Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?

263 replies

ItchySnoof · 15/01/2022 20:44

How fucking out of touch are these people? Given that some families literally can't feed themselves?

Genuinely thought this was a joke Hmm

Seriously? This is The Times idea of an average family being squeezed for cash?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
SquidMonkey · 22/01/2022 02:53

Interesting to hear whether @DirtyDancing has contacted their MP today to suggest the changes to the tax system that I outlined, that would fix a large proportion of child poverty.

From the lack of response I am guessing the answer is that no, they didn't.

Wrongkindofovercoat · 21/01/2022 17:39

My point about council tax doubt very much they will live in a band a house paying a small amount

Depends where you live, Council tax is about £200 a month for my small 3 bed semi and thats one of the lower bands.

Dillydollydingdong · 20/01/2022 23:32

I don't read the Times but I do read the dreaded DM! And I'm constantly astonished by the cost of the clothes they advertise. Do they really think people have got hundreds of pounds to spend on coats, skirts and jumpers? I get my clothes in Tesco Grin

SquidMonkey · 20/01/2022 23:31

@DirtyDancing

It's not about the demographic that read the paper. It's tone deaf Shortsighted. Lacking in any comprehension whatsoever.

It's completely void of any appreciation for people who are struggling, worrying about whether they will be able to pay their fuel bill this winter.

They are sacrificing their veg boxes, whilst some people are reliant on food banks

They are renovating their kitchen for £100k when we know more children are living in poverty today than ever before.

Take away from Hakkasan (one of London's to restaurants) and some kids go to school hungry.

This country has gone complete fucking nuts. The gap between rich and poor is phenomenal.

So DO something then. Instead of moaning about these people who benefit from the current system. 90% of single parents are women. 60% of the children that are living in poverty live in those single parent households. The system discriminates against them and simple changes could easily fix a lot of it:
  • The tax-free allowance should be raised but be per household, not per person.

  • Single parents should get additional payments to recognise that they have much higher childcare costs because they do not have two people to juggle it.

  • Tax thresholds should be per household. So a single parent starts paying 20% when they earn double what two people do when they individually earn that,

  • All thresholds for UC, tax-free childcare, "30 hours" childcare, the threshold for when child benefit is withdrawn etc should be doubled when just one parent is raising the children. The families with two parents would still be at an advantage as they have two people to do childcare to reduce costs

It's no good moaning that some people are well off. It's quite clear that the majority of child poverty comes from single parents (almost all women) is a result of one person - the one whp stayed and tried to do the right thing - having to everything: provide financially, emotionally, give all of their time. And be taxed more than a couple earning the same who have twice as much time to work/ care for their kids.

If you genuinely are outraged about the inequality then campaign to your MP for this. Very, very simple to implement and would make a HUGE difference to poverty in this country.

But you haven't. And I expect you won't, and hardly anyone else on the thread will either.

Having a snipe at fortunate people will fox nothing. Campaigning for policies that would recognise the super-human job that single parents do - doing two people's work - would be much more productive.

SquidMonkey · 20/01/2022 23:20

@ClafoutisSurprise

I’m fed up with the attitude - which you see on here all the time - that people who are well off or even rich shouldn’t even be allowed to talk about their lifestyles and finances. Tone deaf is going on to a thread or into a conversation about council housing or some such and comparing that to problems you have with your £1m+ property or how you’re struggling on a six figure salary. Yet its use seems to have expanded to cover any mention of above average salaries or wealth, regardless of context. There was a poster on here last year who was heavily criticised for a thread about putting £2k per month towards her pension on a £60k salary - the usual cries about it being tone deaf, ‘read the room’, etc., despite it being her thread.

I’m not on six figures or saving £2k a month and fully agree that there is an inequality problem in this country, but sniping at people who are better off isn’t very edifying. The system is at fault, not individuals.

Besides, I didn’t even really register this article as financial clickbait. The telegraph do that far better ime!

This. 100 times
HugeAckmansWife · 18/01/2022 06:37

harmonypuss yes, but 11 pages in we've covered the fact that it's not a poverty Olympics. Should those in the UK using fiid banks be grateful that's an option because elsewhere in the world people are actually dying of starvation? The article isn't about everyone. It's not saying these people's lives won't be worth living without their current 'lifestyle' just that the changes coming are so big that everyone, pretty much, will be affected. For those in that demographic, the changes might not be devastating and life altering no, but they are real.

rwalker · 17/01/2022 18:57

@EmpressCixi@TheHoptimist
My point about council tax doubt very much they will live in a band a house paying a small amount .

Harmonypuss · 17/01/2022 13:45

@givemesteel

I am worried about tax increases, energy bill increases, increases to my mortgage due to interest rate rises, inflation so everything costs more. Put all those things together and I may not be able to afford my lifestyle any more.

At least some of you are fortunate enough to have a "lifestyle", there are millions who, through no fault of their own, truly are already on the crumb-line, never mind the bread-line.

Mirw · 17/01/2022 13:40

People will need "to cut their cloth" to fit their income no matter what other people think. Why read The Times if you are going to be shocked by this. Your post is angry because you want to be angry. Try reading another paper...

DrCoconut · 17/01/2022 13:08

@Frazzledstar1 but if you were that poor you'd have to slum it in the Seychelles this summer rather than a month in the Maldives. Oh the horror.

BoredZelda · 17/01/2022 12:45

The state of this country. I despair.

