Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young daughters - Boxing/karate/self-defence classes (for their safety)

86 replies

whatever1980 · 15/01/2022 22:01

Daughters are between 3 and 9. I don't want to scare them but I'm thinking that it is crucial they learn from a young age how to fight back and defend themselves?

I know males should be taught not to attack/kill but hasn't happened so far and I'm not convinced it will (or make a difference).

I also know it's not all men.

I have no self defence skills and it has stopped me doing early morning runs. I was in a wooded park alone a few years ago in the afternoon with my dog and there was a drunk man staggering towards me and (although I'd used the park daily even whilst heavily pregnant) I realised how vulnerable I was as there was no one else there. I sprinted out. I feel like it's my duty as a mother of daughters to equip them with these skills but I don't want to make them fearful of the world either. I wish this was on the curriculum too.

OP posts:
Amelion · 15/01/2022 23:13

@VelvetChairGirl and in any case - don’t most fights end on the ground? So I think grappling is pretty useful if you’re thinking of something that’s likely to have most practical use.

Amelion · 15/01/2022 23:12

@VelvetChairGirl Karate is mostly punches and kicks, not really focussed on throws.

Amelion · 15/01/2022 23:07

I did martial arts as a teen and competed at national level (still do one of them now). Agree with PPs that a good instructor will teach kids to run/shout for help and so on rather than stay and fight. Martial arts should leave you really fit - which helps if you need to run! Because yes, however good you are it’s still difficult to defend yourself against a much bigger opponent.

And I think what’s really important is that martial arts teach you more than a physical skill. They can give you a physical confidence and an assertiveness. In karate you shout (Kiai) when you’re attacking - to score points in sparring and in the set patterns (Kata). You also spar people of different shapes and sizes and male and female (obvs kids should only fight kids but you get what I mean). Being able to shout at someone and show physical presence is really useful. Case in point - a man was following me in the park a few months ago - in broad day light, the joys of being a woman. He was trying to talk to me and I told him to leave me alone but he kept walking behind me. I turned around and literally shouted at him LEAVE ME ALONE! TURN AROUND RIGHT NOW AND GO! And he did. It also got a lot of attention from other people nearby. But I think being used to shouting/being dominant/aggressive in some way has really helped me.

They can also make you more used to being in a fight sort of situation. If you’ve never been in a fight before, having someone physically attack is likely to be quite shocking - if you’ve done martial arts I think you might be a little more able to react - even if that means shout/run etc.

So yeah - I definitely think it’s worth it - not just because you think physical skills/techniques might be useful but because it gives you a certain confidence too.

immersivereader · 15/01/2022 23:04

Also, we need to teach our daughters how to say 'fuck off' more. With meaning.

VelvetChairGirl · 15/01/2022 23:02

I wish there was more martial arts classes out there, I tried looking into it myself but they are all 7pm or later round here.

i feel they are missing a trick by not doing them during the day when mums are at home.

As for boxing/karate etc, I think something like Muay Thai or taekwondo would be best for a girl because its all kicking people, I wouldn't fancy the chances of a woman against a man with things that concentrate on upper body strength, Karate is mainly throws isnt it? ideally you wouldnt want to be that close to them and they need to be in the right position.

nitsandwormsdodger · 15/01/2022 23:02

Girls and women don’t get raped and murdered because they weren’t taught a karate chop
Most were hurt by someone they knew
Random stranger attack v rare
2 kids are killed every week crossing the road ( often on phones air pods in )
Need to teach girls about spotting red flags early on in relationships having lots of self confidence and self worth to walk away from bad situations and not feeling like you have to be polite,
Be aware of “ask for Angela “ scheme in pubs etc etc that would be far more useful in my opinion

immersivereader · 15/01/2022 22:59

Can heartily recommend.

I did jujitsu from ages 11-18 and the main lesson taken from it was a massive amount of self esteem and confidence. Plus incredible fitness and ability to defend yourself.

SareBear87 · 15/01/2022 22:57

I did self defence classes when I was young. At 11 I started developing rather quickly and mum thought it best I learnt a few moves.
I also did kick boxing but that was seen as "uncool" at my school so I stopped.
I was thankful for the self defence lessons when I started going out at 18. It's amazing how you can disarm a blokes wondering hands with just one finger. Thankfully never had to use the more serious moves!

LadyFuschia · 15/01/2022 22:53

If you do want to find a martial art for this reason then jujitsu is one which focussed on overpowering an attacker in self-defence rather than going in on the attack. It doesn’t look as cool as other martial arts as they end up wrestling on the floor but I think the focus on getting an opponent into a position where you’ve disabled them is helpful for girls who can’t rely on size or strength.

