Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU I’m turning down this job offer?

266 replies

Whatwouldyoudo24 · 15/01/2022 17:45

Name change because this would be outing if you knew me!

I recently had a job interview and then the next day, a job offer.

During the call to offer me the job she said she had some feedback for me, and then proceeded to tell me I was dressed ‘very inappropriately for a job interview’. I was wearing a black flower skirt that is just above the knee, a mustard jumper that is high neck and very thick black tights with black flat shoes. I did have my green coat on for part of the tour as it was outside.

I don’t think it was inappropriate at all, it’s something I worn to work previously and have never had anyone say anything negative about it at all. Something about the phone call, the word inappropriate and my gut is making me feel uneasy about accepting the role now but I can’t tell if IABU?

It isn’t a suit industry, the interviewer was wearing black leggings, leather boots and a long top.

Am I being silly or maybe over sensitive? I’ve never been told I’ve dressed inappropriately for anything before so I might just not appreciate it, though usually I’m relatively good at accepting when I’ve made a mistake!

OP posts:
Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 16/01/2022 10:26

Depends on the industry but it sounds fine to me, plus she was dressed very casually- more than you.

I would email that in light of the fact that she would be your manager, you'd like to understand how you should be dressing for the role as she said you were very inappropriate. That means her comments to you are also down on an email. See how she responds. Be honest and say it had bothered you.
I do think I'd not take the job but she should be put in a position to justify her comments frankly.
She sounds unprofessional and I would not want to work with her. Is it financial services? I'm wondering if this was my old boss!

DisforDarkChocolate · 16/01/2022 09:54

I agree @UseOfWeapons.

There are very few occasions when it's appropriate. I'm thinking of working in a prison or healthcare where a new worker may not know about the dress requirements. Even then this would not be the way to tackle it.

KatherineJaneway · 16/01/2022 09:44

I wouldn't take it. Not with that kind of feedback especially as she is not willing to expand on it when asked. A poor manager indeed.

Quirrelsotherface · 16/01/2022 08:33

It would depend how much I wanted / needed the job to be honest. If it was a dream job, great salary, good hours etc then I'd consider it but otherwise I'd run for the hills. I think it's a strange thing to mention in a job offer, if not actually letting you know what you did 'wrong' or what it is they expect.

Can you imagine now that translates to your work. Yes you're not really doing your job correctly but I'm not going to let you know exactly why that is, so you can't improve.

ShadowGirls · 16/01/2022 08:29

This would be a big alarm bell for me. Not only do I think it was odd to mention it, her follow up response was also very off

I took a job once and had to ring twice chasing up the contract. That was an alarm bell I should have listened to

The job was awful, after a couple of weeks I was ready to leave. So badly ran. I left after six months and then the two managers above me got the sack shortly after

Proceed with caution. I think she would be hard to work for

BraveGoldie · 16/01/2022 08:27

Yeah she sounds like a crap manager. I would suggest bringing it up one more time. Something like:

"Before anything else, I just wanted to clarify something because it's been playing on my mind. You mentioned that my outfit wasn't appropriate, but didn't go into why. I'd like to understand so I know what I'd need to adjust to fit in with the company culture. Could you give me some specific feedback, because right now I'm just a little confused, as I thought my outfit was similar to everyone else's".

If she just had a bad/stupid day and either apologises or gives you reasonable, constructive feedback, then I guess you could go ahead with the job.
If she is again vague or if she is defensive/ overly critical in some way, then that would confirm she'd be awful to work for...?

BraveGoldie · 16/01/2022 08:20

@Pieminster

OP thinks she was smart enough. Myself and others think she was too casual. OP, you were wearing clothes you wear to work every day. You should have upped your game, that's what the interviewer was saying I think. She was weird to say it esp when offering you a job but why won't you listen to anyone saying you were too casual? Because you were. Accept it
Op was very rationale and fact-based in comparing her level of casual to other people's outfits.. "It was a bit too casual" would also have been really easy, clear feedback for the interviewer to give, and that feedback was not given.

You know nothing about the industry nor have you actually seen the outfit.

And yet you are utterly sure you know better than OP what was going on..... what arrogance!

skodadoda · 16/01/2022 08:16

@MichelleScarn

l did try to expand on it at the time and asked what about it was inappropriate but she just said ‘let’s not get bogged down by that sort of thing, the good news is we are still happy to offer you the job’

Ooo that makes it even worse to me, you've done this bad thing, but we won't tell you what, but look how nice we are still letting you in...

This struck me immediately. She sounds a bit of a bully to me.
KatherineJaneway · 16/01/2022 07:57

@RasputinsPickledPenis

I had an interview where I was made to fill out an application form on what was essentially a coffee table. The woman interviewing me complained because she could see down my top as I lent over to write. I was wearing a smart top- it wouldn't have happened if the table wasn't so low!
Sounds rather Men In Black.
UseOfWeapons · 16/01/2022 07:37

@NeverDropYourMooncup

I'd probably decline on the grounds that the person making the call had advised me my clothing was very inappropriate and had pressurised me to give an instant acceptance, so, upon reflection, I had concluded that the company culture was not one I would be comfortable with.

That way, they know exactly what was said.

I agree with this, the person who spoke to you about your ‘inappropriate’ attire was massively inappropriate herself. I’ve been interviewing for years, and never commented on what a candidate was wearing. Because it’s not appropriate! Having read your update that you’ll be refusing the post, I’d give the company feedback as above. By email, quoting exactly what was said. Look elsewhere, OP, and good luck to you.
DisforDarkChocolate · 16/01/2022 07:37

I'm baffled by the suit comments too. I saw a picture of this year's Apprentice contestants recently, they all looked like they had travelled back in time 15 years.

