Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to conclude that it is not a crime to be a "Champagne Socialist"

207 replies

Rosaxpxp · 16/01/2022 08:59

I hear this term getting bandied around as an insult. Surely it is better to be an affluent socialist than a well off Tory!?

OP posts:
CountryGirl17 · 16/01/2022 21:07

@Frazzled2207

Agree I’d associate it with being a hypocrite and out of touch.

I wouldn’t call myself a hypocrite but I am a living example of someone personally financially comfortable and yet a socialist in many ways.

Hi! I don’t knit you so I’m not going to say anything with the aim of insulting you.

My trouble with socialists are that they want a society to be equal and fair, but life isn’t as easy at that. Those with affluence or who are a little wealthy that practise socialism often are in it for themselves. There’s often an element of greed or a attitude to make those who are more capitalist inferior (usually out of greed to impose higher taxes for self-gain). There’s a difference between a well paid public servant who works 9-5 and a well paid business owner who pays the taxes in which benefits the former. When wealth is on the back of tax payers, is the easier route to success as tax is law and require no work. It’s hypocritical to judge those who work hard, as let’s face it, running a business is hard and rewards are well deserved.

MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2022 20:55

But I would never make the mistake of equating socialism with feminism.

I'd agree with I would never make the mistake of equating socialism in practice with feminism. But I think you can't have true socialism without women's rights. But Labour isn't currently socialist. Or feminist for that matter. Right on is the best I'd say. Which is a shame because they had my vote for decades. Sad

inesme · 16/01/2022 20:54

The term to me can be linked to the term 'virtue signalling' As in the true socialist would understand the impact of a 'champagne' (or luxury) lifestyle whereas a champagne socialist still partakes in activities that enable inequality.

Likewise someone who is virtuous does good deeds for good reasons where as a virtue signaller makes it look as if they are doing good deeds to solicit praise, much like the champagne socialist.

thepeopleversuswork · 16/01/2022 20:51

@MrsTerryPratchett

The problem isn't the presence of champagne socialists, it's the absence of beer socialists.

In the media, politics, everywhere. All proclaiming their socialist roots while speaking mockney and pretending to actually care about poverty reduction and equitable treatment.

Just like they pretend to care about women, disabled people, immigrants. Never had a female leader though. The Tories have managed that. More than once.

I totally agree with you on the "beer socialists" point.

But I would never make the mistake of equating socialism with feminism. You'd think logically they would go hand in hand but in fact the Labour party is certainly less supportive of women's rights now and has been for most of its history. It's historically been mainly a working mans rights party.

I don't particularly hold Thatcher or May up as shining examples of feminism in action but, whatever you think of the Tories, they have at least allowed them to happen.

Frazzled2207 · 16/01/2022 20:44

Agree I’d associate it with being a hypocrite and out of touch.

I wouldn’t call myself a hypocrite but I am a living example of someone personally financially comfortable and yet a socialist in many ways.

Fr0thandBubble · 16/01/2022 20:42

@Ionlydomassiveones

Yes I work with the dickheads. Full of angst about the plight of various disadvantaged groups but they would actually be horrified and disgusted if their offspring had to go to school with working class children. They socialise and hire only people like them (white, privileged, well spoken) and live in wealthy, leafy bubbles where the effects of ordinary life don’t affect them. Then they don’t understand why people vote differently to them but they’re so fucking arrogant that it’s clearly other people who are thick and don’t have a grasp of the issues!
This exactly. I have friends who say how awful it is that some people might be against unlimited low-skill immigration, when it's not their (professional) jobs that are being threatened (and indeed they get to benefit from having a cheaper cleaner, nanny, builder, etc.), not their children in a class of 30 where the majority speak English as a second language (because their children are in a private school), not them who are on a year-long NHS waiting list (because they have private healthcare), and so on.
MrsTerryPratchett · 16/01/2022 20:39

The problem isn't the presence of champagne socialists, it's the absence of beer socialists.

In the media, politics, everywhere. All proclaiming their socialist roots while speaking mockney and pretending to actually care about poverty reduction and equitable treatment.

Just like they pretend to care about women, disabled people, immigrants. Never had a female leader though. The Tories have managed that. More than once.

CatsArePeople · 16/01/2022 20:25

There is nothing wrong with being affluent or successful AND to be on the side of working class. But the case with those types is, that they're not. Forcing luxury beliefs on others and patting themselves on the back for "progress". (think electric cars for example)

thepeopleversuswork · 16/01/2022 20:03

@2KidsAndNotCounting

Trust me, I get it. I was mercilessly teased as a teenager because I was at a private school by peers who were at the good comprehensive, told my parents were Tories and capitalists etc. I discovered later most of their parents were far wealthier than mine. To this day I can smell that sort of self-justification a mile off.

