Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Masks..in the school playground??

111 replies

PatButchersEarring · 15/01/2022 18:52

The head of my children's primary school has requested that all parents wear masks in the playground (totally outside, open, no sheltered areas) when dropping off or picking up children- and is rigidly reminding and enforcing this.

Now, the only interaction with teachers is outside, through a fenced off area. There are literally cones and red tape cordoning off any entrances to classrooms. If parents speak to teachers, it is from at least 2 metres away and outside. No parents have been able to enter the school for nearly 2 years- with or without masks.

I understand that schools pose a high risk for the spread of Covid- but masks outside? Really??

Looking at the DFE guidance, this appears to be in direct contradiction, and I'm wondering if it is more of a political statement on the school's behalf as opposed to a rational, thought out preventative measure.

So, my AIBU is 'Is it unreasonable for it to be mandatory for adults to wear a mask when in the school playground?'

OP posts:
grey12 · 16/01/2022 10:31

Do you want to "homeschool" again? Thought not: wear the blooming mask Wink it's just 5min

SuspiciousScully · 16/01/2022 10:06

We haven't had any guidelines on masks at drop off/pick up in months and most parents don't now. But we're not allowed in the playground so we're talking about people stood outside of school grounds, outdoors, largely social distancing. Adding masks to that would make no difference to transmissions (and I have always happily worn a mask whenever it's been required through the pandemic and have not set foot in a shop without a mask since the beginning)!

The virus doesn't spread outside, so it is an empty gesture that makes it 'look' like the school are doing something but in reality it makes absolutely no difference. Of course the transmissions are happening inside the classrooms and not outside at drop off and pick up!

Taswama · 16/01/2022 10:04

Completely standard and completely pointless.
Virus spread outside is extremely unlikely which is why events like parkrun are allowed to take place.

I do wonder what we are teaching our kids about critical thinking when we are doing something that has no actual benefit but is really just for show.

Very glad my dc are now at secondary.

TalkedTooMuchStayedTooLong · 16/01/2022 09:57

Whilst I don't think masks outside are usually necessary, I wear one all day at work (TA), including the playground as a) if a child is upset or injured I can't keep my distance, b) we have some children with physical disabilities which necessitates close contact and c) helpful members of the public have been know to complain if they see a member of staff unmasked in the school grounds, even if outside!

Our school also asks parents to wear them in the playground, that is because a) they rarely keep their distance from staff or each other and b) again, members of the public are hyper vigilant- we've had some complaints about lack of masks and distancing by our parents OUTSIDE the school grounds!

JuergenSchwarzwald · 16/01/2022 09:18

Masked on a public street? I don't think the school have that kind of authority. What happens if the parent isn't masked? Studies show that it is highly unlikely to catch covid outside, seems pointless to enforce these rules

Agreed.

JuergenSchwarzwald · 16/01/2022 09:17

Wearing masks outdoors is nonsensical in my view, unless you have a lot of people in a very small area. If a playground is tiny with hundreds of parents in it, than maybe it's sensible. And a parent might prefer to wear one, given all the unvaccinated children around. But otherwise it's just covid theatre.

Londongent · 16/01/2022 09:12

@AdviceOnLife

My dc's school no parent is allowed in either playground at all. The parents collect in the street and the parents must be masked in the public street when doing pick up.
Masked on a public street? I don't think the school have that kind of authority. What happens if the parent isn't masked? Studies show that it is highly unlikely to catch covid outside, seems pointless to enforce these rules
Plumbear2 · 16/01/2022 08:52

This has been the case in secondary schools for quite a while if I need to visit my child's school for meetings or to hand in an item my child forget. I ensure my mask is on before I press the buzzer on the gate. Why do you think it should be different for primary school?

Sirzy · 16/01/2022 08:45

To me it falls into the category of it may not do any good but it certainly isn’t going to do any harm so why not.

EmmaPaella · 16/01/2022 08:44

Our school wants us to wear masks, and I do, although I agree it seems overkill outside in the playground. However, I feel it is up the them.

ThettaReddast · 16/01/2022 08:41

Our school previously required masks in the playground, it’s now optional and about half the parents are still wearing them. I’m wearing mine, whilst it’s outside there are several pinch points that get crowded and all the staff are wearing them, feels pretty disrespectful to not bother when they are.

HelenaJustina · 16/01/2022 07:43

@Gingerbreadrules you would think so. But all of the cases we have had in our primary this term have been isolated cases brought into school from home. So far touches wood we have had no spread within classes

Ida3456 · 15/01/2022 21:26

It is ‘encouraged’ at our school but only a few people do - I just don’t get the point when you’re outside? We know the virus is not going to spread in the playground at drop off - it spreads indoors amongst close contacts where there is poor ventilation?

jennywasafriendofmrbrightside · 15/01/2022 21:26

Utterly utterly pointless virtue signalling. Wear one if you like if you prefer to not be approached by the HT in the school grounds but they cannot make you - like pp's have said, what are they going to do, refuse to let you take your child home!!

