Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young daughters - Boxing/karate/self-defence classes (for their safety)

86 replies

whatever1980 · 15/01/2022 22:01

Daughters are between 3 and 9. I don't want to scare them but I'm thinking that it is crucial they learn from a young age how to fight back and defend themselves?

I know males should be taught not to attack/kill but hasn't happened so far and I'm not convinced it will (or make a difference).

I also know it's not all men.

I have no self defence skills and it has stopped me doing early morning runs. I was in a wooded park alone a few years ago in the afternoon with my dog and there was a drunk man staggering towards me and (although I'd used the park daily even whilst heavily pregnant) I realised how vulnerable I was as there was no one else there. I sprinted out. I feel like it's my duty as a mother of daughters to equip them with these skills but I don't want to make them fearful of the world either. I wish this was on the curriculum too.

OP posts:
FictionalCharacter · 16/01/2022 13:23

@LovelyMoans

I don't know.

Even with great self defense skills a petite girl is still going to be overwhelmed by a big guy.

I'd worry that it would give overconfidence in some situations, make someone think its ok to take a risk because they feel they can look after themselves iyswim. But maybe not, I dont know

The whole point of self defence classes is exactly that - getting the skills to escape from (not necessarily overwhelm) someone stronger. I’ve learnt brilliant techniques to use when e.g. someone puts their hands round your neck. You learn to do something painful enough to shock / disable them severely enough and for long enough for you to get away to safety.

You’re thinking of normal fighting, where a bigger stronger person has an advantage. In self defence you “fight” dirty. You learn to target eyes, nostrils etc and cause real pain, because you’re in a desperate, dangerous situation and this is no time to be nice.

I did self defence classes followed by karate, and I can recommend it. A lot of it is getting over that mental barrier of feeling helpless and the idea that we shouldn’t hurt people. The great thing about the classes, for me, was being paired with a man, so you practise on a man - practising with a woman is not the same at all.

Dogscanteatonions · 16/01/2022 13:09

I'm a high grade in a martial art and an instructor - I can't recommend it enough for children, they learn so much more than self defence. They certainly can learn enough to escape situations and cause injury if necessary regardless of size but will also develop more situational awareness, faster reactions, quicker decision making for example.

I'm pretty small and once my husband crept up on me when I thought I was home alone and I threw him must of the way across the room and very nearly it the window. Another time my partner's friend asked me to take him down as he didn't think I possibly could. He still talks about how he was on the floor in seconds.

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/01/2022 13:03

My 8 and 9 year old do kickboxing - mainly for the mindfulness, confidence and fitness element of it. It's a lot of fun and fitness for them and it really does calm DD1 down as well - the adults running it are absolutely hilarious.

Ours do a family oriented class so you could join in with them.

dafey · 16/01/2022 12:59

Do it for confidence & fitness but not be too confident if that makes sense.

The most important thing is to get away.

And teach them to be streetwise eg look up from their phone, look at surroundings, take a headphone out, put the phone away etc.

EvelynBeatrice · 16/01/2022 12:56

Sorry just read message above mine - almost identical. Another big fan krav

EvelynBeatrice · 16/01/2022 12:55

Krav Maga ideally but any form of physical activity that develops physical confidence is great, especially for wee ones. Later on, Krav Maga for teens is fab. The Krav Maga instructor we used was ex military female and great role model. She made it very clear that the first priority is not getting into the situation in the first place and the second is getting away. Made the girls practice yelling loudly and told them not to walk about disabled by headphones so they couldn't hear what was happening around them etc. Frankly she was worth every penny we paid for the classes.

MaryAndGerryLivingInDerry · 16/01/2022 12:53

My fantastic self defence (Krav Maga) instructor (who obviously recommends women learning self defence) is very clear that the most valuable tool for women being able to defend themselves is the ability to recognise the signs of a potentially dangerous situation and getting out of it before it ever gets to the point of having to physically defend themselves. Walking away from a situation is self defence. If you’re having to use the physical skills he teaches you- you’re already in serious trouble. He teaches assertiveness, self confidence, and we role play those little interactions were a man is doing nothing obviously threatening- things like a man moving past you and putting his hand on your lower back to “gently” move you out of his way- that he wouldn’t do to a man. He asks us all to offer scenarios we’ve been in were nothing happened but we felt threatened and then we’ll work through possible options for how to remove ourselves from that kind of situation. I’ve never had to use my physical self defence skills but the other stuff? I’ve had to use a lot.

PineConeWar · 16/01/2022 12:50

Even with great self defense skills a petite girl is still going to be overwhelmed by a big guy.

I agree with this, but we have also told DD (also 9) that at some point we will enrol her in some form of self defence class and it is non-negotiable. It will probably be boxing. I also take both DC running during the holidays and have explained why it's important to be able to run i.e. fitness and getting out of trouble.

Hyenaormeercat · 16/01/2022 12:47

DD did karate from age 7-20, up to 2nd Dan. It gave her poise and confidence that in itself was a defence. The only thing I would say is that it takes hard work and time. Real life training is not like Cobra Kai!
She did fight off 2 teenage boys at 16 that tried to grab her bag. 2 boys ran past her, Boy 1 grabbed her bag, got dumped on the floor ..boy 2 came back and then tried hitting her, he joined his friend on the floor...she then ran as fast as she could.

Storminamu · 16/01/2022 12:45

Interesting. How dangerous do you think women's boxing is for girls and young women?

