Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to conclude that it is not a crime to be a "Champagne Socialist"

207 replies

Rosaxpxp · 16/01/2022 08:59

I hear this term getting bandied around as an insult. Surely it is better to be an affluent socialist than a well off Tory!?

OP posts:
TeacupDrama · 17/01/2022 07:27

Champagne socialists are hypocrites they campaign against inheritance tax thresholds rising but do everything they can to minimise their own inheritance tax bill by setting up trusts etc the miliband brothers and Tony Benn did this, , they mock the perceived values of the poor,or they campaign for actions that see the poor penalised the most, blocking the tube by extinction rebellion so poor people can't get to work or arrive late asand as on zero hour contracts or paid by the hour they get paid even less due to actions of ER, but ER activists can get a taxi home. Or they exploit workers themselves "Polish plumbers work so much harder and cost less failing to realise that the only way the polish plumber gets business is by undercutting not that he wants to work for less, but working for less is better than having no money, but they don't want their kids at same school as polish plumbers kids with the TA concentrating on those that have English as second language, or they think diversity is being with people with same views as themselves but with different coloured skin or sexualties but not people with different political religious viewpoints. It is a failure to see that the policies they advocate have the most detrimental effect on the poorest, adding green taxes to energy or fast food etc

Pazuzu · 17/01/2022 07:27

It's the kind of person who sends their kids to private school whilst hating selective schooling.

The kind of person who wants to abolish the Lords then accepts the honour.

The kind of person who screams about taxing everything else but takes full advantage of any loophole possible. (e.g. Flipping your main residence whilst an MP or stamp duty avoidance a la former Labour PM's)

Or former working class area MPs who rarely visit the area then piss off to become the director of a large London museum.

The kind of person who is happy to spend other peoples money on what they believe to be what the poor people want whilst making bloody sure the path of themselves and thebpoor people never ever cross.

Iggly · 17/01/2022 07:12

They all want free healthcare but put their fingers in their ears when you explain you'll be waiting hours on an ambulance, you'll be expected to labour in a waiting room, and you can go years without seeing a doctor

These things have happened because the Tories have underfunded the nhs. It wasn’t always this way 🧐

triggonomeetry · 17/01/2022 07:06

The worst "champagne socialists" I've met have been colleagues from the US. They're all on six figure incomes.

They all want free healthcare but put their fingers in their ears when you explain you'll be waiting hours on an ambulance, you'll be expected to labour in a waiting room, and you can go years without seeing a doctor.

They all want child benefit, free childcare etc but refuse to understand just how much more they'd be expected to pay in taxes, and that there are no write offs.

They claim to care about minorities but not when it comes to understanding why they might be hesitant to take a new vaccine.

They're 1000% on the TWAW train with little regard for women's rights.

They're some of the most closed minded people I know to be honest. Like them as people but can't stand their politics. I've never voted tory in my life but they jokingly/ affectionately say I'd be a trumpster in America Grin me who grew up on a council estate and know more than a thing or two about poverty.

Iggly · 17/01/2022 06:50

Newsflash. Without business and private wealth, the public sector would cease to exist. You can bring as much emotion into it to make your political point but the basic laws of economy don’t change

Newsflash, the private sector wouldn’t exist without the public sector. We wouldn’t have regulations, we wouldn’t have education in its current form, no roads, rail or public transport.

If you think the private sector as it is today would exist without the public sector, you’d be wrong.

One is not better than the other. They are both needed IMO.

The balance has tipped too far towards valuing a very rich minority at the expense of 99% of the population.

LakieLady · 17/01/2022 06:32

@StoneofDestiny

Nothing wrong with being a Socialist and having the money to drink champagne. Surely you don't have to be poor to be a Socialist? If you have worked your way to enjoying a good standard of living and still retain a good moral conscience and sense of social responsibility - great.
"Nothing's too good for the working classes", as my dear old dad used to say when he opened a bottle of Veuve Clicquot every Christmas. Grin
sst1234 · 17/01/2022 00:16

@Iggly

So, if you’re a socialist, what should you do exactly when living in a capitalist society?

Giving your money away won’t change things and make it socialist….

Also what is this nonsense about thinking that business is somehow better? Capitalism ultimately is about exploiting other people for excess personal financial gain. The likes of Jeff Bezos are the extreme end of that. But that’s where capitalism takes you.

