Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?

263 replies

ItchySnoof · 15/01/2022 20:44

How fucking out of touch are these people? Given that some families literally can't feed themselves?

Genuinely thought this was a joke Hmm

Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
HumpreyDowny · 16/01/2022 18:23

For those who couldn't access, here are the screenshot : 1

Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?
Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?
Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?
elbea · 16/01/2022 17:57

@YDBear I know nannies that earn an awful lot more than that. Working in private service for lots of professions generally pays lots, you also have to be okay with being on call 24/7.

elbea · 16/01/2022 17:56

Surely their articles are tailored towards their target audience. I’d imagine that the articles about how to cook a meal for £5 or redecorate your house for £100 you get in the Sun aren’t very relevant to the readers of the Times.

MeredithGreyishblue · 16/01/2022 17:53

You're not allowed to write an article and feature wealthy people. Their views don't matter and they ought to be in sack cloth & ashes fmreflecting on what they've done. Giving them an article that might resonate with them will only encourage them.

YDBear · 16/01/2022 17:51

Nannies get £40k a year. Stone me! I took the wrong path in life.

Glittertwins · 16/01/2022 17:34

@Wrongkindofovercoat

You think a hedge fund manager doesn't earn enough to fully fund a nanny!?

Maybe he isn't very good ? more of a herbaceous border manager ?

I'm love that! I read the comments as well, they were not exactly feeling sorry for this couple either.
HugeAckmansWife · 16/01/2022 17:33

Not every article has to "speak" to everyone. I read the Times - I earn an average salary, am a professional , a single parent. Nothing like in this couple's league but I read the article and understood the idea that even those in that kind of bracket are having to make changes. No, those changes might not be earth shattering and will still leave them in a much much better place than many, but for their family, their dynamic, the current situation and price rises will affect them. Surely that speaks to the fact that these are BIG rises and so if a couple in this demographic are going to have to make changes, it doesn't take a genius to realise that lower income families are going to be even harder hit. As many pp have said, it isn't a misery Olympics

lightisnotwhite · 16/01/2022 17:27

The subtitle says it’s about rising food and energy costs which are common to rich and poor. The tone deaf bit is using a family that can normally afford to employ someone at well over the average national wage. Does it really matter how they are cutting costs? Nope. They’ll be fine regardless.
Pointless.

Newnamefor2022 · 16/01/2022 17:10

@TheMilkyWeigh

Geez people…just because they are in a different financial league to many, it doesn’t mean they are “tone deaf” or out of touch with those less fortunate. I am sure they are very much aware of how others live. But that wasn’t the question asked by the journalist. They alerted asked how they are managing a change in income. And this is their answer.

In the same way that if there was an article where people were sharing their experiences with migraines or tinnitus it doesn’t mean they are tone deaf to people dying of cancer.

Is it tone deaf to print an article about parenting when there are people struggling with infertility? Or about losing a pet when there are people who have lost a child? It’s just different experiences. Those experiences may not match yours, but that doesn’t mean they are not valid.

This.

Lots of people are having to cut back. It's not only sad if they are the poorest of the poor, it's not a race to the bottom.

Covidclaire · 16/01/2022 15:38

@TheMarzipanDildo

I watched that Louise Woodward documentary recently, if I had children I don’t think I’d want some unqualified teenager (that’s what au pairs usually are, right?) looking after them for a fraction of the cost of a nanny!
Wasn’t she looking after a baby? Au pairs are not supposed to be in sole charge of a baby, at any time. Plenty of people get an experienced nanny or use registered childminders or nurseries when their children are very young and then switch to an au pair when the children are older. I won’t need someone experienced in looking after a baby when my kids are 5+, and my needs will change even further then they are say 10+.

There is definitely a place for au pairs but it is not looking after young children.

TheMilkyWeigh · 16/01/2022 15:29

Geez people…just because they are in a different financial league to many, it doesn’t mean they are “tone deaf” or out of touch with those less fortunate. I am sure they are very much aware of how others live. But that wasn’t the question asked by the journalist. They alerted asked how they are managing a change in income. And this is their answer.

In the same way that if there was an article where people were sharing their experiences with migraines or tinnitus it doesn’t mean they are tone deaf to people dying of cancer.

Is it tone deaf to print an article about parenting when there are people struggling with infertility? Or about losing a pet when there are people who have lost a child? It’s just different experiences. Those experiences may not match yours, but that doesn’t mean they are not valid.

