Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are WE being unreasonable?

337 replies

Vindicated2021 · 16/01/2022 09:34

Scattering FILs ashes today.

There will be MIL, me, DH and 2 DDs.
SIL, BIL, DD21, DS17, DD13.

Just getting ready to leave and SIL texts to say "Oh just to let you know DD21 is bringing along a friend for support"

I feel its inappropriate but my DH has hit the roof. No one knows this girl apart from DD21. SIL and BIL have only met her a handful of times.

DH (and I) believe it should be a private family affair without some random girl there who never knew FIL. He said it would feel "awkward". He messaged back saying very politely that he wouldn't feel comfortable and that the whole family would be there to offer cuddles and tissues.

SIL has text back saying "How dare he dictate to her how her family should grieve and that whether he likes it or not she's coming and he needs to get over it as it's not all about him" (she is known to make and like a drama).

We are now heading to what should be a lovely family time of memories and reflection, and DH is raging and I know there is going to be a horrible atmosphere.

Are we being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 11:29

@OrangeShark27

You say the DN has her entire family for support but currently her uncle is throwing a tantrum in the car because she felt she needed a friend and her aunt has started a MN thread to moan about the situation. I'm not seeing an awful lot of support

Her grandmother and mother are grieving someone close to them. You will likely be supporting your DH and 2 DC. Her siblings are much younger. She doesn't really have anyone there to support just her. 21 is an odd age I think, it's an age where funerals really become real but death can be very hard to process. I found that by far the hardest age to lose someone. Let her have her support

It's. Not. A. Funeral!!

If she is so uncomfortable she should not attend this private family event for scattering the ashes.

Not make others feel uncomfortable

Scattering of the ashes is typically a private family affair, not like a funeral

OrangeShark27 · 16/01/2022 11:27

You say the DN has her entire family for support but currently her uncle is throwing a tantrum in the car because she felt she needed a friend and her aunt has started a MN thread to moan about the situation. I'm not seeing an awful lot of support

Her grandmother and mother are grieving someone close to them. You will likely be supporting your DH and 2 DC. Her siblings are much younger. She doesn't really have anyone there to support just her. 21 is an odd age I think, it's an age where funerals really become real but death can be very hard to process. I found that by far the hardest age to lose someone. Let her have her support

WonderfulYou · 16/01/2022 11:25

I agree and would feel very awkward having a stranger at something so personal however your DH’s reaction is way over the top and he needs to calm down.

Happyfeet1972 · 16/01/2022 11:25

I think its weird the friend even wants to be there. Scattering a loved ones ashes is one of the most personal and intimate moments I've ever had and isn't something I'd want to be involved in unless I loved and knew the person.
I don't disagree with your DP and think SIL should have told DN that today isn't really about her, it's a final day to say goodbye to FIL by people who loved him. I agree that DP wishes should trump DNs given he has lost a parent not a grandparent (sil obviously has too but the friend isn't there for her). However your MIL is the one that should come first today, and therefore your DP should not make a scene for her sake. I just hope MIL knew about the friend in advance as its pretty awful if she's been told last min that a stranger will witness her scatter her husbands ashes.

Youngstreet · 16/01/2022 11:21

@Toanewstart22 OP may be travelling and doesn't want to talk about it to already upset dh while he is driving.

dapsnotplimsolls · 16/01/2022 11:19

It's a very personal event and I'd feel very uncomfortable with a stranger there. As others have said, it sounds like she wants an escape route. Your DH will just have to bite his lip and focus on supporting his Mum.

Toanewstart22 · 16/01/2022 11:19

I think it’s more “off” to be starting a thread on this as you’re actually heading off the scatter your FIL’s ashes!

Casamadrigal · 16/01/2022 11:18

You are definitely not being U. This is a private family occasion to remember your FIL. It is likely to be extremely emotional and difficult. It is entirely inappropriate that your niece is bringing someone who is a stranger to all of you, who did not know your FIL and whose presence is likely to make everyone feel uncomfortable and possibly inhibited. Your niece has her entire family there for support and has acted selfishly and thoughtlessly.

In particular I feel for your MIL, who deserves to scatter her husband’s ashes with the comfort of her family around her and without some random hanger on standing awkwardly at the edges.