Newsflash. Without business and private wealth, the public sector would cease to exist. You can bring as much emotion into it to make your political point but the basic laws of economy don’t change.
Ionlydomassiveones · 17/01/2022 00:07

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

mustlovegin · 16/01/2022 23:19

There is nothing wrong with being affluent or successful AND to be on the side of working class

How can one be on a side that is not your side?

Anyone who believes this narrative is beyond gullible TBH

CountryGirl17 · 16/01/2022 22:33

@StoneofDestiny

Socialist spend other people’s money. So, essentially that champagne has been paid for by the taxpayer. The Tory voter, usually private sector workers are those that work to build an economy that collects tax revenues for the public sector to spend on things society benefits from…and pays for the champagne too

So the public sector workers are the bottom of the heap in your analysis - the very ones that keep us safe daily and we depended on more than ever during the lockdown. The ones that couldn't work from home and stay safe in the pandemic - the nurses, paramedics, hospital staff, teachers, police officers, prison officers. I think they work hard enough (though not paid enough) to buy and drink their own champagne and pay their taxes too.

This is the problem with the narrative. It’s not a race to the bottom. At no point did I say the public sector is at the bottom of the run. Though, it’s rather typical to mention those worker’s you’ve mentioned. Trouble with that is that you’re not talking about those in middle to upper management of the civil service that are paid well, 9-5 and demand through policy making more taxation to fund their budgets. So, they expect the private sector to work harder, suffer higher taxes to fund budgets that are unsustainable, where working more efficiently is a solution to needing more money. This won’t happen due to institutionalisation. However, it’s subjective to say those workers you’ve mentioned are underpaid, as farmers work harder and more stressful hours and many are poor…they provide us with food and society cares less.
CatsArePeople · 16/01/2022 22:32

So the public sector workers are the bottom of the heap in your analysis - the very ones that keep us safe daily and we depended on more than ever during the lockdown. The ones that couldn't work from home and stay safe in the pandemic - the nurses, paramedics, hospital staff, teachers, police officers, prison officers. I think they work hard enough (though not paid enough) to buy and drink their own champagne and pay their taxes too.

The problem with "public sector" is not the nurses, teachers, or firefighters. It is the bureaucrats, who do hell knows what and receive very generous pay from the taxpayers.

StoneofDestiny · 16/01/2022 22:07

Socialist spend other people’s money. So, essentially that champagne has been paid for by the taxpayer. The Tory voter, usually private sector workers are those that work to build an economy that collects tax revenues for the public sector to spend on things society benefits from…and pays for the champagne too

So the public sector workers are the bottom of the heap in your analysis - the very ones that keep us safe daily and we depended on more than ever during the lockdown. The ones that couldn't work from home and stay safe in the pandemic - the nurses, paramedics, hospital staff, teachers, police officers, prison officers. I think they work hard enough (though not paid enough) to buy and drink their own champagne and pay their taxes too.

ana1s · 16/01/2022 22:05

I liken champagne socialists to what I call ‘performance socialists.’ An example would be a group of people we know in Primrose Hill who take every opportunity to wax lyrical about the fact that their their DC “just go to the local primary.” They seem to feel this makes them ‘one of the people,’ and rather edgy, but they omit to mention that the school is rammed with celebrities.

Another example would be people we know who have been highly influential in the highest ranks of Labour, yet at home, they employ live-in nannies on less than minimum wage and who have had to leave behind their own children in developing countries!

Realityisreal · 16/01/2022 21:54

I see champagne socialists as people who are quick to judge people and find them lacking, not worthy, not caring etc. but they don't realise their own privileged position isn't shared by everyone.
So telling people to by organic not understanding that one pack of organic chicken could cost an entire weekly food budget for some people.
Not understanding, as proven by posters on this thread, that by sending their children to a private or selective school they remove those often (not always) higher achieving children from the state schools system, less State schools are built because there is 'no demand', the trickle down is then when a school is deemed 'good' house prices rise and the families of those without money are eventually priced out of the areas they grew up in. The champagne socialist would bleat 'they don't have to move, house prices make no difference if you don't sell', not understanding that many people are renting and can't afford the constant rent rises, if this is pointed out then they will then rant about evil landlords when the real reason is their own schooling choices.
I'm not a socialist and don't pass any judgement on anyone's schooling choices but I was brought up on a council estate on the edge of a middle class area and saw this in action.
When the champagne socialists I know talk about us all sharing the wealth and being equal they mean equal at their own, very comfortable level they don't mean they want to share their wealth and we all settle at several levels below their current levels of comfort.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 21:48

Iggly
I think some of the previous posters have given good examples of the hypocrisy.

