Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To bring this up with the parents - my daughter's cousins told them they were thicker and not as good because they don't go to a private school (or should /I just lol and leave it alone!)

138 replies

HacketteofHacks · 16/01/2022 15:53

We had a family 'get together' around Christmas.
My daughters are 12 and 8, their cousins are 7 and 4.
The 7 year old told my 12 year old that she was 'brighter and better' than her because she went to private school.
She also later said to my 8 year old who was struggling to tie up shoe laces (trainers so they could go out to the park) and say 'I can do that I'm cleverer than you'. I've no reason to think my children are lying - I know these children have said other stuff in the past to me.
Now if my DC said that to another child (in an immediate family) I would want to know.
My DH (it's his DB whose children made the comments) thinks it's 'just people isn't it'. And thinks I should avoid...
And before you flame me.. I haven't really got a problem with private schooling - we are lucky enough to live in an area where all the schools are good. But DH and his brother went to a public school and hated it (in fact DH was surprised with DH sent his children to private school as they too live in an area with some good schools).
There also the issue that DB is paid via a limited company so while DH ( and I)pay tax via PAYE we know DB puts a lot of things through his limited company. So he doesn't pay the same amount of tax and maybe can afford to do the private school thing.
Neither DB or his wife went to university. His wife doesn't work (lucky her as her mum gave her shed loads of cash to buy their house) both DH and I do work long hours and we. both have masters degrees. But I would never think I was better than anyone else.
My question is - should I bring this up?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
newyear1 · 23/01/2022 21:46

I went to a state school so have a foot in both camps.

I find some of the generalisations about private school kids on MN threads quite offensive at times; there would (quite rightly) be an uproar if similarly negative sweeping statements were made about state school pupils.

BoardingSchoolMater · 23/01/2022 21:30

This is also my experience @newyear1 There are nice, well mannered children and unpleasant and rude ones at all schools.

newyear1 · 23/01/2022 21:22

Just wanted to counter the generalisation that all private school kids are taught that they're superior and look down on state school kids.

From my experience of the three private schools my kids have attended, this is not the case. My teenagers won't mention they're at a private school if at all possible and their head/teachers would be appalled to hear comments along those lines. Not all private school kids are entitled, arrogant horrors.

Berrybear · 23/01/2022 21:09

When I was wee one of my friends in the street who i played with went to a private school and I went to state school. Their uniform was brown. One day my friend told me that she was smarter than me and went to a better school because it cost her parents lots of money. I replied with 'At least my school uniform doesn't make me look like a turd' which made her cry and fall out with me but as wee girls do we quickly made up but she never said anything like that to me again.

Give your kids a stock response that they can hit out with if their cousins say anything to them again in future.

ChrisAnneTheMum · 23/01/2022 20:57

@stuntbubbles

Just lol and leave it. The private school is doing its job to turn the cousins into little shits, isn’t it?
Horrible and unnecessary.
Why2why · 23/01/2022 20:49

OP from some of your responses it sounds like you too look down on them and consider yourself to be superior. I’m guessing that there’s a lot of underlying competition and comparing between your families.

winnieanddaisy · 17/01/2022 13:58

Tell your children that it doesn't men their cousins are more clever than them , it just means that the parents have more money.
Your children have to believe the school the other children go to won't increase their chances of doing better academically, your children can and will do just as good in their exams etc . You need them to work hard and not give up just because of a nasty comment by their little cousin .

Rummikub · 16/01/2022 23:10

@ana1s

“The OP said she laughed at that comment from the four year old. She wasn’t offended.”

Yes but even remembering it enough to mention is peculiar.

I don’t think it was. It’s reflective.

Remembering a similar incident and how she dealt with it differently.

Everyone remembers off details.

Lockheart · 16/01/2022 22:58

I was privately educated all the way through and I'm trying to remember when I was first aware of the concept that my parents paid for school but others didn't. I think it must have been around age 12? Until then school was just school. Everyone goes to school. There are teachers and playgrounds and blackboards and pegs with your name on. Your parents chequebook doesn't come into it.

I really doubt the 7 year old is coming out with this without any sort of adult influence. I'd bet money she's learning that from her parents. Your issue is with them, not the 7 year old who's being badly taught.

