Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that having a comfortable life is not the same as having a luxurious one?

90 replies

Onlyrainbows · 15/01/2022 17:38

I understand that it's all very subjective and that the "living comfortably" is a very wide spectrum. A simple example would be: living comfortably - to have a car that works and you don't have to worry about its maintenance as you can afford it. Living luxuriously - you own a bran new (or newish) Porsche and you can definitely afford it.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lightning020 · 23/02/2022 14:23

Even if I was rolling in it I would never go to many sit down meals or takeaways. I have never found rich foods agree with me and also find it overpriced. In the case of lower end of fast foods not even tasty. I prefer to eat home cooked as that way I know what's gone in it.

Though I was very taken with McPlant the new veggie burger at McDonalds last week when we went for half term. Even there I only go seldom as I hate eating junk foods and at ds age he can easily buy his own.

TheOriginalEmu · 23/01/2022 19:03

@Adeleskirts

It’s about acknowledging our privilege and realising that if you have a house, a car and can feed your kids and heat your home that IS Luxury to most of the world

Sure, to many people that’s luxury, but you’re missing a key Point on how hard achieving that can be for many people, and totally invalidating their hardships, becayse someone somewhere has it harder.

You could still attempt to empathise with those stuggling.

Of course I empathise with those struggling, I AM one of those struggling. My point was related to a post about the difference between running a car comfortably being comfortable and owning a Porsche being luxurious: I was saying BOTH of those are luxurious. Even owning a car which you struggle a bit with is luxurious on a global scale. This whole post was about something which to me seems to be rather the opposite of empathising with those struggling. Realising that even if sometimes we’re a bit broke but we have a house with heating STILL makes us privileged is not not empathising with people with money problems.
Adeleskirts · 23/01/2022 17:51

It’s about acknowledging our privilege and realising that if you have a house, a car and can feed your kids and heat your home that IS Luxury to most of the world

Sure, to many people that’s luxury, but you’re missing a key Point on how hard achieving that can be for many people, and totally invalidating their hardships, becayse someone somewhere has it harder.

You could still attempt to empathise with those stuggling.

TheOriginalEmu · 23/01/2022 15:03

[quote Freecuthbert]@TheOriginalEmu

I understood your point, but basically you are saying that the whole of the UK are leading luxurious lives which is hugely unfair considering the many problems people in this country still face. I'm sure the many children in this country who don't have a warm home or a bed to sleep in don't feel comfortable let alone luxurious. If everyone here is living in luxury, what is comfortable then?[/quote]
I was homeless as a teenager. But even as a homeless child I had clothes, I had services which could help me, soup kitchens and churches who would help me. Social services helped me. I could still get medication if I was unwell, I could get hospital treatment. Compared to the situation in many many other countries I was still lucky. Am I saying that it’s right I was homeless? Of course not. Was it fun? No. Is it fun being a poor person in 2022 Britain? No. But it’s relative. On the whole most people in this country compared to other countries live a privileged life.
It’s about acknowledging our privilege and realising that if you have a house, a car and can feed your kids and heat your home that IS Luxury to most of the world.

Freecuthbert · 18/01/2022 01:38

@TheOriginalEmu

I understood your point, but basically you are saying that the whole of the UK are leading luxurious lives which is hugely unfair considering the many problems people in this country still face. I'm sure the many children in this country who don't have a warm home or a bed to sleep in don't feel comfortable let alone luxurious. If everyone here is living in luxury, what is comfortable then?

Sort0f · 18/01/2022 01:19

Depends what you see as luxurious.

So is a Porsche, part of a comfortable life, no.

But a comfortable life would include the odd little luxury or luxurious touch. Being able to afford a meal out or buy some nice toiletries.

TheOriginalEmu · 18/01/2022 01:14

[quote Freecuthbert]@TheOriginalEmu

Having a car might be a luxury to me as I don't drive. But I don't think someone is living the life of luxury because they can afford to drive. I've known plenty of really low income people who still drive, passed their test years ago and have low insurance and cheap car etc. It is quite normal in the west and for many jobs it can be a requirement. If we're comparing things on a global scale then aren't all of us in the UK living luxuriously? Even those in poverty here can at least have the safety net of benefits and food banks etc, compared to people who don't have access to clean drinking water somewhere else. It's like comparing a bad situation to a worse one, doesn't make the other luxury.[/quote]
Yes, on a global scale most people in the U.K. are rich. We are hugely privileged even those on bare basic benefits are richer than most in the world.
That’s my entire point.

