Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be considering rehoming my dog?

187 replies

GuiltRiddenDilema · 16/01/2022 11:29

Don’t want to go into too much detail but she’s a 3 year old Dobermann. Had her since 8 weeks old. Was conned by the breeder (the adult dobies I met were not her parents, her parents it turns out … were too aggressive to meet). I did everything by the book, obedience classes, socialisation classes … she just got more and more aggressive. I got a 1-1 trainer … didn’t help. Tried a different 1-1 trainer - helped in the short term but soon went backwards, tried behaviourist who said the dog was fear aggressive and would never be able to be around other dogs or children. I travelled across the country with her for a Dobermann expert who said she’s bright as a button but will always be unpredictable and temperamental.
The area we live in is the worst possible area for her temperament. Lots of offlead dogs running around, lots of small children - I’m terrified she will escape the garden or something. I can’t walk her without being constantly on edge that she’ll hurt someone/something.
I’ve tried for 2.5 years to get her through this but she’s just the same as she always was. We have good days and bad days. I train her daily, I’ve put so much time and money into her training and see nothing for it.

Problem is I love the dog dearly and she’s obsessed with me. The guilt is eating away at me. In the meantime I’m terrified and alienating all the human relationships I have as nobody will come to my house anymore. I can’t even have my grandchild over.
She needs an experienced owner, one that can actually give her some kind of a life.
I’d contact a breed specific rescue and keep her until they could find a suitable experienced owner. I don’t want her going into kennels and I’m not interested in money. I just want to save her 😢

I just don’t know what to do anymore. My own adult children will no longer visit 😔

OP posts:
MaxNormal · 16/01/2022 13:05

OP poor you and poor dog. What a terribly sad situation, those breeders are disgusting.

I do unfortunately have to agree with others who are saying PTS might be the kindest thing for her. Rehoming her would be really stressful, confusing and heartbreaking for her as she clearly loves you deeply. And you cannot guarantee that that will work out for her either. You ultimately have no idea of what you are sending her off to, or whose hands she may wind up in.

If she is PTS, she will be beyond any suffering. It's you that will suffer, greatly, I'm sure. But you'll be suffering out of love for her and putting her best interests first.

LakieLady · 16/01/2022 13:04

@CovidCorvid

When i was having issues someone from the dog board said to me that being put to sleep is not the worst thing which can happen to a dog. I didn’t understand at first and thought of course it is. But the more I thought about it the more I realised they were right. Being so afraid of life /everything is worse for the dog, they must be miserable and uptight to act like this. Rehoming a fearful dog might not be nice for it in the short term though I accept if somehow the fear can be resolved in a new home then long term it might be better. But that’s a gamble. Personally one I wasn’t prepared to take as I knew we’d tried everything. I thought that being rehomed, being scared by new people and then being pts anyway with strangers holding him would be worse than me taking him to the vet. Worst decision I’ve ever had to make and six years on I’m crying as I type this.
I think you did a very brave, and very humane thing @CovidCorvid. Flowers

Dobermanns get so attached to their owners that I think the chances of a successful rehome aren't good. I'm sorry to say that I think pts may well be the best option, OP.

NowEvenBetter · 16/01/2022 13:03

In the meantime, surely your aggressive dog is muzzled when on walks and in the garden? It’s not fair to allow your dog to have the opportunity to escape or approach other animals or humans and traumatise them.

You’re putting your own wants before anyone else’s-above your kid, your grandkid, your animal must be miserable living on its nerves. Doesn’t that make you feel guilty? Wouldn’t passing the problem onto someone else make you feel guilty? Realistically, what do you think will be the outcome here? Animals rescues are overflowing with dogs that aren’t dangerous, and are struggling to rehome them.
How would you feel about being prosecuted if your dog attacks? What about if the council orders it to be ‘destroyed’? Tell us what you think this animals life will be like, years or stress and unhappiness-for both of you.

DotBall · 16/01/2022 13:01

So many people are saying to put the dog to sleep. PLEASE DON'T DO THAT

But at what point should the dog be put to sleep? Before it’s bitten someone or after?