SquidMonkey · 16/01/2022 03:24

@eagerlywaitingfor

Oh God, they're all out tonight, aren't they?
Yep!!!
SquidMonkey · 16/01/2022 03:19

@WindInTheWillows7

I mean, my DH grew up in a country where he would grow vegetables in unclaimed patches of soil, forage for mushrooms, and spend all his childhood summers cherry picking to earn a bit of money, just to survive. He would sleep in coats and hats and at age 9 had to walk miles to buy some milk for his baby sister. According to your logic, people in the UK being given benefits living in council houses, with one meal a day, shouldn't be allowed to DARE complain about their situation, because there are people in their country who have had it worse than them. By his standards, these people are rolling in it. Do you see why your complaint makes no sense?
This. I do think some of the people with these attitudes have led very insular lives and never seen real poverty.
SquidMonkey · 16/01/2022 03:15

@TheGreatATuin

They might not have claimed they're the average family and they might well be The Times demographic, but it's increasingly common for families to struggle to afford basic groceries or have heating on in freezing weather because they can't afford the bills. It's insensitive and in poor taste.
Why? Talking about one person's worries isn't invalidating another's. Or should only the person suffering the most ever be allowed to speak? Do we need to have misery olympics? We can pit someone in the UK who can't afford to turn the heating on and is using foodbanks against people from developing nations where their children start work aged 4 and they have no clean water. Or maybe that's just an absolutely stupid attitude to things and we should have empathy for everybody, whatever their situation.
SquidMonkey · 16/01/2022 03:04

@LethargicActress

Why shouldn't they talk about how people are being affected in the media? Despite the fact that there are many people way worse off than this family, they are still a normal family.

Or is it that newspapers should only be allowed to talk about people at the bottom of the income spectrum because no one else is worthy of consideration? Hmm

I'm afraid this is exactly the view taken on all of these threads. There have been several awful and bullying examples in the last few days. This particular thread appears to have been designed for exactly this purpose: to have a go at anybody who dares to say they are having financial worries if they are not earning a really low income.

No other lived experience is valid and you're evil for saying how you feel or that you are struggling financially if you aren't destitute. That's the bitter message from many of these posters.

It's very depressing, in a forum that was set up to be supportive. Sad

FireMeetGasoline · 16/01/2022 02:41

*latter point

FireMeetGasoline · 16/01/2022 02:40

'This is just clickbait. It infuriates people that they are so out of touch. But in the same breath it is just as infuriating as the 700 clickbait stories about people on benefits with 7 children in inadequate council housing. It is a story created just for the comments.'

And @Disneydatknee88 are you really that out of touch that you've just actually said this?

Do you honestly think that the very real situation where thousands of children are going hungry is akin to this story? 'Clickbait' for likes/comments?

Let me tell you now that your letter point is absolutely more real, and probably 1000 more times to appear in a newspaper (as opposed to the 700 you state). There are children out there, in the UK, who are NOT being given the adequate upbringing that they need/deserve.

This article is disgusting, and a comparison of the 2 extremes equally so.

AllThePogs · 16/01/2022 02:06

@Disneydatknee88

This is just clickbait. It infuriates people that they are so out of touch. But in the same breath it is just as infuriating as the 700 clickbait stories about people on benefits with 7 children in inadequate council housing. It is a story created just for the comments.
Yes totally agreed. It sells papers.
mjf981 · 16/01/2022 02:04

She is 100% a mumsnetter.

Hi! [wave]

Disneydatknee88 · 16/01/2022 01:59

This is just clickbait. It infuriates people that they are so out of touch. But in the same breath it is just as infuriating as the 700 clickbait stories about people on benefits with 7 children in inadequate council housing. It is a story created just for the comments.

FrancescaContini · 16/01/2022 01:46

@BurntToastAgain

It sounds like they’re going to exploit an au pair to save money by expecting her to be a nanny.
Exactly my thought, too.
DustyMaiden · 16/01/2022 01:37

I have to get my chauffeur to run around the rear entrance, change into his butlers outfit and then open the door. We call it job sharing.

AllThePogs · 16/01/2022 01:31

I am poor and read The Times and work hard.

But according to some on here I should be reading The Sun and spend my days being a lazy arse.

OhWhyNot · 16/01/2022 01:27

Ionlydomassiveones don’t forget they will have worked very hard too so deserving of their wealth

Ionlydomassiveones · 16/01/2022 01:20

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Swipe left for the next trending thread