Lostinafield · 17/01/2022 20:54

As well as being subjective, is luxury even desirable though?

PegasusReturns · 17/01/2022 20:19

Luxury to me is paying much more for something that you could still have at a cheaper price if you wanted to

This is very astute.

My financial position has improved over the years. Of all the things that I’ve been able to do: get a mortgage, pay off my mortgage, pay off a relatives mortgage, the things that feels the most luxurious is not having to “shop around”.

If I see something I like in a shop, I don’t Google to see if it’s available for cheaper online. If I’m buying something online and the P&P is £10 I don’t then spend hours seeing if I can buy the same combo of goods for less. I used to do both of these things a lot.

It gives me time back and that’s a luxury.

Crazycrazylady · 17/01/2022 11:51

To me "Comfortable" means not having to panic if the washing machine breaks down and when one of the kids needs a new pair of shoes.
In short, Can comfortably pay the monthly bills without having to worry about it.
I think we fall into this category, We go abroad each year but its saved for ie not out of current account and have some treats ie take away each weekend, but i wouldn't describe us as wealthy by any stretch of the imagination.

onlychildhamster · 17/01/2022 11:05

@CharSiu the key thing though is that luxury doesn't equate to expensive... There was a Covent Garden ex council flat that sells for £1.3 million but that is not 'luxurious' like a new built detached house up north which could sell for the same price and is catering to the footballer market. Undoubtedly, the person who lives in the covent garden flat could be quite well off, but swapping luxury for functionality/location.

In our capitalist world, there is a ton of things that is expensive but not luxurious; for example those DIY kits being sold by restaurants during lockdown for £90 per person. it is a convenience for sure and a treat, but it isn't luxury. Luxury, i think, tends to lean towards more traditional tastes and often has an element of 'service'.

NYnewstart · 17/01/2022 10:15

Luxury to me is paying much more for something that you could still have at a cheaper price if you wanted to. Therefore the difference between comfortable and luxury is say, making that conscious decision to spend more on that fantastic holiday rather than have a cheap week in the uk.
One is comfortable, one is luxury. Not being able to afford a holiday at all is not even comfortable.

CharSiu · 17/01/2022 10:09

I say we are very comfortable as we can pay all bills and buy anything we want though that wouldn’t include a million quid yacht. Though we could buy a new Porsche outright.

I think the dominant attitude is your own lived experienced when young. My own childhood was poor mainly because there were six children. DH had a very wealthy childhood as did his Mother and her Mother. She was going abroad on Holiday with her parents in the 1950’s and her childhood home had extensive grounds including a tennis court. They had servants, DH grew up in a home with a Housekeeper.

@onlychildhamster has a very good definition, we are in the comfortable paragraph but do dip in to the lots of very expensive holidays.

Onlyrainbows · 17/01/2022 09:53

only child I think the Harrods food hall Vs Whole Foods is a decent comparison. I agree that shopping exclusively at Whole Foods is a step above "comfortable" (a bit like the previous point about Waitrose). You can get some amazing bargains at Harrods Food Hall after 5 BTW!

OP posts:
CrimbleCrumble1 · 16/01/2022 22:43

I think I live in luxury, I have a lovely house and everything works in it and all the rooms are the right size and are really nicely decorated.
My DH and I are waiting for a brand new electric car to be delivered.
We go on about 6 holidays a year, have expensive hobbies.
I eat out whenever I want (usually three or four times a week)
I buy what I want which isn’t actually that much as I don’t need anything.

ScrollingLeaves · 16/01/2022 22:28

No it isn’t the same, but it depends on the starting point.

You have compared a car that works and you can afford (comfort) to a Porsche (luxury)

Then there could be a very old second hand car you just about keep going for years (relative comfort) to a car like your ordinary working one you can afford (luxury).

Then only having a bicycle ( but you can do most things you need with it so quite comfortable) to the second hand car (luxury)

Ad infinitum to poverty in one country seeming like luxury compared to the starvation in another.

onlychildhamster · 16/01/2022 21:17

Luxury life: Live in nice and expensive area meant for the wealthy in a property that was traditionally meant for the rich/upper middle class i.e. mansion flat in Kensington, 5 bed detached house in beaconsfield (and its not just expensive because of house price inflation/gentrification); multiple cars or exclusive or very heavy taxi use (London), nanny, private education for the kids even when living in area with decent schools esp boarding school, holiday or multiple homes, multiple overseas holidays in 5* hotel, eating out regularly in high end restaurants that cost £100 per person, expensive hobbies like horse-riding or skiing etc.

