Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are WE being unreasonable?

337 replies

Vindicated2021 · 16/01/2022 09:34

Scattering FILs ashes today.

There will be MIL, me, DH and 2 DDs.
SIL, BIL, DD21, DS17, DD13.

Just getting ready to leave and SIL texts to say "Oh just to let you know DD21 is bringing along a friend for support"

I feel its inappropriate but my DH has hit the roof. No one knows this girl apart from DD21. SIL and BIL have only met her a handful of times.

DH (and I) believe it should be a private family affair without some random girl there who never knew FIL. He said it would feel "awkward". He messaged back saying very politely that he wouldn't feel comfortable and that the whole family would be there to offer cuddles and tissues.

SIL has text back saying "How dare he dictate to her how her family should grieve and that whether he likes it or not she's coming and he needs to get over it as it's not all about him" (she is known to make and like a drama).

We are now heading to what should be a lovely family time of memories and reflection, and DH is raging and I know there is going to be a horrible atmosphere.

Are we being unreasonable here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/01/2022 19:53

It seems likely that if that had been what the OP had meant, she'd have said so.

ancientgran · 18/01/2022 18:13

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime

I think the dead giveaway about it not being a funeral was the opening sentence of the OP:

"Scattering FILs ashes today."

You can't scatter the ashes at the funeral; they'd be either not cooked yet, or too hot to touch. You collect them some time later.

But sometimes, and I think increasingly, people are having direct cremation and the scattering of the ashes replaces the funeral. I know a few people who have done it like that or that is their plan for how to do it. One reason is it is much cheaper and it is easier to arrange the scattering of ashes at a time to suit everyone e.g. you could do it on a Saturday or Sunday when people are off work but it is hard to arrange a funeral for the weekend.
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/01/2022 18:08

I think the dead giveaway about it not being a funeral was the opening sentence of the OP:

"Scattering FILs ashes today."

You can't scatter the ashes at the funeral; they'd be either not cooked yet, or too hot to touch. You collect them some time later.

boringcreation · 18/01/2022 14:17

@CustardySergeant

It wasn't a funeral boringcreation
Ah ok, missed that very important bit of information! Makes total sense now
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/01/2022 13:52

[quote mugoftea456]@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime Did i miss a very important update on this thread?! Grin It would appear so![/quote]
That the friend's boyfriend was driving her there? It was discussed upthread, including whether he would stay in the car or decide to join in as well. Or whether maybe the friend could also stay in the car and only be available for DN if needed.

That was after the OP told us

Vindicated2021 Sun 16-Jan-22 10:28:53
Definitely not more than a friend. As her friends boyfriend is driving them both to the place.

CailleachGranda · 18/01/2022 13:27

@tolerable

sorry,i think yabu. sil advance warned you.She wasnt seek approval,(and u dont know for sure she does) unless dd21s friend strolls up with a dd21s grandads name tatoo 'd n performs an accordian lament..shes proli gony be feel pretty awkward. pick your fights. not today. x
What the fuck?
CustardySergeant · 18/01/2022 13:21

It wasn't a funeral boringcreation

mugoftea456 · 18/01/2022 13:20

@AskingQuestionsAllTheTime Did i miss a very important update on this thread?! Grin It would appear so!

boringcreation · 18/01/2022 13:17

I think it's so odd that you dictate who can and cannot come to a funeral. Not the OP specifically, I mean in general. Most funerals I've been to I didn't know the person who had died, I was there to sympathise with their family who I did know. When my DGM died, seeing my friends at her funeral really lifted me, not one of them had met her before.
If the strict numbers at the OPs funeral were Covid related then absolutely understand, but in general I would not dare say who could or couldn't come to the funeral of my family member.

Bonheurdupasse · 18/01/2022 13:10

@givethatbabyaname

Glad the day went well OP Flowers

Reading your development, I have a suspicion that your MIL ‘worked’ your SIL. Good for her, but terrible she had to do it. She may have said something about how maybe it’s best not to bring any young people at all if it’s so traumatising for them that they need friends for moral support. SIL makes appreciative remarks but knows her DM is saying “if friend comes, no DGC come”, so tells her niece is actually fine and no she doesn’t really need to bring a friend as SIL will be there. MIL ‘reluctantly’ agrees to SILs DC coming.

Sounds like MIL didn’t tell you your DC couldn't come.

Your SIL’s text is stirring. She wants you to know that your MIL was ready to exclude her DC which would obviously have meant your DC too. She’s hoping you will raise it with MIL, who will say “I really didn’t want that unknown girl there” so that SIL can say “everyone is against me - my DM, my DB. Everyone! Nobody cares about me and my children, I’m just trying to be a good mum, we’re the real victims here!”.

Shoddy behaviour at a time like this. But, sadly very familiar to me.

This is probably what happened OP.
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 18/01/2022 11:18

mugoftea456
I know its irrelevent now because the DN's Friend did not come. but i would suspect she is a little more than a friend and wanted the comfort.

Ooh, a ménage à trois with the friend's boyfriend who was going to bring her in his car!

mugoftea456 · 18/01/2022 09:51

I know its irrelevent now because the DN's Friend did not come. but i would suspect she is a little more than a friend and wanted the comfort.

