Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be considering rehoming my dog?

187 replies

GuiltRiddenDilema · 16/01/2022 11:29

Don’t want to go into too much detail but she’s a 3 year old Dobermann. Had her since 8 weeks old. Was conned by the breeder (the adult dobies I met were not her parents, her parents it turns out … were too aggressive to meet). I did everything by the book, obedience classes, socialisation classes … she just got more and more aggressive. I got a 1-1 trainer … didn’t help. Tried a different 1-1 trainer - helped in the short term but soon went backwards, tried behaviourist who said the dog was fear aggressive and would never be able to be around other dogs or children. I travelled across the country with her for a Dobermann expert who said she’s bright as a button but will always be unpredictable and temperamental.
The area we live in is the worst possible area for her temperament. Lots of offlead dogs running around, lots of small children - I’m terrified she will escape the garden or something. I can’t walk her without being constantly on edge that she’ll hurt someone/something.
I’ve tried for 2.5 years to get her through this but she’s just the same as she always was. We have good days and bad days. I train her daily, I’ve put so much time and money into her training and see nothing for it.

Problem is I love the dog dearly and she’s obsessed with me. The guilt is eating away at me. In the meantime I’m terrified and alienating all the human relationships I have as nobody will come to my house anymore. I can’t even have my grandchild over.
She needs an experienced owner, one that can actually give her some kind of a life.
I’d contact a breed specific rescue and keep her until they could find a suitable experienced owner. I don’t want her going into kennels and I’m not interested in money. I just want to save her 😢

I just don’t know what to do anymore. My own adult children will no longer visit 😔

OP posts:
SchadenfreudePersonified · 16/01/2022 12:36

TBH, I wouldn't re-home her - awful as it is, I would euthanise.

I wouldn't dare take the risk that she might end up with someone who also couldn't;t cope, and would just pass her on, and that this would happen time and time again, with her becoming more anxious and unpredictable with every home, or even that she would get someone who tried really hard with her, but she ended up attacking someone - particularly a child - or even another dog.

Aggression is very hard to train out, particularly fear aggression - you don't know what will prompt an aggressive response and it cn be completely unpredictable.

Sorry OP - Really think you need to let her go. (I've had to do this with a fear aggressive dog, too, and it was horrible - a young, healthy beautiful dog, fabulous in the house and with family, but totally unreliable anywhere else, with strangers or with other dogs. i really sympathise - it's a bliddy awful decision to have to make)

oakleaffy · 16/01/2022 12:36

@mayblossominapril

I think you unfortunately you may have to go for the pts option. The vets should be able to make a home visit and bring a vet nurse as well if you have to choose this option
We had our old beloved dog PTS (Terminal illness) and the home visit was so much better for the dog- Who disliked the vets. It was heartbreaking, but so different to having it performed at the surgery. Well worth the extra cost.
zoomies2021 · 16/01/2022 12:35

Sounds like she can't stay with you. But also that you are just at the beginning of looking into your other options - find specialists who can help you look at what else is possible. Research the right shelter etc with as much commitment as you have put into trying to solve it so you can keep her. And once you have found the right people put your trust in them and follow their advice.

GrandmasCat · 16/01/2022 12:35

Anyone know if I could set up an agreement with the rescue that if things didn’t work out with new owners she’d come back to me?

I wrote my previous post before seeing the above. How irresponsible of you.

An agreement like what? Like they report you to police when she hurts a child or kills someone’s pet?

Honestly, if there are rescues to take in a Doberman with such problems on the idea that love and a kind owner will get a dog changed when so much experienced trainers couldn’t , they should be banned from providing dogs to families.

What if your dog ends up with the town’s tug? Perfect candidate isn’t it? Looks intimidating, is unpredictable and can kill just by letting her off leash. Wonderful!

Keep her with you if you can’t PTS, you can just shove it to a well intentioned person knowing what you do.

Eddielzzard · 16/01/2022 12:34

I'm so sorry. What a horrible situation to be in.

I am in the PTS camp. Thinking of Adam Watts who was very experienced and was killed by a dog he rescued. Admittedly that dog had been abused and yours hasn't, but it is an aggressive dog who will be put into a very stressful situation by moving homes.

The best thing for the dog IMO is being PTS in your arms. That's the hardest option for you, but I believe the kindest for the dog. Those dog breeders should be prosecuted. The dog cannot change its nature and it's not safe for anyone.

