Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the driving test system is becoming ridiculous and is harming the economy.

86 replies

HunterGatherer · 15/01/2022 15:43

Yes, I know there's a pandemic on but DS has had his driving test cancelled 3 times now Angry. He has been waiting for over a year (after failing his first test for going too slowly around a roundabout, his instructor who was in the car with him was aghast).
DS is a nurse and currently commutes to work via 2 trains. He frequently has to turn down bank shifts in (in desperately understaffed units) because he can't get there. Quite a few of his friends are in similar situations.
I'm sure other industries are suffering as well. FGS Boris, get your finger out and sort this problem out.

OP posts:
HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 19:05

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

A few people are saying 'where are these mystery driving instructors/driving testers coming from?' and 'Who is going to train them' and so on? But what I don't understand is where the F have they all gone, if there's not enough left? I can't believe they are all off with covid!

They're still working as normal, but because they couldn't work for ages over the lockdowns, they have a HUGE backlog of customers. All our local instructors have had closed books for months as they're just totally full up with existing clients.

So they're still dealing with all the people who turned 17 in 2019/2020, plus the ones who came of age in 2021, and then all the new drivers who are only just turning 17 now - and that's on top of all the older people who want to learn to drive too.

Never thought about this. Thank you.
user1471464218 · 15/01/2022 19:04

This was Republic of Ireland.

britnay · 15/01/2022 19:00

Could he not just move closer to where he works?

Blanketpolicy · 15/01/2022 18:52

But do people want to be a driving examiner at the moment? Spending your working day in an enclosed space with loads of strangers? I doubt it. They also have to fund their own vehicles and fuel, and most are self-employed too. A friend of mine trained to do it pre-COVID and said you really don't make much once you take out all the expenses.

Agree, who wants to train to be an examiner during a pandemic, also knowing after it, when things go back to normal you are likely to be let go.

Why would an examiner need to fund their own vehicle and fuel? Are you getting confused with instructors, learners are tested in their instructors car or their own car. Examiners are also not self employed, they are civil servants (but not the kind that get cheese and wine while working).

Huntswomanonthemove · 15/01/2022 18:51

@HunterGatherer

Yes, I know there's a pandemic on but DS has had his driving test cancelled 3 times now Angry. He has been waiting for over a year (after failing his first test for going too slowly around a roundabout, his instructor who was in the car with him was aghast). DS is a nurse and currently commutes to work via 2 trains. He frequently has to turn down bank shifts in (in desperately understaffed units) because he can't get there. Quite a few of his friends are in similar situations. I'm sure other industries are suffering as well. FGS Boris, get your finger out and sort this problem out.
My brother is a driving instructor. He works six days a week, sometimes seven and he has a waiting list. This is the same with his colleagues. There is a shortage of driving instructors, as many have retired and due to the age demography of driving instructors, that will become even more of a problem.

Virtually every week, he gets an email asking him to train as an examiner because there is a shortage. He has no intention of doing that, as he would be earning a lot less.

I'm not a fan of Boris but what do you expect him to do @HunterGatherer?

Kite22 · 15/01/2022 18:51

@LemonCake79

*@fairylightsandwaxmelts* it can't be hard to find some additional / temporary premises. It's been done with plenty of other public services eg Nightingale courts.

.gov tells me it takes 5 weeks to train to be an examiner and there are specific trainers in place. It really shouldn't be that hard to train some more.

This.

I can't understand people saying there isn't room in the test centres, like the test centres are anything other than a Reception / meeting place for the driver to pick up the examiner. That could really be done in any building, surely ? They managed to build all the Nightingale Hospitals which surely need a LOT more things that are specific to treating unwell people.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 15/01/2022 18:48

A few people are saying 'where are these mystery driving instructors/driving testers coming from?' and 'Who is going to train them' and so on? But what I don't understand is where the F have they all gone, if there's not enough left? I can't believe they are all off with covid!

They're still working as normal, but because they couldn't work for ages over the lockdowns, they have a HUGE backlog of customers. All our local instructors have had closed books for months as they're just totally full up with existing clients.

