Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are WE being unreasonable?

337 replies

Vindicated2021 · 16/01/2022 09:34

Scattering FILs ashes today.

There will be MIL, me, DH and 2 DDs.
SIL, BIL, DD21, DS17, DD13.

Just getting ready to leave and SIL texts to say "Oh just to let you know DD21 is bringing along a friend for support"

I feel its inappropriate but my DH has hit the roof. No one knows this girl apart from DD21. SIL and BIL have only met her a handful of times.

DH (and I) believe it should be a private family affair without some random girl there who never knew FIL. He said it would feel "awkward". He messaged back saying very politely that he wouldn't feel comfortable and that the whole family would be there to offer cuddles and tissues.

SIL has text back saying "How dare he dictate to her how her family should grieve and that whether he likes it or not she's coming and he needs to get over it as it's not all about him" (she is known to make and like a drama).

We are now heading to what should be a lovely family time of memories and reflection, and DH is raging and I know there is going to be a horrible atmosphere.

Are we being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
LuluBlakey1 · 16/01/2022 11:53

I understand your husband being upset.

Very strange that a stranger would want to attend I think. Also strange that they are being driven by the stranger's boyfriend who will, hopefully, remain in the car. Your niece sounds a bit of an attention seeker.

I don't understand why the niece can't be comforted by her parents, siblings and anyway she should be comforting them and her grandma and not just thinking of herself.

SIL sounds a monster- niece has probably learned some of the 'I do what suits me' behaviour from her mother.

Rise above it for the sake of DH's mum today. It will be a tough enough day without a row. No need for much contact anyway.

Everydaydayisaschoolday · 16/01/2022 11:53

This is an interesting post and the vote is very evenly divided.

If the niece wants the company of a friend whilst scattering her GPs ashes it seems fine to me. I'm at a loss to understand why it should be an exclusive event.

If her uncle is the sort to get into a rage over things and create an unpleasant atmosphere at family events and her mother is a known drama queen I can can quite understand why she would want a uninvolved person there as a buffer.

ShinyHappyPoster · 16/01/2022 11:52

YABU although it's a difficult time and emotions are fraught so your UR is understandable. But SIL wasn't asking for permission. She was informing you that her DD's friend was coming. That makes your DH's response a bit odd tbh.
It's easy to redirect grief into petty arguments and disagreements but it won't help anyone. Flowers

SimonedeBeauvoirscat · 16/01/2022 11:52

@ConsiderablyRicherThanYow IT’S NOT A FUNERAL

How many more fucking times

Hiphopopotamus · 16/01/2022 11:51

Mumsnet is bonkers sometimes. The amount of threads I’ve seen with almost unanimous agreement that a persons child/spouse/random friend shouldn’t be allowed to tag along to a girlie lunch or a hen do or something as it ‘spoils the dynamic’. But people are falling over themselves here to explain why a 21 year old should be able to bring along an unknown (to the family) friend to an intensely private family moment.

OP - you are your DH are absolutely not being unreasonable. It’s totally inappropriate.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 16/01/2022 11:51

@ConsiderablyRicherThanYow

A 21 year old woman can, of course, bring a single friend for support to a funeral. It is very unreasonable for another attendee to suggest otherwise and to rage about it.
Why do so many posters seems to think it is a funeral. This is the scattering of the OPs DHs parent not their funeral. The 2 things are very different events.
VillanellesOrangeCoat · 16/01/2022 11:50

Similar situation happened for me when scattering the ashes of a parent. The friend had never met my parent, didn’t attend the funeral, but came to the scattering of the ashes. First time they’d met us. It completely changed the dynamic of the occasion.
You husband has every right to his feelings, and I’m sorry so many posters are minimising his grief and feelings of discomfort having a stranger present at an emotional event. It’s no wonder men are reluctant to talk about their feelings.

CuriousaboutSamphire · 16/01/2022 11:50

@Mischance

I do not see a problem at all. Why cause a family row over nothing at all.
He's grieving his father and feels uncomfortable with the idea of a stranger beig close, watching that grief?

Perfectly normal and there is no need to judge him for it or to suggest he is wrong for feeling that way.

ConsiderablyRicherThanYow · 16/01/2022 11:48

A 21 year old woman can, of course, bring a single friend for support to a funeral. It is very unreasonable for another attendee to suggest otherwise and to rage about it.

BurntO · 16/01/2022 11:48

I’d hate it to OP. A funeral? Fine. But for the ashes I think it is inappropriate realistically what could SIL do though? Her child is grieving too and she probably felt she couldn’t say no

Medievalist · 16/01/2022 11:48

However, I suspect your 21 year old niece is also uncomfortable at the thought of the event planned for today and feels happier having a friend nearby for support.

DN should have been told very firmly that the day is not about her and that, as an adult, she needs to put her own discomfort aside and consider whether the woman who is scattering her DH's ashes would wish the event to be observed by a complete stranger. (Sounds as if DMIL has reluctantly agreed to this in order to keep the peace).

Ash scattering is deeply personal. My dsis and I were the only people involved in scattering our dps' ashes. Family and friends had been to the funerals.

dapsnotplimsolls · 16/01/2022 11:47

[quote OrangeShark27]@WinnersDinner I know it's not a funeral but that doesn't change the fact she will likely need support. I would have found going to the scattering of my grandparents ashes quite scary at that age, and I imagine a likely scenario is she has confided in a friend that she is worried about going and the friend has offered to come to make it easier for her.[/quote]
She's 21. Why would it be 'scary'?