TheGoldenWolfFleece · 16/01/2022 12:33

If she's that aggressive, do the right thing and pts. Rehoming her is passing the buck onto someone else.

LuckySantangelo35 · 16/01/2022 12:31

You sound a lovely, caring owner but your daughter and grandchild need to take precedence

Sproutpie · 16/01/2022 12:29

I had a dog with the same temperament, different breed to you. I was very anxious and was becoming isolated. I spoke to my vet for advice and was advised that rehoming would be too risky. I was advised to put my 2 year old girl to sleep. With a very heavy heart that’s what I did. I had to put the safety of people first. I do feel guilty but I don’t regret the decision.

mayblossominapril · 16/01/2022 12:28

I think you unfortunately you may have to go for the pts option. The vets should be able to make a home visit and bring a vet nurse as well if you have to choose this option

ChiefStockingStuffer · 16/01/2022 12:28

@Spud1130

Personally I'd have her put to sleep. Living a life so stressed isn't be good for her, and I couldn't personally ever rehome a dog and not know what happens. Yoube tried several interventions and unfortunately, some dogs just aren't wired right. I had one like this although the only reason he was manageable was because he was small (under 10kg). There are many fates far worse than a humane death Flowers
I agree with this. An aggressive dog won't be rehomed.

You've tried everything.

I'd have her put down.

Please report the breeders.

RedMozzieYellowMozzie · 16/01/2022 12:27

You've consulted experts who say she's unstable and unpredictable. You can't pass that on to someone else to deal with - what if she attacked and hurt someone? The right decision would be to have her pts. A trip to the vets with her loving owner is far preferable to months of upheaval in her life which will probably lead to the same ultimate end anyway

Iamnotamermaid · 16/01/2022 12:27

Unlike the breeders, you now have to be responsible for this situation. If the dog is not safe to be around, constantly in a state of fear (which does not make for a happy dog), and cannot be trained, there is sadly only one option.

Certainly discuss options with a breed specific rescue as they have almost certainly come across this situation before. You say you live in the worst possible area for her - maybe a new home somewhere quieter will be worth a try. But a fear aggressive dog is a ticking time bomb which will eventually cause someone or something harm.

oakleaffy · 16/01/2022 12:27

@IllManneredBitch

You worry that the dog will escape the garden and attack a small child. The dog makes your house too unsafe for your family to visit. But the thing that you'd feel guilty about is putting it to sleep? You have an animal capable of killing someone and with an unstable and aggressive temperament that is genetic and can't be improved through training. Taking it to the vet and having it humanely euthanised is the least awful of all the options.
Agree 100percent. It would be grossly irresponsible to pass an aggressive dog on. Jack Lees was killed by such a “ Passed on” dog. Doubt any responsible rescue would want to take on such a liability.
Cherrysoup · 16/01/2022 12:27

You must employ one of the solutions above. I wouldn’t go to a breed specific rescue. I would either use the people in the link in the first few posts or put to sleep. At least then you know she went peacefully and what happened to her. I’m going to be horrible here and tell you to check the background of the breeder you next use far more carefully. Consider your breed choice and why you want a dog. If it’s just companionship, get something less renowned for their ability to guard.

I’m really sorry you are going through this, one of mine was incredibly dog aggressive and it was a nightmare just trying to do normal walks.

Keladrythesaviour · 16/01/2022 12:26

Definitely speak to a breed specific rescue. Our friends had a fear reactive Dalmatian and worked so hard with him for years. Blue cross/RSPCA/dogs trust all said to PTS. Found a Dalmatian rescue and he's now living his best life in a home suited to his needs. Breed fanatics will often be willing to take on basket cases no one else will touch .we have a lurcher and are supported by a lurcher charity and they often re-home reactive and fear aggressive dogs with specialist foster homes who have no visiting children, wide open spaces etc and they can live happily. It's not always a happy ending though so you will have to bear that in mind, but a specialist rescue will be far more honest and open about what is possible than anyone else.

I have a reactive dog, but thank fully not aggressive. It is incredibly hard. Rehoming her, if you can, will be the kindest thing. She isn't happy and as much a she loves you, she will bond with a new family. Some places allow open adoptions too, so you could always discuss this.