I have no suits, I'm not buying any either. I'm self-employed and get interviewed all the time and regularly get offered work. People judge me on my skills not if they like my jumper.

chocolateorangeinhaler · 16/01/2022 07:30

She has a point. But she has conveyed it badly. I've interviewed loads and had people turn up in trainers and crumpled t shirts, it screams "I'm not serious about this" regardless of qualifications and experience. It's difficult for women as men can just pop a suit on. Lots of women in admin where I work wear the latest fashion which seems to be cold shoulder tops or those floaty frilly blouses, which is more what you would wear meeting mates for lunch imo.

Take it on the chin and ask her to send you the company dress code so you can wear appropriate attire.

ThePrionOne · 16/01/2022 07:20

Something about the phone call, the word inappropriate and my gut is making me feel uneasy about accepting the role now

Listen to your gut. If you needed the job badly, then maybe it would be worth the risk, but she has already demonstrated to you that she has poor management skills, given her brush off when you asked for more information on what was wrong with what you wore. If it was unimportant to you, you wouldn’t have asked.

Might you want to apply to work there again in future? If so, you can give your very bland reason for not taking the job. If you think it’s unlikely you’d want to work there, you could give genuine feedback that you were concerned that she would give you negative feedback, which she was then unable to justify with a response. What possible reason could there be for giving negative feedback on an interview, without explaining why or what should be changed. The only reasons I can imagine, are that she is a poor manager, or that she wants to make you feel insecure.

LovedayCL · 16/01/2022 07:18

How the job market has managed thus far without hyper vigilant MNers and their highly effective twat radars vetting potential opportunities I cannot imagine

Lack of imagination not particularly evident...

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 16/01/2022 07:12

I interview regularly and what someone wears is not what we score ffs. Id be v concerned by her comments. You obviously scored high enough to be offered the job. Id be turning that one down if i were you in your circumstances. What you were wearing sounds perfect and the last post i sat on a panel for had a salary of approx £100k (not london)

Palavah · 16/01/2022 07:07

@MyrtlethePurpleTurtle

All the interviewer is saying surely is that aiP is the best candidate for the job but needs to up her sartorial standards
But is unwilling to explain what they are in order to help OP decide whether she can/will meet them
Pleasebeafleabite · 16/01/2022 07:02

It’s not about holding down a job, is it? It’s about the hiring manager being weird before the OP has accepted the job, so she can decide to say no based on it. I don’t think she needs spidey senses here, just a twat radar

How the job market has managed thus far without hyper vigilant MNers and their highly effective twat radars vetting potential opportunities I cannot imagine

As an aside, how do we know the OPs high neck jumper wasn’t tight ribbed fine gauge material showing every bra line and her nips? Or short sleeve showing a full tattoo sleeve? Both would be “very inappropriate” at interview Grin

MarieG10 · 16/01/2022 06:27

I think you have an insight into what worker for her would be like. You are uneasy. Listen to your feelings and decline it

RedRobin100 · 16/01/2022 06:08

@Mummadeze

I would decline the job because she sounds bitchy and negative. I think her comment about your appearance was out of order and unnecessary. I would also feedback that her attitude has made you re-think the cultural fit. She deserves to be taken down a peg or two.
This
LovedayCL · 16/01/2022 05:47

It didn’t have this on the back did it, OP? 🤔

AIBU I’m turning down this job offer?
LovedayCL · 16/01/2022 05:46

How the permanently outraged of MN keep their red flag spidy senses in check long enough to hold down a job for longer than a week I’ll never know

It’s not about holding down a job, is it? It’s about the hiring manager being weird before the OP has accepted the job, so she can decide to say no based on it. I don’t think she needs spidey senses here, just a twat radar.

Aloha7373 · 16/01/2022 04:38

I can’t believe how many people are saying always wear a suit Confused. I remember a guy who interviewed at my previous company a few years ago in a suit - people still never let him live it down. Literally no one cares what anyone wears in my industry (tech) it’s about whether you actually have the skills to do the job and get results.

Of course if you’re customer-facing (sales, etc) it makes sense, but come on guys. Suits for every job?! As someone who now hires I’d honestly think you were a bit naive and would worry you hadn’t had a new job since 1995.

daisychain01 · 16/01/2022 04:22

How the permanently outraged of MN keep their red flag spidy senses in check long enough to hold down a job for longer than a week I’ll never know

Ridiculous comment.

It would be far worse to take a job where it's clear from the get-go that the recruiting manager is demeaning and patronising to the candidate, then gives mixed messages by offering them the job. And failing to be clear about the supposed dress-code faux pas. Clumsy is being generous, controlling and cryptic more like.

The OP's instincts are not lying. Never ignore your spidey senses, they're what keep you from danger (evolutionary-wise).

TooManyPJs · 16/01/2022 03:45

If she would be your manager I definitely would take the job. She sounds awful. 1. On giving that feedback at all while offering the job 2. Even worse not proving specifics after giving negative feedback which leaves a person not understanding where they went wrong. And that rude, dismissive comment "oh let's not get in to all that" would have been the veil in the coffin fir her. A shitty or good manager can make or break a job.

Oblomov22 · 16/01/2022 03:37

Red flag. She didn't just use the word inappropriately, she said very inappropriately. Then when pressed wouldn't explain.

Swipe left for the next trending thread