Happyfeet1972 · 16/01/2022 11:43

@OrangeShark27 then she shouldn't go. Surely at 21 she is old enough to understand no matter her own grief, there are people who have lost someone closer than a grandparent and their needs come first.
I lost 2 grandparents at 17-18 and while i went to their funerals wasn't invited to scattering of their ashes. I understood that the wishes of my bereaved grandparent/uncles/aunties and what they needed were above mine.

Having scattered a parents ashes, I think its incredibly weird a stranger would want to go tbh.

AlwaysinaFlap · 16/01/2022 11:40

@ClariceQuiff

It should ultimately be your MIL's decision.
No way should this shit be put on MIL today of all days.
TheOccupier · 16/01/2022 11:39

YANBU - this is inappropriate.

Sounds like the DD takes after her mother in drama-queen tendencies and has found a friend who similarly enjoys drama.

ESGdance · 16/01/2022 11:37

@Vindicated2021

Scattering FILs ashes today.

There will be MIL, me, DH and 2 DDs.
SIL, BIL, DD21, DS17, DD13.

Just getting ready to leave and SIL texts to say "Oh just to let you know DD21 is bringing along a friend for support"

I feel its inappropriate but my DH has hit the roof. No one knows this girl apart from DD21. SIL and BIL have only met her a handful of times.

DH (and I) believe it should be a private family affair without some random girl there who never knew FIL. He said it would feel "awkward". He messaged back saying very politely that he wouldn't feel comfortable and that the whole family would be there to offer cuddles and tissues.

SIL has text back saying "How dare he dictate to her how her family should grieve and that whether he likes it or not she's coming and he needs to get over it as it's not all about him" (she is known to make and like a drama).

We are now heading to what should be a lovely family time of memories and reflection, and DH is raging and I know there is going to be a horrible atmosphere.

Are we being unreasonable here?

I suspect that your DH is raging at his sisters “How dare he…..” tirade after he replied back with a calm and gentle supportive text to his sister expressing his preference.

It seems it’s the SIL blow up rather than the actual friend that is now setting the tone.

I suspect that she uses her anger, dominance and volatility to control everyone around her.

Today don’t step into her rage. Concentrate on MIL, DH, FIL memory and all the DCs.

WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 11:37

[quote OrangeShark27]@WinnersDinner I know it's not a funeral but that doesn't change the fact she will likely need support. I would have found going to the scattering of my grandparents ashes quite scary at that age, and I imagine a likely scenario is she has confided in a friend that she is worried about going and the friend has offered to come to make it easier for her.[/quote]
Then why bring up a funeral?

She has her whole family there for support

And, if she doesn't feel like her family will be her support she should simply not attend

She doesn't have the right to make others uncomfortable because she would be.

She is one person, her not being comfortable alone is one thing, her bringing a random stranger is making multiple people uncomfortable.

Just no

EmpressSuiko · 16/01/2022 11:36

I see it from both sides but I don’t think I could get angry over this, my parents allowed me to bring a friend to my grandmothers funeral, it’s not that family don’t offer support its just some people find it easier to confide in their friends.

Your niece is grieving as well and please don’t forget her friend is going to feel very out of place and awkward but they clearly care about your niece an awful lot.

Personally I’d let it go, it will still be a special family moment for you all

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 16/01/2022 11:36

I'm with your DH.

A stranger will change the dynamic. It's intrusive and thoughtless of your SIL. Is she your DH's sister or the wife of his brother? That's relevant as well, I would think.

Happyfeet1972 · 16/01/2022 11:34

And yes there's a huge difference between a funeral and scattering of ashes. A funeral is a celebration of someone's life and normally attended by lots of people. It's hugely different and so much more intimate, not at all comparable. It's one of the most loving things you can do for a person, to scatter them where they wanted to be, where they were happy, after they've died. I think the friend will regret coming tbh, she'll feel so awkward and out of place.

MananaTomorrow · 16/01/2022 11:34

@OrangeShark27, the DN also has her father there to support her. And her mum. Basically her family around the same way that the OP’s dcs have her and their family around to support them.

The OP’s DH is grieving just as much as the SIL. So by your standards he is just as justified to have a tantrum as his sister. (Not that I believe either fi them are actually having a tantrum. That’s your words there)

The DN is NOT on her own wo support, no more than any other members of the family. She actually has the same support than anyone else.

Which then bears the question: why does she feel the need to have more support than anyone else? She has mum, dada and sing lungs around her right?

OrangeShark27 · 16/01/2022 11:33

@WinnersDinner I know it's not a funeral but that doesn't change the fact she will likely need support. I would have found going to the scattering of my grandparents ashes quite scary at that age, and I imagine a likely scenario is she has confided in a friend that she is worried about going and the friend has offered to come to make it easier for her.

PinkWaferBiscuit · 16/01/2022 11:33

I honestly can't understand why the friend would even agree to attend something so personal. Why would they want to be there it's incredibly inappropriate to go to witness a stranger scatter their loved ones ashes.

I really hope your MIL hasn't had this sprung on her and that she and your husband are able to say goodbye properly without having a stranger standing awkwardly in the corner witnessing their grief.

Stompythedinosaur · 16/01/2022 11:29

Generally best to remember you can't generally dictate the actions of other adults.

TopTabby · 16/01/2022 11:29

I think it's completely inappropriate for her to be there.
I think she'll probably realise that for herself actually & I can imagine she's going to feel pretty awkward.
It'd be a polite greeting & no more from me, it's not really a social occasion.