Gingerbreadrules · 15/01/2022 21:25

It does seem a little bit bonkers given the children and staff are spending all day in very close indoor contact without masks. The junior school I go into weekly has done away with all mitigations apart from hand sanitiser in the office! Children are much more likely to bring it home to parents than parents bringing it into the school.

Opihr · 15/01/2022 21:20

I work at a school and we always thought masks in the playground were ridiculous but our LA wanted us to promote the message. I think we promoted it once in very small letters and never enforced it as it is bonkers. Masks have never been mandatory outdoors in this country.

I fully understand why schools are twitchy about COVID, I really do, but measures like this really don't help.

Bluebluemoon39 · 15/01/2022 21:15

hugging and chatting with others knowing full well she has it , then passing it to everyone else.

Oh, you didn't mention she was hugging and chatting Hmm

How do you know she infected you though??

Whyisitsodifficult · 15/01/2022 21:13

You’re outside! What complete bollocks and just virtue signalling. I would ignore. It’s time to get back to normal now. You’re outside 🙄

MummyMe87 · 15/01/2022 21:07

Both my kids schools have had this since they went back in April last year. Really don’t see the issue. Wear a bloody mask, reduce the risk as much as possible of covid spreading in schools

lms2017 · 15/01/2022 21:07

@Bluebluemoon39

have had covid recently and I am pregnant , turns out a parent had it and didn't notify anyone just sent her child in everyday with her dropping off and picking up

Maybe she didn't want to tell people because she was worried about ridiculous attitudes like yours. She was perfectly entitled to send her child into school.

How many others actually test and know if they have it or not?

At the moment not many I would think as people are wising up to the fact it's basically a cold for most. Symptomless for about a third.
And of course, there's the fact you can't get LFT's now (probably as they are trying to phase them out gently-gently like).

Some people honestly won't know what to do with themselves when this is all properly over.

No no did you read my post she was supposed to be isolating at home! , yes for someone else to bring her child in if symptomless but NO to be standing at the gates hugging and chatting with others knowing full well she has it , then passing it to everyone else.

My attitude is not ridiculous at all. Irresponsible people thinking only their health matters , that's ridiculous.

BaggaTDoubleTroubleDoubleG · 15/01/2022 21:05

@Bluebluemoon39

have had covid recently and I am pregnant , turns out a parent had it and didn't notify anyone just sent her child in everyday with her dropping off and picking up

Maybe she didn't want to tell people because she was worried about ridiculous attitudes like yours. She was perfectly entitled to send her child into school.

How many others actually test and know if they have it or not?

At the moment not many I would think as people are wising up to the fact it's basically a cold for most. Symptomless for about a third.
And of course, there's the fact you can't get LFT's now (probably as they are trying to phase them out gently-gently like).

Some people honestly won't know what to do with themselves when this is all properly over.

Yes the parent can send her kid to school but she shouldn’t leave the house to do the drop off! That’s going against the isolation rules and could lead to a fine!

You can get LFTs, we are still testing regularly and are following the rules having found out that we have Covid. We are not slavish rule followers by any means but we do believe in behaving correctly and avoiding infecting others where possible.

Qwertykeys · 15/01/2022 20:57

Yabu , school staff are working hard to keep your children in school. Unless your exempt is it too much to put a mask on when collecting your children.

Bluebluemoon39 · 15/01/2022 20:46

have had covid recently and I am pregnant , turns out a parent had it and didn't notify anyone just sent her child in everyday with her dropping off and picking up

Maybe she didn't want to tell people because she was worried about ridiculous attitudes like yours. She was perfectly entitled to send her child into school.

How many others actually test and know if they have it or not?

At the moment not many I would think as people are wising up to the fact it's basically a cold for most. Symptomless for about a third.
And of course, there's the fact you can't get LFT's now (probably as they are trying to phase them out gently-gently like).

Some people honestly won't know what to do with themselves when this is all properly over.

scammedmum29 · 15/01/2022 20:45

It’s been the norm where I am. Just get on with it

BaggaTDoubleTroubleDoubleG · 15/01/2022 20:42

Our nursery has asked parents to wear masks at handover and drop off (outside). I’m grateful for them for keeping going through a pandemic, so if that’s what they want then I’m not going to be bloody minded about.

We’ve all gone and got Covid this week anyway, probably from nursery.

Swipe left for the next trending thread