I have no problem with people having money and spending that money as they see fit. I do object to people with a lot of money and a lot of social capital dictating to people with less of both how they should vote/educate their kids/pay tax/live their lives, when they know they will never face the sorts of dilemmas poorer people will have.

2KidsAndNotCounting · 16/01/2022 19:48

@thepeopleversuswork

well- the example of a champagne socialist I can immediately thought of is my DS1's godmother who told us that our values were wrong and we were tory shills because we put our SEN, autistic and cognitively challenged DS into a private school. Then sold her house to buy another in a better catchment area for a better state school. Quite frankly I consider that we were more fucking honest about it.

This is exactly what I consider core champagne socialist behaviour. Self-interested self-benefiting behaviour which is passed off under a socialist fig leaf while allowing you to have a go at people who try to improve their lives in a more obviously visible way.

I grew up surrounded by wealthy people who had moved within the catchment area of one of the UK's best comprehensives and then loudly congratulated themselves for being socialists while simultaneously describing people who went to private schools as "Tories".

Thank you for saying that. The situation with our former friend was really really hurtful and to be told we were morally bankrupt because of the above is still something that 6 years later really upsets me.
thepeopleversuswork · 16/01/2022 19:40

well- the example of a champagne socialist I can immediately thought of is my DS1's godmother who told us that our values were wrong and we were tory shills because we put our SEN, autistic and cognitively challenged DS into a private school. Then sold her house to buy another in a better catchment area for a better state school. Quite frankly I consider that we were more fucking honest about it.

This is exactly what I consider core champagne socialist behaviour. Self-interested self-benefiting behaviour which is passed off under a socialist fig leaf while allowing you to have a go at people who try to improve their lives in a more obviously visible way.

I grew up surrounded by wealthy people who had moved within the catchment area of one of the UK's best comprehensives and then loudly congratulated themselves for being socialists while simultaneously describing people who went to private schools as "Tories".

Croissantly · 16/01/2022 19:34

[quote Tealightsandd]I wonder if Gary Neville uses any tax avoidance schemes? Legal, but not very socialist...

I don't know how he votes but I'd say someone like moneysavingexpert's Martin Lewis is a good example of someone who is wealthy but is genuinely concerned about helping those less fortunate - and is willing to spend his own money doing it.

www.getsurrey.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/martin-lewis-gives-100000-money-22747513[/quote]
Hmmm I mean he makes money from his money saving tips- he isn't doing it for nothing or just to be nice, and he could have helped people without broadcasting it. Not saying he doesn't care or that it isn't admirable, but similarly he benefits from caring about poor people (if that makes sense), and has built a lucrative career around it.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 19:32

It's not about criticising the wealthy. It's about criticizing the ones who are hypocrites.

2KidsAndNotCounting · 16/01/2022 19:23

well- the example of a champagne socialist I can immediately thought of is my DS1's godmother who told us that our values were wrong and we were tory shills because we put our SEN, autistic and cognitively challenged DS into a private school. Then sold her house to buy another in a better catchment area for a better state school. Quite frankly I consider that we were more fucking honest about it.

She also attacked us because when my mother died I bought a small cottage which I let out- when she herself is a fucking landlord- also through an inheritance. It truly defies common fucking sense.

It's the smugness. The idea that you are a more moral person and better than others because you are so far up your own arse you cannot even see your own hypocrisy.

Mayorquimby2 · 16/01/2022 19:10

[quote Tealightsandd]I wonder if Gary Neville uses any tax avoidance schemes? Legal, but not very socialist...

I don't know how he votes but I'd say someone like moneysavingexpert's Martin Lewis is a good example of someone who is wealthy but is genuinely concerned about helping those less fortunate - and is willing to spend his own money doing it.

www.getsurrey.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/martin-lewis-gives-100000-money-22747513[/quote]
I think G Neville is the exact demographic that the Tory's will eventually try to rebrand themselves as and target.

The classic "socially liberal, fiscally conservative" type capitalist.

He was quick enough to rail against lockdown measures when it hurt his hospitality empire.
I'm a huge fan of his btw, but he's clearly not immune from she criticism.
Ultimately I don't think that's a silver bullet to show him as a hypocrite and discount his opinions. He's part of society and he's operating within a system that he didn't design.

