Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to conclude that it is not a crime to be a "Champagne Socialist"

207 replies

Rosaxpxp · 16/01/2022 08:59

I hear this term getting bandied around as an insult. Surely it is better to be an affluent socialist than a well off Tory!?

OP posts:
Iggly · 17/01/2022 12:59

What’s the deal with valuing “wealth” over everything?

Who says that the wealthy are the right people to have all that money? The only ones saying it are those who already have it or are deluded enough to think they may get some of it.

I would value a nurse over a billionaire like Jeff Bezos for example.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/01/2022 12:57

How do public servants create wealth? They don’t, they merely make a contribution by law from income tax.

Not directly perhaps. But businesses would struggle to make money without roads, police, telecommunications, an educated workforce and many other things

StoneofDestiny · 17/01/2022 11:43

Also I don't believe you can be on the side of the poor if you are rich. Unless you want all other rich people to give away their money but retain your own

Nonsense. Many people now living comfortably have come from very humble beginnings - hard manual jobs, low wages, unhealthy hours and crap rented housing on sink estates. They will know exactly what it's like to be poor. You don't forget that in a hurry. Just because things improved in your life doesn't make you a selfish, narrow minded person who values money over people. It's because of their background, many people 'give back' in thanks they have escaped their dim past. Nor do these people suddenly think the Tories represent their views.

JudgeJ · 17/01/2022 11:38

@Adhdpita

Don't think you've seen the word used in the right context. Champagne socialists are massive hypocrites and show a complete lack of awareness to their fortunate backgrounds and circumstances.
It's a very old phrase, certainly it was around in the 70s if not before. I've always taken it to refer to people who can afford to have 'socialist ideals' because they'll never be adversely affected by its outcome. It's what is now referred to as 'virtual signalling', look at what a good person I am, a name that always comes to mind is Linekar, don't know why!
Notcontent · 17/01/2022 11:35

@Deliaskis

Well..... when I've heard the term, it hasn't been used to describe just socialists who are affluent, but those where there is an element of blindness to the reality of other people's circumstances, e.g. loudly decrying anybody who chooses private education for their children, but failing to acknowledge that the state system works a lot better for people who live in affluent areas with access to excellent schools and children smart and resilient enough to cope with what might get thrown at them.

I don't think it's merely affluent socialists that are called champagne socialists, it's just the hypocritical ones.

I think the above is a spot on. I live in a part of North London that is full of such people!! Very nice people often but feeling very smug and superior about their virtuous choices.
TheToddlerLife · 17/01/2022 11:32

@SnackSizeRaisin But the families who don't have money have no choice but to send their children to the bad school. Sending your child to private school is still buying them an advantage over poorer children.
Most under performing schools are that way because they have a large intake of children from deprived backgrounds and all the associated problems that come with that. Sending a child to private school is essentially paying to not have to mix with the riff raff. No one would publicly admit it, and they can dress it up how they like...smaller classes, extra curriculars, yadda yadda, but when you drill right down to it, not having to mix with the working and underclasses is what it comes down to.
That's also why people people pay a premium to live in nice middle class areas when they could get the same house for much less in a working class area.

ColletteTheLot · 17/01/2022 11:31

No, I don't have a spare room - we are comfortable as we don't live beyond our income! We have a house that fits us - smaller than we could have afforded if we'd stretched ourselves with a big mortgage, but a small mortgage seemed a better choice to us. We're not wealthy, we drive a 9 year old car in order to have a nice holiday once a year.

I volunteer around 6 hours a week (and yes I work full time and have children), I donate to 4 small charities on direct debit - about 20% of our income after mortgage / essential bills (ie, council tax, electricity, gas, insurance).

Neither my husband or I are high earners, but as I say, due to choices we have made, we are financially comfortable.