GrandmasCat · 16/01/2022 12:25

After 3 years of training due to aggressive behaviour she is already with a highly experienced owner (that’s you, BTW, trainers train the owner more than the dog)

You have done a lot for her, and even the more experienced trainers have told you she will always be aggressive. You love her, know her and despite all the training cannot manage her and is making your life very difficult.

You ABSOLUTELY CANNOT REHOME her, she is too dangerous for that, if she doesn’t hurt or kill someone known to the rehoming person, she will when she is passed down to the next owner.

You know what you need to do, it is a huge sacrifice, but the right decision considering the grief she can inflict on you or other family or the possibility you may end up in jail for rehoming her even to someone who couldn’t fully understand the responsibility they were taking on as well as you do.
Flowers

CovidCorvid · 16/01/2022 12:23

Personally I’d feel more guilty rehoming, thinking the dog could be scared and confused. At least when pts they’re out of mental torment ….and a dog which behaves like this is going through that. My BIL always said my dog was mentally ill. He believes that as some people can be mentally ill so can animals. I’m not sure but ive since found out the breeder I got him from has had issues with other aggressive dogs so I do think maybe a genetic element combined with not knowing what might have happened to him for the first six months of his life. So maybe he was abused?

IllManneredBitch · 16/01/2022 12:21

You worry that the dog will escape the garden and attack a small child. The dog makes your house too unsafe for your family to visit. But the thing that you'd feel guilty about is putting it to sleep? You have an animal capable of killing someone and with an unstable and aggressive temperament that is genetic and can't be improved through training. Taking it to the vet and having it humanely euthanised is the least awful of all the options.

oakleaffy · 16/01/2022 12:20

If a child is bitten , it will be game over anyway.
And realistically, little children are unpredictable in their movements- I don’t blame your daughter for not wanting to visit.
There are enough “ Good natured” dogs desperately looking for homes- So a known fear aggressive dog is unlikely to be rehomed as we live in a society where people are sued for dog bites- and this is a known unpredictable, strong dog.

Daenerys77 · 16/01/2022 12:20

This is very sad, but you have done everything you possibly can and you need to do what is best for you and your family. Having a relationship with your children and grandchildren is much more important than any dog.

Kshhuxnxk · 16/01/2022 12:19

Once you give her up that's it you need to walk away. I love dogs more than most people and would never say this lightly but pts may be the best option for the dog. You say shes obsessed with you. In that case theres a high possibility you may be the one that she attacks. I don't understand dog owners who don't acknowledge when pts is the right thing for the dog. You've tried everything you could.

Youngstreet · 16/01/2022 12:18

A friend of mine had her dog pts.
Ddog had always been unpredictable.
Would nip for no reason.
Friend was moving to live nearer to dc and new dgc.
She would never have been able to have family visit with dgc.
She didn't want to rehome a dog that she knew may bite.
It was the best solution but still broke her heart.

Hoppinggreen · 16/01/2022 12:16

@Stompythedinosaur

I think you are kidding yourself if you think an aggressive adult dog will be rehomed.
I’m sorry but I agree. PTS might be the only option unfortunately If this dog is just very very bonded to you then being in kennels will be awful for it and even breed specialists will struggle with such an aggressive dog. Being PTS might be better for the dog than being passed around, left in kennels and who knows what else
oakleaffy · 16/01/2022 12:12

@GuiltRiddenDilema
You do seem to be responsible- Sadly genes do come out in temperament.
A muzzle will make her MUCH safer around people and dogs.
I’d not want an aggressive dog, no matter what the reason, and nor would many people
If a Doberman specific trainer can’t do anything, I don’t know what to suggest.
A local dog of not dissimilar breeding wears a muzzle all the time after seriously injuring innocent dogs- It went to court.
A muzzle at least keeps everyone safe.

bluetongue · 16/01/2022 12:12

@Pendolino

I would talk to the breed specific rescue to see what they say but prepare yourself that you may need to consider euthanasia. Really sorry you’re in this position after trying so hard to do the right thing. Irresponsible breeders have a lot to answer for.
This is what I would do as well. I’ve worked through some behavior related issues with my dog through a specialist behavior vet and she told me from the beginning that many of these problems have a strong genetic component so don’t blame yourself.

Luckily my dog had anxiety issues but wasn’t dangerous or aggressive but will admit to considering rehoming as a puppy. I was able to throw money at the problem but realise that’s not always enough.