You think everyone should be struggling?

don't reflect how the majority of people are living/existing

But the majority aren't. Your situation, whilst sad and should be better, is not typical of people in the UK. Disability benefits should increase, you'll not get an argument from me on that, but it isn't right to say the majority of people are struggling.

BoredZelda · 17/01/2022 12:39

I am worried about tax increases, energy bill increases, increases to my mortgage due to interest rate rises, inflation so everything costs more. Put all those things together and I may not be able to afford my lifestyle any more.

I think the rule is you have to state your monthly income so you can be judged as to whether A) you are lying about it (usually that's a yes) and B) whether you deserve to lose your lifestyle because people are going to foodbanks.

celiamary · 17/01/2022 12:18

The Sunday Times had more about them which put it into perspective. They are just showing that everyone needs to manage their own budget carefully.

Last week there was a thread about MN being too middle-class! Judging by the responses to this I would say not.

givemesteel · 17/01/2022 12:06

Does every cost of living article have to be about those already on the breadline?

I think there are an awful lot of people (myself included) who loom externally like they live a good life but are living on quite tight margins.

I am worried about tax increases, energy bill increases, increases to my mortgage due to interest rate rises, inflation so everything costs more. Put all those things together and I may not be able to afford my lifestyle any more.

PeopleBakwas · 17/01/2022 11:52

I don't think she's on Mumsnet, she's got too much money.
Most of the people here seem to have money issues.
Deadbeat partners.
Benefit / CMS issues.
The only issues this site seems to be good for in my opinion are the health, DIY and conception boards.
Other than that it seems to attract people from the lower end of the financial section to middle income.
This woman is not part of that.
This site is actually very unrelatable, as this thread confirms and the OP's opinion.

sjpkgp1 · 17/01/2022 02:22

@DrierThanANunsNasty

It’s a newspaper, it’s twisted to fit the narrative their target demographic wants to hear.

I wouldn’t go all frothing at the mouth about it.

This. Someone I had worked with once featured in a 2 page magazine article about how women were treated in work (and her experiences particularly). After she left the company, she approached the magazine, and she was paid for it. There was a lot of anonymity going on "names have been changed etc." Whereas I would not have said that it was all utter nonsense; there WERE a couple of grains of truth in it - it was mainly made up or vastly exaggerated stories, and it did only tell one side. I felt sad when I read it, and I wasn't sure who I felt sadder for. I do think the press will misquote, exaggerate, twist the narrative when it suits them.
AllThePogs · 17/01/2022 00:07

@rwalker

Not interested but presume there overheads will of gone up like everyone else's . They probperly pay more in tax than most of us earn and as a family. Pay massive council tax but use the same amount if not less public services than the rest of us . Have there kids privately educated and take nothing from the state Have private health care taking nothing from NHS. Employ staff conturbting to the economy .

Ill never be in the same position as them but don't begrudge them it .

People in London pay less council tax than other areas of the country. In some boroughs people in an expensive house pay less in council tax than an ordinary family in other parts of the country.
Harmonypuss · 16/01/2022 22:51

I'm on about £10k/yr in benefits.
I'm disabled, can't work and have a mortgage.
Half this goes on my mortgage (fortunately it's a very small one), leaving me with less than £90/wk for everything else. It's a real struggle but somehow I just about scrape by, although with the new cost of living increases and the cost of gas and electricity going through the roof again in April, heaven only knows what I'll do.
The government has said benefits will go up but that's not until April and if last year's increase is anything to go by (I got less then £1/wk increase), I'm not expecting to see much more this year.

Newspaper stories like this (as much as they show that even people with massive income will be making a change or two to their spending patterns), don't reflect how the majority of people are living/existing, it just feels like they're rubbing our noses in the fact that they have so much money/spend massive amounts of it and pointing out that they're easily able to cut £30k from their annual spending without really seeing much difference in the way they live.
Oh what I'd give to just see £30k!

Kennykenkencat · 16/01/2022 22:37

Money definitely does buy happiness.

I know if someone deposited a 7 figure sum in my bank account tomorrow I would be over the moon. My stress levels would go down and I could turn the heating up to get feeling back into my stone cold fingers.

The only thing that is making me not happy atm is my lack of money.

TheHoptimist · 16/01/2022 22:34

[quote EmpressCixi]@rwalker
Agree with you except for this
Pay massive council tax but use the same amount if not less public services than the rest of us

The richest boroughs in London, especially Westminster, actually pay the lowest council tax rates in the country.[/quote]
Westminster has high levels of social housing as well though including new arrivals
The very rich and the very poor

Jk987 · 16/01/2022 22:27

@WinnersDinner

How are they out of touch?

They were asked what they were doing to help with the current cost of living squeeze

Should they have lied?

It the word squeeze. They're going to be warm, well fed, sheltered, entertained etc. They are cutting costs but they aren't suffering.
TheRussianDoll · 16/01/2022 22:20

I’m up north. Levelling up means nothing here.

I’m lucky. I’m nearly 60 and lead a comfortable life but as I say, seeing poverty via my work, is awful.

whenwillthemadnessend · 16/01/2022 22:03

Lols

I guess they dont expect the reader to live outside of the M25

Ionlydomassiveones · 16/01/2022 22:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

FurierTransform · 16/01/2022 21:58

Genuinely thought this was a satire piece when I read it. How unaware can you get... And I bet the hedge fund manager husband knew nothing about her doing this piece and is seriously pissed off. She has a unique name and he will be easily identifiable, in an industry where reputation is everything.

Swipe left for the next trending thread