TeacupDrama · 17/01/2022 11:23

a champagne socialist is hypocritical, you can be comfortably off and a socialist vote labour
a comfortably off genuine socialist pays any employee properly and fairly, they pay their taxes, they don't falsely claim to be self employed when they are not; they don't pay themselves just in dividends or share options, they don't set up trusts to avoid inhertance or capital gains tax, if they are landlords they don't evict good paying tenants just because new tenants might pay more, they don't gazump people to get second homes in picturesque villages, they don't pretend that local secondary is good enough for everyone else but their children. They do not say immigration benefits everyone then complain to the school that children with English as a second language take too much of teachers time. They do not think increasing taxes which affect the poor most are the best way of advocating for climate change, they do not try to exclude poor families from local school by agreeing with extravagant uniforms that effectively deny entrance to poorer children
But most importantly real socialists do not sneer at the poor or disparge their views as being thick bigots that need to be told by better educated socialists how to think and that their problems are not real

TheToddlerLife · 17/01/2022 11:21

@ColletteTheLot Well the central principle of socialism is equality, including equal distribution of wealth.
If you're comfortably off (compared to others who are poorer) then how is that being a socialist, unless you're willing to give away a large chunk of your money to the poor.
Everyone pays tax, that doesn't make us all socialists.

RunningInTheWind · 17/01/2022 11:18

@ColletteTheLot you absolutely CAN pay more tax. The government has a dedicated webpage and you can just pop in your details. Well done for following through on what is usually empty blather.

mustlovegin · 17/01/2022 11:09

I'm not aware I can choose to pay more tax? Can I?

Maybe you have a spare room, you can invite someone to live there for free? Surely you have some clothes you don't use every day, you could hand those over? You get the idea...

mustlovegin · 17/01/2022 11:07

I had a very working class up bringing, but basically married into middle class, and live a lower middle class life style now. But I am still socialist through and through, as is my husband. I pay my taxes, would happily pay more to support society

Perhaps you have too much, why don't you give more up in line with you socialist ethos?

ColletteTheLot · 17/01/2022 11:06

Why don't I pay more? I'm not aware I can choose to pay more tax? Can I?

3cats2kids1dog · 17/01/2022 11:05

@DottyHarmer

Quasi-insulting sneery label? I find it’s the “champagne socialists” who largely do the sneering - despising others and claiming to be morally superior when in fact behaving no differently themselves.
i'm not saying they don't.... just that, that's the level political discussions seem to be at... "you're a tory snob" "you're a champagne socialist" "you're a thick brexiteer" "you're lefty europhile" It's all about sneering put-downs and less about trying to understand and respect other people's points of view...
DottyHarmer · 17/01/2022 10:50

Quasi-insulting sneery label? I find it’s the “champagne socialists” who largely do the sneering - despising others and claiming to be morally superior when in fact behaving no differently themselves.

3cats2kids1dog · 17/01/2022 10:38

its just another quasi-insulting sneery label that some people use to denigrate people who are different to them (opinion and circumstances). It phrased just right to get the target's back up while allowing the user a satisfying glow of smug self-righteousness....

CountryGirl17 · 17/01/2022 10:25

@ColletteTheLot

The idea that, for what ever reason, you become more comfortably off, or even rich, you have to change your politics is just utterly ridiculous.

I had a very working class up bringing, but basically married into middle class, and live a lower middle class life style now. But I am still socialist through and through, as is my husband. I pay my taxes, would happily pay more to support society. We both volunteer. But because we have a comfortable life style, I should suddenly be a Tory???

I respect your comment.

If you would happily pay more to support society, why don’t you? What is holding you back?

ColletteTheLot · 17/01/2022 10:21

The idea that, for what ever reason, you become more comfortably off, or even rich, you have to change your politics is just utterly ridiculous.

I had a very working class up bringing, but basically married into middle class, and live a lower middle class life style now. But I am still socialist through and through, as is my husband. I pay my taxes, would happily pay more to support society. We both volunteer. But because we have a comfortable life style, I should suddenly be a Tory???