Slamming people who send their children private but paying over the odds to move to the catchment area of a highly rated state school - pricing out poorer families. Or doing a Blair. Send them to a state school but pay for private tuition.

Also tax avoidance schemes, and the likes of the Lib Dem NIMBYs holding a sign saying "refugees welcome"....but then opposing housing developments in their leafy areas.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 21:39

With inheritance tax, the fairest way is to tax on the wealth and income of the recipient.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 21:37

It's possible to respect and/or like someone whilst holding different political opinions. Also, integrity, principles, and honesty aren't necessarily a left/right issue.

I admire both Churchill and Attlee.

PurpleParrotfish · 16/01/2022 21:30

I was thinking about this because of a related thread the other day.
Our family’s financial circumstances changed dramatically recently because of a bereavement and inheritance. As someone who’s leftwing I might be called a hypocrite for not giving most of the money away rather than keeping it for my own kids’ future. If I did, I could, say, transform the lives of one poor family… but I haven’t.
I would however vote for everyone in the same position as us (and the very wealthy) to pay much higher inheritance tax, land tax, capital gains tax etc. Because then the benefits would be much bigger - potentially a well functioning NHS, investing upfront to support families rather than the state having to pick up the pieces later at 100x the cost, not having loads of rough sleepers on the street in winter, proper support for disabled people etc etc. So I’d vote for that because the rewards in terms of the sort of society I want to live in would be much greater than the personal financial cost.
This may put me in the champagne socialist category.

Iggly · 16/01/2022 21:29

@Tealightsandd

But re champagne socialism, it's the hypocrisy that's the issue.
But what exactly is the hypocrisy?

Take the Conservatives. They don’t live on the minimum wage - despite claiming it’s enough to live on. They don’t give up their family inheritance, despite claiming you just need to work hard to get anywhere. Biggest hypocrites going.

Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 21:28

But re champagne socialism, it's the hypocrisy that's the issue.

Iggly · 16/01/2022 21:28

@toconclude

Not a crime. Just bloody annoying. And the idea that only socialists care about other people is both false and gratuitously insulting
Haven’t seen much evidence of it from the likes of the Conservatives. My experience is that it’s easy to say things like “oh people should just work hard”, but that’s easier said than done.
Tealightsandd · 16/01/2022 21:25

My trouble with socialists are that they want a society to be equal and fair, but life isn’t as easy at that.

It doesn't necessarily have to be equal or fair - but everyone should have enough. The essentials - plus a bit extra for at least some treats, because there's a difference between living and existing and because health is holistic (with mental well-being playing an important role).

This can be achieved whilst still having different levels of wealth within a population.

Tax isn't meant to be about 'punishment'. It's about ensuring we live in a civilised society, where we ensure that everyone including the more disadvantaged and vulnerable is ok.

Tbh though sometimes socialist ideals and self interest coincide. Enough desperate destitute people in a society and it's a potential threat. The welfare state, NHS, and council housing weren't brought in for altruistic reasons alone.

toconclude · 16/01/2022 21:20

Not a crime. Just bloody annoying. And the idea that only socialists care about other people is both false and gratuitously insulting

Iggly · 16/01/2022 21:16

So, if you’re a socialist, what should you do exactly when living in a capitalist society?

Giving your money away won’t change things and make it socialist….

Also what is this nonsense about thinking that business is somehow better? Capitalism ultimately is about exploiting other people for excess personal financial gain. The likes of Jeff Bezos are the extreme end of that. But that’s where capitalism takes you.

Frazzled2207 · 16/01/2022 21:15

@CountryGirl17
I agree with quite a lot of what you say. I don’t however recognise myself in that description.

I do on the whole think it’s probably easier to claim to be a socialist when looking from a position of relative privilege. Doesn’t make it wrong though.