Youngstreet · 16/01/2022 11:17

I think sil is in the wrong.
If my dd wanted to bring a friend she would be told gently but firmly that it wasn't an appropriate situation.
A 21 year old does not need a friend to be there when she has her family unless her dp's are toxic, not the case here.
It's not a funeral and is a very private occassion.

NellieWellietheEllie · 16/01/2022 11:15

I think you're being a bit unreasonable. We had a family death when my nephew was 21. I could tell he hated everything about the whole thing having never had any experience of death before (those of us who were older were at least familiar with the rituals of death, for him I think the whole situation was just unbearable). He had a friend around all the time too, as I think it was the only way he could make it through. I didn't begrudge him and mostly let them do their own thing, while concentrating on other family members who did want family support.

Toanewstart22 · 16/01/2022 11:15

Thoughtless? Yes

But your dh to be “raging” is an over reaction.

CherieBabySpliffUp · 16/01/2022 11:13

YANBU, it sounds like the DN wants an excuse to bail early.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 16/01/2022 11:13

The OPs husband has lost his dad, I don't think it's possible to over react in this situation, he is feeling what he is feeling

Yes

There is something a bit off telling a man whose father has died that he is ‘overreacting’

Santahasjoinedww · 16/01/2022 11:09

So what happens if the bf says he isn't sitting in the car alone? Does he tag along? What if all the dc needed a friend? Sounds like a bus trip in the making. Surely having her dps there was enough support not taking a random person unknown to anyone?! Sounds like an attention seeking madam being pandered to imo.

WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 11:05

@Swonderful

It's a bit weird but you're totally overreacting! There could be lots if reasons she wants a friend there. Maybe she feels uncomfortable with the family for some reason. You're risking ruining an event and your relationships over something very minor.
I'm baffled by these posts

The OPs husband has lost his dad, I don't think it's possible to over react in this situation, he is feeling what he is feeling

Losing a father is a lot worse than losing a grandparent, his feelings should be taken into account far above the neice, who if so uncomfortable could not attend and pay respects privately with her friends at a later date.

Swonderful · 16/01/2022 11:03

It's a bit weird but you're totally overreacting! There could be lots if reasons she wants a friend there. Maybe she feels uncomfortable with the family for some reason. You're risking ruining an event and your relationships over something very minor.

Sandsnake · 16/01/2022 11:02

I don’t think he’s being unreasonable at all. At a personal and emotional event like an ashes scattering, I would imagine that people attending would like to be able to express their grief without a stranger present. The friend bringing comfort to the 21 year old is likely to make others at the event less comfortable, which is unfair.
Also, the timing. Messaging on the morning to say what is happening is unacceptable and seems deliberate on SIL’s part to make it a ‘done deal’. This should have been raised well in advance.

ChessieFL · 16/01/2022 11:00

YANBU. We are scattering MILs ashes later this year and I don’t even feel I should be there and I’ve been married to DH for 8 years! Events like this should be close family only unless all the close family are happy for others to be there, which isn’t the case here.

rainbowstardrops · 16/01/2022 10:58

YANBU. Scattering ashes is hugely personal and the friend didn't even know him!
If it was to the funeral then fine but not scattering ashes.

ClariceQuiff · 16/01/2022 10:54

@phishy

I would be coldly polite to them today and then ignore them from then on.
I wouldn't do this. The guest might be unwelcome, but what's the point of deliberately creating a bad atmosphere? It's not the time or place to take the high ground or 'punish' people.

Be polite to the girl and niece, not 'coldly polite', and don't let this be the gateway to some long-running family feud by ignoring her ever-after.

Lemons1571 · 16/01/2022 10:54

It’s the late notice and lack of opportunity to talk it through that would seal the deal for me. If SIL had phoned up last week and had a chat about it and the reasons why, I’d be ok about it. Landing this on you when you’re just leaving is awful.

Notonthestairs · 16/01/2022 10:54

YANBU.

I hated having to hold it altogether at my mum's funeral let alone at the scattering of ashes.

phishy · 16/01/2022 10:50

I would be coldly polite to them today and then ignore them from then on.

sammylady37 · 16/01/2022 10:50

@Alayalaya

Maybe your niece is gay and it’s her girlfriend. Regardless, I would have told MIL I wasn’t going unless it was family only. Two can play at the game of spoiling it for everyone.
What an awful thing to suggest doing to a bereaved woman on the day she’s scattering her husband’s ashes.
KatherineJaneway · 16/01/2022 10:47

YANBU