Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that having a comfortable life is not the same as having a luxurious one?

90 replies

Onlyrainbows · 15/01/2022 17:38

I understand that it's all very subjective and that the "living comfortably" is a very wide spectrum. A simple example would be: living comfortably - to have a car that works and you don't have to worry about its maintenance as you can afford it. Living luxuriously - you own a bran new (or newish) Porsche and you can definitely afford it.

OP posts:
MedusasBadHairDay · 16/01/2022 12:39

@sweetkitty

For me comfortable is, if the washing machine broke tomorrow morning I could go straight to Curry’s (or whatever) and buy a new one or if the DC needed a new jacket I could just go buy one right now. Maybe it’s relevant to my childhood.
Yeah I'd agree with this.

Comfortable is also being able to buy something that is better quality and will last, rather than having to get the cheapest, worst quality option.

It's being able to check your bank account without feeling anxious.

So I don't think you need to earn loads and loads to be comfortable - just a little more than would cover bills and essentials. Enough to have savings and the occasional treat.

Onlyrainbows · 16/01/2022 12:31

Exactly Winner I think luxury is pretty well established. I think the Harvester example is a very good one. When we were on a lower income, going out for a meal was something we couldn't really afford unless it was McDonald's. Maybe every once in a while we went to Turtle Bay, but I still wouldn't have considered that a luxury. Going to The Ivy would have felt more of a luxury. Maybe to some it would still feel like a "chain restaurant experience" albeit more upmarket.

OP posts:
A580Hojas · 16/01/2022 12:16

Yanbu. Daft question.

WowIlikereallyhateyou · 16/01/2022 12:14

@Onlyrainbows

Exactly the "finer" things very well put. I think it also varies widely depending on number of children and any potential childcare costs. A household income of £100k might seem insanely high to many, but after tax to some will still only give them a comfortable life.
Well that rather depends. An income of £100 k with everything paid for and no debt, can provide most luxuries. Whereas, £100k and massive mortgage and outgoings wont. Which is why i never see the point in the threads asking how much makes someone wealthy, because it depends on many factors. You can have an income of millions and still exceed it with outgoings.
Lolalasagna · 16/01/2022 12:09

When I was much younger I used to earn 6 figures, and whilst I never considered myself wealthy as such, I never worried about money, ever. Ate out all the time, thought nothing of going into London and dropping £500 on a new outfit or bag, did my supermarket shop without even looking at prices, gave no thought at all the things like shopping around for energy tariffs. Saved between £1,000 - £2,000 a month. If I'd wanted a Porsche I could have afforded to lease one no problem.

I'm now on a very average income, new clothes are a treat and always from the high Street or ebay, can't remember the last time I went out to eat. Whilst I still spend more than I should at the supermarket (working on that!) I do shop around and look for discounts, meal plan etc. My car is 9 years old, but it's paid for. Some months I manage to save £100-200ish. Someone up thread mentioned pay day not being notable - it is very much in our house because as we get close to it the bank account starts to look pretty empty and it's nice to have it topped up again!

Even in comparison to my 'old' life I would still describe myself as comfortable - I can afford to feed myself with more than the basics, whilst I'm careful about energy usage I can put the heating on without panicking. I have enough good quality warm clothes and shoes. Our house is nicely decorated, cosy and warm, although i have a million things I'd do to it/ buy for it if I had more money. If my car broke down I'd have to put any significant costs on a credit card, but I'd be able to pay it off over a few months.

Not being comfortable to me means not being able to afford more than the very basics, and not being able to comfortably fund in some way an emergency purchase such as car repairs or a new washing machine etc.

WinnersDinner · 16/01/2022 12:09

YANBU

I personally think luxury isn't competitive either

Some might be accustomed to a luxury lifestyle, but I don't get behind the whole 'if you eat beans on toast and have 10p on your heating meter you'd think a 3 bed house and a harvester meal is luxury'

Luxury is pretty established regardless of context.

And it's definitely different to being comfortable

camperqueen54 · 16/01/2022 12:09

We have an ok income 90k but I just consider we are comfortable not luxurious. I have 1or 2 luxurious items but that's it. I don't have to worry about affording housing or food or clothing and we manage a foreign holiday.
I'm quite glad I don't lead a luxurious life. I would feel fake and greedy. There are only so many resources in the world.

gogohm · 16/01/2022 12:05

Yes of course, many of us live comfortable lives but we still need to budget our finances. We can't afford sports cars and holiday homes but we live very comfortably with our second hand cars, townhouse and 2 holidays a year

CounsellorTroi · 16/01/2022 12:02

Flying is a luxury to me. I love it. Not a frequent flyer even before Covid but I do think people take it for granted now and it annoys me when people moan about it.

OpalOwl · 16/01/2022 11:42

I earn a little over minimum wage, DH works part time but brings in about the same each month. I would describe us as comfortable. Our Mortgage is paid off and no DC. We eat out when we want, holiday or two each year. Its all relative to outgoings.

Onlyrainbows · 16/01/2022 09:15

I see there's a general consensus. On the Facebook group I asked, people mentioned living comfortably with £20k (I genuinely can't understand how if they still have housing costs. Many were shocked that 100k wouldn't give s love of luxury. I think two things happen here, they're not taking into.account any UC, tax credits, etc... For the 100k they don't take taxes into account.

OP posts:
ComeOnSpringtime · 16/01/2022 00:48

Comfortable life = Having what you need.
Luxurious life = Having everything you need + anything you want.

sweetkitty · 16/01/2022 00:04

For me comfortable is, if the washing machine broke tomorrow morning I could go straight to Curry’s (or whatever) and buy a new one or if the DC needed a new jacket I could just go buy one right now. Maybe it’s relevant to my childhood.