Comfortable life: being able to pay the bills and go to a mid-priced restaurant i.e. pizza express on a tastecard/local family eatery/access other entertainment options without it being financially crippling. to be able to buy new clothes from a wide range of shops /Charity Shop Primark to Joules/Boden) and while not every item can be bought from the mid range option, you can shop at a variety of places and not just be limited to the cheapest things you can find. Being able to save. Living in housing which isn't considered overcrowded and not worry about affording it.

onlychildhamster · 16/01/2022 20:52

@Onlyrainbows when I think luxury, I think Harrods food hall. Not even planet organic or whole foods (though maybe exclusively shopping there would be a bit higher than comfortably off).

onlychildhamster · 16/01/2022 20:38

Some aspects of my life would feel pretty spartan to mumsnetters- no car, small 2 bed flat. I know a friend in Yorkshire thinks my life is very primitive compared to hers; as she is able to rent a 3 bed house (despite only 2 people) and has 2 cars.

But I feel privileged that I can put £1k in mortgage overpayments every month while still being able to go out to eat every week and having holidays and being able to buy everything I need and want. I don't think I will ever live in anything but a flat or own a car as any increase in earnings would probably just go to childcare, education or mortgage for a 3 bed flat (it would be a flat cos I prize location and you need to make compromises to stay within budget and afford the former 2). But I don't really see that as Spartan living, just priorities.

I mean, I know someone who lived in a studio in Kensington without a washing machine despite being able to afford a much bigger place. I think he just prioritized saving and investing...he did also have holidays!

Cameleongirl · 16/01/2022 20:36

I think being financially comfortable is not having to budget every penny. You can cover your bills and own your own house, for example, but still not really be “comfortable.” My parents were like this when I was growing up, they shopped at cheaper supermarkets
(never Sainsbury’s let alone Waitrose!) and new clothes rather than hand-me-downs were a treat. They weren’t poor, but there wasn’t much for extras and I don’t know how they handled crises like the car breaking down.

DH and I definitely live more comfortably and I really appreciate it. We’re not in the luxury cars and clothes category, but we can give our children more treats and holidays, we’re not counting the pennies. That’s being comfortable, IMO.

Luckily, my Dad is more financially comfortable now too.

CatsArePeople · 16/01/2022 20:27

I'm irritated by people who live very comfortably, and in relative luxury, but then moan that they are "poor".

LovelyMoans · 16/01/2022 20:16

my comfortable life would probably be luxurious to some and quite spartan to others

This....

Kite22 · 16/01/2022 20:12

@Onionpatch

I always think the opposite of comfortable is uncomfortable, so to me if you can afford everything you need, it is a comfortable life. In particular the things like adequete housing that feels safe, heating, suitable clothes for the weather, reliable transport, a nutritious diet and sensible working hours to afford it all, in a job with health and safety regs. It doesnt make me uncomfortable to not have a holiday for instance or not to eat in restaurants. That goes into very comfortable /well off to me.
This makes sense.

You have a nice house, a car in good repair, children are in good schools (either a good state school or independent if the local options aren’t great) and if anyone in the family needs something, it’s not a problem to go and just buy it.

Once you get into the realms of paying for private education, you are definitely getting into luxuries that the overwhelming majority of the population can't afford. That is 100% getting into 'wealthy' territory on any scale. (Acknowledging that some people might have that 'wealth' paid for by other family members outside of their household)

LuaDipa · 16/01/2022 19:49

Comfortable isn’t loaded, it’s comfortable. I would consider comfortable as not having to worry about paying for the basics and a few extras. Luxury would be living like a Kardashian or a football player.

HintofVintagePink · 16/01/2022 18:57

We are comfortable. We live in a lovely home which we can afford to extend and renovate. We have two cars and I can fill the car with petrol and the boot with groceries and not worry. The children do a couple of after school clubs, wear nice clothes (from sales!) and we have two holidays a year and a few weekends away. We are very fortunate.

We don’t live in luxury though. Luxury to me is high end of everything, multiple holidays abroad a year, private schools, expensive hobbies, brand new cars and shopping for fun and STILL not worrying about it.