AnnaSW1 · 15/01/2022 22:52

I'd recommend Krav maga

LankylegsFromOz · 15/01/2022 22:50

I've spoken about this with my DH about our DD who us 6. We're not sure martial arts would be the most beneficial in these circumstances, what they need is a course where they learn to fight smart and dirty. I don't think there are courses out there like this though

Lesina · 15/01/2022 22:45

Self defence is brilliant. Also teaching them how to monitor situations, be aware of their surroundings and how to run if necessary. I hate that we have to do it but until violence against women is properly dealt with we need to ensure our girls and women have a fighting chance.

Also teach them that biting marks them out as a psychopath.. and people tend to stay clear of them. Sink their teeth in deep and hard. Saved me .

WorraLiberty · 15/01/2022 22:43

@LovelyMoans

I don't know.

Even with great self defense skills a petite girl is still going to be overwhelmed by a big guy.

I'd worry that it would give overconfidence in some situations, make someone think its ok to take a risk because they feel they can look after themselves iyswim. But maybe not, I dont know

All good instructors will drum into their pupils that the very best form of self defence is to run/get yourself straight away from the danger.

They teach that physical self defence is a very last resort.

ElEmEnOhPee · 15/01/2022 22:43

I'd do Krav Maga if it was an option. It's unfortunately not taught in my area.

minipie · 15/01/2022 22:42

I agree with it being a great skill to learn, great exercise and for confidence.

However I wouldn’t ever ever want to give my DDs the impression that some self defence or martial arts classes would mean they could fight off a male attacker.

Pikaso · 15/01/2022 22:38

I would.
Apart from the self defence aspect it’s also great for fitness and confidence building.
Plus, keeps them off Social media for a couple of hours doesn’t it

EmmaH2022 · 15/01/2022 22:36

OP sprinting out was the most sensible thing even if you had self defence skills.

I think you can sign them up for any of these as a discipline but self defence in general when they are teens.

gobbledygoook · 15/01/2022 22:32

The best self defence advice is first - run away if you can, do not try to fight if you can run!

Self defence classes are taught as a specific skill, would you be able to find any of those locally? Your other options are good too, but when I did self defence classes it taught us what to do if grabbed from behind / arms restrained / grabbed from the front etc rather than trained martial arts moves which might be more limiting iyswim?

NotTheGrinchAgain · 15/01/2022 22:32

My dd age 11 does martial arts and self defence.It's great for fitness but due to covid there has been no sparring for 2 years. It is great for stamina, strength and self confidence. Currently she is learning how to disarm someone.

If someone attacks my DD she will make as much noise as humanly possible and strike where it genuinely hurts. (Let's put it like this, I don't let her anyway near my solar plexus.) And then she will run like the wind.

I consider this an absolutely essential part of her upbringing. She isnt over-confident. She knows the big lads in her Class could overpower her. She is aware, and alert.

And my logic is, if I was going to attack someone I might back off if she could do me some damage in exchange.

Freecuthbert · 15/01/2022 22:31

You don't have to send them to karate, kickboxing etc in a way that makes them fearful of the world. It should be presented as just another fun activity which also keeps them fit and healthy! The self-defence aspect is another benefit of it. I think it can instill confidence in young girls too.

Sorry I'm a bit washy on the details, but I remember hearing about a nurse who had some self-defence training and used that to fight off someone her husband had hired as a hit on her! He was armed and she wasn't and she killed him in self defence. It was either him or her and she fought for her life and won.

MrsJBaptiste · 15/01/2022 22:29

Oh God, whatever... 🙄

Embracelife · 15/01/2022 22:29

@LovelyMoans

I don't know.

Even with great self defense skills a petite girl is still going to be overwhelmed by a big guy.

I'd worry that it would give overconfidence in some situations, make someone think its ok to take a risk because they feel they can look after themselves iyswim. But maybe not, I dont know

self defense classes will teach how and when to walk away/ run And how to be aware of surroundings And basics like don't walk around texting on phone But also what to do if in a situation
PinkSyCo · 15/01/2022 22:28

Why can’t you enrol your DD’s in defence classes without making them fearful? I persuaded mine to join without putting the fear of God in them easily enough.

RussianSpy101 · 15/01/2022 22:28

@2ducksandI why not?

RussianSpy101 · 15/01/2022 22:28

Absolutely get them into boxing / martial arts!

Swipe left for the next trending thread