Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to conclude that it is not a crime to be a "Champagne Socialist"

207 replies

Rosaxpxp · 16/01/2022 08:59

I hear this term getting bandied around as an insult. Surely it is better to be an affluent socialist than a well off Tory!?

OP posts:
BrambleRoses · 16/01/2022 09:33

Champagne socialism itself perhaps is not so much a problem if we are merely talking about someone who happens to be wealthy believing that wealth should be more evenly distributed.

However, that belief almost unfailingly comes with a pious and often unrealistic outlook which lectures and hectors, which gives handouts and bestows charity on others, rather than working for better conditions for working people. I think that socialism on its own was not really the core movement of the Labour Party and it is a pity this has been forgotten.

WrigglyDonCat · 16/01/2022 09:33

No more or less of an insult than assuming that somehow a socialist is automatically a better person than a conservative (small s and small c).

A bigoted arse is a bigoted arse, regardless of their political persuasion, gender, race, religion or any other characteristic. Judge people on their actions.

Deliaskis · 16/01/2022 09:33

Agree with @psychomath .... it's not a criticism of a status of wealthy+left, it's a criticism of a behaviour.

psychomath · 16/01/2022 09:32

X-post. Can you give an example of where you've heard it used in that way?

psychomath · 16/01/2022 09:30

To me the term means more than just being affluent and also left leaning. It implies some kind of hypocrisy and/or someone who puts theur own need to be at the centre of 'class war' drama ahead of things that would actually help people who are struggling. Like going on about anti-capitalism while owning loads of expensive designer handbags, or signalling socialist values by going to rallies for (just as an example) solidarity with Palestine while ignoring pressing issues that affect working class people in their own community. It may be that they ignore the issues that aren't as trendy, or maybe they conflict with some of the champagne socialist's own values, and so get conveniently swept under the rug because it doesn't fit their overly simplistic world view. There's more to it than simply being middle class and leafleting for Labour, for example.

Rosaxpxp · 16/01/2022 09:23

@Deliaskis

Well..... when I've heard the term, it hasn't been used to describe just socialists who are affluent, but those where there is an element of blindness to the reality of other people's circumstances, e.g. loudly decrying anybody who chooses private education for their children, but failing to acknowledge that the state system works a lot better for people who live in affluent areas with access to excellent schools and children smart and resilient enough to cope with what might get thrown at them.

I don't think it's merely affluent socialists that are called champagne socialists, it's just the hypocritical ones.

A lot of people I have heard using the term "Champagne Socialist" seem to be coming from the angle that you have got no right to be a socialist if you are wealthy.
OP posts:
Deliaskis · 16/01/2022 09:17

Well..... when I've heard the term, it hasn't been used to describe just socialists who are affluent, but those where there is an element of blindness to the reality of other people's circumstances, e.g. loudly decrying anybody who chooses private education for their children, but failing to acknowledge that the state system works a lot better for people who live in affluent areas with access to excellent schools and children smart and resilient enough to cope with what might get thrown at them.

I don't think it's merely affluent socialists that are called champagne socialists, it's just the hypocritical ones.