change the subject "race you to the swings" or whatever. Their children have probably heard the parents saying it and haven't thought it through in their heads. Although whether they actually mean it or not, they'll soon lose the superiority complex as they go on in life

Emerald5hamrock · 16/01/2022 18:05

Do you not see the irony in your initial post op? The dig about sils mother giving cash to buy the home and then not going to university and sil being a sahm. Your being equally judgemental if not more so because your an adult. Your talking about a 7 year old who is still learning.

Yep, just one big judgy clan teaching their DC to follow, the only difference is 7 y.o's don't know how to be underhanded, or veil their judgement with fake concern.
Jealousy is one of the worst characteristics in a person, don't bite or teach your DC it.

Sloughsabigplace · 16/01/2022 18:01

@itsgettingweird it’s the only time I have ever risen to one of ex h jibes in all these years. He said he was embarrassed that his son was thinking of doing some thing so “uneducated” when his sisters children were all destined for great things.

I told him that I hoped an “uneducated” paramedic never had the need to save his life one day then. At least he had the shame to look embarrassed.

Momicrone · 16/01/2022 17:57

Just be thankful your kids aren't going to grow up to be entitled twats

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/01/2022 17:56

@Bananarama21

Do you not see the irony in your initial post op? The dig about sils mother giving cash to buy the home and then not going to university and sil being a sahm. Your being equally judgemental if not more so because your an adult. Your talking about a 7 year old who is still learning.
Exactly this.

Don’t rise to a 7 year old op, it’s very petty.

BertiesShoes · 16/01/2022 17:55

The only thing I resent is that it's pretty obvious they use a limited company to avoid paying the taxes that most of us pay. It's not envy - more annoyed.

This is plain nasty. My DH had a Ltd company until recently - he paid all the taxes that he had to via his Ltd company. Yes, there are slightly different tax rules to PAYE, but he also paid corporation tax, plus didn’t get sick pay, holiday pay, employer pension contributions etc. No redundancy pay if he didn’t work.

As someone who worked PAYE, I know the differences and there are swings and roundabouts to both. He liked the flexibility of contracting via a LTD company, but he certainly wasn’t avoiding paying taxes. Sorry, but you do sound envious, maybe go self employed via a LTD company yourself if you think you will avoid tax? But I assure you, you won’t!

You sound jealous and are making this about your BIL and SIL working lives (or lack of) rather than the schooling. So what if her mum gave her some money, my kids will be getting some when they are older, we have inherited quite a lot, why shouldn’t we share it?

Comparison is the thief of joy. Enjoy your own life, don’t compare with others.

Happyher · 16/01/2022 17:55

The child was probably complaining to her mum that she wanted to go to school locally with all her friends and her mum has told her she will get a better education and qualifications in more age appropriate language and DN is probably repeating it with her own interpretation. Just reassure your own kids that it’s not true and they can do equally as well if they try

Bananarama21 · 16/01/2022 17:48

Do you not see the irony in your initial post op? The dig about sils mother giving cash to buy the home and then not going to university and sil being a sahm. Your being equally judgemental if not more so because your an adult. Your talking about a 7 year old who is still learning.

itsgettingweird · 16/01/2022 17:47

@Sloughsabigplace

My ds has dealt with this shit most of his life.

His father (my ex h) has 5 siblings, all had children around the same time we had ds.

We split when ds was 4, ds went to state school - ex h parents pay for all their other grandchildren to go to prestigious private schools, as they did thier own children, but they hated me so didn’t pay for ds.

Not that I cared actually, never said a word, they can spend their money how they wish and I didn’t want my ds schooling dictated to me anyway.

All cousins are now teens. All in or going to Oxford/Cambridge other prestigious unis.

Ds did okay at school, but decided to do a BTEC and is 19 now and is training to be a paramedic.

He gets a sneered at by his father and his fathers family and it does hurt him. Oh, and obviously it’s all my fault - I’m thick and ds is thick like me/has been dragged up by me and now dh blah blah blah - it’s all a stick to carry on beating me with.

All untrue and pathetic but hey, if it makes them feel good to slag off a person they haven’t clapped eyes on in 15 years, then they can crack on! I must live a happier life than them. My son is wonderful, happy, an amazing big brother to his little siblings and is doing something he cares about in life.

He realised a few years ago that despite the thousands spent on education, his cousins are cunts and all the expensive education in the world doesn’t buy you compassion or class.

A paramedic.

Clearly not thick then.

If covid has taught us nothing then we've learnt that our nhs workers are the essential backbone of this country health wise.

Go you ds for doing something so useful to society .

JustUseTheDoorSanta · 16/01/2022 17:45

I don't think it's worth a family row over nonsense that a 7 year old comes out with. Teach your girls to ignore any silliness from much younger kids and move on.

MsTSwift · 16/01/2022 17:36

My mother was told that they were the best at her public school and got a rude awakening at university when she met state and grammar students far cleverer than her!

Naive to think this isn’t inculcated into the pupils - how else do you justify the fees?!

5128gap · 16/01/2022 17:29

In fairness to your in laws, they might have picked this up at school, either from other students or the school itself. Schools after brag about having the 'brightest and best' students. It's supposed to foster pride in being part of the school community.

TheOccupier · 16/01/2022 17:23

Can't see the relevance of your second paragraph about their financial arrangements Hmm but I think you should have a word with SIL. "Brighter and better" sounds like it may have come from the school. I'd want to know.

Echobelly · 16/01/2022 17:18

Honestly, I would talk it up to little kids talking crap and not mention to parents unless/until you see further evidence of worrying behaviour. It's like when we were kids and some kids would be all 'My dad is richer than your dad' etc

TheHoptimist · 16/01/2022 17:17

In what way do you think using a limited company saves tax?
You pay tax in a different way and have more expenses linked to companies house etc but the days when there was a large difference are long since gone.

Oldraver · 16/01/2022 17:16

My only thought would be ...money doesn't buy manners

SoupDragon · 16/01/2022 17:11

I would just teach my children to roll their eyes and ignore it. There's no need to stop to the level of a 7 year old with equally rude retorts.

I think it's come from the parents (one of other of them) and the 7 year old is basically parroting what she's been told.

I would be disgusted with my children if they'd come out with those comments.

Bingbangbongbash · 16/01/2022 17:10

YABVU

People don’t use limited companies to avoid paying tax, and if you think they do, maybe the cousins are right. For clarity, anything put through the company must be a legitimate business expense. If it is not, it will be excluded from tax calculations - unless you’re accusing your BIL and his accountants of tax fraud, which would be a much bigger issue than his kids being horrid.

Stop being so jealous, it’s only making you feel bad.

ancientgran · 16/01/2022 17:06

Tell your children to just laugh and say they go to state schools as they are clever and don't need the extra help but they hope their cousins do OK.

RockallMalinHebrides · 16/01/2022 16:59

@WinnersDinner

YABU

Your post reeks of jealousy

7 year olds say annoying shit all the time, I'd ignore and tell your older children to ignore too

It really doesn't.
2bazookas · 16/01/2022 16:59

Teach your children some harmless nonsensical responses.

" Your parents sent you to private school to make your hair grow."

 "  Talking to cousins makes your teeth  fall out"
SailingNotSurfing · 16/01/2022 16:58

The kid is 7, not 17. She'll soon learn her lesson, if she carries on with that silly attitude. Local children will take the piss out of her if she starts with her sneering and jeering. Private schoolkids where I grew up (Oxford, not anywhere rough as fuck) got a lot of stick for their straw boaters and daft blazers - looking back, maybe we were jealous?