Wrt the champagne socialist Russel Brand summed up his experience (before he went completely off his axis) that when he was poor and criticizing the rich they said he was jealous and when he was successful and criticizing them they called him a hypocrite.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 19:03

I wonder if Gary Neville uses any tax avoidance schemes? Legal, but not very socialist...

I don't know how he votes but I'd say someone like moneysavingexpert's Martin Lewis is a good example of someone who is wealthy but is genuinely concerned about helping those less fortunate - and is willing to spend his own money doing it.

www.getsurrey.co.uk/news/uk-world-news/martin-lewis-gives-100000-money-22747513

thepeopleversuswork · 16/01/2022 18:58

@mustlovegin

I don't think it's merely affluent socialists that are called champagne socialists

By definition you cannot be socialist and 'affluent'. Affluent implies you are in possession of way more than you 'need'. Hence, you should give it up to those who are more deprived, no longer remaining 'affluent' in the process.

I think that's a bit simplistic. Socialism doesn't literally mean you are expected to give away all your non-essential income to the next poor person you see.

It's a theory which advocates that the means of production and distribution should be owned by "the people", as opposed to just being in the hands of the owners of capital.

In theory this should mean that everyone's income and assets roughly even out. In practice everyone knows it doesn't work like that. Socialists tend to espouse giving to poorer people and they generally support redistributive policies but you can't say that having money automatically disqualifies you from being a socialist.

A lot of socialists throughout history have come from very affluent backgrounds. Look at Karl Marx, the granddaddy of socialists, just for starters.

I think a lot of the reason why the term "Champagne Socialist" was coined in the first place was because it was striking that there were a lot of wealthy people who advocated for socialism.

At the time socialism was born it was quite difficult for someone from poverty to have any real influence over political theory because poor people were often illiterate and often couldn't vote. So its hardly surprising that as a political movement socialism was driven by an educated and therefore relatively affluent class. I think one of the greatest contradictions of socialism is that its often a political choice of fairly wealthy people and I think that's one reason why it has struggled to take off in Britain. But that doesn't mean that wealthy people cannot be socialists.

CountryGirl17 · 16/01/2022 18:55

Socialist spend other people’s money. So, essentially that champagne has been paid for by the taxpayer. The Tory voter, usually private sector workers are those that work to build an economy that collects tax revenues for the public sector to spend on things society benefits from…and pays for the champagne too.

StoneofDestiny · 16/01/2022 18:49

Not heard the term Champagne Socialist for a while.Those who are insulated by wealth, opportunity & privilege yet espouse dogma & proletarian leanings beyond what the majority of people who have to work with no safety net (other than the welfare state) considered reasonable. Then have the gall to look down, patronise or insult those who do what they can with what they have got, & make political decisions accordingly

Take out 'proletarian leanings' and you've described every Tory I've ever heard speak.

mustlovegin · 16/01/2022 18:42

I don't think it's merely affluent socialists that are called champagne socialists

By definition you cannot be socialist and 'affluent'. Affluent implies you are in possession of way more than you 'need'. Hence, you should give it up to those who are more deprived, no longer remaining 'affluent' in the process.

RoseAndRose · 16/01/2022 18:37

I don't think it's merely affluent socialists that are called champagne socialists, it's just the hypocritical ones

Strongly agree with this

CaptaNoctem · 16/01/2022 18:33

@Iggly

People who are socialist and use private schools do want that for everyone ffs

Ah like Diane Abbott you mean. Selective schooling is "indefensible" but she sent her own son to a private selective school with fees (currently) in the region of £20K a year.

Way out of reach of most people.

mustlovegin · 16/01/2022 18:24

If you are an affluent socialist you are in all likelihood hypocritical and cynical. How can you not be?

There's no contradiction involved in being a well off Tory

HTH OP

sst1234 · 16/01/2022 18:21

@the80sweregreat

Why can't someone with money be a socialist ? What I liked about Gary Neville was his honesty! Yeah, I'm rich but I care too, It was enlightening to be honest.
He’s either an opportunist or as thick as mince if he thinks that is the meaning of champagne socialism. Being thick as mince also means he will fit right into the current cohort of Labour Party. Gary Neville is a prime example of someone who benefitted from a free market industry.
5128gap · 16/01/2022 18:15

Tbh I actually admire them. I'm of a background and income bracket where socialism is in my best interests, so my ethics have never been tested. To vote for something that brings you less benefit because you feel its the right thing is laudable in my view.