Bitbloweyoutthere · 16/01/2022 12:40

When I'm running, I tend to see everyone else as a potential threat, so I'm at least alert. Then I go through my options:
Right in by the road. If I'm attacked, I'll get into the road and hope a car stops.
OK, I'm alone here, but I can see a couple further up.
I could probably knock him off his bike.
I've got enough puff left to run at this point.

I've been lucky though. The most frightened I've been was when 2 lads off bikes cycled too close and too slowly to me. I was worried they'd rob my phone.

Then the lorry that pulled over to my side of the road and waited until I got close before he opened the cabin door and jumped out. I ignored him and carried on running.

I never stop if men try to address me.

Neron · 16/01/2022 08:55

I'm a long time martial artist. Competed in kickboxing and K1, trained in MMA and Thai boxing before switching to Brazilian Jiu-jitsu for the last 7 years.

I'd try to run. If I had to respond, I'd kick the knees and then run. In theory - in the real situation you just don't know.

Most of the youths nowadays use weapons, but I'm still grateful for everything I know.

BraveGoldie · 16/01/2022 08:31

@KO81

I box. I took it up as it the best fucking cardio exercise ever, plus it is immense at building bone density and staving off osteoporosis (another largely female treat). I don’t have a daughter, but if I did I will get her boxing. It is such good exercise, teaches incredible discipline, balance, poise and reaction, plus knowing how to swing a fuck-off right hook never, ever hurts.
You have totally sold me!!!!
massistar · 16/01/2022 08:29

My DD does jujitsu. It's fantastic for fitness, strength and self confidence. She spars mainly with boys. I'm not sure how much good it would do her in a real life situation but I hope some of the reactions would kick in to at least give her a chance of getting away.

Ylvamoon · 16/01/2022 00:22

Nope, martial arts does not teach how to fight... what it does teach if taught properly is how to block a punch or a kick from the front or side. That combined with the surprise element can be enough to get out of a tricky situation. Being able to fight off 5 strong guys is only possible in movies.

They are also taught not to use the active fighting skills outside the training sessions or competitions and even there are strict rules. Because some can be very damaging to the unsuspecing victim which basically is GBH.

Bitbloweyoutthere · 15/01/2022 23:58

Martial arts don't tend to teach what to do if there are a few of them attacking you, either. There's never the level of aggression that you see in proper fights, and I've broken up a good few fights over the years.

TheMoth · 15/01/2022 23:55

Ds has done martial arts from an early age. But he can only do it in a controlled environment. Lay summer, he was getting some physical shit from his mates. The thought of blocking their attacks didn't cross his mind, as it wasn't in the usual room. We live in an area patrolled by large gangs of kids. Many have knives. Some like to herd kids like fucking animals. If he's attacked, he needs to run like fuck.

Dd has no interest in martial arts and I can't make her go. I worry more about ds than dd. She is more at risk when she starts having relationships.

I have no martial arts at all. I am tall and have no qualms about saying no. I run on a path frequented by cyclists, dog walkers and drug dealers. There are generally more cyclists about when I go. I am fully aware that not being attacked is more luck than anything I do or don't do.

Barbarantia · 15/01/2022 23:51

stop peddling that myth. Without training, punching and punching hard does not come naturally.
Girls will be weaker yes. That doesn't mean they should lie down and allow the worst to happen to them. They should at least pluck some hair or gouge an eye and go down fucking swinging. Maybe even stay alert enough to see a break to run for it and have the stamina to keep moving once they've started running. I find any sport can give the confidence, courage and stamina to do that but specifically martial arts targets giving those.

SantaClawsServiette · 15/01/2022 23:23

Also - going out running isn't dangerous in terms of being attacked unless you are in some very extreme setting. You are likely in more danger of getting hit by a car.

SantaClawsServiette · 15/01/2022 23:20

I think these activities can be fun and build confidence, but self-defense skills are really not going to help a woman being attacked by a man in anything but the most unusual situation.

Amelion · 15/01/2022 23:20

@VelvetChairGirl I meant statistically speaking, I don’t know anything about the fights you’ve been in Grin

Barbarantia · 15/01/2022 23:20

Do it with them. It's a great family activity with the right club!
And definitely great for self defence. Our sensei teaches the kids not to get into fights and definitely no starting fights.
But she regularly teaches punch and run. She teaches them to make sure they can buy enough time to run away by inducing enough surprise or pain. Helps the kids who would normally freeze or be tempted to fight to the death.

pinkstripeycat · 15/01/2022 23:19

My kids started karate tots at 3 years old. It’s more about having fun at that age. As they get older they learn more self defence. Now they are teens and practice ju jitzu. It’s great for protection. No fighting just defending themselves

VelvetChairGirl · 15/01/2022 23:16

[quote Amelion]@VelvetChairGirl and in any case - don’t most fights end on the ground? So I think grappling is pretty useful if you’re thinking of something that’s likely to have most practical use.[/quote]
None that I have been involved with no, they normally end with a swift kick to the head and hot footing it out of there.

Ylvamoon · 15/01/2022 23:16

My DD does Taekwondo with a girl heavy club in our area. They teach active self defence as part of their curriculum.
It doesn't have the throwing to the floor parts as in judo or karate. Focus is on keeping the oppnent at a safe distance, with well placed kiks and punches.
I must add, not the Olympic dicipline, but with ITF - there is a huge difference.

Swipe left for the next trending thread