Cocogreen · 16/01/2022 22:49

My son is a new teacher who did some teaching placements in very good private schools ( he was state educated).
He found that the kids weren't snobs, nor the teachers, just about all the snobby entitled behaviour ( like that displayed by that child) is what you hear from parents.

recklessgran · 16/01/2022 22:31

Don't worry OP. My privately educated brat of a niece once referred to my children as her "peasant" cousins. She was about 6 at the time so must have heard the term from her parents. Mine were slightly older and asked me what she meant. She lived in London and we lived very rurally. I passed it off by telling mine that it was because they lived in the countryside.

interferingma · 16/01/2022 22:17

@Sloughsabigplace well done your DS for doing such a demanding and worthwhile job. You need brains, grit and huge dollops of character and empathy to be a paramedic.

ana1s · 16/01/2022 21:55

“The OP said she laughed at that comment from the four year old. She wasn’t offended.”

Yes but even remembering it enough to mention is peculiar.

Saskatcha · 16/01/2022 21:27

I’d be surprised if most 7 year olds know what kind of school they go to let alone how that interfaces with our education systems, etc. This is coming from home I expect.

VioletLemon · 16/01/2022 21:21

Tiresome dull adults are the reason children have absorbed this message. "we are better, more privileged and smarter because we have more money".
Load of utter shit, I've taught for 30 years and in a couple of private schools. In all honestly the most deprived areas I worked in had the brightest, more intelligent kids. Some lovely kids in every school but in private school I encountered some of the most miserable, dense, unlikeable kids. Sawmore attachment disorder than I saw in really poor background schools with many adverse experiences. Sadly some parents think that by flinging money at a child it equals Nurture. It doesn't and lots have serious issues as relationships with parents are farmed out to tutors, clubs, etc etc. Can't buy manners or Nurture or confidence.

Rummikub · 16/01/2022 21:16

The OP said she laughed at that comment from the four year old. She wasn’t offended.

ana1s · 16/01/2022 21:13

“The 4 year old niece started telling me I shouldn't be doing exercise because 'mummy doesn't do that'. “

Well so what? Are you and your husband that insecure that you are remotely bothered by the comments of a 4 year-old? Christ on a bike! Do you have any idea how this is coming across? The child is FOUR - not 40! It was hardly a value judgement on you - she was probably just commenting that she’d never seen her own mum doing that in the garden.

You sound deeply bitter and hell bent on reading anything and everything into the throwaway comments of a young child to fuel whatever jealously you have against these people. Most people would t even register that kind of comment or give it a second’s thought. Yet here you are....

lanthanum · 16/01/2022 21:10

My guess is that the child's logic is "you have to pass a test to get into our private school; cousins aren't at private school so they must have not passed the test".

If it happens when you're around, you can explain "DD's school has lots of clever children in it, and we chose it because we know she'll do very well there." Explain to your kids why their cousins might have thought going to state school meant they didn't pass a test for private school, and encourage them to say something similar.

It depends on your relationship with the parents what you say to them - it might be worth mentioning that their kids seem to think that if you don't go to private school it must be because you're not clever enough. They might be anxious to correct the misunderstanding too.

As for being able to do up shoe laces, if a 7 year old can do them and an 8 year old can't, they're inevitably going to pleased with themselves.

saraclara · 16/01/2022 21:08

Have your kids not learned how to eye roll yet?

Older cousins should be able to put a 7 and a 4 year old down quite easily. Definitely not worth risking a family fall out over this (though it sounds like you might be looking for a reason to fall out with them).

MrsColon · 16/01/2022 21:00

Say something if it comes up naturally in conversation, or wait till you overhear it.

A kid on our street said "at least I go to a private school" during an argument with my brother (same age). He grew up to be a nice young man eventually (and incidently, got far, far worse results at school than my bro & rest of siblings).

They're very young, and are either picking this prejudice at school (in which case your SIL/BIL will likely be horrified) or at home (in which case the parents won't thank you for bringing it up).

WorraLiberty · 16/01/2022 20:57

Kids say shit all the time.

I'm more surprised your 12yr old couldn't put her 7 yr old cousin in their place.

Gunpowder · 16/01/2022 20:55

Sorry, don’t know where the random z came from.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/01/2022 20:55

What ate the parents like? If they're decent people then you should tell them as if it was me, I'd want to know. If its likely they've heard it from their parents then I wouldn't bother

Gunpowder · 16/01/2022 20:55

Bit harsh weonlyz, she’s only 7! Grin

Weonlyhavealoanofit · 16/01/2022 20:54

Next time the little darlings start talking about ‘being clever’ perhaps this response may help ‘Oh I think your mummy and daddy had to pay for you to go to school because they were worried that you’re not v talented and they’re trying to give you a leg up and it’s costing a fortune that’s why your daddy is going to get into trouble with the government. He isn’t paying his taxes because he’s got to pay your fees. Yes if we were all like you and your parents there wouldn’t be any schools or roads or hospitals’.