Odd that you and DH didnt know MIL didnt want GC there.

Sorry for your loss

ancientgran · 18/01/2022 09:41

@Kittysummer

If the SIL thought it would be ok, why did she text you. I have had this in the past. So why ask? Because they know it is wrong.
Or because it is polite to let people know who will be there.
Kittysummer · 18/01/2022 09:38

If the SIL thought it would be ok, why did she text you. I have had this in the past. So why ask? Because they know it is wrong.

ancientgran · 18/01/2022 09:38

@TheOrigRights I would be fine for my adult child to bring a friend for support at such an event. I don't know my adult child's friends, but I'd hardly think he was bringing someone along for a jolly. And I'd like to think that this friend would show the expected dignity and respect.

I feel the same as you.

ancientgran · 18/01/2022 09:36

@RufustheFloralmissingreindeer

who do the kids have

Mum, dad, nanny, siblings, cousins?

At mil funeral all 6 grandchildren sat together….later one of them described it as being in the splash zone at a theme park. The 26 year old started sobbing and then the others followed. It was lovely that they were all together

Not everyone has the same relationships, it doesn't have to be the same for everyone. My brother and sister are very close, I'm a bit of an outsider, I don't know why but it has always been like that and it isn't likely to change now. So they were a support for each other through the years with family funerals.

When my father died when I was a child my mother had my best friend in the family car so I had someone for me and I will always be grateful that she was understanding. It was commented on by aunts/uncles but my mother was making the decisions and that was that.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 18/01/2022 09:05

who do the kids have

Mum, dad, nanny, siblings, cousins?

At mil funeral all 6 grandchildren sat together….later one of them described it as being in the splash zone at a theme park. The 26 year old started sobbing and then the others followed. It was lovely that they were all together

Melm22 · 18/01/2022 08:29

Shoe on the other foot, what about the friend! This won't be the nicest of events to go to, but they want to support their friend, you've got each other, who do the kids have?

Witchcraftandhokum · 18/01/2022 04:38

PinkWaferBiscuit

Witchcraftandhohohokum

I just don't understand why your DH thinks he can have a say over another adult's actions.

I just don't understand why some people come onto a thread and don't bother reading the whole thing, at least read the OPs posts.

What bit do you not think I've read?

BritMommyAbroad · 18/01/2022 01:58

I’m glad the day went well and without incident.
And just for the record, you were absolutely not being unreasonable. It’s completely out of order to invite a random stranger to something so personal.

Mamanyt · 18/01/2022 01:32

This should be entirely MIL's decision. And your DH needs to manage to calm himself. He seems to be the source of the drama, and the horrible atmosphere, in this case. Your SIL is pretty much right, if her DD needs her friend there, it is not your right to judge. Especially if the young lady is well-behaved. If she is not, then rage AFTERWARDS.

ConsiderablyRicherThanYow · 17/01/2022 23:28

@StepAwayFromGoogling

I have to say I'm amazed at people saying this is OK. Scattering of ashes is very personal, likely to involve people getting upset and the opportunity to reminisce about a person everyone there knew and loved. It's not OK for someone to drag a complete random into that. I'd hate a stranger watching me cry and listen to me talk about my Dad while I was saying goodbye to him. I think that's a proper selfish, arsehole move by DN and SIL.
I don't know what funerals people are attending that aren't personal, that don't involve people getting upset or that don't have people reminiscing about the deceased? I believe the pp that say to them it's a very different event. But surely you understand that for some of the rest of us these are almost identical? In a sense the scattering of my dad's ashes was less upsetting for me because more time had passed since his death. Seeing him at the funeral directors was awful, seeing his coffin disappear to be burnt was terrible, scattering his ashes on a sunny day outside was relatively tranquil. We all experience things differently.
AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 17/01/2022 23:17

Isn't the real point that if you want to turn up with some random the family has never met before, at what many people regard as a very personal and private occasion, youask the rest of the family whether that is ok, rather than telling them at the last minute that you are doing it?

TheOrigRights · 17/01/2022 22:37

@StepAwayFromGoogling

I have to say I'm amazed at people saying this is OK. Scattering of ashes is very personal, likely to involve people getting upset and the opportunity to reminisce about a person everyone there knew and loved. It's not OK for someone to drag a complete random into that. I'd hate a stranger watching me cry and listen to me talk about my Dad while I was saying goodbye to him. I think that's a proper selfish, arsehole move by DN and SIL.
And you opinion shows just how different people are, and why it's important to ask.

I would be fine for my adult child to bring a friend for support at such an event. I don't know my adult child's friends, but I'd hardly think he was bringing someone along for a jolly. And I'd like to think that this friend would show the expected dignity and respect.

StepAwayFromGoogling · 17/01/2022 22:02

I have to say I'm amazed at people saying this is OK. Scattering of ashes is very personal, likely to involve people getting upset and the opportunity to reminisce about a person everyone there knew and loved. It's not OK for someone to drag a complete random into that. I'd hate a stranger watching me cry and listen to me talk about my Dad while I was saying goodbye to him. I think that's a proper selfish, arsehole move by DN and SIL.