Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Estate agent want to charge £30k

129 replies

ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 15/01/2022 17:23

I get that estate agents are on commission to incentivise them to get the best price but surely there's a better way?

We live in London and are very lucky to have a lovely home. estate agents want 1.5% + VAT commission which would be £30,000 if we get the asking price.

But they don't do any more work for the £30k from me Vs the £7.5k they'd get selling a small flat. Do they? With Rightmove etc the benefit of the flashy high street office must be negligible.

IABU - there's more to it and the service and experience justifies the cost
YANBU - just use an online seller and pay £1,500 there's no way a local office can add £28.5k of value.

OP posts:
Twiglets1 · 16/01/2022 09:21

I thought the same thing when my sister and I made the decision to put out flat in central London on with Savills. At 1.5% commission they will be making over 30k when we complete. BUT the price was the same as many other agents were charging in the area and we could not do viewings ourselves as we don’t live there most of the time.
Several months down the line I feel differently. They have to pay for an office in central London and salaries for experienced and professional estate agents. Our main contact has been brilliant and has managed our difficult sale with integrity. They have conducted over 30 viewings and have got us the best price I feel.

puffyisgood · 16/01/2022 09:05

there is generally a slight tendency for estate agents' commissions to only go up slowly in £ terms, and therefore down in % terms, as properties get more expensive, but you need quite big variations in value to really see it.

Warblerinwinter · 16/01/2022 08:55

@Pinotpleasure

Ha! We lived in the USA and when we sold our house we had to pay 5% commission to the realtor.

It’s like a cartel there and almost impossible to get on the MLS (multiple listing service) without using a realtor,

Generally property is much cheaper in us, so you probably still pay less relatively.
ThinkAboutItTomorrow · 16/01/2022 08:52

@Ileflottante

I always wonder if threads like these are an attempt to get people to work out what the ‘lovely house’ in London is worth. Grin
I said upthread it's been valued at £1.65m. Not stealth boasting or whatever at all.

I know it's a lot but it's normal round here. Streets and streets of 4/5 bed terrace houses with tiny gardens selling for £1.5-2m.

Rationally I think London / SE house prices are bonkers but seem likely to stay that way, for houses with gardens at least.

OP posts:
MoFro · 16/01/2022 03:12

Go with EA but negotiate and get what you want.
Put in a higher percentage if they get you over XXX or complete within a timeframe

A good agent will get you a good sale through their contacts and reputation

verytiredofbeingshoutedat · 16/01/2022 02:29

Don't put it on with an online EA! Not a property of that value . That's madness.

I actively discount any properties being marketed by purple bricks or online EAs. They don't see process through in same way.

Had a house sale chain break down before due to ineptitude of purplebricks, who were selling house we tried to buy - months wasted and we'd already paid for surveys and searches. We walked away in the end. Never again

UniversalAunt · 16/01/2022 00:21

‘ Good agents have a little black book of buyers who are looking for property in particular areas (in our case, our road and the one next to it)’

That’ll be prospective buyers who are cash ready & keen to buy. Expect serious offers & a smooth sale.

scoobydoo1971 · 15/01/2022 23:55

For anyone thinking of using an online estate agency like Strike, forget the sales pitch and read the contract offer terms very carefully. My recent dealings with Strike have been very poor and I wouldn't trust them to sell a wendy house, let alone the portfolio of houses I offered them to value this week. They have made critical mistakes on the valuation documents, their EA failed to mention the legal tie in to their legal service in the verbal offer (so free rightmove isn't so free after all), or the hard sell extra's they throw at you like organising professional photographs. Various staff members leave voice messages with no direct reply line and when you ring the office they haven't a clue how to connect you back to these named people. It doesn't inspire confidence that potential buyers would be able to contact them either. No one rings back as promised, and I have asked my agent to change the mistake on the valuation form FIVE times by text and email...with no reply...when I am potentially putting £1.8m of property their way, and the promise of more in the future. All estate agents are evil in my opinion, but to borrow from George Orwell, some are more evil than others...

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 15/01/2022 23:54

@OakPine

In my experience, estate agents do nothing to secure the best price. Many times it appears that they just want the quickest sale.

For example, if your house is selling for £3M, and they get 1% commission, then they get £30k. If they manage to bump the price up to £3.2M, then they only get £32k.

In my experience, they want the (example) £30k in their pocket, and won't hold out/do any additional work to get an additional £2k.

Go with the online agent initially. See if it sells. Don't assume that an expensive agent is working on your behalf.

Good luck!

This is very true. We recently sold a house for 530k which is what I would have valued it at. One estate agent told us to put it on at offers in excess of 500k in hope of enticing a bidding war - wtf?!

I hated this idea and to me it showed the desire for a quick sale. Also, what a way to treat prospective buyers. Offers in excess of put me right off as a buyer, just say what you want for your bloody house - you'll only get what it's worth anyway! Anyway I digress......We ignored him, went with a different estate agent and got £530k which was just slightly under the asking price.