So they're still dealing with all the people who turned 17 in 2019/2020, plus the ones who came of age in 2021, and then all the new drivers who are only just turning 17 now - and that's on top of all the older people who want to learn to drive too.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 15/01/2022 18:46

Shame there's no middle ground tbh.

Yeah, I agree - there's no perfect way unfortunately. Some people are excellent in lessons and will freeze on the test, others will struggle on lessons but have a fluke test and pass first time.

It's also hugely location/time/route dependent as to how likely you are to pass your test in my opinion!

HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 18:45

@user1471464218

At the risk of de railing this thread.....until 2007!!!!!! you could just drive without passing your test. Had to display l plates and no motorway driving, but essentially you could legally drive unaccompanied.
What country are you in? I am pretty sure this has never been a thing in the UK.
HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 18:44

@fairylightsandwaxmelts

Always believed that driving lessons should be assessed on hours driven and skills learned rather than tests. Tests are stressful, people fail under test stress all the time and excel and drive perfectly otherwise.

But you can have two people and give them both 40 hours of lessons - one will be test ready after 30 hours and the other nowhere near ready after 40.

Passing someone to drive because they've clocked up a certain number of lessons is a bit silly, really.

Yeah, I get that poster's point, and it's a shame that some people who are really good drivers cannot pass their test, when others pass quickly, and they're shite!

But passing people on hours driven/skills learned is not a great idea.

Shame there's no middle ground tbh.

HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 18:43

@LemonCake79

I completely agree *@HunterGatherer*, the Driving Standards Agency should have waiting time targets to meet like everyone else.

It was terrible when I passed 23 years ago but now it's just appalling. No one wants standards compromises but there needs to be more tests available.

Really feel for your DS.

I agree. @HunterGatherer I have no advice, just sympathy and hugs. I feel SO sorry for anyone trying to learn to drive, OR get their A levels or GCSEs done, OR anyone who is at uni. Also, people starting a new job, and not being able to spend time with people 1 to 1 actually learning the job properly etc.

SO many aspects of life have been ruined because of covid. And frankly, I am sick to death now of certain public service departments using covid as an excuse for poor service.

I agree that the Driving Standards Agency/DVLA need to buck up their ideas. Not only with stuff like this, but the driving licences too. Some people are waiting on driving licences (after being banned for a year or 2, or losing their licence temporarily because of an Illness or epileptic fit etc,) and have been waiting 6 to 9 months or more!

They are right up there with many of the GPs when it comes to useless customer service. I don't understand why more isn't being done tbh.

A few people are saying 'where are these mystery driving instructors/driving testers coming from?' and 'Who is going to train them' and so on? But what I don't understand is where the F have they all gone, if there's not enough left? I can't believe they are all off with covid! Confused

user1471464218 · 15/01/2022 18:43

At the risk of de railing this thread.....until 2007!!!!!! you could just drive without passing your test. Had to display l plates and no motorway driving, but essentially you could legally drive unaccompanied.

HelloFrostyMorning · 15/01/2022 18:43

@Shade17

Learners shouldn't have to take a test under stress, and no one should ever drive stressed, ever.

But driving IS stressful and you will find yourself in stressful situations. If you can’t handle that then you’ve got no business being behind the wheel.

Hmm good point, but I also see the other poster's point, that someone could be a great driver, but lose their nerve when being tested.
Shade17 · 15/01/2022 18:41

Learners shouldn't have to take a test under stress, and no one should ever drive stressed, ever.

But driving IS stressful and you will find yourself in stressful situations. If you can’t handle that then you’ve got no business being behind the wheel.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 15/01/2022 18:29

Always believed that driving lessons should be assessed on hours driven and skills learned rather than tests. Tests are stressful, people fail under test stress all the time and excel and drive perfectly otherwise.

But you can have two people and give them both 40 hours of lessons - one will be test ready after 30 hours and the other nowhere near ready after 40.