There are far too many instances of dogs attacking people (especially children) for us to not stand back and be objective about the situation.

ZoeTheThornyDevil · 16/01/2022 12:59

I'm sorry, but I agree with most of the PP that in the circumstances you describe you should have her humanely put to sleep. I have never, ever advised that before and have zero time for people who aren't committed to the dogs they've taken on. But some animals are simply not suited to the lives available to them in this world, and being quietly put to sleep is far better - for her and for others - than living a life in which she is always afraid and stressed and always a risk to others.

godmum56 · 16/01/2022 12:59

Its real genuine love to rehome a dog you can't cope with...and don't ask for her to come back to you, that helps nobody. Yes approach breed specific rehoming but also PTS is not the worst thing that can happen. I have had a dog PTS who wasn't safe, she loved me and was very gentle with me but had funny turns when she would be dangerous. I took advice first but it was some 20 years ago when much less was known about dog behaviour and psychology.

DotBall · 16/01/2022 12:57

This happened to a friend of mine with a much smaller breed dog. He had him PTS as he couldn’t have forgiven himself if the dog went elsewhere and became even more aggressive and out of control.

Throckmorton · 16/01/2022 12:54

Sometimes being PTS is the kindest option. From her point of view, she is with her favourite person for all her life, and has no awareness that the end has come. In her mind she's lived a lovely three years and all is great to the very end. The alternative may be that she leaves her favourite person and faces an uncertain and stressed future. This isn't nice for her. I know and sympathise about how much it will hurt you to have her PTS, but please think it over, and with the mindset that there would be no guilt in making that decision. Humans tend to want to live forever and in whatever circumstances, and they can foresee that while things might be bad in the interim, they will improve, which sustains them through the bad times. Animals live only in the present - they don't hope for a future, and a bad present is not offset for them by the posibility of better times.

I really synmpathise - losing an animal that you love is really hard, and it's clear you love her and have her best interests at heart.

Olliesocks · 16/01/2022 12:50

Your dog is not happy. You are not happy. Your family is not happy.

For who’s benefit are you prolonging the situation? You have tried everything for her. Having her PTS does not make you a bad owner. It is doing what is right for her. No matter how hard it is.

Blanketpolicy · 16/01/2022 12:49

A family member had their dog PTS last month after it went for and bit their wife, don't wait until the inevitable happens. You have pulled out all the stops and done everything you can for your dog (our family member didn't, lock down puppy and zero training 🤬)

You know the dog and the risks, you have had experts explain this to you. If your dog escapes and seriously injures or kills someone it will entirely be your fault. Can you live with that?

Attempting to rehome will just be stressful for the dog and it is unlikely to be successful. I know PTS will be unbearable, but it is the right thing and your ONLY option.

anditgoesonandon · 16/01/2022 12:49

So many people are saying to put the dog to sleep. PLEASE DON'T DO THAT.

Find a reputable rehoming charity that specializes in the breed. They will be able to assess the dog and come to a decision about what's right.

I have a dog with nervous aggression, however he is a chihuahua, so it's a lot more manageable than such a large breed. We live in the countryside and we have no young children in the family. He is perfectly content and happy with us, he just gets scared when strangers are around and when in unfamiliar places. He wouldn't attack anyone, he just needs his own space when scared.

I hope that your dog can be rehomed to a similar type of place.

gunnersgold · 16/01/2022 12:47

@CovidCorvid I agree with you , I had a very tricky pony when I was young and the easiest thing would be to sell her on but I was scared what would happen to her . If I couldn't keep her as a pet I would have had her euthanised. It's Much more normal in the horse world than the dog world to do this and it shouldn't be the worst outcome . If she hurts a human she will be pts anyway and how will you live with yourself worrying about where she is for the next ten years . A sad situation all round though .

Porcupineintherough · 16/01/2022 12:45

@Yants and where do you suggest the OP source these other dogs for hers to experiment on? Or do you think she should just take her to the local park and give it a go?

Porcupineintherough · 16/01/2022 12:44

If you care for your dog then have her pts in her own home and you next to her. Dont put her at through the strain of rehoming when it's so unlikely to result in a good outcome.

Yants · 16/01/2022 12:44

If it was me and she was as sweet and loving, loyal and affectionate (with me) as you say she is then I'd be prepared to make what ever personal sacrifices are necessary to keep her, and if that means friends and family no longer come round then so be it, you can still go out and visit them.

As far as being aggressive with other dogs is concerned have you had chance to see how she interacts with other dogs when she's off the lead? Dogs are often far more insecure and reactive when they're on the lead than when off it.

SleepOhHowIMissYou · 16/01/2022 12:43

If she's only three now then you're likely going to be spending your grandchildren's childhood prioritising her over them if you keep her.

You won't get that time back, when they're grown they're grown. Is it worth missing out on a relationship with your grandchildren because you cannot provide a safe environment because of an aggressive pet?

SmellyOldOwls · 16/01/2022 12:42

@GoodnightGrandma

Sometimes euthanasia is the kindest thing for the dog.
I think this too. If you pass her on you risk her being used as a fighting dog or something.
Elphame · 16/01/2022 12:42

Speak to one of the specialist Dobermann rescue centres.

Someone I used to work with used to adopt problem Dobies so there is a chance that her life can be turned around.

nancyclancy123 · 16/01/2022 12:39

You sound like a caring and responsible dog owner but the right thing to do would be to pts.
You can't continue to live like this and it would be the kindest option for the dog. flowers

LettertoHermoine · 16/01/2022 12:39

@IllManneredBitch

You worry that the dog will escape the garden and attack a small child. The dog makes your house too unsafe for your family to visit. But the thing that you'd feel guilty about is putting it to sleep? You have an animal capable of killing someone and with an unstable and aggressive temperament that is genetic and can't be improved through training. Taking it to the vet and having it humanely euthanised is the least awful of all the options.
This.
Thelnebriati · 16/01/2022 12:38

Have her PTS, don't risk her ending up as a junkyard dog.
I wish euthanasia hadn't been so demonised. Sometimes its not the ideal outcome, but the most realistic.

CaMePlaitPas · 16/01/2022 12:38

I'm so sorry you're in this position OP.

As you say, you've tried everything and been responsible but this dog can't be trained.

I'd pts and say goodbye. She has the potential to hurt and kill, rehoming will stress her out. Don't have that on your conscience.

GrandmasCat · 16/01/2022 12:38

@zoomies2021

Sounds like she can't stay with you. But also that you are just at the beginning of looking into your other options - find specialists who can help you look at what else is possible. Research the right shelter etc with as much commitment as you have put into trying to solve it so you can keep her. And once you have found the right people put your trust in them and follow their advice.
She is not at the beginning… she has been to many trainers around the country including Doberman specialist ones who have told her this dog’s aggressiveness cannot be reigned.
SchadenfreudePersonified · 16/01/2022 12:38

BalladOfBarryAndFreda

Sorry - I didn't read down and hadn't realised that you'd effectively advised the same as me.

Couchbettato · 16/01/2022 12:37

I know it's hard to hear but if she's had so much intervention and you've been politely told by professionals she's always going to be unpredictably temperamental, she's not likely to change.

Whilst some kennels do try to re-home and rehabilitate, they've only got finite resources.

You've got to consider her quality of life.

Living in a constant state of fear is no life at all. And love sometimes means making hard choices for our pets to protect them. Even if that means PTS while they're still "healthy".

It's better a week too early than a day too late, and all that.

I know you said you don't think you could do it, but if you rehome her, and she bites someone, you've just passed the buck on to someone else. Someone who won't love her like you do, and won't bring her any comfort.

But ultimately you can't shield her from every one and every thing forever.

She sounds really unstable, and in a world where we don't understand the whys the how's the what's and the where's of a dog's psyche then the kindest thing to do is to PTS imo.