Talkwhilstyouwalk · 15/01/2022 23:44

Yes, this pisses me off about estate agents too. I don't see how it's more work to sell a more expensive house, although size of the house and time its likely to be on the market need to be taken into account.

They all do this though

My advice would be to negotiate down to 1%, or even .75%.

MsFogi · 15/01/2022 23:32

YANBU we recently used Hamptons Internation for my mother's house - they were shit from day one, I suspect Purple Bricks would have been better.

Changemaname1 · 15/01/2022 23:27

Can you not go to an estate agent with fixed fees ? I got valuations with a few of the local bigger estate agents and about half were fixed fees and the other half a percentage of the sale price ?

Or is that not a thing for houses above a certain price ?

MooshWoosh · 15/01/2022 23:19

I should add, the house we were discussing went for near enough 20% over asking

MooshWoosh · 15/01/2022 23:16

When we were buying our current home, we encountered a few Purple Bricks/ online estate agent types.

Generally, they were awful! I mentioned once that we would offer over asking which was standard in our area. The woman looked at me as if I had two heads! She actually tried to get me to start with a lower offer. Despite the fact that every single property of that type was going to closing date within a week. She had zero idea of the local market.

Obviously this is just one example, but we decided then to use traditional EAs when we came to sell ours.

OmgIThinkILikeYou · 15/01/2022 23:08

We were on with Purple Bricks, the only viewings I got were by me advertising the listing on local selling groups on Facebook and were all a waste of time.

Put my property up with a local agent after a few weeks of nothing with Purple Bricks, it was under offer same day it was listed. They also helped a lot in chasing the buyers solicitors etc through to completion.

Technosaurus · 15/01/2022 22:58

I once sold a property (via inheritance) through a high end estate agent. The whole thing was a dream - it never even went on the market. They knew the price it might go for, had people on their books who they knew were willing to buy in the area at said price, asked me if they'd mind doing some "pre market" bookings, we had three asking price offers by the evening. Picked the cash buyer, all done and dusted in 6 weeks. They were worth their weight in gold.

Kipperandarthur · 15/01/2022 22:58

A lot of people here are confusing the VAT element that’s going to HMRC and not the estate agent.

DixonD · 15/01/2022 22:56

@ThinkAboutItTomorrow

I like the sliding scale approach *@stoptheballs*

Even at 1% it's £20k

I see the point but not sure big houses round here are that much harder to sell. The time it takes on average is a actually less, if the online reports are anything to go by.

My worry is time wasters but for ~£28k I think I'd put up with a bit of that.

Have you never sold a house before?

Anything between 1%-2% perfectly normal and acceptable.

(Ex-conveyancing assistant).

OakPine · 15/01/2022 22:53

In my experience, estate agents do nothing to secure the best price.
Many times it appears that they just want the quickest sale.

For example, if your house is selling for £3M, and they get 1% commission, then they get £30k. If they manage to bump the price up to £3.2M, then they only get £32k.

In my experience, they want the (example) £30k in their pocket, and won't hold out/do any additional work to get an additional £2k.

Go with the online agent initially. See if it sells. Don't assume that an expensive agent is working on your behalf.

Good luck!

Sodullincomparison · 15/01/2022 22:33

We were just offered 0.5% but we had to go to market this week. Huge shortage of new properties around here.

CoffeethenCrochet · 15/01/2022 22:31

When we viewed our current house through purple bricks it was relatively easy. As I liased with the seller directly through the purple bricks website. The problems arose when we had our offer accepted, and then discovered that the seller "had" to use a purple bricks conveyancer. It took forever, our solicitor was constantly chasing and we could have completed a lot sooner if it hadn't been sold through purple bricks. We will never use or purchase a property through purple bricks.

Kipperandarthur · 15/01/2022 22:24

Negotiate to 1%.
I would not view a house with an online agent or sell with one.

Last sale of mine - SW London - not at your bracket - whilst the EA was a pain, they held the sale together when there were problems. They were aggressively successful.

I know people who have paid similar commissions to you and whilst it’s always a bit galling a good EA should not be underestimated. You often find out when things start going less than smoothly how much they hold the chain together.

At your market I think people would be very put off with Purple Bricks and such like.

Ileflottante · 15/01/2022 22:18

I always wonder if threads like these are an attempt to get people to work out what the ‘lovely house’ in London is worth. Grin

Whydoesthecatalwaysdothat · 15/01/2022 22:17

Don't do the viewings yourself. DH and I used to really hate this. We like to look around and make comments about what we like/don't like and it's impossible when the vendor is following you around like a hawk. We also found that vendors talk too much. Sometimes you just want to wander through the house and observe it in semi-silence.

StrikeItLuckyShuffle · 15/01/2022 22:16

strike.co.uk/

This company looks really good It has great trust pilot reviews
Been seeing lots of adverts on tv for it lately