CountryGirl17 · 17/01/2022 10:16

@SnackSizeRaisin

In respect to phrase Champagne Socialist, it refers to the hypocrisy that exists as these public servants enjoy the wealth created by the tax payer

Not really. Public servants get paid for a job and pay tax on their salary, just like any employee. Anyone can work in the public sector and "enjoy the wealth" e.g. bin.men, dinner ladies, a variety of jobs

How do public servants create wealth? They don’t, they merely make a contribution by law from income tax. The level of taxation generated by public sector works from their in not comparable to the taxes that businesses pay. In reference to wealthy public servants, these are middle to upper management with influence and power to make budget decisions that favour themselves or the lucrative contracts they award their friends or relatives or the kickback they earn from pharmaceutical companies for example.
SnackSizeRaisin · 17/01/2022 10:08

In respect to phrase Champagne Socialist, it refers to the hypocrisy that exists as these public servants enjoy the wealth created by the tax payer

Not really. Public servants get paid for a job and pay tax on their salary, just like any employee. Anyone can work in the public sector and "enjoy the wealth" e.g. bin.men, dinner ladies, a variety of jobs

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/01/2022 10:04

Also it's not always wrong for labour MP's to send their children to private schools. I would think badly of anyone who sacrificed their child's happiness for their principles. There might be some cases where local schools are poor and the child is at risk by attending them. I am thinking of Diane Abbot. As long as the mp in question is campaigning for better schools and voting the right way then that's fine. What's hypocritical is to only send your child to the best state school and pretend all schools are as good. In general I would expect labour MP's to send their children to the local state school

CountryGirl17 · 17/01/2022 10:00

In reference to Public v Private Sector, It’s fair to say that one can’t exist without the other and that’s true. Though, it all comes down to the NOLAN principles of selflessness, integrity, objectivity, accountability, openness, honesty and leadership.

In respect to phrase Champagne Socialist, it refers to the hypocrisy that exists as these public servants enjoy the wealth created by the tax payer and is morally questionable. As a taxpayer, we don’t have a choice as to how much we pay, where that money goes, how it’s spent, the value of that service, the efficiency of civil servants and potential waste of money - we are legally bound too all of this. The only option is tax avoidance and socialists and use avoidance schemes too. That’s where the hypocrisy exists.

It’s different with the private sector, as consumers have the choice to support companies by using or buying their goods. If consumers don’t like the perceived greed or corruption, consumers have the right to use a different supplier. With the public sector, we have no choice, but to accept their behaviour.

So, in the news, if you think parties during the pandemic were only at No.10 (Tories), you’d be mistaken. How many MPs (Labour included) in Parliament used their offices for drinks? How many teachers had gatherings in their staff rooms with wine or beer, how many gatherings were in staff rooms at hospitals, how many council workers had parties in their chambers etc. None of this we know for sure, only I know of few businesses that held socials, against the rules, but businesses don’t abide by the NOLAN principles.

Greed is everywhere.

triggonomeetry · 17/01/2022 09:55

These things have happened because the Tories have underfunded the nhs. It wasn’t always this way

Right, but we voted for that? And we continue to vote for it? Which is my point - if they want ambulances within minutes and yearly doctors check ups, and they don't want to labour in waiting rooms or things like triage where they might be waiting days if others are in need, then they will have to pay for that through taxation - yet they all do whatever they can to make sure their tax bill is shockingly low and appear gobsmacked when I tell them what our tax rates are 🤷🏻‍♀️.

They wouldn't stand for the above (all of which I've experienced personally over the last ten years) but like us, apparently wouldn't be happy to fund it properly either.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/01/2022 09:52

Also I don't believe you can be on the side of the poor if you are rich. Unless you want all other rich people to give away their money but retain your own.

SnackSizeRaisin · 17/01/2022 09:49

There is nothing wrong with being affluent or successful AND to be on the side of working class”

It's not about sides. It's about a fairer society for all. I think a socialist society genuinely would be better for 99% of people. The rich can avoid state schools but only the extremely rich can avoid the NHS, as there isn't sufficient private provision for intensive care. Clean air can't be bought by individuals. And surely no one wants to see beggars in the street and low level crime that results from poverty.
You'd have to be selfish or stupid to think that our current way of doing things works for anyone other than the very rich and selfish. Stupid = believing that all poor people are lazy, or that rich people are inherently more deserving