Passing someone to drive because they've clocked up a certain number of lessons is a bit silly, really.

cherryonthecakes · 15/01/2022 18:26

It seems that emergency driving tests are available if you're NHS and need to drive as part of your job

www.gov.uk/apply-emergency-driving-test

To think that the driving test system is becoming ridiculous and is harming the economy.
Qwertykeys · 15/01/2022 18:23

I too advocate the cancellation apps , my son passed yesterday the test apps do work and bring tests forward a considerable amount of time . There is a huge backlog our test centre started doing Saturday tests .

cherryonthecakes · 15/01/2022 18:23

Always believed that driving lessons should be assessed on hours driven and skills learned rather than tests.

Some people learn faster than others. I believe that there are studies which show the younger you are, the fewer hours you need to reach test standard.

I don't think that the hours driven is a good benchmark when lots of people drive with a parent sitting alongside them. Unfortunately many of those parents may lie or have bad habits that the learner hopefully doesn't pick up. If the hours driven is with a professional then that makes driving too expensive for people on low incomes who currently use their experiences driver parents instead.

lovelychops · 15/01/2022 18:20

Remember lots of examiners are off with covid too. You're in an enclosed space with another person, and the amount of people turning up without masks etc is unbelievable.
They are also staggering how many examiners are in the office at one time so tests are spaced out.

Do try and get a cancellation though OP you can travel and take the test anywhere. We're in North West and have had candidates from down south come up for a test. So there is availability if you are prepared to travel .

Scrowy · 15/01/2022 18:18

They have tried to do something and that is make it legal to drive with a trailer without an additional test to take that cohort of tests out of the system.

The only problem is they flip flopped about doing it several times leaving the agricultural sector in limbo for quite a long time as it became impossible to book a trailer test as it was known they were no longer going to be a legal requirement but they cancelled the original date the law was changing without setting a new one meaning you couldn't book a test but couldn't drive legally without one for quite some time.

Its now been fixed and the law has changed but I'm not sure the general public are aware that its now legal to tow a cattle trailer without an additional trailer licence

They are also prioritising HGV licence tests due to the shortage issues in that sector

lovelychops · 15/01/2022 18:14

@Ariela

Half the problem is that people are desperately booking tests even though the new driver isn't ready for it. Hence the apparent slow supply, it's the fuel crisis all over again. However if you look fervently for cancellations these do come up quickly
This. My partner is an examiner and the amount of people booking a tedt when they're not ready is unbelievable. Remember you don't need a set amount of lessons you can theoretically book a test any time
cherryonthecakes · 15/01/2022 18:13

My teens went through this too.
Ds had 4 cancelled and his theory expired
Dd had 2 cancelled and passed
And the process to book was so difficult - waiting in a queue with 100,000+ people

gorseinonn22 · 15/01/2022 18:09

I don't think you can increase the number of examiners quickly, hence my view there should be some priority in the mean time. I'd raise the minimum driving age given children are in school or training until 18, as a starter.

Snowiscold · 15/01/2022 18:06

Always believed that driving lessons should be assessed on hours driven and skills learned rather than tests.

One of my DC learned to drive abroad, where it’s harder than in the uk. You have to pass the theory test before you are even allowed to do a single practical lesson. You have to pass a first-aid test. You have to have lessons with an approved driving school - no getting your dad to teach you. You have to take a minimum number of lessons - 40 hours - which must be logged and submitted. You must have a lesson in the dark. Among other things.

fairylightsandwaxmelts · 15/01/2022 18:05

@LemonCake79

*@fairylightsandwaxmelts* it can't be hard to find some additional / temporary premises. It's been done with plenty of other public services eg Nightingale courts.

.gov tells me it takes 5 weeks to train to be an examiner and there are specific trainers in place. It really shouldn't be that hard to train some more.

But do people want to be a driving examiner at the moment? Spending your working day in an enclosed space with loads of strangers? I doubt it. They also have to fund their own vehicles and fuel, and most are self-employed too. A friend of mine trained to do it pre-COVID and said you really don't make much once you take out all the expenses.

The other thing with test centres is they need to be in central-ish locations to account for all the road conditions covered on the test. So you need to be able to cover A roads, junctions, roundabouts - you need places to do all the manoeuvres (safely) etc.

There's no point setting up a test centre in an area with no examiners and where it's not feasible to do multiple test routes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread