Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are WE being unreasonable?

337 replies

Vindicated2021 · 16/01/2022 09:34

Scattering FILs ashes today.

There will be MIL, me, DH and 2 DDs.
SIL, BIL, DD21, DS17, DD13.

Just getting ready to leave and SIL texts to say "Oh just to let you know DD21 is bringing along a friend for support"

I feel its inappropriate but my DH has hit the roof. No one knows this girl apart from DD21. SIL and BIL have only met her a handful of times.

DH (and I) believe it should be a private family affair without some random girl there who never knew FIL. He said it would feel "awkward". He messaged back saying very politely that he wouldn't feel comfortable and that the whole family would be there to offer cuddles and tissues.

SIL has text back saying "How dare he dictate to her how her family should grieve and that whether he likes it or not she's coming and he needs to get over it as it's not all about him" (she is known to make and like a drama).

We are now heading to what should be a lovely family time of memories and reflection, and DH is raging and I know there is going to be a horrible atmosphere.

Are we being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 16:46

@MintJulia

I can't see the issue. As long as the friend is respectful, I don't understand why it is a problem. DD21 is an adult, she is old enough to know who she wants by her side.

Yabu and a bit controlling IMO.

It's up to MIL who attends

Not any of those invited to bring extras

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 16/01/2022 16:46

@Vindicated2021

Well...here's a development and a half......!

I text SIL just to ask how she was doing and she replied, "yes I'm OK. Just having a drink to Dad. Still can't get over mum not wanting the grandkids to be there though. There was no way in hell my kids would miss saying their final goodbyes to their Grandad!"

I sent a diplomatically reply back, but this was the first I had heard about no grandchildren!!!

Perhaps MIL confided this to her daughter that she'd rather the kids weren't there and she talked her out of it? If that was the case why would you know about it?
blyn · 16/01/2022 16:44

The friend may be more than a friend.

MintJulia · 16/01/2022 16:36

I can't see the issue. As long as the friend is respectful, I don't understand why it is a problem. DD21 is an adult, she is old enough to know who she wants by her side.

Yabu and a bit controlling IMO.

1forAll74 · 16/01/2022 16:31

I would not see it as awful,or a problem, if an extra person attended a scattering of ashes occasion.

Nanny0gg · 16/01/2022 16:14

@Vindicated2021

It really was beautiful. Never realised how heavy ashes are (if that makes sense?!) He was always watching his weight when he was alive so a couple of jokes were made. Was absolutely perfect and the sun was shining 😌
Yes, it's really surprising isn't it?

I'm glad it was such a lovely day. It made all the difference when we did this for our friend.

WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 16:12

@Vindicated2021

Well...here's a development and a half......!

I text SIL just to ask how she was doing and she replied, "yes I'm OK. Just having a drink to Dad. Still can't get over mum not wanting the grandkids to be there though. There was no way in hell my kids would miss saying their final goodbyes to their Grandad!"

I sent a diplomatically reply back, but this was the first I had heard about no grandchildren!!!

Sounds like it wasn't their decision not to bring the friend in the end then, more forced on them.

Good for your MIL

Vindicated2021 · 16/01/2022 16:10

Well...here's a development and a half......!

I text SIL just to ask how she was doing and she replied, "yes I'm OK. Just having a drink to Dad. Still can't get over mum not wanting the grandkids to be there though. There was no way in hell my kids would miss saying their final goodbyes to their Grandad!"

I sent a diplomatically reply back, but this was the first I had heard about no grandchildren!!!

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 16/01/2022 16:04

@PinkWaferBiscuit

That's unfair. There isn't a blanket rule saying that it should or shouldn't be a private family affair. Just because that's your view on it doesn't mean that applies for other people.

Its not just my view though and it's not unfair Confused. It's quite a widely held view that the scattering of someone's ashes is exactly that a personal and private family event.

By unfair I meant it's unfair to make that assumption.

I've scattered ashes of more people than I wish, and some of those occasions have been close family only and others have not.

I don't see why people would assume it is always a family only event unless specified otherwise.
I would assume it was invite only though and it seems the SIL gave her DD permission to invite her friend.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 16/01/2022 16:03

@dizzygirl1

Your DH has you for support, why is DN not allowed anyone for support? I think you're being unreasonable, she's not asking for a massive party, she's bringing a friend for support.
She had her family there for support and surprise surprise she seemed to cope absolutely fine.
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 16/01/2022 16:02

[quote WinnersDinner]@SliceOfCakeCupOfTea

Based on the OP this was also supposed to be a private family event

Hence the reaction and the small guest list[/quote]
Was that known by all involved though? SIL didn't seem to know that it was exclusively for family? I had assumed SIL to be the DH's sister but may be wrong.

dizzygirl1 · 16/01/2022 15:57

Your DH has you for support, why is DN not allowed anyone for support? I think you're being unreasonable, she's not asking for a massive party, she's bringing a friend for support.

Mydogmylife · 16/01/2022 15:57

@ConsiderablyRicherThanYow

A 21 year old woman can, of course, bring a single friend for support to a funeral. It is very unreasonable for another attendee to suggest otherwise and to rage about it.
It's not the funeral though , it's the scattering of the ashes which most people feel is a much more private affair
Vindicated2021 · 16/01/2022 15:55

@StarbucksSmarterSister

No, the friend didn't.

OP posts:
ivykaty44 · 16/01/2022 15:55

It’s not all about the granddaughter and how she needs a random friend to grieve, which upsets the next generation

Not on

Roselilly36 · 16/01/2022 15:53

@Mischance

I do not see a problem at all. Why cause a family row over nothing at all.
This ^
StarbucksSmarterSister · 16/01/2022 15:50

I'm glad it went ok.

Did DN actually attend the funeral and cope without her friend there? If so, I don't understand the need for a friend today. It seems odd to me.

pictish · 16/01/2022 15:32

Good God I would HATE for a random teenager to be brought along to a personal, private moment like that. I’m so glad they came without the pal. Sod having her as an audience, whoever the fuck she is.
Absolutely inappropriate.

OnwardsAndSideways1 · 16/01/2022 15:24

Glad it all worked out for you OP and FIL is in a beautiful place.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 16/01/2022 15:04

Had the deceased's wife actually been told her niece planned to bring a stranger with her? I can't find that in the OP's posts.

If SiL was sending a text just as OP was setting off, perhaps after she got the "please don't, it will upset me" reply she thought "oops, maybe I'd better tell Ma too", and the person who has the most say of all on an occasion such as this simply told her not to?

twominutesmore · 16/01/2022 14:59

I'm glad it all went well op.

FWIW, since it's all sorted, I find it odd that DN needs support from a friend when she is surrounded by family, I find it odd that the friend wants to attend such a private family moment, and I think your SIL should have asked you if the friend could attend, not told you it was happening and then become angry when your DH objected.

It sounds as if common sense prevailed in the end.

Mummyoflittledragon · 16/01/2022 14:53

Grief isn’t a competition
No it isn’t. Yet an adult should be able to understand their wants don’t trump the needs of other family members. I lost a parent whilst I was a child and a 21 yo scattering the ashes of the GP can well do without support of a random for the sake of everyone else.

WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 14:52

@WeAllHaveWings

His feelings trump the niece Losing a parent is far worse than a GP

Grief isn't a competition, I know full well what losing a parent is like as I have lost both of mine, one during covid lockdown in horrendous circumstances I would not wish on anyone.

I could grieve that loss with a maturity my niece doesn't have, I can feel compassion and be concerned about my for niece grieving a very much loved grandmother too, and I would not have hit the roof when she wanted something simple that would help her such as support from a friend. The OP has asked for opinions and I have shared mine, people have different opinions, I don't see why you think I have to justify that opinion to you.

When your nieces request will impact someone else's grief they have a say

DN doesn't get to ruin it for others, she is one person, her decision impacted multiple other people.

It would have been better for her not to attend than attend with someone who would ruin others experience.

I'm glad they didn't have the gaul to bring them in the end and the OP and the family could grieve in private

Darbs76 · 16/01/2022 14:51

I wouldn’t allow my children to bring friends along to something like that no. So no you’re not BU

TatianaBis · 16/01/2022 14:50

@EmmaGrundyForPM

this happened with my Dad. His ashes were interred and my Mum asked the minister who had conducted the funeral service, and who'd been a friend of my Dad's, to come along and read a particular psalm and say a prayer. She made it clear it was just going to be her, me and my sister there.

He turned up with his wife. My mum knew her but they weren't friends as such. After he had said the psalm and prayer, Mum, sister and I all said a few words but it felt really odd saying them in front of a stranger. The ministers wife then announced she was going to read a poem, and read out some Godawful verses that my.dad would have hated.

My Mum was too polite to say anything, it was horrible though.

Given that it is too late to do anything I think you'll just have to get through it as best you can.

How bizarre, I would have stopped her mid poem and said my dad had good taste in literature and this was crap.