Freecuthbert · 16/01/2022 00:03

@TheOriginalEmu

Having a car might be a luxury to me as I don't drive. But I don't think someone is living the life of luxury because they can afford to drive. I've known plenty of really low income people who still drive, passed their test years ago and have low insurance and cheap car etc. It is quite normal in the west and for many jobs it can be a requirement. If we're comparing things on a global scale then aren't all of us in the UK living luxuriously? Even those in poverty here can at least have the safety net of benefits and food banks etc, compared to people who don't have access to clean drinking water somewhere else. It's like comparing a bad situation to a worse one, doesn't make the other luxury.

user1471453601 · 15/01/2022 23:55

Surely it's reative? I feel I'm "comfortable" , but if you'd told me 20 years ago that I would no longer worry about paying bills, or what may happen when I went to an ATM, I'd look at me now and think I was living in the lap of luxury.

Now, I'm fine, I go abroad for eight weeks a year, I buy presents at Xmas and still have money in my account.

I actually have less money coming in (I'm now retired), by about 50% but I don't have a mortgage as I was able to pay it off with my lump sum when I retired. And no debts apart from monthly utilities.

So, my life feels just fine, I don't drive so have no idea what wanting/having a Porche might feel like.

As for "the finer things in life" , again, I think that's relative. We eat well
, Organic and locally sourced. But im basically a peasants at heart (three generations away from being in the Workhouse), so maybe my standards are low.

MaxNormal · 15/01/2022 23:49

OP I get what you mean. A warm house, good quality food in the fridge, money left over to save or treat yourself after the bills, basically all that you need and an absence from worry.
Clearly that wouldn't stretch if you then decided you wanted to be head to toe in the latest designer gear and have several 5-star long haul holidays a year though.

Disneydatknee88 · 15/01/2022 23:47

We live a comfortable life in the sense that we have enough surplus earnings to put by in savings each month. If something breaks, we can afford to fix it and not have to worry. If we want a takeaway we can have it. If the kids need £20 to go out with friends they can have it. Christmas and birthdays are never a problem..but we can't just spent thousands on a new car or a holiday. We still have to wait a while to save up for those things. For me that is comfortable.

TheOriginalEmu · 15/01/2022 23:43

@Onlyrainbows

I understand that it's all very subjective and that the "living comfortably" is a very wide spectrum. A simple example would be: living comfortably - to have a car that works and you don't have to worry about its maintenance as you can afford it. Living luxuriously - you own a bran new (or newish) Porsche and you can definitely afford it.
Having car is a luxury, having a car that you don’t have to worry about affording to run is massively privileged. On s global scale that makes you rich.
PurpleSky300 · 15/01/2022 23:40

To me, 'comfortable' means you just don't need to worry about money. Plenty of savings, no need to be budget for groceries or bills, not troubled by unexpected expenses, able to fund a social life, etc. I wouldn't expect things like "pay day" to have any significance each month because someone who is comfortable would always have enough basic cash to cover their living costs.

blyn · 15/01/2022 23:35

'Comfortable' and 'luxurious' are not the same and everyone is at a different level, what is luxury to one is normal to another.. To be 'comfortably off' is pleasant and something for which to be aimed.

SEOeieio · 15/01/2022 23:28

"Comfortable" may be code for well-off, for some, but for me, it means we don't worry about paying our bills or how we'll afford basic necessities. We can afford to treat ourselves, modestly, without worry, but we still have to live within our means, and we try to save where we can so we will have enough in the future.

Luxurious living would be knowing we could stop working and be okay for the rest of our lives, never having to splurge only in moderation.

Kite22 · 15/01/2022 23:19

I agree with @Believer99 that it depends where you have 'come from'.

I would say we are comfortable, in that I know there is money in the bank if the boiler breaks down or any of the white goods or unexpected repairs to the car, etc. I know we can decide to nip to the pub for a meal if we fancy it once a month or so.
But we can do that because we are careful with money in so many other ways. I don't consider that a 'sacrifice' , I consider it 'being sensible'. Quite frankly, if I won on the Premium Bonds next month, I still couldn't bring myself to pay out the money that is bandied around on so many threads on here as being quite normal.
I think a nice coffee out is a luxury, whereas I have seen posts on student budgeting threads, or child pocket money threads indicating they think 'a few coffees' is part of a normal budget for someone with no, or little income.

Obviously 'comfortable' and 'luxurious' are different levels of freedom to spend on stuff you don't need, but I think your own background and attitude to money both have much more influence on what you think both words mean.

Bringmeadog · 15/01/2022 23:13

I was homeless a few years ago for a short time. This year I holidayed in the Caribbean (on a heavily discounted flight and self catering, which others may turn their nose up at) and that felt luxurious.
However, I also swam in the lake the other day, when most other people would be at work. The water temp was about 4/5 C and it was a beautiful, still, albeit cold day.
Winter sun shone on me and the whole setting felt luxurious, so it’s a state of mind as much as anything.

silentpool · 15/01/2022 23:10

I consider my life luxurious - but then I have simple tastes. I've lived in many developing countries and now am very appreciative of the free amenities we have.

Luxury, if by that, you mean, expensive or branded things - I don't want that particularly. It's a mindset thing.

Freecuthbert · 15/01/2022 22:55

Omg I wish there was an edit button.

It was meant to say can throw in some nice things too on a whim without budgeting. Big things, such as holiday or new car not on a whim but can be budgeted for and not unattainable.

Sorry!